Ever since first heard Hvorostovsky sing this at Cardiff Singer of the world, I've been a fan of his, although I think he sings less well these days. But Pavel Lisitsian leaves H at the starting post. Listen to the way he ascends to a perfect top G, and THEN goes to the whole of the next phrase without a breath!! Phenomenal.
On top of everything else, his diction is eerily clear. I don't speak Russian at all, but when I hear him, I imagine that I can understand every word, so perfectly does he enunciate every syllable. Lemeshev also has this gift, which is the hallmark of the greatest.
On just this one aria this is the finest voice I have ever heard anywhere, it is just absolute perfection in every way. I actually picked this up for £1 in my local Poundland about 5 years ago on a CD of all Russian Opera, other singers include Ivan Koslovsky, Boris Christoff, and many more, but this particular track is my favourite by a great distance. There is something about Russian culture that has always stood out from the rest and this is just one example. Current favourite is Ms Netrebko
@AulicExclusiva I completely agree. Lisitsian's performance here, and many of his other recordings, are worthy of the great Italian baritones of yore such as Battistini, Ancona, and Stracciari. At the risk of antagonizing the "bel canto police" (I think you know whom I mean), Lisitsian--as well as Schlusnus, Janssen, and Merrill--are all relatively modern bel canto baritones. Thanks for sending my way, and thanks to GOS for posting.
@meltzerboy As Galli-Curci said, bel canto is not and cannot be a static thing, even though it has some steady principles. I would add Joseph Schwarz to your list. He is a great favourite of mine.
@AulicExclusiva A brilliant statement from a singer who sounds familiar to me. Definitely Joseph Schwarz is part of the bel-canto group. I listened to the aria you sent and liked it very, German language and all. Thanks!
Sublime !Dal vivo aveva una bella voce di barotono Verdiano !Che dolcezza nella sua voce .....e si ,la vecchia scuola dove LA emozione e LA iterpretazione giusta erano importanti ! Sublime Lisitsian Grazie .
Is this from the complete recording conducted by Melik-Pashaiev, or a later recording? In any event, it is magnificent. Lisa was a fool not to fall for Yeletsky after hearing this!
The glory of this truly glorious voice is that wholly distinctive vibrato. There are times when I think he really is my favourite singer. And especially in this repertory.
There isn't a pint of comparation.this is the TRUE Tscahikowskian spirit...the TRUE psychological speech of Yeletzky...the TRUE expression...the TRUE beauty!!!!
My god, you are sooooo right! I mean Hvorostovsky has a nice voice, but HERE it´s all coming directly from the heart. I believe Lisitsian every word he is singing. Hvorostovsky on the contrary is much too vain to sing so honestly and purely....
My dear sir or madame:they are different eras...M. Litsitsian belongs to the Era of authentic Beauty...to the ra when you were listenign to a singer whom REALLY WAS all that he/she was singing...
But those times of beauty and perfection are over...unfortunately...So,today,we have one like DH...no more.
My dear sir..or madam..i'm a simple dilettante...and I agree with you...I like and enjoy wood singing...and,in this concept,I can put litsitsian,chernov..and khvorostovsky,too...
Such a wonderful singer... a pity the world was not given the chance to experience during his prime... I feel very much the same about Vishnevskaya.
VoiceClassical 2 months ago
Beautiful baritone. Henry Fogel just did a retrospective on Lisitsian this evening on WFMT network. Heard some great singing there, also!
dedyabrian 2 months ago
Mazurock is no piker either.
Ettoredipugnar 2 months ago
superior to hvorovstovsky's luke warm faked impassioned renditions.
marcellny 3 months ago
Последнее время последние слова арии поют: "О милая, доверьтесь мне".
Natalotos 4 months ago
@Natalotos Да, это и я заметила.
