I cant imagine why you would think that Fear Factory has helped JG Thirwell & Roli Mosimann=Wiseblood? cept for some royalties. Its kinda like saying Charles Manson helped the Beach boys. I suggest you check out more of JG Thirwells extensive back catalogue as well as his producing credits and and rethink that as more like who he has helped.
Considering when this was made, it's a crazy good song. However, I think Fear Factory's cover sounds better simply because the sound Wiseblood was going for didn't exist, at the time. It's a good song, either way, and I'm glad I found this version, because it's not on Spotify.
Its not like it didn't exist. Its two different goddamn genres. Plus JG Thirwhel and the dude that used to be in the swans were working with completely different equipment- they were going for a different sound.
@AROAH1337 Same thing here. I had no idea this was a cover. Fear factory helped out Wiseblood out if anything. And yes, FF version is better because this version is missing the oomph of bass that the song needs.
Fear Factory is better in my opinion, I don't get the big deal here. Bands do covers because they like the songs and want to play it... usually they make the song better anyways.
You guys are clowns. I loved the FF version, didn't even know til now that it was a cover, and I definitely agree that this is the better version. Much better conveys the sense of chaotic evil. Even though FF's has more grimey vocals, it's very standardized and a bit cookie cut in style. This version is very unique.
How can this be compared to Fear Factory's version? It is obviously much better, but it never would have existed without this, which is decent, so I give it props.
Christ, do half of you not even know who Foetus is? FF did a decent cover, but it doesn't come close to the original. Besides, they covered it because it's a good song, and if it weren't for bands like Wiseblood, Foetus, and Swans, there would be no Fear Factory. So quit bitching.
HAHAHAH what the fuck!! This makes me think of a retirement home, or carnies. Fear Factory version is MUCH better. Even spine tingling, if you have a system worth mentioning.
@manka6 Thanks! All the years spent screaming Castle Killer. Well, thats not to hard to change up. Kasso Killer huh? Now I feel that I need to do research on this song.
Songs like this walk the line with bad taste and extreme awesomeness so ahead of its time!! PS Should I also mention something about FF? has anyone done that duuuuhhhhhhhh WHO CARES!!!! arguing about covers is beyond a waste of time LONG LIVE THE NEW FLESH but seriously all your ages are showing LISTEN TO FOETUS REAL HARD AND TRY AND GO BACK TO FEAR FACTORY!! GO ON!!
alright... this was horrible. bad production, the vocals sounded like a bad joke, what was all that "ow!" stuff in the middle? seriously, fear factory made this song listenable. that is all.
@crazyirishdan... & for every 3rd or so person shaking their head about someone knowing what true industrial music is, there is a 4th or 5th or millionth like you who takes more time to complain about it then I took to write a comment... Wow very funny!! I think people like you have no room to give advice on maturity other than to yourself. Please don't be butt-hurt or waste any more time with messages directed at me: To do so would be even more pathetic, instead, just accept that we disagree.
People who take bands like Fear Factory & Slipknot over bands like Foetus & Godflesh are funny. Hey guys; don't forget to shop at Hot Topic to complete your taste in music with some really trendy clothing. But when you check out and have your conformist angry metal kid look complete, go home and get to know some bands that make real industrial music. Bands like Swans, Godflesh, Dissecting Table & Scorn have been making real industrial music since the 80's
@pathogensmusick I would say everything above is pretty redundant; I was turned onto this song by the FF version long before I ever heart of Foetus or Godflesh; I've listened to all four but for completely different reasons. FF/SK are both metal bands with industrial elements and neither claims to be industrial.
For every person going apeshit for either band/approach there's at least a third shaking their head sadly at both of them, wondering when they're going to show some maturity...
foetus is the man! This came out in 87' when a lot of u were sucking on ur mothers tits! A pointless remake by FF. Most of u don't even know what this song is about!
I had no idea mall metal band Fear Factory had covered this. Could only be terrible. Foetus and Wiseblood weren't perfect by any means but at least this is their own. I don't see how FF would contribute anything new or worthwhile to this.
