I liked this, but unfortunately, she doesn't even come close to the stage presence Sa Dingding has. She also simplified a lot of the trills (or removed them completely) to suit her own voice, effectively dulling down the song, and taking out that interesting ethical element.
I'm going to have to say that Sa Dingding comes out above this in every way, including wardrobe (those pants look ridiculous).
I agree with you. This doesn't even come close to Sa Dingding's, especially the high parts where she suddenly just diminishes her volume, probably because she doesn't have the air to support her. However, the real problem is that she totally did not understand this song.
不咋的
SherrySilverW 3 weeks ago
没那种感觉....
wangtingxt 1 month ago
唱得不行。
xiaotianlang 2 months ago
音不准,跑了好几个,而且高音不高,低音低不下来,简直太差了
pommeying 5 months ago
萨顶顶和她比起来就是一个女王,这个给人家提鞋都不够格
pommeying 5 months ago
就俺觉得她唱得比原唱好听嘛。。。不一样的感觉,可能欣赏不了萨顶顶的版本,觉得太装了。。
tinaxin 11 months ago
呼吸好困难的感觉,萨顶顶肺活量好大!
pamorj 11 months ago
比起原唱来,她唱就是一垃圾
xuxiao100 1 year ago
没唱上去啊。。。不够给力=,=
mime262 1 year ago
這歌令人呼吸困難
johndaveli 1 year ago
这首歌还真蛮适合黄英的。
pingyuan130 1 year ago
我也是先从这里先听到的这首歌,后来听到萨顶顶的。郁可唯的确没唱出那种空灵的感觉,这歌就是高胖胖制作的,他当然听得出唱得上不上道
wangyt101 1 year ago 2
很不错啊。有她自己的一种特别的味道。
selfplaying 1 year ago
真的唱得不好,紧张,没气,一点也不响亮,差点听不到她唱什么~!!!钟舒淇的版本比她好~!!因为声音能进到麦克风里~!!!郁可唯加油吧~!!这首歌透露她唯一的缺点,很可惜~!!!本来挺完美的~!!!
shulingzhizhan 1 year ago 4
i like this one better then the original
aznkingdom12345 2 years ago
没有原唱唱得好,没有气势
不过总体来说还是不错~尤其是那句在大风里飘啊
godwatelsecani 2 years ago 2
刚看到这个的时候就想 哇 这个女孩厉害的 这个都敢唱····能唱好么····果然她没surprise我···
tammyzhang 2 years ago 2
郁可唯不停挑战难度的精神本身就是别人没有的了。。。。
shuraowen 2 years ago 3
她能唱成這樣就好好了..
但她不是少數民族,所以感覺沒有到那個唱生命的位置吧..
如果換是黃英的話,肯定更好!
薩頂頂的歌不容易喔!
lucyalice09 2 years ago 16
我觉得可唯现场唱成这样很不容易了!而且本来就不是可唯选的歌。黄英本来要唱呢!
highburycatherine 2 years ago 3
goil! better then ever
MadHutmacher 2 years ago
you can't copy cool
echibee 2 years ago
我也觉得那群评委很过分。。。。这歌多难啊。。。。故意跟人家过不去!
675857560 2 years ago 5
she is pretty.
tellbrother 2 years ago
nice performance... but the stylist should be fined by the high way patrols for making a walking traffic-light-like costume ....
TorvCookie 2 years ago
No contestants in the group can challenge that song, except her...
The costume is hideous, which is not her fault. But her voice is amazing!!!
Imagine her voice on pro studio recording quality!!!
cocoplushay 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
超难听
neptunehaixing 2 years ago
lol give her a break....its a hard song to sing... trust me all stupid chinese operas are super hard to sing
fancyfashiondiva 2 years ago
Like Sa dingding better.... anyway She's not bad at all......
xiaoyi519 2 years ago
服装配的也 哎~
vitaa688 2 years ago
比原唱差远了
crownboston 2 years ago
其实我当时听完就觉得唱的蛮不错的, 不知道那群评委为什么一起吃错药说唱的不好。。。要怪只能怪那个编舞的, 如果不看直接听的话。 简直有录音的效果了。 可唯真棒!!
jaisycal 2 years ago 15
I liked this, but unfortunately, she doesn't even come close to the stage presence Sa Dingding has. She also simplified a lot of the trills (or removed them completely) to suit her own voice, effectively dulling down the song, and taking out that interesting ethical element.
I'm going to have to say that Sa Dingding comes out above this in every way, including wardrobe (those pants look ridiculous).
gladiolii 2 years ago
I agree with you. This doesn't even come close to Sa Dingding's, especially the high parts where she suddenly just diminishes her volume, probably because she doesn't have the air to support her. However, the real problem is that she totally did not understand this song.
But, I love her outfit!
emanresuelbaman 2 years ago
She only prepared for this stage presence like one week.....I think she indeed did a great job. Especially her singing part is awesome.
jaisycal 2 years ago
芒果台的舞美服装设计也真够雷人的,不伦不类的头饰,不伦不类的袍子,不伦不类的扇子,不伦不类的伴舞。以为梵文歌就是跳大绳啊。。。
小郁唱得还是不错的。
kaleege 2 years ago 3
山寨了一些日本歌姬的舞蹈动作吧。舞美的确配不上唱。
pc2sky 2 years ago
舞蹈也不是她自己设计的,只能说芒果台的舞蹈设计有问题。 她唱的很不错的。
jaisycal 2 years ago
這歌唱得幾好....夠氣
SIMTSZ 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
討厭鬱可唯﹐唱歌不怎麼樣﹐但一本大小姐的模樣。 支持劉惜君和黃英!
monkeyboyn25 2 years ago
唱歌不这么样?你有病吧
mathboyx215 2 years ago
還可以啦,,,,但她唱歌是還可以的
SIMTSZ 2 years ago
Surely she can, you can have a look at "完整高清版 小彩旗 萨顶顶《万物生》@09湖南卫视小年夜春晚" Thanks
colincomeon 2 years ago
Awesome! I am not sure if the original singer (萨顶顶) can sing it better on live stage. The judge was obviously biased.
jcjzhao 2 years ago 5
finally someone speaks from my heart!!!
jaisycal 2 years ago