01052010 NYE Boys @TransTV IMB SHINee covering

[sushimonstaa]

gue ga pernah nonton IMB, tapi rasanya aneh ngeliat video ini mengingat salah satu dari mereka duduk di sebelah gue tiap kelas hari Selasa -____-"

[armyamalia]

they just do the cover dance guys

they do that just for fun

so don't judge too much guys

[djmamintada]

@Liuquil lo yg hrsnya biasa aja, gw ngmgin judge nya yg ngehina shinee sih bkn nye boys nya ye gondok

[nhiere]

setuju banget!! plagiator dan dance cover itu beda banget!! XD LMAO~

[UnieShawoL]

SarangNYE .... ^^

[Super060296]

guys, this is called COVER DANCE. they're covering dance. you shouldn't mad at them because they are copied BB dance. actually, shawol (in indonesia specially) should say thanks to them. why? cause, they just bring k-pop wave to indonesia. FYI, covering dance or something is NOT easy

[XpararocksX]

WHAT THE HELL did you see when they introduce themselves? so it's just covering huh? just sayin.

[djmamintada]

judge terakhir mksdnya apa tuh? "suara yang perfect... bukan perfect, paling nggak itu suara yang baik, yang layak." suara shinee udah jauh melebihi layak woi, dasar gila.

[Liuquil]

@djmamintada yauda sih biasa aja. dia org lebi bagus dr lu x bisa msk IMB. lebay abis

[huaishi223]

i've seen so many failed attempts to cover korean dances. and i'm sick of that.

this one... not too good, but didn't fail either, so i can say, they did a fairly good job.

i'd like to see them freestyling though. instead of covering dance moves, freestyling will showcase their talent more.

[dinidingdong]

yang jadi jognhyun oppa bagus dance nyaaa hehe ;)

[Boschandira]

Mereka kekurangan orang. gue seneng banget kalo bisa diajak gabung. :)

[irulez]

ooh they're pretty good~ it's good to see others covering shinee!! lol

shinee <33

[xoxoxowhatsxoxoxo]

they're very good at covering.. :)

many people disagree because of your covering..

but look, even the jury doesn't take it as a problem..

and..

if you really want to covering it on TV, i think you should show the real one on the big screen on your back..

see??

even when korean artist covering another artist,, they show the real one for the match..

& think about the audience who don't know about K-Pop.. they don't know your covering is match perfectly or not..

[aquafreesia]

stylenya mirip yah

[NadyaZagita]

hmmm,,, they're good... but, why who be the key isnn't good ?

[podeclover]

In fact, I like them but I must agree to one of those critics to NYE. You guys would be a better performers if you give a proper credit. You guys should tell the audience before or after the performance properly. This is in order to appreciate the difficulties of the artist and the choreographer who did hardwork to make the moves and style have gone through.

OK? Be better each day, guys...

[podeclover]

This is also one of the ways to bring KPOP ARTISTS to Indonesia and have a concert here....U guys who said bad things here want that too, huh? Think about that!

[podeclover]

It doesn't matter if people say bad or good things about them. For me, this is one of the ways to tell KOREAN ARTISTS <which of many don't know how popular they are in Indonesia> and the whole nation of Korea about how big the spreading of KPOP and Korean culture in Indonesia is. Since in Korea there ARE also many cover-dancers, so why not having them in Indonesia. It's not NYE fault or something, it's just the trend of covering KPOP group's dance in the world.

[reiibsbholic]

cover dance isn't as easy as it seems. we need thanks to them who help to spread korean wave ^_^

[pcipta]

Opini : Cover dance yah.. Kayaknya untuk diperlombakan aneh bnget deh, yg dilombain persepsi orang tuh "gerakannya", eh tp kan gerakannya ngikut yg udah ada

[keo2pooh]

they are great dancers....

but I think its better if they shouldn't be cover dance coz hey look at them! they really have talent so why should be something that people didn't accept if they can make something better than this....

maybe there are people like cover dance (esp. me) but I think Indonesian not ready for something like this...

[ellesharon]

@Stefabcdefghijklmn if you don't understand what DANCE COVER is, just shut up your mouth!

[ellesharon]

I love kpop, and I think NYE Boys very creative with their style,

and guys, this is DANCE COVER it should be looks a like the real one,

if they don't I'll be very dissapointed.

so I think they are cool! :D

[Stefabcdefghijklmn]

halah,tai iki,isie cuma ikut2 boyband Korea,kl gini ga usa ikut Indonesia Mencari bakat donk, harusnya ikut INDONESIA MENIRU BAKAT,wew!!

tampang aj jauh dari yg di Korea sana,wkwkw,,,,,its oke,kuhargai deh perjuangan niru2nya ,huaaammm..............

