@emik854 yeah! He was even a backup dancer once in Dream High XDD He's somewhere in this vid even though you can't see him thaat well: [Real 2PM] Dream High 촬영장
hope brian comes big in a couple of years time,, same as don. from my opinion,, if brian is gonna make a debut he should re-record this song and make this song big. well just something i thought..
wat wat wat??!!! i dont get this, is this brian kang dude famous [like bigbang famous]??? did he like write this song??? and some1 plz tell me WHO THE HELL ARE 3RD DEGREE???? i've been googling for 1 hr and frankly there isnt actually any reliable source found besides a fb fan page...
btw soz for the loudness cuz im kinda new to this music/band thingo and i got this very nice song off my friends ipod :D
@xd3stineex 3rd degree used to be a group : Terry He, Don Lee, and Brian Kang. They made music videos and songs, and song covers. Yes he did write this song, Brian got accepted to JYP (a famous south korea trainee school (?)) So in a couple of years or less he might be a singer in a group or a solo artist. He is pretty famous I must say. They are not famous as BIG BANG, but they are famous in their own way :]
@Muzik13elieve unbelievable. Just because he is saying Without you... So everyone is copying each other when they say I or You or We or The then. all the songs are plageurism
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! This song just speaks to my heart. Its true that nothing was ever the same without you, it was better..When you broke my heart, I found that m y heart never belonged to in the first place. How can you break something that you never really had?
reminds me of some one. without u never thought any one make me feel this way. i know i shld let u go. with out u with out u i dont wanna leave but guess i hav too with out u. liveing with out u breathing with out u. this song and the words reminds me of some one.
just downloaded the song :) i suspect this will become the most played song on my ipod for a while haha. i hope to see 3rd degree unite someday. and look forward to seeing the new KPOP IDOLS on stage!!!
OMG I had my iPod on shuffle and this song came on (I completely forgot I had this) and I was both shocked and pleasantly surprised at the same time :P AWESOME SONG.. love his voice, hope he and don are doing fine in Korea!
i teared to this songg T_T amazinggg vocals!!! especially those HIgh vocals...those were killer vocals :DD wow. so all the vocals are completely Brian's?? Im kindof confused on that D:
this is amazing. i kno i say tht on a lot of vids[well, actually im prty much the only one who knows...so i probably didnt have to say that....but wutever]but this one is srsly beautiful. i started crying in the beginning and i dunno why. its not cuz i like relate or wutever, cuz i dont. its just beautiful. and befor this i was all sad tht 3rd degree wuz brekaing up so i guess thts also it....
omg, i fell in love with this song as soon as I heard the piano at the beginning. and Brian, you have AMAZING vocals. I can't believe you could do this and you're only 16 years old. I wish u a great career with JYP and can't wait to see when u debut cuz you're definitely going to be the next biggest thing to ever hit kpop! =)
@pooringrain I know they usually have stage names ^^; [ But still, wouldnt you be able to tell by looking at them?] Theyre still in training (I think.) so I guess they still go by Brian and Don lulz :D.
If Brian debut anytime soon, the view count for this video will increase! XD
destiny428 4 days ago
Only 138k views? Damn... It deserves more.
95SilentNINJA 4 weeks ago 2
The piano tune sounds a LOT like Yiruma's River Flows In You. o.o
TheNewJul 1 month ago
@TheNewJul IKR!
copyright...
MizdahChopstik 3 weeks ago
JYP better let them debut soon~
Myrikai 1 month ago 6
@Myrikai wait wait wait
is he in jyp right now
like is he a trainee
omg seriously :D
emik854 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@emik854 yeah! He was even a backup dancer once in Dream High XDD He's somewhere in this vid even though you can't see him thaat well: [Real 2PM] Dream High 촬영장
Myrikai 2 weeks ago
luv it ;p
IHEARTPI710 2 months ago in playlist t-heezy
This is a masterpiece. Keep them coming.
agreatactress 2 months ago
Such a touching song
caligilz 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow ! Love it !
dalee94 2 months ago
I CANT LET CHU GO BACK TO LOL
hjdutch 4 months ago
WITHOUT CHU
hjdutch 4 months ago
this song is amazing <3
cheerios2098 4 months ago
Best luck for you
GabinJo789 4 months ago
cant wait for his debut ^ ^ good luck brian~!
