dude you played this beautifully. i wrote down some of the notes from watching you (i already learned some by ear) and I'm gonna go play it now. peace.
While yes, it is good, it needs to be slowed a bit. This pianist is playing it ever so slightly too fast. Please dont get me wrong, I do like this version.
I'm not a musician, so take this with a grain of salt. I'm not trying to put you down in any way (this was amazing).
But my input is this: Go slower. I think the pace is too quick, and the emotional value is diminished as a result.
Like I said, though, I could not duplicate this in any way, shape, or form. So let me just leave you with: Good job
MrGarky 8 months ago
Bass line is played as octaves - Brilliant job though
godzirrafied 11 months ago
uhm, How in the hell could you dislike something like this???
wowmoen 11 months ago
uhm, How in the hell could you dislike something like this???
wowmoen 11 months ago
Why you hide the code?
PS: you are amazing!
jevchi 1 year ago
I wanted to blog about this but embedding is disabled :( Sad face ):
Deeply enjoyed!
larceniii 1 year ago
I cry when I listen this
wyczerpany19 1 year ago
Wow! Great job!
xmissfaycex 1 year ago
i am incredibly how simple this song is on piano. thanks for the video. i didnt know what to do with my left hand until now
silentsmokeNIN 2 years ago
good job but hoffmensch007 plays this song on piano very very well
c3llyc3ll1 2 years ago
...please re-record this with better quality because you're really good at it and it needs to be heard properly :)
fleurdemal 2 years ago 3
so beautiful.
fleurdemal 2 years ago 2
dude you played this beautifully. i wrote down some of the notes from watching you (i already learned some by ear) and I'm gonna go play it now. peace.
TheDivineVessel 2 years ago 4
Awesome cover bro!
Sean19a7x2 2 years ago 2
this was amazingly done!
please make a tutuorial. I would LOVE to learn how to play this.
cassieburleson 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
xxkmr803xx 2 years ago
If you did a tutorial to this, I would love you forever dude. PLEASE! You played it so well so that would be awesome.
danieliscool2121 2 years ago 10
5 star
razzriff 2 years ago 2
beautiful
doors36 2 years ago
While yes, it is good, it needs to be slowed a bit. This pianist is playing it ever so slightly too fast. Please dont get me wrong, I do like this version.
omegaman7769 2 years ago
Nice Job. Damn I love that song so much. Still if defintly one of his greatest albums ever.
dahak8875 2 years ago
Beautiful.
TeinCave 2 years ago
very well done.
aggelium 3 years ago
i got chills listening to this, it's incredible!
almost as good as the original, a bit of synth in there and you've got it! (Y)
nabxf 3 years ago
wow i so wanna learn this song.
twistedkatana1 3 years ago
This is absolutely brilliant. Brought me to tears. Thank you.
MoonlitForest 3 years ago 5
meesss i saw no mess that was awesome i say nice job we say haha
ddawgsmash 3 years ago
Nice!!!
juditalonso 3 years ago
i agree!!!!! post tutorial please and sheet music maybe?
Survivalism001 3 years ago
do it by ear. it's simple.
afkamistan 2 years ago 2
Wow, this is sooooo amazing. If you could post a tutorial it'd be even more amazing. GAH my ears are still in shock.
lathspellvash 3 years ago
YEAH!!
Survivalism001 3 years ago
Awesome!
CJ2004 3 years ago
Awesome
reptilenin 3 years ago
nothing is like Trent Reznor,but this is pretty fucking close 5 stars nice job.
Survivalism001 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
u made me cry with this song brings me memories!!
when my ex used me!!!
HeirQueen16 3 years ago
Brilliant! Sounds like Trent is in the studio playing it live right now.
RussX5Z 3 years ago 4
Truly beautiful! Good work. Love this song!
doubleilisi 3 years ago
One of my favorite songs by NIN- So beautiful, you covered it perfectly! I Have to learn this on the piano asap... Thanks so much for sharing xx
alienslikeme 3 years ago
amazing job dude
daedalusx360 3 years ago
Beautiful - I cried when I first heard the actual song.
You really did it justice.
kikhuana 3 years ago 3
Tutorial Please!!!!!!!!
XxTheAlmostxX 3 years ago 2
i second this
Funk96 3 years ago 2
two thumbs up
nixxxxxxxxy 3 years ago 2
Wow, this is so beautiful. Trent would be proud :)
Desecrated 3 years ago 4
good job. it's not too fast at all.
missmurder99 4 years ago
Wow, indeed gave me chills, too. Good job there. :)
TheSOADGirl 4 years ago 10
beautiful.
=)
deadend228 4 years ago
Comment removed
mclarenv12 4 years ago
asskicking!
sadata 4 years ago
Suena de maravilla !!!
Fantástico ;)
jesabama 4 years ago
nice but too fast
gmanut 4 years ago 3
Hell yeah! Very cool! Awesome!
Funnycreature17 4 years ago 3
That sounded amazing, very nice playing!
Saphothere 4 years ago 2
that was beyond good my friend.
momslap 4 years ago 3
dude...you gave me chills that was so good....15th version i heard tonight and yours is the best on youtube. Congrats!
GNation77 4 years ago
beautiful man..
iluwtwigg 4 years ago
Amazing song.. So moody, love the way the keyboard sounds, very close to the original.. You keep the sad mood in the song, just great.
Depechexb 4 years ago
that's just amazing. great job
dprevite 4 years ago
Nice! Now show what keys your pressing so we can play too : D You should make another vid but aim the cam down at all keys : )
Nice vid!
12creations 4 years ago
fingerlickin good ^-^
zer0sum80 4 years ago
hi5 yamaha sy series synth buddy
bingham79726 4 years ago
amazing
myownway795 4 years ago