Amazing. Simply amazing. I don't know if this is Beatles or not (I hope this is from The Beatles). Some say this is Pink Floyd's. Some other say this is from The Pretty Things or White Trash, but if it's not from any of them, I just can say these guys had a lot of future and shouldn't have given up.
Amazing how many 1970s-80s BEATLES BOOTLEG books claimed this to be a real Beatles outtake (along with PINK LIPNIS PAPER TEST). At the time before CDs, almost NOTHING had leaked out of Abbey road studios. So fans were willing to accept anything as BEATLES outtakes. I dont think it sounds at all like the Beatles, tho I could see it being by Pink Floyd, didnt find it worth recording. Bizarre overdubbing on this version.
So, we've orchestrated it, now! Nice attempt, but it's better accoustic. I just wish somebody could do something with the speed increses. I'm told this is not them, but a group of non-Beatles that tried to sound like them one night around a campfire. Glen Campbell, at least one of the Bee Gee's and a few other people I don't remember. But, my ears tell me this IS The Beatles!
@RedVynil Nobody knows who did it. There's no hard evidence behind any possible origin. Hell, it was released originally under a vinyl bootleg from a now defunct bootleg record label. We don't even have the damn tape itself. If we did, it would a cinch proving or disproving the Beatles theory. My guess is, it's probably long gone.
If this is real, it sounds like one of those Jeff Lynne productions. He did the Anthology newbees and I personally don't like his morbid productions. The are downers
@capitolemiproducer This was originally a bootleg of unknown origin that circulated around during the mid 70's. The overdubs were added by a third party; it was originally just an acoustic demo.
Does anyone know the origin of the overdubs, whoever did it did a clever little job, especially beat matching the pitch shifts! Would love a high quality mp3 of this!
@Jeremyrishe Actually, yes. According to the Wikipedia page, whenever Paul, Ringo or George Martin (Their sound producer) were asked about this song (Using either of the titles), they said it doesn't ring any bells.
Regardless, even if this isn't Beatles, it's still one great piece of music!
I freaking love the beatles, and I know they bring happiness and that's why they were put on this earth, but for some reason, there is always a sad feeling to it as well. Im not sure why, whether its because of how happy and joyful they were and the fact that only paul and ringo exist. or that the good memories may not carry on and on forever. that way, way into the future, people wont feel the same was as me, or feel the same way as people did in the 60s. the excitment
This made a lousy song even lousier. My theory is that it may be the group that Bill Wyman was producing at the time called "The End". in 1968, Apple put out an advert for people to send in their recordings and that's why it was found in 1970 in the trash after a housecleaning. I doubt that it was John and George messing around in John's home studio in Sep. 1966.
stop complaining, this is pure psychedelic! whether its really by the beatles or however the quality is in the beggining has nothing to do with anything. its perfect..
Amazing. Simply amazing. I don't know if this is Beatles or not (I hope this is from The Beatles). Some say this is Pink Floyd's. Some other say this is from The Pretty Things or White Trash, but if it's not from any of them, I just can say these guys had a lot of future and shouldn't have given up.
szmty 3 days ago
yea whats up with the cars @0:59?
elotrain 4 weeks ago
Good song, don't get me wrong. But it's not The Beatles. Voices are for sure not the guys.
mccartney2006 1 month ago
Comment removed
billywhitewolf 1 month ago
Que buen tema! Beatles forever
NacPop66 1 month ago
Amazing how many 1970s-80s BEATLES BOOTLEG books claimed this to be a real Beatles outtake (along with PINK LIPNIS PAPER TEST). At the time before CDs, almost NOTHING had leaked out of Abbey road studios. So fans were willing to accept anything as BEATLES outtakes. I dont think it sounds at all like the Beatles, tho I could see it being by Pink Floyd, didnt find it worth recording. Bizarre overdubbing on this version.
anti666luv 2 months ago
good song
jagexfanbag 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
So, we've orchestrated it, now! Nice attempt, but it's better accoustic. I just wish somebody could do something with the speed increses. I'm told this is not them, but a group of non-Beatles that tried to sound like them one night around a campfire. Glen Campbell, at least one of the Bee Gee's and a few other people I don't remember. But, my ears tell me this IS The Beatles!
RedVynil 3 months ago
@RedVynil Nobody knows who did it. There's no hard evidence behind any possible origin. Hell, it was released originally under a vinyl bootleg from a now defunct bootleg record label. We don't even have the damn tape itself. If we did, it would a cinch proving or disproving the Beatles theory. My guess is, it's probably long gone.
TheBoldImperator 2 months ago
@TheBoldImperator Well thats why it says "Un known artiest" LOL
KingAbacus2009 1 month ago
If they had released this on an album, it would have increased their awesomeness through the ceiling.
WanagiAkicita 4 months ago
The overdubs are by iamaphoney - a great musician and a troll spreading Paul is dead desease
turtlliwdnifuoyehthr 4 months ago
面白い！
MrPetsounds1966 4 months ago
If this is real, it sounds like one of those Jeff Lynne productions. He did the Anthology newbees and I personally don't like his morbid productions. The are downers
capitolemiproducer 4 months ago
@capitolemiproducer This was originally a bootleg of unknown origin that circulated around during the mid 70's. The overdubs were added by a third party; it was originally just an acoustic demo.