Like most guys I've heard FF's version first. This (original as I understand, right?) sounds too much German, which usually (not always) mean soft and nearly toothless. 8D
Look on net, no, they are Americans, OK, somethimes I do mistake. 8D
Wow, way to make yourself look ignorant. They are not American or German. FF covered this for a reason. It is edgy. The song is about a killer in NY in the 80s. A lot of the lyrics written by this guy have jokes thrown in. (including this song). I never heard the FF version until 3 minutes ago. It sucks. They id not change enough to be considered a good cover and the mastering is shit. Too much compression.
Wow, way to make yourself look ignorant. They are not American or German. FF covered this for a reason. It is edgy. The song is about a killer in NY in the 80s. A lot of the lyrics written by this guy have jokes thrown in. (including this song). I never heard the FF version until 3 minutes ago. It sucks. They id not change enough to be considered a good cover and the mastering is shit. Too much compression.
You know, I heard FF's version first and it scared the living shit out of me, that was in 2001. and now, in 2010, I am listening to this.......Haaaaaaaa.........lol, the funniest shit I'v ever heard in my life.
i actually hate thisversion... just a matter of opinion tho. Fear factories vocals Kill this version in a fashion. Plus they are so much more in your fucing face with it.
this song is covered in grit, I've never heard anything so gratingly intense, vocals are raw/ not aestheticized. Absolutely no pollish by a metal scream, vocal trainer dickwad.
Sounds less heavy than FF, and the vocalist sounds like he's trying a bit too hard to sound "evil", but it's still a great song. I just like FF's version better.
I like the original song and Fear Factory's cover. Why is there such a huge debate? Good bands do covers of songs that deserve it. Fear Factory wouldn't have covered this if it didn't deserve it, so they obviously see this as a good song.
this version's alright & a bit entertaining (With its foretelling of bands like latter-day Ministy, Godflesh, Skin Chamber & such bands), but the Fear Factory version is just downright savage, a great throwback to the sound found on their "Soul of a New Machine" album & easily the highpoint of the otherwise terrible & disappointing "Obsolete" album (That is if you buy the Digipak version)
@Chapas45: This came out a year before Land of Rape and Honey, and Twitch really did not sound anything like this. It is more accurate to say that Ministry (circa Land) reeks of Foetus/Wiseblood/etc.
The FF just has more guitar and more production, if you like that sort of thing...
yeah, i was thinking of rape and honey when listenting to this. if i didn't have fear factory's obsolete, i would have guessed that this was al jourgensen.
and it was FF that turned me on to the more industrial bands like ministry and wiseblood.
Wow, I had no clue FF did a cover of this. I like this more.
RainWiLLIDie 4 days ago
I cant imagine why you would think that Fear Factory has helped JG Thirwell & Roli Mosimann=Wiseblood? cept for some royalties. Its kinda like saying Charles Manson helped the Beach boys. I suggest you check out more of JG Thirwells extensive back catalogue as well as his producing credits and and rethink that as more like who he has helped.
misskeir 1 month ago
Both versions are amazing. Period.
S133S 1 month ago
I have the first press of this LP and its not terrible!
Bewohner2000 2 months ago 2
Considering when this was made, it's a crazy good song. However, I think Fear Factory's cover sounds better simply because the sound Wiseblood was going for didn't exist, at the time. It's a good song, either way, and I'm glad I found this version, because it's not on Spotify.
AROAH1337 4 months ago
@AROAH1337
Its not like it didn't exist. Its two different goddamn genres. Plus JG Thirwhel and the dude that used to be in the swans were working with completely different equipment- they were going for a different sound.
lightlittlebrownboy 2 months ago
@AROAH1337 Same thing here. I had no idea this was a cover. Fear factory helped out Wiseblood out if anything. And yes, FF version is better because this version is missing the oomph of bass that the song needs.
hfoslund86 1 month ago
Great song
oldcrow213 4 months ago
Fear Factory is better in my opinion, I don't get the big deal here. Bands do covers because they like the songs and want to play it... usually they make the song better anyways.
RazerDrummer901 4 months ago
@RazerDrummer901 FF version is amazing but considering this was done way before it deserves much more credit.
S133S 1 month ago
love and devotion
stevosomebizzare 5 months ago
Never heard this before... this is kinda cool.
claypatt81 5 months ago
Compared to FF version this sounds weak.
