American Idol - Robbie Carrico - One

[sgaznwang]

I remember him from Boyz N Girlz United!!!

[BfeoAdmin]

You guys clearly don't know much about singing, or perhaps you've never heard a decent performer live. This guy isn't that good.

[lynnmerf]

I really like this performance, This guy is very good he may have not made the Idol #1 but he will go far in music I think. I love his new song " If Only " that he put out on his country CD!

[jordynordy]

he sould of won

[sweetiepea13]

in my life was weird, if i were your woman was boring, i believe didnt show personality or emotion for me, vanishing was old fashioned again, 1 rock & roll 2 many was ok, hello again was forgettable i cant even remember it, thank the lord for the night time was also forgettable, a change is gonna come wasnt a great song and didnt like the performance for some reason, fever wasnt right for her, hit me up was corny and weird. sorry but i just aint a fan and dont think she desreved 3rd place. sorry

[sweetiepea13]

i hate to break it to you, but im not mistaken. i truly think so. she is a great singer, but for me shes a little too loud for my taste. there are some loud singers that i like and im a fan of but syesha isnt one of them. its complicated but true. also, there are performance she did that i liked and these are all of them: tobacco road, yesterday, i will always love you, proud mary, if i aint got you. me and mr jones is old fashioned, saving all my love was the wrong song for her, gotta get you

[sweetiepea13]

WHAT HAPPENED!!!! HE SHOULD OF GOTTEN AT LEAST THE TOP 12!!! STUPID JASON AND SYESHA FOR STEALING THE GOOD PEOPLES PLACE THAT HAVE TALENT!!!! LEARN TO PERFORM YOU 2!!!!

[MrCrayonInk95]

@sweetiepea13 WTF! OK I go beyond agreeing with you on Jason Castro but Syesha? She was the best girl singer that season! Im hoping you meant to say someone else. Syesha had an incredible performance each week. Even in Hollywood round when she literally had no voice she blew everyone away.

[dirkbogarde44]

Fucking vile !

[b33p]

That was kind of crappy.

[tannerwise7]

I still can't believe he can't out so soon and this was like three seasons ago.

[CrazyKirlia]

I don't think this guy's elimination is on Youtube. Anyone have a link? I've been searching for it...

[AmericanIdolRulez]

I voted for him that week! hes so good!

[FallApartAgain]

I spent some time with him when he was in some band like 10 years ago. Never thought of him as a rocker. Don't watch AI so only just found out about this. He is ok. Considering how lame some people in the top 10 seem to be, I am surprised he didn't get through.

[lilmaof5]

Luv this Guy....Missing Picket Rocks!!!

[TheEpicHeart]

He really should have won, this cover of "One" is epic... but it's been said before, A.I. is more of a popularity contest than anything else.

[bananablama]

Isn't it? I really think he got cheated, this performence was amazing.

[SuperPanetone]

@TheEpicHeart Have you seen that years winner? Way better :S But this guy deserved to go further

[itsbuzzy]

He's wearing a wig!

[WTHitsMAT]

he was prtty good... can't believe he got out so early but hey american idol is becoming a popularity contest

[LeaveItToJeremy]

his birthday is one day after mine

[TheNewNewfie]

This guy is pretty good.

[Smilley76]

David Aruchuleta #1

Robbie Carrico #2

David Hernandez #3

David Cook #4

[efehdoodle]

Aruchuleta is a pussy-boy bitch

[zerohero38]

very cool, and very good 5/5

[ny11764]

wow this seemed so long ago i liked him he had a good voice i loved hot blooded

[GPXgirl]

I love him.. oh and, your a loser to believe rumors..

[hotiscalo]

if the 2 davids wernt in this season he woulda won but no but he shoulda won stupid davids -.-

[KangarooPerson123]

yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[BlingyDamon3]

i think he should've stuck to the boy band image cuz that would work a lot better than a rock image with his voice and instincts on stage

[humannumber4]

his voice is good, if it was his voice only that was in the competition he would've definetly made it into the top 12, but he was actually kind of a rock poser and thats what i didnt like about him, unlike David Cook that had a band Axium. Axium had good rock songs and thats what David brought into the competition...

[ghainlink10]

well, hes a good singer. but cooks voice has a nicer texture to it. i do like this guy tho.

[JasonCastroFan797]

he's good

[LBoy3334]

i thought that was awsome

[PepperX2000]

He should have made it alot farther.

[gmomgg]

this guy was fake as hell, but he was a good singer regardless. i was expecting this guy to at least make the top 12.

[PepperX2000]

Me too. After his first performance I predicted him to make the top 5 but instead he came in 20th.

[taekwonducky7]

His hair is fake..or so I've heard..

[lancelangston]

he's awesome but with david cook in the same season he had no chance. can he come back?

[PepperX2000]

No. Once someone makes the Top 24 they can't come back.

[Smilley76]

I agree, based on his voice, but he was kinda a rock poser.. But i loved this performance.

[rsSAXESrs]

He was horrible..

[kiidso0freshh]

robbie > micheal

[TyTy7873]

he was the only one i liked!!!!! Can't believe they sent him home! And he can sing rock, but i think he can sing other songs better, and ppl r sayin his hair is a wig, um okaay lol thts funni

[gmomgg]

yeah, he's a fake rocker, but he had good vocals, and i can't believe he got beat out by luke menard.

[guitarpeyton24]

michael and robbie were the only ones i liked on this show this season

i quit watching when they got kicked

[jcastrocrazy]

my uncle is in the band that sings this song

[gmomgg]

three dog night?

[jcastrocrazy]

yup my uncle plays the piano

[muzikmafia27]

wow are you serious? your uncle was in three dog night? your fucking kidding me?

[jcastrocrazy]

nope im not i went to their concert this november

[muzikmafia27]

Wow. That's cool.

[urep17]

this man deserves to stay longer in the show than any of the girls who are still in top8! oh America! God Bless you!

[dutchesam]

i love robbie and i wished he would have lasted longer

[Liisasahk]

love it!