Added: 4 years ago
From: ProfessorWhat
Views: 67,371
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (318)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Liz didn't die, she went off to travel the cosmos!

  • So mean goodbyes but none harder then saying good bye to the most faithful :(

  • I really really really hope you could upload a video exactly like this one, but with every companion to date :C

    It was awesome.

  • 9 is missing D:

    

  • 9 Daleks disliked this video.

  • What does he say when he leaves Leela? Sorry about my shit english :D 1:50 past, the fourth doctor.

  • @Potuk08 He says "I'll miss you too, Savage". That was his nickname for Leela

  • Jamie and Zoe's always the saddest for me, by far. Because Jamie says "I won't forget you." And then their memories are wiped.

  • Beautiful Video

  • how a bout a new version?

  • i simply LOVE how the tardis takes off at the very end of this video :) wish it took off like that every time

  • And what about Barbara and Ian?

  • @omer8882

    yeah.. i didnt have a good copy of the chase at the time...good idea though..

  • The video is very nice. But where is Martha?

  • @omer8882 Check the date its uploaded, 3rd season probably didnt end by then.

  • Consider "They Break My Heart" a -- ahem -- companion piece.

    This brought tears to my eyes; 900 years, and he's had to say goodbye to so many. (sniff)

  • PEOPLE PLEASE READ, this vid was made in 2007, Martha and Donna hadn't even happened yet. Quit haranguing the poor guy. Also WTF, 8 dislikes? Must be Daleks.

  • great work. thanks. I'm bawling my eyes out now.

  • good video!! :)

  • So heart-wrenchingly bittersweet. Sometimes bittersweet, sometimes happy, sometimes tragic. You captured perfectly most of the most memorable deparature of the Companions. Well done!!!

  • I... Oh... um... excuse me a moment, I need to go have a good cry.

  • wheres ace

  • @coolcole025 Ace and the Doctor never got an on screen farewell because the series was canceled before she left the TARDIS.

  • will u do it with martha and the new ones plus where was the peri and ben and polly?

  • Were'd you get the Adric scene from? I just simply love it the music going silent combined with actually seeing him hit Earth, it's a great way to show how proper re-editing of a scene can do, makes it a lot more dramatic.

  • @ultimatedbz2 yes it was the best part of earthshock

  • I'd just like to leave a quote that I think suits this vid: "I don't age. I regenerate. But humans decay; you wither and you die. Imagine watching that happen to someone that you You can spend the rest of your life with me, but I can't spend the rest of mine with you. I have to live on. Alone. That's the curse of the Time Lords."

  • This is one of my favorite Fan made Dr who vids. I go back and watch it every once and a way!

  • I want to watch the very first Doctor Who's all over again now :') it really is (and still is!) an amazing show, its something I can never forget, but all those goodbyes, its so tough for The Doctor sometimes :(

  • This is probably the best tribute video I've ever seen for Doctor Who. You have almost every emotional goodbye, and I love it! I watch it all the time, which probably makes me weird, but oh well. Quick question, what is the episode you use for the Third Doctor?

  • scince I saw this episode and heard this music (in addition to my weeping sounds) it stayed in my brain and didn't let go. I humm it every once in a while, I play it on piano without thinking, and whenever I hear it, I feel as if this is the right thing to do.

    I do believe that it has something-magical, something DOCTORish.

  • It's Thanksgiving and this video just made my day.

  • This is heart-wrenching to watch, so very, very sad. But also incredibly beautifully done. One of the very best Who fan videos I have ever seen!

  • "One day, I shall come back. Yes, I shall come back." - Doctor Who has progressed in so many ways, but you just don't get speeches like that any more :'(

  • Tennant was by far the best. His series was full of pure mystery and passion. Matt is a good replacement since he's fun and goofy, but no one will ever compare to Tennant's acting.

  • man that's soo hard to watch.. :'( I love Doctor who. So bittersweet.

  • rose leaving was the most upsetting..

    she was an amazing companion, fair play!, tom baker seemed like a good doctor too, with his lovely scarf, this song is soo beautiful!, not to mention, david tennant, is weirdly attractive, lmao!

  • I know, I loved that doctor

  • nice vid, but wheres big ears? i know it wasn't a very good goodbye scene with rose, but you could have had him saying good bye to charles Dikins or somethin.

  • @snakeyreef - well.. it was supposed to be just a different way to see the older companions leave up till rose.. and i didnt want to have a regeration goodbye with the 9th.. it was just companions...

    i am suprised people are still watching this thing!

  • @ProfessorWhat what 'bout when Jack gets shot, you could edit something with Jack's goodbye.

  • @ProfessorWhat yes people are still watching this.

  • This is a great idea! Thanks for a wonderful look back.

  • Is there a way to download this! This is awesome!