MyNatalie31 4 months ago
Ever since first heard Hvorostovsky sing this at Cardiff Singer of the world, I've been a fan of his, although I think he sings less well these days. But Pavel Lisitsian leaves H at the starting post. Listen to the way he ascends to a perfect top G, and THEN goes to the whole of the next phrase without a breath!! Phenomenal.
adamastorBassBar 6 months ago
What a great rendition! Absolutely beautiful!
sevcik2 7 months ago
wonderful performance, Lisitsian was one of the biggest baryton not only in russian repertory
mongemark 7 months ago
Amen! Every syllable provides proof positive for his supremacy! Thanks for sharing
RoyKa2010 9 months ago
On top of everything else, his diction is eerily clear. I don't speak Russian at all, but when I hear him, I imagine that I can understand every word, so perfectly does he enunciate every syllable. Lemeshev also has this gift, which is the hallmark of the greatest.
Matt75003 11 months ago 2
2:22 - 2:37
Incomparable.
phatphace 11 months ago
Lisitian singing comes through the soul.
joejoe4812 1 year ago
On just this one aria this is the finest voice I have ever heard anywhere, it is just absolute perfection in every way. I actually picked this up for £1 in my local Poundland about 5 years ago on a CD of all Russian Opera, other singers include Ivan Koslovsky, Boris Christoff, and many more, but this particular track is my favourite by a great distance. There is something about Russian culture that has always stood out from the rest and this is just one example. Current favourite is Ms Netrebko
lanzanut 1 year ago 2
Very heavy weight Russian sound; very lyrical; I would prefer to Hvor in this aria.
tennispro4408 1 year ago
Que voz la de este hombre, me encanta su color!
noonkaya 1 year ago
Изумительный голос и человек!!!
01Vlv 1 year ago
The long phrase leading to the high note and down from it was nothing short of phenomenal! This whole performance is truly Golden Age.
AulicExclusiva 1 year ago 2
@AulicExclusiva I completely agree. Lisitsian's performance here, and many of his other recordings, are worthy of the great Italian baritones of yore such as Battistini, Ancona, and Stracciari. At the risk of antagonizing the "bel canto police" (I think you know whom I mean), Lisitsian--as well as Schlusnus, Janssen, and Merrill--are all relatively modern bel canto baritones. Thanks for sending my way, and thanks to GOS for posting.
meltzerboy 1 year ago
@meltzerboy As Galli-Curci said, bel canto is not and cannot be a static thing, even though it has some steady principles. I would add Joseph Schwarz to your list. He is a great favourite of mine.
AulicExclusiva 1 year ago
@AulicExclusiva A brilliant statement from a singer who sounds familiar to me. Definitely Joseph Schwarz is part of the bel-canto group. I listened to the aria you sent and liked it very, German language and all. Thanks!
meltzerboy 1 year ago
@meltzerboy That should read, "liked it very much."
meltzerboy 1 year ago
Все врет главное!))))))) Вот как мужчины заливают))) Обещания!)))
fotyafotieva 1 year ago
to think we have been degraded from lisitsian to hvorostovsky
rexeterna 1 year ago
Fantastic. Delicate, expressive, moving. The best. Thanks for posting.
lektorblomme2 2 years ago 2
sublimely beautiful
gestas60323 2 years ago
Sublime !Dal vivo aveva una bella voce di barotono Verdiano !Che dolcezza nella sua voce .....e si ,la vecchia scuola dove LA emozione e LA iterpretazione giusta erano importanti ! Sublime Lisitsian Grazie .
bodiloto 2 years ago
Pavel was a teacher of Dmitri Hvorostovsky.
This baritone was extraordinary. I'm a fan of Dima .
I adore him.
MARISOLDELMONACO 2 years ago
I too adore Hvorostovsky and Lisitsian!
gloria25031 2 years ago
One of the greatest baritones Russia's produced. Spectacular voice and elegant phrasing. Listen to his An die Musik. It's definitive.
vpo2g2 2 years ago
@vpo2g2
Not just Russia, Lisitsian ethnically is Armenian...