CarmelChocolate100 5 months ago
hope brian comes big in a couple of years time,, same as don. from my opinion,, if brian is gonna make a debut he should re-record this song and make this song big. well just something i thought..
maihlubkoj 5 months ago 24
@maihlubkoj and then we can all be like we knew him from third degree before JYP
The34Show 5 months ago in playlist The34Show's favorites
优美的歌声!
blacksun92 6 months ago
Comment removed
blacksun92 6 months ago
wat wat wat??!!! i dont get this, is this brian kang dude famous [like bigbang famous]??? did he like write this song??? and some1 plz tell me WHO THE HELL ARE 3RD DEGREE???? i've been googling for 1 hr and frankly there isnt actually any reliable source found besides a fb fan page...
btw soz for the loudness cuz im kinda new to this music/band thingo and i got this very nice song off my friends ipod :D
xd3stineex 6 months ago
@xd3stineex 3rd degree used to be a group : Terry He, Don Lee, and Brian Kang. They made music videos and songs, and song covers. Yes he did write this song, Brian got accepted to JYP (a famous south korea trainee school (?)) So in a couple of years or less he might be a singer in a group or a solo artist. He is pretty famous I must say. They are not famous as BIG BANG, but they are famous in their own way :]
PurpleSunshineStable 6 months ago
Comment removed
zhertec 6 months ago
@PurpleSunshineStable ooohhh ok, i get it now thanks!!! and hopefully brian will make it big :D!!!
xd3stineex 6 months ago
@PurpleSunshineStable and Don gotaccepted to JYP too??
rxy2394 5 months ago
Comment removed
rxy2394 5 months ago
@xd3stineex he made a cameo in dream high :)
lovetvxqforever22 4 months ago
@lovetvxqforever22 who was he ??
iSaranghae97 3 months ago
@iSaranghae97 one of the backup dancers for jason's (wooyoung) performance
it was only like 30 seconds
lovetvxqforever22 3 months ago
I like how YouTube is now becoming FaceTube or YouBook with the new features in comments... not important.
THIS SONG IS NUMBER ONE!
thecoolguy555 7 months ago 6
it's been over a year, but i still keep coming back to this song.
hope brian's having a good time at JYP
im gonna be his biggest fangirl when he debuts!
JessHeIsMe 8 months ago 8
without chu?
look at the lyrics im serious
CV8659 8 months ago 2
awesome song
SKULL9669 8 months ago
this song is so beautiful !
i feel like crying when i heard it )':
can't wait to see brian and don debut ! :D
xStarlitee 8 months ago
Comment removed
xStarlitee 8 months ago
Guh, I hope they debut soon, I'm getting so anxious to see them!!
ForeverCellist 9 months ago 7
<3 BRIAN KANG<3 i love you.
please debut soon, i cant take this anymore,
I CANT WAIT FOR THE DAY YOU DEBUT<3
xXAznRockersXx 9 months ago 14
the instrumental intro reminds me of Wedding Dress - Taeyang, but I still like it :]
==xsapphireskies
XxmoondustxX 9 months ago
Comment removed
XxmoondustxX 9 months ago
Comment removed
XxmoondustxX 9 months ago
Comment removed
XxmoondustxX 9 months ago
I hate when people "cover" the video screen with a link. Like, everytime I go to press play I go the link -__- lol.
Iwishonedayy 9 months ago
man i wish sing this song
lilcool132 10 months ago
I wish this song was on iTunes
S3r1alN0 10 months ago
Good luck and all the best...
you are really amazing...
:) <3
emilyczern 10 months ago
I'm completely addicted to this song.
GermDisaster 11 months ago 7
i have to agree wit ha comment that it sounds like wedding dress a little that i compare the sound
toybirdy 11 months ago
"chu" inspired by Wonder Girl's "nobody, nobody but chu" or F(x)'s "do it do it chu~ it's chu~ chu~ chu~ chu~"
Muzik13elieve 11 months ago
@Muzik13elieve wtf?? he just says without you, it can't be inspired by someone
belcikaliyasemin 10 months ago
@belcikaliyasemin i meant how Koreans who hear the song Nobody were always emphasizing on "Chu" like Perez Hilton.
Muzik13elieve 10 months ago
@Muzik13elieve unbelievable. Just because he is saying Without you... So everyone is copying each other when they say I or You or We or The then. all the songs are plageurism
jthengtang 10 months ago
@jthengtang LOL Chill' i was just pointing the "chu~" part out. I'm not a hater. I don't hate this song. It's not like i'm bashing them or anything.