DjJokerr 6 months ago
You guys are clowns. I loved the FF version, didn't even know til now that it was a cover, and I definitely agree that this is the better version. Much better conveys the sense of chaotic evil. Even though FF's has more grimey vocals, it's very standardized and a bit cookie cut in style. This version is very unique.
korrosyve 6 months ago 3
OMG, follow the history. It goes Foetus, Then Skinny Puppy then Fear Factory.
supermanicedm 6 months ago
How can this be compared to Fear Factory's version? It is obviously much better, but it never would have existed without this, which is decent, so I give it props.
worthlessprotoplasm 6 months ago
Christ, do half of you not even know who Foetus is? FF did a decent cover, but it doesn't come close to the original. Besides, they covered it because it's a good song, and if it weren't for bands like Wiseblood, Foetus, and Swans, there would be no Fear Factory. So quit bitching.
PersonMan92 7 months ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
i like the drums and industrial samples better in this version
hotchocolate801 8 months ago
Comment removed
hotchocolate801 8 months ago
HAHAHAH what the fuck!! This makes me think of a retirement home, or carnies. Fear Factory version is MUCH better. Even spine tingling, if you have a system worth mentioning.
proaudiohd 8 months ago
who is fear factory?
ScrapingFoetus 8 months ago
CASTLE KILLER!!! there is no debate. its all tunes. GRIZZLY SACRIFICIAL SLAUGHTER!!!!
OBAMFSpike 9 months ago
@OBAMFSpike It's actually Kasso Killer. I know, I thought it was Castle too.
manka6 6 months ago
@manka6 Thanks! All the years spent screaming Castle Killer. Well, thats not to hard to change up. Kasso Killer huh? Now I feel that I need to do research on this song.
OBAMFSpike 2 months ago
This is gay. The FF version is waaaay better!
vikingmetaliscool 10 months ago
all versions of this song are bad ass if you know what it's about. There's a book called "Say you Love Satan". and I do.
scottms0666 10 months ago
Songs like this walk the line with bad taste and extreme awesomeness so ahead of its time!! PS Should I also mention something about FF? has anyone done that duuuuhhhhhhhh WHO CARES!!!! arguing about covers is beyond a waste of time LONG LIVE THE NEW FLESH but seriously all your ages are showing LISTEN TO FOETUS REAL HARD AND TRY AND GO BACK TO FEAR FACTORY!! GO ON!!
blarrrrgehh 11 months ago
covers in general suck.
SuperMrMaximo 11 months ago
Umm... GET BOTH! FFs version is great, but I like this one too. Thanks!
SkilletsUSMC 1 year ago
alright... this was horrible. bad production, the vocals sounded like a bad joke, what was all that "ow!" stuff in the middle? seriously, fear factory made this song listenable. that is all.
deathsopus 1 year ago
@jasonbigelow fuck you the fear factory cover is just as good as the orginal
Turdfishtheband 1 year ago
ok, so there is a cover by FF...lets check it out.
anyhow, dis dirtdish album is one of my favourite tattoos on my soul.
frietzuurvleesmayo 1 year ago 2
Not 2 mention Foetus influenced FF and other bands!!!
666kinski 1 year ago
Look up "Rikki Casso"" the acid king.Chilling story!
Blokechest 1 year ago
@Blokechest Damn Striaight. "Say you love Satan!"
TwitchMD 1 year ago
Why do so many people find it so difficult to see good in two things at once?
OrgrimFreeman 1 year ago
You can watch the movie "Where Evil Dwells" (this song was created for the soundtrack) at ubu dot com
olderthanyou 1 year ago
No shit who cares about who covers this song. do some fuckin' research ppl. there's a story behind these lyrics.
JhonnyMurder 1 year ago
@crazyirishdan... & for every 3rd or so person shaking their head about someone knowing what true industrial music is, there is a 4th or 5th or millionth like you who takes more time to complain about it then I took to write a comment... Wow very funny!! I think people like you have no room to give advice on maturity other than to yourself. Please don't be butt-hurt or waste any more time with messages directed at me: To do so would be even more pathetic, instead, just accept that we disagree.
pathogensmusick 1 year ago
People who take bands like Fear Factory & Slipknot over bands like Foetus & Godflesh are funny. Hey guys; don't forget to shop at Hot Topic to complete your taste in music with some really trendy clothing. But when you check out and have your conformist angry metal kid look complete, go home and get to know some bands that make real industrial music. Bands like Swans, Godflesh, Dissecting Table & Scorn have been making real industrial music since the 80's
pathogensmusick 1 year ago
@pathogensmusick I would say everything above is pretty redundant; I was turned onto this song by the FF version long before I ever heart of Foetus or Godflesh; I've listened to all four but for completely different reasons. FF/SK are both metal bands with industrial elements and neither claims to be industrial.
