Added: 5 years ago
From: wwwMeccaCentricCom
Views: 18,653
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (52)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • scribd (dot) com/nb812 

  • 0.36 - 1.20 Exactly the point, me personally i ascrib to the salaf aqeedah, but he is right so many young muslim brother who aclaim to the salaf aqeedah have that problem, they think their qadhi or mujtahid just like Sh. Abdal hamik Murad explain.

    Even salafi scholars Like dr. bilal philips who i have great respect, say the same thing( it can be found Difference Between Salafiyyah and the Neo-Salafis.

    I don't want no replay regarding my comment just study the deen with good intention.

  • Looks like a dick, sounds like a dick, is a dick. Mad Tim Winter.

    Tim Minchin is more entertaining, talks and sings more sense and his 'fancy dress' is more attractive.

    Allah hu akbah and humbug.

    Islam is banal and an insult to a universe which has evolved into consciousness of itself.

    There is nothing supernatural nature is super enough.

    The rest is superstitious nonsense for the likes of 'Sheik' Tim Winter to make a living from- and sound 'deep' and 'knowledgeable' and sincere. A dick !

  • In attacking Tim Winter you have revealed far more about yourself than you have done of the person you are attacking. That you are cowardly, narrow minded, and deeply prejudiced is revealed in your offensive tirade against Mr Winter. Cowardly, because it is easy to abuse people when you are safely secreted by the internet; narrow minded, because you attack a religion which has fed and nourished a whole civilization possessing depth; and prejudiced, because you cannot see the validity of...

  • @bayreuth79 Can you remind me what it is Tim is an expert on? Oh yes. Arcane mythologised historically unverifiable oft plagiarised mumbo jumbo, selected hadith, based on faith rather than evidence. Apart from a few so called 'Golden centuries' themselves heavily mythologised, Islam has been bloody, violent and oppressive for millions for centuries, Every Muslim country is corrupt, backward split and stuck. You may be deluded by proxy of your expert in mumbo jumbo -TIm- the rest of us aren't

  • @CorporalNym PS. How does Tim know what God wants? Is he in conference with Mr. God? Does he get messages? Arcane archaic mumbo jumbo complete with its secret language, argot, mumbo jumbo.

  • If you believe what you say it is your task to prove what you claim, but of course that would require an erudition that you lack. It is easy to make any number of unfounded assertions, but difficult to back up what you claim with cogent evidence. I think we both know that you cannot prove that Islam amounts to "mumbo jumbo" because if you could you would go into print and enlighten us all. Curiously as with many of your ilk, you are so convinced of your own opinions that evidence is superfluous

  • @bayreuth79 Its all been done before by many, yes more erudite than me and probably you.

    Try Ibn Warraq's WHY I AM NOT A MUSLIM for a start. Islam is based upon superstition and the supernatural. There is nothing supernatural. Clearly you believe there is. So you prove it to me, the onus is upon you not me. I don't believe in mumbo jumbo. Islam does not reflect reality. If only belief and truth were the same thing. But they are not. Tim is a priest in a large cult and has wasted his life.

  • The difference between you and I is that I can see the cogency of arguments on both sides of the atheist/theist divide. Things just aren't as obvious as you seem to suggest. You say that the onus is on me- that is reasonable enough-; but it seems to me that it is also on you as well, if you are going to deny the supernatural outright and allow no possibility for it whatsoever. Why not? What distinguishes you from an agnostic, who simply says he doesn't know? I need to know how you know...

  • @bayreuth79 The difference between you and I is; you are open to the supernatural. I am not. Prayer does not fix toothache.

  • You assume that because people have put forward seemingly coherent arguments against Islam & the supernatural, that these arguments are really cogent. With respect, you forget that many intelligent and erudite people can put forward counter-arguments no less convincing. Personally, I think you can make a good cumulative argument for the existence of God certainly no less convincing than the atheist argument. Look at, Denys Turner, Swinburne, Keith Ward. All top academics... 

  • @bayreuth79 It is obvious . There is nothing supernatural. Nature is super enough. Is nature not enough for you? You want more than there is? What kind of 'spiritual materialism' are you involved in. Is this universe not enough for you that you need magic as well? Islam is mumbo jumbo all religions are, Islam slightly more so. There are no arguments for the supernatural, there is lots of rhetoric, but there is a desire for the comforting delusion it provides.The desire is the problem.