Muzik13elieve 10 months ago
@Muzik13elieve No it's inspired by a dota/hon/lol player chu
hjdutch 4 months ago
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! This song just speaks to my heart. Its true that nothing was ever the same without you, it was better..When you broke my heart, I found that m y heart never belonged to in the first place. How can you break something that you never really had?
MrDatman88 11 months ago 4
Love this song! <3333333333333
have it on replay on my iTunes @_@;
Miss 3rd Degree & Brian T__T
lilmandyx3 11 months ago 4
the beginning sounds like river flows in you
luvoanime 1 year ago 3
....this song is amazing............
punkyfish2009 1 year ago 2
I LOVED THIS SONG AS SOON AS I HEARD IT LAST YR. i cant believe it's been so much time since this song was made.. <3
supersunshiine 1 year ago
Miss Brian :(
destiny428 1 year ago 2
its been 8 months since he left.... :'(
babyshaay 1 year ago 3
"Without chuuuuuuuuu" x3 !
RudeLemon 1 year ago
:) ...
Thuy111 1 year ago
Omg Brian...
I discovered 3rd dregree so late: Today... And you guys are already gone.
Brian you're going to be my new bias ;) Fighting<3 I'll look out for you and the other members too!
People like you and 3rd degree make us want to reach for our goals.
paaandaaaflaaff123 1 year ago 5
OMGGG...
Can't stop listening to this songg...<3
Briann Fightinngg...
Goodluck in JYP..=D
You really got talent..
ngolee 1 year ago
OMGGG...
Can't stop listening to this songg...<3
Briann Fightinngg...
Goodluck in JYP..=D
ngolee 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hi guys, please check out the music video that my friends and I made for this song! I just posted it in the Video Responses, thanks and enjoy!
sushi726 1 year ago
This is amazing, and I love it so much <3
TheLoneDevil 1 year ago
same chords and instrumentation as wedding dress-taeyang? really original dude.
alchen162 1 year ago
This song is so beautiful:) I love Brian so much!!! I miss him and 3rd Degree!!
SamanthaNicole49 1 year ago
Good luck in JYP!
KevHuyn 1 year ago
Wow! I am amazed! This sounds so good!
ElizYaj 1 year ago
BRB, raping the replay button. (:
kpopismyheaven 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
1.put ur middle finger on ur nose
2. Say the name of the person u luv
3. U will be asked out by dat person or kissed by dem 2moro
For dis 2 work post it on 2 Otha pages.
phengxiong15 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1.put ur middle finger on ur nose
2. Say the name of the person u luv
3. U will be asked out by dat person or kissed by dem 2moro
For dis 2 work post it on 2 Otha pages.
SuDbUd99 1 year ago
Everytime i listen to this.. I miss her really much.. I cant live love without chu..
BboySynthesis 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1.put your middle finger on your nose
2.say the name of the person you love
3.that person will say i love you or ask you out 2moro
4.post this on two other videos for it to work
:')
bc123132123132 1 year ago
reminds me of some one. without u never thought any one make me feel this way. i know i shld let u go. with out u with out u i dont wanna leave but guess i hav too with out u. liveing with out u breathing with out u. this song and the words reminds me of some one.
lottie1712 1 year ago
just downloaded the song :) i suspect this will become the most played song on my ipod for a while haha. i hope to see 3rd degree unite someday. and look forward to seeing the new KPOP IDOLS on stage!!!
aegyoSB 1 year ago 85
So beautiful song ♥
Yumehito57 1 year ago 33
I can imagine in another year or so, this video views will shoot up kazillion XD
destiny428 1 year ago
i love this song a lot. i love you so much Brian !! we wish you make a dream !!
virtuegather 1 year ago 4
ahhhh!!!!! i love this song already!! Brian!!! i love you!!
memorymoua 1 year ago 6
hi everybody~ i am a freshman here^^
nice to meet you all^^
Brian's song is aweasome^^
even 3rd Degree was disband~
but full support to them^^
ashleyiloveu 1 year ago
U gotta love this song. i was hoping that 3rd degree was gonna make an album. but i guess its not happenin.....
kenlee93 1 year ago
its sad and there should be a music video awww this brings back memories...but I LOVE IT!! KEEP IT GOING!!
alwaisehavelovenyou 1 year ago
awwh love this song...so sad :(
ninakikwang100 1 year ago
aww I really miss Brian ..... (T_T)
SprnkldPANCAKE 1 year ago
Guys, many songs have this 4 chords order, so it is not strange that some piano parts sound pretty familiar.