[dianaafriya]

I kinda proud of them. Guys, please don't be mad.

they clearly said that the follow the Korean idol group dance so I think they're imitated that and what's wrong with that? You guys supposed to be proud because Korean wave is spreading everywhere now. beside, u guys supposed to hear what were they saying at the beginning video.

[bugabooble]

jangan cover di TV dooonkkk...

[blueyeschessier]

@bugabooble trus mo dimana? di layar tancep? SuJu aja cover di tv ga jadi masalah.. sebelum ngehina.. prluas pengetahuan dulu ya ;)

[winanatalia]

sorry but i have to say you're sucks

[blueyeschessier]

@winanatalia what a lame~

[amberloves01]

i saw a shinee cover in America(i'm also from America hehe and i'm in love w/ them).....Shinee is shining around the world XD

[blueyeschessier]

@amberloves01 yeah ! ;)

[almightyhaha]

haha they are stars?;-o

[blueyeschessier]

@almightyhaha nope, but they will, i guess..

[134d91rL]

this is the first time i saw SHINee cover from Indonesia..

and they're so cool.. ^^

[ranievengenz]

its a good start tho,,

but you cant say covering something as a carrier,,lets learn from cobus potgieter, he is a fame covering drummer and he's not famous as a covering drummer, he's famous because his great drummer play.i hope NYE can show us more than just covering,,they got good talent

[moiatashi]

who are the names? i only know the one being key, which looks like jokwon :D

[08996809831]

@moiatashi shinee member? they're onew, taemin, minho, jonghyun, and yes key.. i agree key and jokwoon has something in common, and i love both of them :-)

[breeww]

u guys can post your cover dance on youtube or go perform on non-competition event, but not like this. u said u did not plagiarize anything, but did u even gave credit to the original kpop group? if the judges didnt ask who was the original kpop group will u guys even mention it? i'm not saying u are not good or anything, u guys definitely have talent, but i'm just kinda not happy with it. just saying. maybe it will kinda gave u guys some suggestion. keep up the good dance. peace out.

[blueyeschessier]

@breeww i believe they would mention it.. don't ya think that they did it on backstage to the crew.. and the staffs or crew told the judges as well.. i think that's how they work about it..

[breeww]

@blueyeschessier just mention it to the crew? what's the point of that? the point is that they SHOULD mention it by themselves WHO exactly are they covering to ALL of the audiences. not JUST MENTION "we're covering dance from korean group". give a proper credit! jeez. and are u one of them? saw u answering all the bad comments. and trust me, there are wayyy lots of people who knows exactly about kpop. so stop saying things like "sebelum ngehina, perluas pengetahuan dulu ya".

[cynicalmadhatter]

@breeww LOL. "give a proper credit!" say those words to Suju too.

[kotarodeassy]

NYE BOYS ROCKS YO. ... !

[sekikaoru]

I'm happy they did shinee cover.and I'm a shawol^^

because I hope with their dance they can spread more about K-pop in Indonesia.

and I hope shinee will come to Indonesia

[cynicalmadhatter]

Hm, come to think, you don't like them for what? For being a dance cover of kpop idol? For copying 2PM? For going on air on TV and dancing other people's moves? If you dislike them because of going on air on TV and dancing other people moves, don't you know even 2PM their self and Super Junior did a dance cover? don't you know that in Korea itself, many dance cover that going on air on TV for a contest too?

[thebomzyonji]

yoohoo ! sarangNYE ^o^ !

[riskakeren]

waktu pertama mereka tampir heart beat mereka smpet di tny, mereka itu group apa? meniru dance ato nge mix dance, mereka blg mereka mix juga, harus nya mereka ga ngmg nge mix dance, tp mereka blg covering alias meniru dance dr group korea

no offence ya, cm berpendapat seharusnya mereka ga ky gitu, cm menyayangkan aja :)

[hyun125mr]

I am an ELF, I become an ELF for a long time. I'm Indonesian people, and I am also very love Korea. with seeing NYE's performance, I feel very disappointed, I hope they can following Korean boyband's creativity , not imitate it like this. my Idol's creation has sold for an event like this. ELF, can u feel my heart? whether this is can we called talent? This is other people's talent! I hope NYE can use their own style and dance! if only like this, people who with no-talent can do it !!!

[blueyeschessier]

@hyun125mr so many ELF who support them. they find it helpful to introduce SuJu to this nation. stop insulting them unless you can do better.FYI, i'm an ELF since Kyuhyun not a member yet. i didn't buy pirated goods. so, iproudly say that i am Kpop lovers. did u kno that even SuJu done a cover dance too??? did ya know about 'Sheellen' ??? the group who covers Shinee in Thai. n u kno what, coz of that they can appear in the same stage with Shinee

[cynicalmadhatter]

@hyun125mr FYI, Super Junior did a cover dance on air too and even they performed it at SS2. so, what's your problem yo?

