@969Username He's doing it slowly for you to see the technique. If he did the move in a half-second, you wouldn't be able to react as you would try focused on yourself falling.
@scottith1 well yeah it would be pretty difficult to do that in a real fight, but if somebody gives u a jab and u grab it if u do it quick enough U just "Might" be able to pull it off, lol xD
lol - in think there is no "attack" in aikido likes this :D !
He did a bad job. Do not controle the uke in the rigth way and don't brake his balance as good as he schould. Additional he stand to far away from uke.
I'm very sad about, that we are not able to find a real good shiho nage video on youtube. I think i gonne to post one ;) !
(Sry grammatical errors - a german was writing ;) )
O sensei is probably rolling in his grave at this butchering of his 'twenty year' technique.
It was a cracking good demo of how not to do shihonage;
Upon receiving uke's attack (if you can call it that)you stepped straight into the 'inside' where in reality uke would introduce his left fist to your face!
2)After uke's attack, there was a great deal of movement on your behalf while allowing uke to stand on posture. At no time throughout the entire technique was uke taken off balance.
for example: when he (sensei) hold uke's hand above his hand, if uke has a little bit of brain uke would pull his hand, and then sensei would become uke :)
think about that before you give a grade to comments
P.S. it is only one example, I am beginner and I saw 3 mistakes
The pants are called Hakama, and means that he has a grade at least about 3rd kyu, this differs from different styles though, in some clubs you can't wear them until you have a black belt grade.
He performs this technique very badly actually, you have to have your hands in front of you the whole time, uke could have pulled him backwards very easy.
Even though this is not an "Aikido Move for beginners", he should been able to perform a lot better with a black belt, maybe he just borrowed it...
I have NEVER posted a negative comment about another aikido-ka's aikido before...until I watched these "Expert Village" demos. 1st: you WILL NOT learn an aiki technique from video. 2nd: Unless this guy is much better in person you WILL NOT learn an aikido technique from him. Come on, people. We catch enough flak from non-aikido-ka without stuff like this on the net.
all these aikido videos from "expertvillage" are very embarrassing for the fine art of aikido. This is aikido at its worst (ineffective, not applicable, rigid technique, no attack).
There are many ways of doing me, but this guy puts himself within the rich of nage's left arm. That's a no-no for a blackbelt.
Oh and the uke should deliver an attack. That's the whole point of being the uke. There's no attack in the video, what is he trying to do, correct nage's hair ?
@shihonage So true LOL, I thought Aikido was about stepping OUT of the line of attack not TWISTING yourself out and risking that instant of a possible attempt of an attack.
in this particular technique the instractor only showing the basic move how to apply the shihonage.this tecnique is verry effective spcially when your opponent strike you in a overhead attack.
u know what. Shihonage IS a very effective technique, however i dislike this example, during the course of the move the uke is hardly taken off center balance...the way im taught, as you bring their arm through your center you raise their elbow with yours to keep tension and take them off center.
This is an authentic technique. When done properly, it works. This guy should have used an overhead strike with more intensity. 99% of the time Shiho Nage is is done against an overhead strike. I've been a cop for 14 years and have had to use shihonage several times. It does work.
abso-freakin-lutely. One of the qualities I've noted in true martial arts masters (of whatever style) is HUMILITY. As in, not running others down, and in the process boosting themselves up.
good technique just one thing i dont agree with is the training method demonstration...when the partner comes at him with his arm noone is going to keep their arm straight like that i dont knw if that was a push or shove but in a real situation that kind of push or shove would get u no where and it looks stupid...what im saying is training methods should be as realistic as possible
Too much beer, i think!
ekkenaab 6 months ago
I dont get it.
Why doesn't the other guy use his left arm?
I mean.. wouldn't it be a natural reaction to hit the instructor in the face if he grabs one of your arms?
969Username 10 months ago
@969Username He's doing it slowly for you to see the technique. If he did the move in a half-second, you wouldn't be able to react as you would try focused on yourself falling.
NXPenguinFlutist 10 months ago
How many times does he say 'technique' at the start?
MitchellToren 1 year ago
do disrespect... but LMAO. i would like to see him do that in a real fight. Popcorn at the ready
scottith1 1 year ago
@scottith1 well yeah it would be pretty difficult to do that in a real fight, but if somebody gives u a jab and u grab it if u do it quick enough U just "Might" be able to pull it off, lol xD
Muhaiminahad 1 year ago
this is for begginers, not a demonstration,
anyways it would be helpful if you could make a longer clip and put more details, does Sensei Ronald slide his hands to his opponents wrist?
kenseisato1989 1 year ago
Ok, it's not really good but I think his movements are not as bad as most of you say.
RyuBlade1980 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To see why GSP did not break Hardy's arm copy and paste
"UFC 111 GSP vs. Dan Hardy (Gracie Breakdown)" in search bar
myksgrl 1 year ago
My guess would be none.
watts18269 2 years ago
This here is a horrible way to do me.
shihonage 3 years ago
dang you're fat!how do you do martial arts!no offence
PJRYproductions 3 years ago
what's that shit???????
takaz2 3 years ago
nice lock i didnt know that b4
NmgnSelva 3 years ago
lol - in think there is no "attack" in aikido likes this :D !