  • I'm going to be in a pie

  • Very Good :'(

  • Great video! It's sad, and I love the song Doomsday. You missed Christopher Eccleston though :(

  • I love this video, it emphasises the most important theme of Doctor Who, LOSS. It starts with him abandoning everthing he knows and finishes with him returning to try to save it then having it taken away. He has lived for nearly 1000 years when compared to a human lifespan that seems like an eternity, so all of his compainions at some point must say goodbye and he knows that every new friend he makes will eventually leave him.

  • Oh ... Dodo's departure was done by proxy ... she got sick, then left a note with Ben and Polly to tell the Doc she wouldn't be coming. Barbara and Ian, left on a Dalek time machine to go back to earth ... and as for Ben and Polly, that got wiped sadly, as was victoria's.

  • it is his destiny to be along.for his power he pays terrible price

  • Bugger, showing my age, I remember all of these like it was yesturday. Not only did they have very different personalities, but they sometimes had different storylines as well. Pertwee's version spent a lot of time with U.N.I.T. I even saw the polit movie as a kid where the dialeks were digging into the core of the earth.

  • you could use this in a zombie flick

  • Did the sixth doctor now have any goodbyes? Seems a shame he was left out!

  • He doesn't really have a "goodbye" scene for anyone, or even himself :(

  • Am i the only person who thinks that Hartnell sounded really heart broken when he said goodbye?

  • @sc0rge Dispite what everybody says, the Orginal Doctor, was the BEST Doctor.

  • Sigh I'm gonna miss David tennant as the doctor.....

  • wheres the nineth doctor

    when he regenarates into tenth doctor...

    cuz the nineth doctor says goodbye to rose!!

    reply back

  • well. .it is him saying good bye to his companions as they leave and i couldnt put rose twice ... this was made a long time ago.. i need to make a new video ..

  • looking forward to seeing a new version of this awesome vid.

  • Great video! Since it was made in early 2007, it doesn't have parting scenes with Martha and Donna.

  • i want to make a tribute to donna at some point. been working on professor what #13 so.. havent had the time to make a new video

  • It's just hurt to see how much pain companions bring to the Doctor.He is so sad and completely alone in the end.I watched only new school, so didn't know that.Thank you for showing.

  • I cried <3

    Great work... it's rare I see videos with the scene changes so well matched to the music. Like, Three's exit was perfect. Among other stuff.

    Thank you.

  • you are most welcome.

  • Well it would have been better had you had the 6th Doctor after all he did lose Peri or else you just fail at knowing Doctor Who.

  • lol... no i have every episode on dvd and it just didnt fit the video of how she left.. there was no real goodbye between the two of them.

  • The doctor so !! sad :((

  • Parting is such sweet sorrow.

    Grand video.

  • Bloody Brilliant!

  • brilliant work

  • This is one of the most depressing video on youtube, and I love it! Very well done, I may even have a tear falling...I love the classics series as well as the new so it was all quite emotional for me

  • Always thought this was beautiful. I found the William Hartnell and Tom Baker pieces quite nice. I know this was made before Donna's exit and the video's end fit because Doomsday was when Rose left, but it still would have been cool to see Donna's farewell here as well. Still, very nice.

  • this is a wonderful peice of music which complmented the video perfectly

  • i loved that. 5/5 (: i wish you put martha leaving and the doctor wiping donnas mind, and where the doctors saying like "she cant remember me" to her parents though ^^

  • Umm...this was made in 2007.

  • oh XD

  • Great compilation !

  • Beautiful video, it all works so well with this fantastic music :)

  • Wonderful video. Especially loved the goodbye clip from William Hartnell - my first Doctor as a young girl - and still one of my faves

    Thnx

  • Amazing :)

  • Beautifully done...

    If you ever re-edit this, a minor suggestion is to wind the music back a wee bit so we can here The Doctor and the others.

    But that's inconsequential - this is a good effort on your part, and I luvved watching it.

  • you desvered the 5 stars here you go the the best tribute iv see so far

  • goosebumps all over *shudders*

  • Nice vid

  • Tennant is a class act, and has set the standard pretty high for the new fella.

  • This is a great video, as a fan of both the 'classic' and 'new' series of doctor who, its always great seeing ppl edit together vids that use clips from both. Well done for making me feel 6 again!!

  • This video is really beautiful and touching will try one day to watch all the episodes of the classic series ^^

  • best 5 and a half minutes I've spent this week :-) Thanks for making!

  • Well said gabyella. I loved Rose too. Its not the same without her and it won't be the same without david tennant either xx

  • All you people who say you didn't like Rose are pathetic and ridiculous. Rose was the best companion and actress that ever happened to doctor who. You obviously don't understand true talent when you see it. Welldone to who made this clip, very well done (: you should make some more like this

  • The only one pathetic and ridiculous is the twat you cannot respect other people's opinion. Yes, Gabyelle, I'm looking at you.

