The pilots were trained to follow instruments especially at night. The contradicting warnings telling them they are too fast and too slow led them to believe that nothing could be trusted. They relied on the tower providing altitude and alas that too was incorrect. They were truly flying blind and the only hope was the rescue plane finding them so they could follow it back to land but it came too late.
Pherhaps the landing lights could of helped the pilots to spot the see? Im not an oficial pilot but i think that they should of put on the landing lights in order to see the ground
I'm amazed that even in this modern age we have so many accidents occur at night that probably wouldn't have happened during the day (or at least would have been more survivable). Now I pretty much fly only during daytime and I sit way in the back - well unless I can get a free upgrade to 1st class.
Well i can state that, I , who hasnt got any experience flying planes, would have gone to cruise thrust and slow climb.
Seriously if you got engines at idle for about 1min and you got your speed brakes deployed, how the hell can you stay at 10,000feet with speeds climbing and dropping rapidly, by that info i would have trusted my logical thinking and do whats safest until i got time to think this one out.
They were 100% confused with all the alarms going off. It probably got to a point where they didn't know what alarm to trust.
But they should have known that you must trust the pull up warning.It's an accident after all, such a small thing like a plastic tape was the main culprit.
@ThePowerofThe0tak that what confused me at one stage aswell. Apprently it impacted and the left engine took in ocean water after this the plane climbed up 221 feet before plummeting down.
@oke139 No. The stick shaker works because air passing too slowly over the control surfaces literally shakes the controls. The airplane itself is designed so that happens at too-low airspeeds, no matter what the computers and instruments do. (The voice may well be connected to the computer, I don't know)
@Scott1821 If you have ever been in the cockpit of a plane "airliner" at midnight over the ocean it's like turning off the lights in the room and cover your eyes with a blanket.
flight 603 was over land well close so they turned the plane around note NATGEO has cut off alot of scenes from this episodes because it was long you need to watch it on the DVD there are more scenes youy havent seen yet
I'm probably a bit naive here...but when you have a Ground Proximity Warning and you are actually so darn close to the ground or water, won't the plane's powerful lights be able to pick up something on the ground as a visual for the pilots?
I know it was night and dark but the water would have shone off the plane's lights, right?
Thanks for that. However, my point is this: When they were flying blind not knowing whether they were too low and when the ground proximity warning went off, wouldn't it have been a good idea to switch on the powerful take-off/landing lights at least to check if they were close to the ground/water? That could have helped!!
you are talking ab out landing lights, these are used for departure and arrival, located in different places on different aircrqaft. but once you are airborne then you normally turn them off at around 10,000 feet, or even lower. so in their case they would have been turned off (9,700ft)
you got other lights like beacon and navigation, but those are not visible to the pilots and they dont make that much of a reflection on water.
Could it be an UFO incident? They are known (allegedly) to cause instruments to go haywire.
battwann88 3 months ago
Comment removed
dannykrieke 6 months ago
what the f*ck happened to the computer??
F*cking Windows 95??
waddlerobloxxxx 8 months ago
why dont they turn on their landing lights.....
YanYan1337 10 months ago
@YanYan1337 Or ALL of their lights?
taylorover9000 9 months ago
I´m peruvian, so its sad to see this. :(
gflyer95 10 months ago
The pilots were trained to follow instruments especially at night. The contradicting warnings telling them they are too fast and too slow led them to believe that nothing could be trusted. They relied on the tower providing altitude and alas that too was incorrect. They were truly flying blind and the only hope was the rescue plane finding them so they could follow it back to land but it came too late.
eneity7 11 months ago
lol at emirates plane @ 1:34 they dont even fly to peru
luckypatrice2 11 months ago
Raise the speedbreaks!!! :(:(:(
fdsajklj 1 year ago
220 kts groundspeed means it's not overspeed.
fdsajklj 1 year ago
TOO LOW...TERRAIN!
andysoxd 1 year ago
i can't help noticing that the copliot seems to smile sometimes :/
EagleHawk175 1 year ago
Pherhaps the landing lights could of helped the pilots to spot the see? Im not an oficial pilot but i think that they should of put on the landing lights in order to see the ground
nial12345 1 year ago
I'm amazed that even in this modern age we have so many accidents occur at night that probably wouldn't have happened during the day (or at least would have been more survivable). Now I pretty much fly only during daytime and I sit way in the back - well unless I can get a free upgrade to 1st class.
md65000 1 year ago
This is a terrible incident, however, the NTSB guy's sound effects at 3:09 are pretty funny
MsYumo 1 year ago 2
This sucks. TH=he poor guy thinks he's helping them, but he's using their junk info. Bummer.
lyssaryan77 1 year ago
There are lights underneath the airplane, why can't they see the reflection of the sea against the light?
