Liang Jian 《亮剑》 - Speech

[ruofan1982]

我怀疑这种所谓的《亮剑》精神！！！

举几个极端的例子， 二战中的日本，战死到最后一人的战术，也没有 改变自己的命运，或者说没有根本改变命运。

电影《巴顿将军》说， 没有那个国家是靠着他的士兵殉国而被拯救的， 我们要让敌人为他们的国家殉国。

我比较支持巴顿的观点， 比较务实。

我的意思希望大家理解！

[MasterZhang]

Pretty much. In the book, he gives a speech about the use of special warfare. And then the latter half of the book begins. I see what they were going for...but it's not a very good speech.

[TheAkastewie]

我同意你的观点，现代化战争中，几乎不可能出现刺刀见红的场面。­。甚之不会出动陆军。。。但作为一名军人必须要有这种亮剑精神。­给敌人一种心里恐惧。

[freelhj]

@ruofan1982 所谓的亮剑精神就是勇气，叫你不要还没开打就尿了。巴顿那话更多­意义上说的是战略战术层面的作战思想。最后，日本人那种不叫勇，­叫疯狂。

[lin05292008]

@ruofan1982 我支持这种亮剑的精神。这是最起码的战斗意志。要理解李云龙的经­历和他所在的时代背景。无论是抗日，或是国共内战，他所在的一方­都处于劣势。单是二战，日本不是单单想打败中国，而是要灭亡中国­。立场上这是决不可妥协的。就算实力上不及日本，也要抗争到底。­投降了，归顺了的，叫汉奸。不单拯救不了中国的命运，还出卖了自­己的人格和灵魂。

我认为你可能没读懂，所谓亮剑精神，李云龙强调的是弱方面对强者­的态度和精神。胜败乃兵家常事。战可以输，但精神不可以灭。世事­无常，一切物质无恒衰，无恒强，只要精神不死，就有希望，情势就­会有扭转的一天。提到二战中的日本，德国，意大利，挑起战火的邪­恶轴心国和灭绝人性纳粹主义，放眼全世界是不得人心的，会遭到反­抗和抗争，他们是必败的。此消彼长，正义一方的胜利，是时间的问­题。

[Aristocrax]

It's basically a rant on how courage and morale can decide the results of a battle. *yawns*

[terrykuok2007]

小說中李雲龍的論文是特種兵理論。

[0112333]

This guy is simply a bandit. Tu Fei.....

But it is his attitude that is what is admirable and necessary in China today.

[MasterZhang]

Yeah, IMO it's not a very good speech. Nowhere near as good as Ding Wei's.

[orgrishburger2]

i don't see technical stuff there, apart from saying brave brave brave.

[zhuhaoyue1013]

That is necessary, too~

[reasonltd]

in 1950s, in PLA, among many illiterate generals, it should be regarded as of high quality dissertation. A+

for today's illiterate generation, it is a good show, but merely a show, because this generation is a show generation, but merely a show generation. hope it is not the reality

[HUIANZZQ]

love this vedio. be a man, show your sword to your enemy, don't chicken out!

[sungaoshan]

awesome fuck those japanese

[championofcathay]

I love innuendos

[linanhai1983]

Awesome!!! 为什么不加上英文字幕，让狗日的也好好看看。个人认为，《亮剑》­这部片子应该出口到美欧日。

[longhanfei]

顶！