  • ... a different worldview.

    

  • @bayreuth79 An inaccurate world view. Islam does not reflect reality.

  • If that is the case, demonstrate that what you claim is true. Most importantly of all, actually read and study before you make wild, unverifiable claims.

  • Comment removed

  • well im a muslim and i know you have to believe in god and his prophet, but we shouldnt judge people on their beliefs and the best thing to be as a person is a good and honest one, so you should be happy that you are a good person, but still read about islam and try and learn more you will be surprised because islam is a beautiful religion and this man is a good example and the best example is the beloved prophet mohammad (pbuh)

  • @awesomewelles90 lol, your question is amusing.. in the first place, does an atheist believe in heaven?

  • I don't think this man get the appreciation he deserves, he is a true genius of our time and of the Muslim world.

  • @Omer698: I think his adherence to Sufism and Scholasticism is a reason why he is not appreciated by the Salafis. The Salafi thinkers have got very strong voice in Sunni Muslim lands. I am a little bit surprised at his too much adherence and obedience to the legacy of the middle-age tradition while he came with western background. But no doubt, he is an appreciable thinker and speake. In most cases he is far more better than the prominant Salafis.

  • @Omer698

    "he is a true genius of our time"

    How so? He says nothing worthwhile. He is simply asserting his god exists and bolsters that will all kind of fancy-sounding mumbo-jumbo. He is the Muslim equivalent of William Lane Craig

  • True Muslim Scholar and typical English lecturer!

  • Islam is Shura, no matter the Ijthihaad (I think). JazaakAllah khair for this wonderful explanation, Sheikh Murad!

  • Amazing scholar..finally came out of england..love his speeches..

  • Dear Shaykh Abdal Hakim Murad, I am very much thankfull for your amazing speeches. I was wondering how can I purchase them and also I was wondering if you organize any open lectures, I would love to attend them. May Allah bless you.

  • Many people will look it as my superstition but earliar in the evening I was thinking what it is that Allah wants from us and fortunately I find this video which say pure hearts and good intention which I think I should resolve to, May Allah bless all the beleivers with his mercy and Afiya.

  • أشهد أن لا إله إلا الله , اشهد ان محمد رسول الله صلى الله عليه و سلم.

  • Hello Friend

    Fear God..Bring your proof where is allah said kill?

    peace

  • PEACE BE ON YOU ALL!

    Shaykh Abdal Hakim Murad is genius. He is a muslim well known scholar. Undoubtedly one of the most influential Muslim thinkers alive today. He is a translator of Hadith, and teacher. Equally conversant in both traditional Islamic scholarship and Western thought and civilization. One of the mystifying capabilities of the human brain is embodied in the genius. He is genius and is an individual with astounding creative talents and distinguished mental abilities.

    GREAT JOB

  • Absolutely.

    Completely agree.

    He is one of the most impressive and incredible scholars of our time, without a doubt.

    A true 'Islamic Scholar', rather than just Muslim scholar if you know what I mean. Huge asset to the Muslims of today.

  • the brother is too smart to understand..unless i really pay attention. mash'Allah

  • because they are not all true, some are diluted

  • brilliant.

    May Allah Bless you.

  • mashallah so learned

  • I've this video - ordered it from meccacentric. very powerful video. it brings calmness and a peace of mind to you. JZK

  • ALLAH BLESS AMERICA!

  • I totally agree, Allah bless America for being against communism and atheism and guide the Americans to truth InschaAllah.

  • Amen!

  • Hey, i'm a muslim and a marxist so where do i fit in into this bigoted Ummah eh?

  • Islam has it's own system. It is not extreme capitalism, i.e. get what you can at the expense of others, and it is not extreme socialism, i.e. everyone will get same share no matter if someone works harder than someone else. Islam encourages business and bersonal betterment WITH social responsibility - it is sort of the middle way. So if you are Muslim, you really can't be Marxist. If you are Marxist, then maybe you are Mu'min instead of Muslim? But, who am I to judge. No offence intended. Peace

  • Good message. He reminds me of an Elf of LOTR with his ears! (That IS a compliment!)

  • Nice, concise message, thankyou jazakallah brother. and May Allah (swt) reward you for the upload :)

  • masha'allah

  • very nice brother

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more