WackoX1337 1 year ago
Well i can state that, I , who hasnt got any experience flying planes, would have gone to cruise thrust and slow climb.
Seriously if you got engines at idle for about 1min and you got your speed brakes deployed, how the hell can you stay at 10,000feet with speeds climbing and dropping rapidly, by that info i would have trusted my logical thinking and do whats safest until i got time to think this one out.
oke139 1 year ago
@oke139 amen to that! u think it would be obvious!
PurpleJade83 1 year ago
why didnt the pilot JUST CLIMB. why risk it.
mechatengu 1 year ago
@mechatengu
They were 100% confused with all the alarms going off. It probably got to a point where they didn't know what alarm to trust.
But they should have known that you must trust the pull up warning.It's an accident after all, such a small thing like a plastic tape was the main culprit.
netlord 1 year ago
is there an alarm that says the airplane is too high?
StupidBlech 1 year ago
@StupidBlech No..becouse you cant fly to high..the plane will lose power and fall down. You will notice by the aircraft behavor.
loch70 1 year ago
Pause at the real footage at 8:15. isn't that fella on the left a little bit young to be an emergency rescue crewman?
eatmoremonsters 1 year ago
why aren't they able to climb back up after the initial impact?
ThePowerofThe0tak 1 year ago
@ThePowerofThe0tak that what confused me at one stage aswell. Apprently it impacted and the left engine took in ocean water after this the plane climbed up 221 feet before plummeting down.
FLT111 1 year ago
[sigh] ok trained pilots... the stick shaker is physiological- it can't lie.
iiiset 2 years ago
@iiiset I could be wrong but isnt the stick shaker attached to the computer?
oke139 1 year ago
@oke139 No. The stick shaker works because air passing too slowly over the control surfaces literally shakes the controls. The airplane itself is designed so that happens at too-low airspeeds, no matter what the computers and instruments do. (The voice may well be connected to the computer, I don't know)
iiiset 1 year ago
The freaking stick was shaking! Is that not enough signal to know that they are stalling?
AlucardPR 2 years ago
I like this guys voice better then the other guy ....
amazedwhat 2 years ago 22
@amazedwhat
I actually like the other narrarator's voice because Its less scary to hear than this one.
SidB8 1 year ago
@amazedwhat right on! He also narrates 48 hours on A&E
LOLMAN22 1 year ago
You can see nothing
961470 2 years ago 4
it's night-_-
961470 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why dont they just look out the window
Scott1821 2 years ago
@Scott1821 If you have ever been in the cockpit of a plane "airliner" at midnight over the ocean it's like turning off the lights in the room and cover your eyes with a blanket.
dreampilot2 2 years ago 20
Always trust stick shaker.
GamertownUSA 2 years ago 4
LMFAO
MR. KILBERTUS
Laurynn1111 2 years ago
ahaha my drama teacher is in this!
sammy27slammerjammer 2 years ago
what? With a possible collision with a mountain or skyscraper? what the hell they are in the ocean!
AndyMcArren1356 2 years ago
flight 603 was over land well close so they turned the plane around note NATGEO has cut off alot of scenes from this episodes because it was long you need to watch it on the DVD there are more scenes youy havent seen yet
FLT111 2 years ago
Whoop Whoop! Pull up!
Too low terrain!
surfco 2 years ago
unreal..what a tragedy. intense experience.
EricGodClapton 2 years ago
lights are located on the landing i think
volks1234 2 years ago
I'm probably a bit naive here...but when you have a Ground Proximity Warning and you are actually so darn close to the ground or water, won't the plane's powerful lights be able to pick up something on the ground as a visual for the pilots?
I know it was night and dark but the water would have shone off the plane's lights, right?
uchilledfrance 2 years ago
On question about that light thing... they don't need the light on unless they're taking off or landing.
toakodan 2 years ago
Thanks for that. However, my point is this: When they were flying blind not knowing whether they were too low and when the ground proximity warning went off, wouldn't it have been a good idea to switch on the powerful take-off/landing lights at least to check if they were close to the ground/water? That could have helped!!
uchilledfrance 2 years ago
you are talking ab out landing lights, these are used for departure and arrival, located in different places on different aircrqaft. but once you are airborne then you normally turn them off at around 10,000 feet, or even lower. so in their case they would have been turned off (9,700ft)
you got other lights like beacon and navigation, but those are not visible to the pilots and they dont make that much of a reflection on water.
contemporarymonk 2 years ago