I'm Super Junior's fans too, and I'm sure that I become ELF longer than you. I know them since debut.

"if only like this, people who with no-talent can do it !!!" oh, yeah, and I'm sure you can do like trigazillion times waaayyyy better than NYE.

[fLoOz21]

@hyun125mr im agree with u.. at first whn i heard that they will perform suju - sorry2, im so excited n i thought they would only use the songs n dance with their movement. sorry to said this but i personally feels that they ruined the original one. Just my thought though.

[TVXQ83]

REQ dance TVXQ dong ^^

[raracinta]

OMAGAHHDD THIS IS TALENT. SarangNYE! <33

[uya2ninja]

i think,, this is talent.. they can make the same movement with the boybands it self.. actually i'm a dancer,, n not really good in covering dance,, but they can,,

and i think it's awesome,, :D

hemmm~ maybe just input for themm,, maybe they can mix the coreo from them selves with the coreo from the songs,,

i love NYE..

like what k-pop lovers said in Bandung...

sarangNYE.... ahhahaha

keepp movin boys,, ^_^

[Janah131]

haduuuh...aqw lupaaa...gag nonton...

[blueyeschessier]

they only help to spread the Korean wave to the nation. they do not acknowledge/claim that the choreography was theirs. talent that they offer is cover dance. sorry if anyone was disappointed. they are alsothe Kpop lovers and they love all the artists that they cover. the cover dance group  are alreday exis in other countries and they all appreciated by Kpop lovers.

[justluvkpop]

namanya juga "Cover Dance" ya memang tugasnya meniru dance dr artis2 itu yg di-cover, mereka udah ngejelasi apa itu cover dance, sharusnya berterimakasih sama NYE Boys yg membawa korea ke Indonesia~~

NYE, hwaiting~ sarangNye~!!

[viehyeELF]

NYE boys~ keep Hwaiting guys,,, lets spread kpop in Indonesia~

tadi gw udah kirim sms dukungan lho...

SarangNYE~

[shulachulaa]

that is SHINee's face after plastic surgery...

SHINee will cry 1 week after saw this...

[rotisepan]

@shulachulaa lol super wtf

[cynicalmadhatter]

@shulachulaa oh really? you know SHINee very well then. Tell them that in Indonesia, there is another cover dancer like 'Sheellen'. And weirdly, many people dislike them, unlike 'Sheellen'.

[zxxzxxz07]

pdas kali comment"nya.. T_T

[4nLGe]

THIS NOT TALENT!!!!!

[cynicalmadhatter]

@4nLGe do better than them then. Show that you got talent. Will you?

[nap199100]

MY RESPOND????I'M CRYING!!!!WHY?I LOVE THIS "REAL" MV VERY MUCH BUT this?????ITS CRACKED MY IDOL IMAGE!!!COPIED IS NOT TALENT I THINK!

[zxxzxxz07]

@nap199100 i like too..everybody may comment bout this group.. but helllooow...u should think..can everybody do this?? OR can u do this?? do u really can look like the real one??do u have any talent so u can join IMB???

they just fanatic to korea n want indonesia know about shinee.. logicly.. will the real boyband like shinee,suju,n 2pm will come to indonesia to debut??? i think it's hard to realizing if they can come,not all people in indonesia can watch them.. so let them xpres it >=/

[rotisepan]

@zxxzxxz07 yeah right if they come here only just for debut, i hope the price is not too expensive! they're not even famous here yet dammit -__-

only u-kiss would understand us :')

anyway this is Indonesia mencari bakat, they supposed to dance with their own dance moves, they already express themselves, i mean, NYE is totally famous in bandung, and also kpopers indonesia has already knew them right? they got utube facebook lots of media :) they're famous! -my english bad? deal with it :D

[zxxzxxz07]

@rotisepan your english not to bad la.. ^^

right.. ^^7

[citrajusuf]

@nap199100 i hope you do know the different between copying with cover dance

[cynicalmadhatter]

@nap199100 Duh! dance cover dear. Blurry much?

[yanionew]

deg-degan nunggu performnya tadi...

gomawo NYE BOYS....

[nap199100]

@yanionew : oonni,,r u one of shineeworld member?did u saw that your onew will be cried all night long because of this?

[12345gxtreme]

@nap199100 hurm .. maYb THEY WILL CRY .. but mayB not , bcause they dance so gud , i know its copying but mayB they will proud of NYE BOYS .. such a gud dancer . haha , i think .

[uya2ninja]

@nap199100 : hehhe,, maybe they will smile,, not crying.. :) not all of indonesian now about shinee,, from tthis event,, shinee maybe will spread into the small city of indonesia.. just be positive nap,, ^_^ thx

[cynicalmadhatter]

@nap199100 another that really close with their idol.

[yanionew]

@nap199100 : ha ha ha... i think onew feel happy to know this LOL