RavensysteM 1 year ago
OMG I had my iPod on shuffle and this song came on (I completely forgot I had this) and I was both shocked and pleasantly surprised at the same time :P AWESOME SONG.. love his voice, hope he and don are doing fine in Korea!
supersunshiine 1 year ago
Whenever i miss Brian, i come here.
RokuoVideos 1 year ago 4
:/ hate to admit it but i miss 3rd degree<33
indieecouture 1 year ago 4
@indieecouture im proud to say it tat i miss 3rd degree. :(
kenlee93 1 year ago
haha~where can I get the music background of this song~.~!
AngloIrish1989 1 year ago
first part sounds familiar ;p GOOD SONG STILL (^_^b)b
iflyouup 1 year ago
@iflyouup its the piano part for river flows in you by yiruma
jelobes 1 year ago
first time hearing this.. omb, brian's voice gives me the chills o.o . gah, this is so effin' amazing(:
BriiCakee 1 year ago 3
THIS IS AMAZING!! <3 I love it! Go Brian!
rinsohma107 1 year ago
I dont approve of this.. taking river flows in you for intro without giving credit..
watermel0n123 1 year ago
@watermel0n123 well then maybe you should listen carefully retard. it's not exactly the same
blahblahblahblahblec 1 year ago
Legit. :]
TheAsianGuitar 1 year ago
This song is very very good, lyrics wise as well as melody. 5*
MrAriun 1 year ago
replayed this like 50 times
love it :)
dashou52 1 year ago
Comment removed
MANDKAN13 1 year ago
i love this song. <3
LalaisaznHaha 1 year ago
lol the piano is yiruma's river flows in you
LittleStickfigure 1 year ago 2
@LittleStickfigure
its not, it just sounds like it. (:
TheAsianGuitar 1 year ago
its like withoutchu so it sounds kinda funny but it is still really good
FurryFluffball 1 year ago
There's Without You by 2PM, Without You by U-Kiss, and it's just my opinion but this is my favourite. Without You by Brian Kang.
SakuraHanaB 1 year ago 6
Wow.
Brian is <3
Wowwwwww.
He's so talented :D
SakuraHanaB 1 year ago
what? sounds so much like river flows in you!
watermel0n123 1 year ago 2
repose you from your stress yet julie???
MrTubbymunkins 1 year ago
Woww this is so good..
KiyoSmerfy 1 year ago
Comment removed
FragileHearts 1 year ago
Piano sounds like a Yiruma song.
munkymp3 1 year ago 6
Love love love! I'm glad that JYP signed Brian :) hwaiting! all the best! -3
MissYT941 1 year ago
LUV THIS SONG!
srk65girl2 1 year ago
does someone have the piano sheet musik?? if you have could you please send it to me in a PM.... omg its sooo beuatifulll <333333
letiic 1 year ago
the begining sounds like twilights lulaby..
denizkilic 1 year ago
I luve this song it makes me wanna cry everytime
loverofnigahiga 1 year ago
earrrrgassmmm<3
TheBlueHummingbird 1 year ago
omg i listen to this over and over about 100 times a day
whitedog2k9 1 year ago
link doesnt work :(
thr333zy 1 year ago
i teared to this songg T_T amazinggg vocals!!! especially those HIgh vocals...those were killer vocals :DD wow. so all the vocals are completely Brian's?? Im kindof confused on that D:
Lamppostshines 1 year ago
wow! you're really good. I'm so in luv with this song. great job!
yozo217 1 year ago
you were very worthy to make it in to JYP
jn926 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Your amazing. Have you gone Pro yet??
redroonie 1 year ago
Your amazing. Have you gone Pro yet?
redroonie 1 year ago
river flows in you.
andyyang3 1 year ago 2
ahhh..OMG i am going to be your number one fan. you guys are really awesome
mitsukiwong13 1 year ago
I Love This SOnng <3
lovexcandii137 1 year ago
wow
UR VERY TALENT
nkaujhmoobhaam 1 year ago
AMAZINGG:)
llklkstrawberry 1 year ago
ilovethissong...
f4k3truth 1 year ago
this is amazing. i kno i say tht on a lot of vids[well, actually im prty much the only one who knows...so i probably didnt have to say that....but wutever]but this one is srsly beautiful. i started crying in the beginning and i dunno why. its not cuz i like relate or wutever, cuz i dont. its just beautiful. and befor this i was all sad tht 3rd degree wuz brekaing up so i guess thts also it....