For every person going apeshit for either band/approach there's at least a third shaking their head sadly at both of them, wondering when they're going to show some maturity...
crazyirishdan 1 year ago
LAMELAME LAME. FF's version is 100's times better. He sounds like hes just talking in this version. It's gay.
suckmeballsalot 1 year ago
lmfao this is so boring... chopped and screwed...1:07 lol hahahaha
whatever, either way, im glad this song exists... by FF!
ikillednoe 1 year ago
Now FF ver is so much better....This sounds childish and retarderd.
Albanijac 1 year ago
foetus is the man! This came out in 87' when a lot of u were sucking on ur mothers tits! A pointless remake by FF. Most of u don't even know what this song is about!
666kinski 1 year ago 4
Fear factorys version is far more superior
thetypezero 1 year ago
Fear Factory's version runs circles around this.
This is terrible. You mad? Deal with it. "smug".
ModPrime 1 year ago
Not trying to be a dick, but the vocals sound like they're being done by somebody with downs.
RaidenTheAlmighty 1 year ago
He has a kinda slingblade thing going there,hmmmn.
DIYWMD 1 year ago
I had no idea mall metal band Fear Factory had covered this. Could only be terrible. Foetus and Wiseblood weren't perfect by any means but at least this is their own. I don't see how FF would contribute anything new or worthwhile to this.
TheGreatEcstasy 1 year ago 3
wow...way to have your song blown out of the water by another bands cover.
Seriously, this blows cock...Fear Factory's is way the hell better.
MetalheadAlex9 1 year ago
Totally, utterly, agree with you.
SocialDissimulation 1 year ago
Good but the ff version is way more brutal.
Props to wiseblood for making this :D
DoomMaster307 1 year ago
Fuck Fear Factory
Overproduction and trying too hard to be "evil". JG doesn't need post-production to be creepy and unsettling.
islanderboy 1 year ago
wow this version is fucken retarded, the FF version makes me wanna kill people, this one....not so much
youngdickinsonharris 1 year ago
stumo is a young bloke
upstartnufc 1 year ago
Like most guys I've heard FF's version first. This (original as I understand, right?) sounds too much German, which usually (not always) mean soft and nearly toothless. 8D
Look on net, no, they are Americans, OK, somethimes I do mistake. 8D
SwineNahNah 1 year ago
@SwineNahNah
Wow, way to make yourself look ignorant. They are not American or German. FF covered this for a reason. It is edgy. The song is about a killer in NY in the 80s. A lot of the lyrics written by this guy have jokes thrown in. (including this song). I never heard the FF version until 3 minutes ago. It sucks. They id not change enough to be considered a good cover and the mastering is shit. Too much compression.
TheRandomn0ise 1 year ago
@TheRandomn0ise
I just looked on web... so, not Americans, OK, so what?
And some years (mm, 5-6 maybe?) ago I looked up about story under the lyrics, bt I've might have missed some humor in it, true,
SwineNahNah 1 year ago
@SwineNahNah
Wow, way to make yourself look ignorant. They are not American or German. FF covered this for a reason. It is edgy. The song is about a killer in NY in the 80s. A lot of the lyrics written by this guy have jokes thrown in. (including this song). I never heard the FF version until 3 minutes ago. It sucks. They id not change enough to be considered a good cover and the mastering is shit. Too much compression.
TheRandomn0ise 1 year ago
@SwineNahNah actually one of them is an Australian that now lives in America
misskeir 1 month ago
You know, I heard FF's version first and it scared the living shit out of me, that was in 2001. and now, in 2010, I am listening to this.......Haaaaaaaa.........lol, the funniest shit I'v ever heard in my life.
TheJake3 1 year ago
i actually hate thisversion... just a matter of opinion tho. Fear factories vocals Kill this version in a fashion. Plus they are so much more in your fucing face with it.
MY OPINION
SeanCamp92 1 year ago
this song is covered in grit, I've never heard anything so gratingly intense, vocals are raw/ not aestheticized. Absolutely no pollish by a metal scream, vocal trainer dickwad.