TheBoldImperator 2 months ago
Too bass-y to be a Beatles song. Martin never mixed bass like that. Nice try tho.
bobomacinsquash 5 months ago
Nice, Mr Starky...sounds like ur drummin alright...it does.
GPa2010 6 months ago
0:43
Where did you get that moving abbey road?
lucaalbano8 7 months ago
@lucaalbano8 Its from the Beatles 2009 Remasters commercial.
larryinc64 4 months ago
@larryinc64 Really? And how that CD named?
galialma 3 months ago
@galialma Sorry, wrong source its actually It's from the Mini-Documentary from the box set. /watch?v=RT7ax5-C4W at 0:15.
larryinc64 3 months ago
@galialma OK. Thanks
galialma 3 months ago
If this is really a Beatles song, then, there's no doubt about it, it's their worst!
ENACODNOM 9 months ago
@ENACODNOM they have never ever claimed this. Sounds like something they would have tried, but maybe they were so embarrased they never claimed it.
SubMetal1000 8 months ago
Who overdubbed this?
ABBEYROADSTUDIO9 10 months ago
The rock music added to the demo reminds me of the 1996 beatle sessions, the backing production sounds a lot like "Now And Then"
musicelliott 10 months ago
"One feels it almost instantly, unless one of us died."
AUGUSTOursscccp 11 months ago 9
@AUGUSTOursscccp thats whAT the song says and without rehearsing it
MJBSAMMYGz 5 months ago
Does anyone know the origin of the overdubs, whoever did it did a clever little job, especially beat matching the pitch shifts! Would love a high quality mp3 of this!
patrickjohnjackman 1 year ago
Damn, cool video, whatever this is
Yoshi5020 1 year ago
Has anyone ever bothered to ask the Beatles themselves if this is there song or not? Wouldn't they have an idea.
Jeremyrishe 1 year ago
@Jeremyrishe Actually, yes. According to the Wikipedia page, whenever Paul, Ringo or George Martin (Their sound producer) were asked about this song (Using either of the titles), they said it doesn't ring any bells.
Regardless, even if this isn't Beatles, it's still one great piece of music!
DingoWalley01 11 months ago
i love the Beatles
marietoe15toe 1 year ago
@pdorn777 no shit
NowhereManStudios 1 year ago
it`s pretty simillar to pink floyd`s brain damage
k0stil 1 year ago
this video is awesome!!!
I freaking love the beatles, and I know they bring happiness and that's why they were put on this earth, but for some reason, there is always a sad feeling to it as well. Im not sure why, whether its because of how happy and joyful they were and the fact that only paul and ringo exist. or that the good memories may not carry on and on forever. that way, way into the future, people wont feel the same was as me, or feel the same way as people did in the 60s. the excitment
llpowers 1 year ago
@llpowers of the beatles wont last forever.
sorry for rambling on and on.. does anyone feel the same way? i dont even know if i am making any sense right now.
llpowers 1 year ago
This made a lousy song even lousier. My theory is that it may be the group that Bill Wyman was producing at the time called "The End". in 1968, Apple put out an advert for people to send in their recordings and that's why it was found in 1970 in the trash after a housecleaning. I doubt that it was John and George messing around in John's home studio in Sep. 1966.
bigbadm1 1 year ago
At the time this came out in the late 70s many beatle fans knew it was not the beatles at all. and to this it is NOT THE BEATLES
JPGRNG 1 year ago
Sorry...doesn't sound like the Beatles. Not just that it's unfamiliar, it doesn't sound "Beatlesque".
stpetric 1 year ago
Recovered in a trash bin? I can see why.
xvoy2002 1 year ago
damn!
have anybody asked paul or ringo?
k0stil 1 year ago
How is nobody mentioning the blatant (and kinda cool) modern overdubs on this version?
reverendflash 1 year ago
check out my combo breaker
GnikNusEht 1 year ago
Remember Paul saying that you were one of the best drummers there is.....Carry that weight of the world.....
magnusdering 2 years ago
RT: its true you can convert this clip into an mp3 or mp4 on that site mp4ify. google mp4ify! awesome!
minazahazazugemo 2 years ago
stop complaining, this is pure psychedelic! whether its really by the beatles or however the quality is in the beggining has nothing to do with anything. its perfect..
Hoohaz 2 years ago
Paul corpse nonesense again lol
beatleandy1 2 years ago
the subliminal message junk just makes the video trippy and enjoyable. its all about the song though... i love it all
Hoohaz 2 years ago
If this was really an unreleased Beatles recording recovered from a trash container it would still be a studio tape of studio quality.
LODGE4444 2 years ago
is it exit or re-enter?
GnikNusEht 2 years ago
what is that very together thing??????
jsebastianst 2 years ago
Watch Paul McCartney has a joke on my channel thanks
GlennRoaming 2 years ago
there will never be a beatles reunion as long as john remains dead
GnikNusEht 2 years ago
...you make it sound like he has a choice!
hopebgood 1 year ago
@GnikNusEht Not to mention George
Talalay99 1 year ago
the song sounds great
sanguine111 2 years ago 9
I thought this was debunked years ago. Can't tell if it's really them since the sound quality is so horrIble.
LODGE4444 2 years ago
i thought so too...
MikeyNL1038 2 years ago
nice vid
deadboyrunning 2 years ago