soccerDITTOetc935 1 year ago
omg, i fell in love with this song as soon as I heard the piano at the beginning. and Brian, you have AMAZING vocals. I can't believe you could do this and you're only 16 years old. I wish u a great career with JYP and can't wait to see when u debut cuz you're definitely going to be the next biggest thing to ever hit kpop! =)
xAthrunx93 1 year ago 4
Oh gosh, I totally love this song ö
Brian you're awesome, love your voice and love the lyric <3
Kawaiitje 1 year ago
AHH! I can't listen do this anymore..it makes me sad that 3rd Degree's over. But I'm looking forward to see the new JYP stars.. ;)
licara123 1 year ago 132
@licara123 u know how they usually have stage names. what are their names now?
pooringrain 1 year ago
@pooringrain I know they usually have stage names ^^; [ But still, wouldnt you be able to tell by looking at them?] Theyre still in training (I think.) so I guess they still go by Brian and Don lulz :D.
licara123 1 year ago
@pooringrain it's third degree
virtuegather 1 year ago
fuck the 5 dislikes!!!!!
SHINeeLoveTillTheEnd 1 year ago
Wow, this song is amazing. I love the melody =) Continue with you hard work!
mschocco91 1 year ago
hey do you have instrumentals for this?? love itttttt~
rainyseas0n 1 year ago
i keep listening to thisss...
AHAH i miss third degree :(
TEMPORARY5683 1 year ago 155
@TEMPORARY5683 wait what happen to third degree?
flysnake12 1 year ago
damn its soo good, i just wish you had the lyrics for this as well
LP4EVER250 1 year ago
@LP4EVER250 it's in the description box
musiqlove77 1 year ago
Omg brian i love u <33333 thats all i have to say xD
xoHockeyPlayaox 1 year ago 3
this is amazing, in fact a whole lot more than that.
poshnsheek 1 year ago
I've been listening to this for the last hour.
Its so good! :)
ohshnapitsrameen 1 year ago 3
I love your voice, Brian! Sounds like Kpop, haha. You should sing it in Korean, would sound great too!
ey1987 1 year ago 2
awesome song, the screaming in the back sound like MJ, but still love this song
DarkAngels590 1 year ago
guess im too addicted to this song
AznCookii 1 year ago
you are so good
cutie3208 1 year ago
I think you need to make an MV for this .. even if it's a homemade one . :)
HolyShhharon 1 year ago 6
makeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee a musiicccccccc video XD
i3atC00ki3s 1 year ago 3
woow this so sad jsut like korean songs cool im crying its soo cool keep it up brian
GDG4EVERH44 1 year ago
its amazing i love you guys!! brian i love your voice very much.... keep up the good work!!
bykuaya 1 year ago 2
I can totally see this a kpop.
nickjonasbigfan 1 year ago 3
woooow this pic is soo wonderfull
SandyIgnalski 1 year ago
now i know what it sounds like @ the beginning; Yiruma - River Flows In You
...only a little; but yeah (:
maybe on a lower scale.
burst808 1 year ago
@burst808 i thought that too but it's still an awesome song ^^
inspirations are a magical thing ^^
dramaluv911 1 year ago
This awesome song needs a music video to go with it. (:
Floris951 1 year ago 5
this sounds great a lot better than the other shit these days
in0n0myname 1 year ago 2
Awh, good luck in sing for your heart.
I bet lots of people will come to see you. (: LMFAO - this song sounds so azn pop. xP
xnameissarahx 1 year ago 3
this is catchy fasho....
nyx926 1 year ago
i like this song but i feel like itz copying wedding dress..it sounds very similar...
chocobearX 1 year ago
this sounds like the original Apologize (one republic) + Big Bang = upgrade = 3D! haha.. nice!! Keep it up =3
ShancQ 1 year ago
okay this is like the greatest song like everrrrr =] i heard it today for the first time and i loveeddd it. make a video?
xloveablemex26 1 year ago
song sounds like soo korean in english hurrhurr i dont think a america band would ever make a song like this and sounds o:
toybirdy 1 year ago 3
i say u make a video
XskillzdatzkillzX 1 year ago 2
I make beats and this song has inspired me so much you guys are like hella awesome XD if you guys ever work on a song with me holla at me xD
oniflores 1 year ago
Brian, this is your best work. :]
I really love the song! I'm so downloading it to my cellphone.
You should totally make a MusicVideo for this. Hehee, you don't have to, but I think that'd be really cool.
Anyways, I couldn't imagine Brian singing this, it sounds so different than when you sang Billionaire with Terry&Don. <3
Keep it up, H`waiting(:
xAyuka 1 year ago