Blumpkinlvr 1 year ago 3
this is tight who is it
go36able 1 year ago
Sounds less heavy than FF, and the vocalist sounds like he's trying a bit too hard to sound "evil", but it's still a great song. I just like FF's version better.
Ktulu418 1 year ago 3
Fear Factorys Cover Is Way Better
Dunit215 1 year ago 4
It's good, but not like this. This is Masterpiece.
kretinkooper 1 year ago 3
@kretinkooper
You are one smart bastard!
uncIesamy 1 year ago
Dead Milkmen cover is way better.
coprographia 1 year ago
I like the original song and Fear Factory's cover. Why is there such a huge debate? Good bands do covers of songs that deserve it. Fear Factory wouldn't have covered this if it didn't deserve it, so they obviously see this as a good song.
ArchetypeZero 2 years ago 31
@ArchetypeZero I prefer this version, but I wouldn't have even have found out about Wiseblood if I hadn't heard Fear Factory's cover.
TwitchMD 1 year ago
@ArchetypeZero
seanhendry6 1 month ago
say you love satan
MrBlairblack 2 years ago
most awful gay shit ever, FF can easily beat this so called attempt of song
ThrashL0Rd 2 years ago
hail ricky kasso
the acid king lives on forever
say you love satan
derewal 2 years ago 2
You sound gay for Ricky Kasso.
disciplinemisanthrop 2 years ago
Fear Factory does a damn good cover of this song... and i agree with anyone who says the vocals sound more brutal on the FF version.
Downfallofyou 2 years ago 15
really? o.k.
935323 2 years ago
i think they both sound the same....
DaedricLavaWhiskey 2 years ago
how can you dispute. This is the inseption.
935323 2 years ago
Can someone tell me who the song is about can't remember his name THANKS!!
mikexxx21 2 years ago
Ricky Kasso
360dodge 2 years ago
Go with the composer over the poser. Anybody can ape.
triomatt 2 years ago 2
this version's alright & a bit entertaining (With its foretelling of bands like latter-day Ministy, Godflesh, Skin Chamber & such bands), but the Fear Factory version is just downright savage, a great throwback to the sound found on their "Soul of a New Machine" album & easily the highpoint of the otherwise terrible & disappointing "Obsolete" album (That is if you buy the Digipak version)
GasmaskAvenger 2 years ago
@GasmaskAvenger:
obsolete was great; better than digimortal and archetype (anything from the last decade).
Chapas45 2 years ago
the Fear Factory version sounds better. vocals sound more demonic
GodofDrums666 2 years ago 5
No way. Fear Factory is good, but this version is ancient power.
kretinkooper 2 years ago 3
the FF vocals sound more more ''devilish' in my opinion
RisingDevilOfChaos 2 years ago 4
@Chapas45: This came out a year before Land of Rape and Honey, and Twitch really did not sound anything like this. It is more accurate to say that Ministry (circa Land) reeks of Foetus/Wiseblood/etc.
The FF just has more guitar and more production, if you like that sort of thing...
dar205 2 years ago
yeah, i was thinking of rape and honey when listenting to this. if i didn't have fear factory's obsolete, i would have guessed that this was al jourgensen.
and it was FF that turned me on to the more industrial bands like ministry and wiseblood.
Chapas45 2 years ago
Don't get me wrong, I enjoy Fear Factory, though I went through Skin Chamber first.
dar205 2 years ago
yeah.. the FF version is awesome
itsbutchertime 2 years ago 3
Man, this reeks of al jourgensen and ministry (which is not a bad thing). But Fear Factory's version is better.
Chapas45 2 years ago 2
I love FF, but I think their covers tend to miss the spirit of the originals. Either way though, good fucking song =)
Agallochness 2 years ago
fear factory did an awesome cover of this song,but this one sounds darker if you get me.
crazysharky666 3 years ago 2
I got ya. heard it on acid 15 years ago. Took this long to find this tune again, has the same affect without acid. Feel ruined.
kretinkooper 2 years ago
Yeah I've got to say Fear Factory's version was much better.
treycarterrocksalot 3 years ago
Fear factory did a pretty fucking awesome cover of this, original still sounds cool
SVD151k 3 years ago 3