He did a bad job. Do not controle the uke in the rigth way and don't brake his balance as good as he schould. Additional he stand to far away from uke.
I'm very sad about, that we are not able to find a real good shiho nage video on youtube. I think i gonne to post one ;) !
(Sry grammatical errors - a german was writing ;) )
TorbenMaMe 3 years ago
Exactly !!
Also no lowering of center...AIKIDO is not valet !! we must lower our center...
joseignacio0104 3 years ago
O sensei is probably rolling in his grave at this butchering of his 'twenty year' technique.
It was a cracking good demo of how not to do shihonage;
Upon receiving uke's attack (if you can call it that)you stepped straight into the 'inside' where in reality uke would introduce his left fist to your face!
2)After uke's attack, there was a great deal of movement on your behalf while allowing uke to stand on posture. At no time throughout the entire technique was uke taken off balance.
aikibrown 3 years ago
thi stinks;
for example: when he (sensei) hold uke's hand above his hand, if uke has a little bit of brain uke would pull his hand, and then sensei would become uke :)
think about that before you give a grade to comments
P.S. it is only one example, I am beginner and I saw 3 mistakes
nix2727 3 years ago
ohhhhh yeahhhh!!
sonofsarek01 3 years ago
I thought it was common knowledge this guy doesnt have a clue what he is doing, and really shouldn't be yudansha no matter what tradition he follows.
Sparrowhawk1138 3 years ago
as you say.. beginners :) you know beginners start very slowly, and ofcourse he is slow... look at his tummy -.-
skunkfood 3 years ago
thers someting coming out of your mouth... its bullshit
bencarloflores 3 years ago
what is this????this is a bullschit!!!!!
Ludobuffon 3 years ago
He is trying to show the technique at slow speed people -.-
He's wearing the blue pants (don't know the name anymore) so he's probably good
skunkfood 3 years ago
The pants are called Hakama, and means that he has a grade at least about 3rd kyu, this differs from different styles though, in some clubs you can't wear them until you have a black belt grade.
He performs this technique very badly actually, you have to have your hands in front of you the whole time, uke could have pulled him backwards very easy.
Even though this is not an "Aikido Move for beginners", he should been able to perform a lot better with a black belt, maybe he just borrowed it...
fxiologist 3 years ago
Ok, that would fail a 6th kyu grading.
ketsan 4 years ago
LAME !
myokai 4 years ago
I have NEVER posted a negative comment about another aikido-ka's aikido before...until I watched these "Expert Village" demos. 1st: you WILL NOT learn an aiki technique from video. 2nd: Unless this guy is much better in person you WILL NOT learn an aikido technique from him. Come on, people. We catch enough flak from non-aikido-ka without stuff like this on the net.
catnip1970 4 years ago
all these aikido videos from "expertvillage" are very embarrassing for the fine art of aikido. This is aikido at its worst (ineffective, not applicable, rigid technique, no attack).
moralapostel 4 years ago
There are many ways of doing me, but this guy puts himself within the rich of nage's left arm. That's a no-no for a blackbelt.
Oh and the uke should deliver an attack. That's the whole point of being the uke. There's no attack in the video, what is he trying to do, correct nage's hair ?
shihonage 4 years ago 4
haha i just realized your screenname is the same as the technique hes showing =]
funnyfunkyfreak 4 years ago
@shihonage So true LOL, I thought Aikido was about stepping OUT of the line of attack not TWISTING yourself out and risking that instant of a possible attempt of an attack.
vxa1314 7 months ago
i'm yellow belt and i can in all honesty do that technique more effectively
adamax9 4 years ago
How embarrassing, and a black belt too...
theolifant 4 years ago
I know exactly what school he's from. And its a total embarrassment to Tomiki. Go watch Tetsuro Nariyama shihan for good tomiki.
shikakubu 4 years ago
in this particular technique the instractor only showing the basic move how to apply the shihonage.this tecnique is verry effective spcially when your opponent strike you in a overhead attack.
csu86 4 years ago
u know what. Shihonage IS a very effective technique, however i dislike this example, during the course of the move the uke is hardly taken off center balance...the way im taught, as you bring their arm through your center you raise their elbow with yours to keep tension and take them off center.
BarakzaiKings 4 years ago
I agree, their is no off-balance, atemi, hakko zemi, or happo no kuzushi...I wonder what style of Aikido this is?
waterbushi 4 years ago
This is an authentic technique. When done properly, it works. This guy should have used an overhead strike with more intensity. 99% of the time Shiho Nage is is done against an overhead strike. I've been a cop for 14 years and have had to use shihonage several times. It does work.
godanp 4 years ago
Armchair experts...how quaint.
watters23 4 years ago 4
abso-freakin-lutely. One of the qualities I've noted in true martial arts masters (of whatever style) is HUMILITY. As in, not running others down, and in the process boosting themselves up.
CTDjevin 4 years ago
good technique just one thing i dont agree with is the training method demonstration...when the partner comes at him with his arm noone is going to keep their arm straight like that i dont knw if that was a push or shove but in a real situation that kind of push or shove would get u no where and it looks stupid...what im saying is training methods should be as realistic as possible
123wingchun123 4 years ago
Its zombie self defense, for when the undead attack... or the very arthritic
witchtemplar 4 years ago