  • No, to read what you wrote, means I have to switch half of my brain off to get on your leve.

    Cretin

  • A truly wonderful tribute.

  • Barbara and Ian went home in dalek spaceship, Katarina was ejectd into space, Liz went back to cambridge university, Dodo's stayed in the country when ben and Polly joined and gave her tardis key to them to give to the Doctor, ben and polly Left in the Faceless ones when they found it was the same day they met the Doctor, stephen stayed on an alien planet to look after a tribe of savages and the Doctort asked a family ifd they could take victoria in because she stayed on earth and had no family

  • Oh man! I never liked Rose, and I was so happy when I heard that she was leaving. But then, that song really got the waterworks going. Still does. And this video has me bawling! Well done!

  • I accept your answer of your dislike for Rose, but I disagree with you. Rose was a constant constrast to the doctor like cherry pie to steak, but it worked. I had a lump in my throat when Rose went to the alternate dimension.

  • awesome video. very intriguing and VERY well edited to go with the music. I love it!!

  • bloody fantastic!

  • The best video I've seen. Great job using the former doctors and their companions with Rose's song. Excellent!!

  • i cried when rose was torn away from the doctor it was so sad!! : .(

  • one of the best videos ive ever seen on youtube! honestly! brilliant!!!!!

  • Although Peri is said to have 'survived' and lived with King Yrcanos, Nicola Bryant herself is highly upset that they did this. She agreed that Peri would not have done so. In Trial the Matrix is so twisted, and it is the MASTER who says that Peri survives... but can you really trust the Master.. or the Matrix..I think not. So Peri's survival.. is highly questionable. Some people think she's dead, some believe she's alive. I believe that character met her demise when Yrcanos blasted her to death

  • Absolutely Amazing! 5 stars and favorited!

  • The saddest goodbye was when Adric was killed. But Personally when Tegan left, I was heartbroken!!

  • Oh, Jamie. *Is broken*

  • brill vid

    b

    r

    i

    i

    l

    5/5

  • this is marvellous

  • It's like Enya, but good.

    Ooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh! Oooooooooooooohhhhhhhhh!  Ooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhh!

    Like you Notsohappi I'm indestructible

    You know, travel does broaden the mind!

    I'll miss you too savage!

  • There should have been 6th Doctor and Peri--who had almost the most dramatic exit (besides Adric and Tegan ie a death..and seeing WAY too much death)....Her body gets switched and she gets executed (although people argue she lives.. it's a good two-way story --did she die.. or does she live...

  • I hate to be the one to tell you this but at the end of Trial of a timelord it is revealed Peri survived and ended living as a warrior queen with King Yrcanos.

  • yeah but can we trust the master because he told the doctor

  • did you ever think of updating this with the recent companions? i really like your video. There should be like a second part...

  • this is a great video. ive never noticed before but th 5th doctors farewells seem to hurt the doctor more than the others

  • i think that is why the time crash with the 5th and 10th really meant something.. since the 10th has had the same problems.

  • where did you get the clips from?

  • Fantastic!

  • i love this song

  • I expected to hate this, but it made the hair on my arms and neck stand on end! Just goes to show how important the music is - if only they could rescore the 1980s episodes...

  • You cant say that!

    The 80's episodes had awesome synth music :)

    This music is all well and good but well, its a bit OTT, I think malcolm clarke or paddy kingsland had the right idea. (Earthshock, Logopolis)

  • Oh my, Adric's death is so angst with that music and loved all those farewells, specially the Savage with the fourth and all of the five doc's farewells, the third with jo was also so emotive, sadly we never saw Ace's farewell with the Doc, hopefully one day we'll know what happened, thanks for the vid.

  • This is AMAZING it makes me cry everytime I see it.

    Hats off to you!!!

  • she did come bak an im realli glad she woz the best companions of all doctor who series donna woz funni tho

  • LOVE IT!!!!!! could you update it if you can... to martha and Donna leaving it would make the video even more AMAZING!!!!!!!! if not dw it's amazing anyway!!!!!

  • I'm crying, sad but true...

  • i love the fact its got all the doctors in it <3

  • Amazing!! This music makes me cry! Love doctor who

  • Very nice job! Did they not show the leaving of Peri? I've never seen how the Doctor leaves Jo Grant... OMG! So subtle yet so sad - what happened there? Did he just leave her for her own good or what?

    You probably didn't need to include Doctor No 8.

    Very nice video.

  • Made me sad.

  • its absolutely fantastic!! it would be great if you included Astrid Jack and of course Martha!!!

  • bloody fantastic!

  • Btw, did you know you were nominated for the DWTW slash awards on livejournal?