BeautySavesWorld 1 year ago 2
Bravo! Bravo! Archibravo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DemianPoor 2 years ago 2
What a singer, I can't believe my ears.
dermotafan 2 years ago
Yes. That's it.
dermotafan 2 years ago
This is the most beautiful version of this aria I've ever heard. What a gorgeous voice.
lmspr 2 years ago 4
Off the Charts....HUGE!
sagalat 2 years ago 2
Is this from the complete recording conducted by Melik-Pashaiev, or a later recording? In any event, it is magnificent. Lisa was a fool not to fall for Yeletsky after hearing this!
billyguns2 2 years ago 10
@billyguns2 Alexander Shamil'evich Melik-Pashayev is also ethnically Armenian conductor.
joejoe4812 1 year ago
the best baryton ever!
petrof4056 2 years ago
Can somebody tell me where I can find the whole libretto og this opera?
gomongio 3 years ago
The glory of this truly glorious voice is that wholly distinctive vibrato. There are times when I think he really is my favourite singer. And especially in this repertory.
davidhberlin 3 years ago
Wow! And besides all, so clearly prounced Russian! Bravissimo Pavel! You sent tingles down my spine!
lamsalgado 3 years ago
How can you compare Hvorostovsky to this beauty??
Fallout06 3 years ago 19
There isn't a pint of comparation.this is the TRUE Tscahikowskian spirit...the TRUE psychological speech of Yeletzky...the TRUE expression...the TRUE beauty!!!!
Ankhsnammon
Ankhsnammon 3 years ago
@Fallout06
My god, you are sooooo right! I mean Hvorostovsky has a nice voice, but HERE it´s all coming directly from the heart. I believe Lisitsian every word he is singing. Hvorostovsky on the contrary is much too vain to sing so honestly and purely....
79pirastro 1 year ago
@Fallout06 ?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
balkanjiq 10 months ago
@Fallout06 You can't : )
Ettoredipugnar 4 months ago
@Ettoredipugnar I agre! Dh is brilliant as well, I'd say Pl=L was his role model :-))
MyNatalie31 4 months ago
@Fallout06 Seeing as" this beauty" (Lisitian) may well have been Hvorostovski's role model - very well indeed! :-)
MyNatalie31 4 months ago
thank you for posting this. it's marvellous.
only the typo in the tag Lisitsian made it hard to find this as it doesn't come up in search
solomaki 3 years ago
Listening to this makes me cry every time...
Thank you for posting this gem!
primobaritono 3 years ago
What a rich quality to his voice. His singing has so many plusses - liquid legato, beautiful breath control. And I melt from that soulful vibrato.
cantorandopera 3 years ago 2
INSUPERABLE YELETZKY!!!!!!!!!
ankhsnammon
Ankhsnammon 3 years ago
Wow, this is great. I have loved the Hvorostovsky version, but this just takes the cake. THANKS
redsox2213 3 years ago
My dear sir or madame:they are different eras...M. Litsitsian belongs to the Era of authentic Beauty...to the ra when you were listenign to a singer whom REALLY WAS all that he/she was singing...
But those times of beauty and perfection are over...unfortunately...So,today,we have one like DH...no more.
Ankhsnammon
Ankhsnammon 3 years ago
Thanks for the lesson. A simple I agree or I disagree would've been fine. I just enjoy good singing...no more.
redsox2213 3 years ago 2
My dear sir..or madam..i'm a simple dilettante...and I agree with you...I like and enjoy wood singing...and,in this concept,I can put litsitsian,chernov..and khvorostovsky,too...
Respectfully,
Ankhsnammon
Ankhsnammon 3 years ago
Tremendous singing, excellent post -- thank you. May I recommend Lisitian's fine rendition of "si puo" (available on YouTube)?
kgus123 3 years ago
Of course! that performance is more than perfect!
Ankhsnammon
Ankhsnammon 3 years ago