  • the what???

  • (Argh, youtube won't let you post links.)

    Ok, go to google, and search 'dwtwslashawards' and click on the first (or second) result.)

    I don't know who nominated you, but you've been nominated for 'Best Group Fanvid' (it's in Section 5, scroll to the bottom of the page, there's a LOT.)

  • ...

    WOW.

    ...

    I give you five stars, but you deserve WAY more.

    This further cements my belief that the character-surprise in S4 is a BIG HUGE MISTAKE. (I don't wanna spoil you, though.)

    Damn, now I feel like crying ... fantastic job!

  • I have seen all of it. (smile)

  • Oh, good! (You never can be sure online ... I offend people so easily, I'm trying not to take any chances.)

    I love Rose, she saved the Doctor from himself, but she had a good, FITTING send-off in 'Doomsday' and I personally think that bringing her back in S4 was a BIG ASS MISTAKE. It just ... it ruins 'Doomsday' and what EXACTLY did Rose do besides tear the walls of reality some more and end up with the random Doctor-Mark-Blue.

  • Fantastic video! I love this song and the clips work so well with it. There really are a lot of goodbyes for the Doctor - it never stops.

  • Great stuff ... I had an idea tho:

    There is some existing video from the end of "The Savages" that shows Steven's leaving scene. Maybe you can use that?

    The scene where Victoria leaves at the end of "Fury from the Deep" would be terrific, if it existed. I watched the recon and it is probably one of the most bittesweet leaving scenes from that era of Who.

    There is also the death of katarina in Dalek Master Plan, the scene where she's flushed out the airlock still exists and would work well.

  • love this music so much :)!

  • Amazing!

  • this is marvellous

  • yeah i agree with the person below me vvvvvvv

    IT IS GREAT THOUGH !!!!!!!

    I LOVE THE DOOMSDAY MUSIC!!!!!!!!

    KEEP MAKING VIDEOS THIS IS GREAT im a HUGE doctor who  fan lol and i have to admit that video is really cool!!!!!! make more XD

  • You should update this with Martha, Jack and Astrid

  • i might be making one with the martha theme with the newer stuff in the near future... right now working on episode #13 of Professor What

  • this is brill 5 star

  • This is fantastic. The music and the clips work perfectly with each other. Very nice.

  • WHERE DO YOU GET THE MUSIC FOR THIS

  • it has not shown what hapond to the amrican companyon with the 7th doctor why???

  • Just what DID happen to Perri? Think i must have missed one!!!! Or perhaps not, does anyone know?

  • Wonderful every time I see this. Are you going to include Martha and Jack as well?

  • I'm back to comment on this properly - all I did last time was moan about Murray Gold (and actually, he's not been bad this year), whereas what I should have said was:

    This is an excellent piece of work - exhaustive and impeccably timed.

    Thanks.

  • i think Adric probaly got the best departure from the series. it was a brilliant episode. didn't detract from the story line, which as much as i like the new series i feel that they sometimes detract from the story (i.e. Doomsday)

    and it was a nice emotional scene, and showed that in all the wonder of the Doctors life. ppl do get killed

  • bloody fucking brilliant.

  • 5/5 its a brilliant vid however there's no Martha or 6th doctor and peri from the trial of a timelord

  • this was made just after runaway bride..so no martha available and as for peri.. i wanted only face to face style goodbyes.. (smile)

  • actually he doesn't say goodbye to catherine tate's character yet (those of you who watched the doctor who episode on scifi liast night at nine) he in fact lets her travel with him

  • wheres the nineth doctor?..i kinda liked him

  • Good question, i liked Chris Ecclestone too but i guess everyone couldn't be fitted in because Colin Baker wasn't there either.

  • The 6th and 9 Doctor didn't have a emotional goodbye for the companions.

  • what happond to the amrican one then

  • She was killed but then it turns out she wasn't killed.

  • IS THAT THE AMRICAN ONE

  • if its peri your talking about then the doctor thought she died but it was a trick by the valiard and she decided to live with a warrior king

  • this is really good its had for the doctor

  • hi you will have to forgive me only started watching in 2005 only have Genesis Of The Daleks and The Movie for classics and every ep of new until series four and VOTD, but is it Brig when Nyssan leaves and fifth goes "no dont leave not like this!" ?

  • That wasn't Nyssa leaving, it was Teagan Jovanka or The Mouth On Legs (aka Janet Fielding), an Aussie character through & through. She was great!

  • may i ask whether u could upload the scene where Jamie and Zoe say goodbye to the Doctor, please???

  • i only had loaded a small bit.. and not the whole thing.. sorry

  • may i ask whether u could upload the scene where Jamie and Zoe say goodbye to the Doctor, please???

  • Why didn't you do Jack?