Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (84)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 唱的好沒力...去聽一下外國的版本好嗎= =?

  • Tremendous! Excellent costume and a wonderful powerful voice. Ignore the people who have no idea what they're talking about, this is how it should be done. Young coloraturas ev'rywhere learn from this magnificent performance.

  • 頑張ってハイFを歌いきってるのは素晴らしい事と思います。もう­少し中音域も充実しているとなお良いと思います。素人の感想で、­すみません。

  • 好讚

    

  • not nice at all...

  • この曲は、悪い心を持った女王が娘を支配しようと怒り狂って絶縁­を迫るところ。もっと怒りの表現が出来てないと、いくら高音が出­ても、世界ではno emotionalとか、そういう評価を受けてしまうと思う。せ­っかくここまで高音が出るのだから、表現も成長して欲しい。

  • @moerenodame

    同感!!!!!私もチャレンジしたことあるから、わかるけど、コ­ロトゥーラの転がす部分に神経使ってるのが伝わってきて!!。も­う、音ちょっとくらいハズしてもいいから、狂わんばかりの怒りが­見たい。

  • @moerenodame たしかに。これはなんだかただ歌ってるだけのミュージカルみたい­だ。

  • なんか残念感に包まれてしまうなあ。さて、お耳直しに・・・・・­・

  • GODDIVAって曲聴いてね

    

  • @kainene6

    アリプロ厨帰れ 俺も好きだけど

  • もうちょっと怒り狂ってほしかった

  • FだFだヨ!がんばれーーー!!!

    って感じですね。でもいうのは簡単だよねえ。

  • sings like a queen on the cross.

  • 美しい声です。 【yuki】

  • oh damrau! may god bless you..

  • ブラボーは出ないな

  • Her voice sounds too gentle for this charater, she may need to remember something angerly to have a right mood to sing

  • Falsetto... She's forcing her voice :S

  • @1K1Valenta shes not using her falsetto, but she is forcing her voice, and she is forcing her vibrato

  • ちょっとズレがあるような気がする。

    あと歌詞が少し簡略化されてる気がする。

    でもあと一歩って感じだと思う。悪くは無い。

  • You guys should know how is hard to sing in germany when you are japanese.

  • @CandyBlog agreed, plus, it takes TONS of time and patience to train your voice to sing in that range, even if not all of the notes are quite correct, add that to the japanese person singing a german song and you get quite a complicated act that she was tallented enough to come so close to perfecting it, and for this, I comend her *throws a rose*

  • Taiwan boy 朱育陞Yushengat present only 15 years old!!

  • This is... not painful. Actually Tarja Turunen could do a better job. For one thing, you would be able hear her. This lady is just... not the best in the world. Her high notes are off and she has little to no feeling/emotion in the song. And the spread out arms just look silly.

  • @SenshiofWolves

    I agree with you...Tarja could do it better

    This woman don't have that kind of anger that is need in this aria...(sorry for my bad english)

  • Not another lyric coloratura trying to sing this :(

  • @carami4 There's a reason why I haven't attempted this yet...

  • @SenshiofWolves Lol yeah. I'm a soubrette working my way into lyric coloratura repertoire. I would not ever dare try to sing this song for a performance (minus the fact I dont have the notes yet) :P

    It just requires a much fuller voice, a dramatic coloratura.

  • 請google"台版魔笛"

  • one of the more interesting costumes iv seen for this character.... :O

  • márromenos!

  • Her sing is so fast so a don't like it( ̄ー ̄)

  • Her singing is not as good, very far from being fair

  • わー☆

  • her german is really good!!!! I can understand everything.

  • このアリアを歌った宮部小牧という人は、聖徳大学音楽学部の講師­も務めているプロですね。

  • uffffffffffff

  • 後後後後

  • I´m German. And i can understand her and that´s very good xDD

  • To be frank, this aria is beyond her ability.

  • This is one of the most difficult arias to sing. She did well in making it through the whole piece, but she definitly did not make a good job at singing it.

    In my opinion she should try singing lyrical arias. She has not the voice for a coloratura soprano, or at least not yet. Just because one can reach those high notes(and she even had difficulties reaching them at all), you are not necessarily able to make them sound right.

  • missing the Fs

  • LOVE the dress. If she would lose the horns she'd be the best costumed Queen of the Night on Youtube.

  • Not bad, perhaps a few more angry face...Thanks!

  • 雞皮疙瘩!

  • It's ok. But not the best. Though I'd love to be able to sing half as good as she does. lol

  • abaixa o braço ¬¬

  • 夜の女王のアリア色々みたけどこれはかなり立派です。すいごいな­あ。ここまで出来るのは多くないすよ。

  • wow amazing! is this student's work? brilliant!!!

  • すばらしい。

    期待してます。

    主役のお名前を教えてください。

  • Perhaps Germanic Opera's are best left to the Germans, or at least Europe, this is just weird.

  • @fremenofarakis I know some very fine Asian singers...especially Koreans. This is just a bad production.

  • this voice is sharp >.,<

  • Very amateur voice and definitely not strong enough for this aria, along with her acting. She's placing it completely wrong, the B flat at the end is weak and erratic, not to mention her german is far from great.. Generally just unimpressive and "meh".

  • @robski91

    You mean "meheheheh"...

  • the costme is amazing

  • Hmmm!

  • nice, nothing more. Far from perfect....

  • She missed three out of the 4 top Fs, and there is very little interpretation. She also looks more like a black ram than the queen of the night. She may not be able to threaten Sarastro with her top F, but she can still butt.....

  • @baritonebynight good job XD *thumbs up*

  • baritonebynight, she missed more than just three of those F6's in that part of the aria... Do you know if this is actually a professional production where people paid to see this? By professional, I mean an actual opera company?

  • @oneworldguy I figured this was a student presentation (and a bad one at that).

  • @baritonebynight She may be just nervous in the moment G_G Ok, it's not perfect at all, but was VERY good in my opinion.

  • @wen21s She's a bit better than Florence Foster Jenkins...I'll give you that.

  • I did not like it... she does not know how to sign this aria...

  • it's too pretty. it needs to be a little more angry! it's talking about hell's vengeance inside of her. This lady is just singing the song and not acting at all. Disappointing.

  • This is amazing!!!!

  • 1:10のとこすごい。。。

  • Average performance. Awful posture of the Queen during the whole aria.

  • @ImanalinMr

    yes....i don`t feel it ><... still Diana`s Damrau performance is the best...^^

  • Its  .................. magic !!

  • Ah wow, this is great. That voice is really awesome. She sent shivers down my spine and it's just so great! Loved it since I'm 3

  • 声高すぎ。すごいなぁ。。

    絶対にこんな声出ないわぁ。。

  • 声高いな、こんな綺麗で高い声がよく出せるな、と感心

  • すげぇなぁ・・・・・良くこんな声が出るもんだ・・・・。

  • efafefae

  • I like it. every time I listen this opera, women's voice is very beautiful. probably, it is the best beatutiful of all things in the world.

    I am absorbed in the voice and lost myself

    in the forest of beautiful voice opera.

    I can't help appliciating the beautiful voice that gifted from god.

    thanks!

  • 彼女はいい声して,しかし少し式,Diana Damrauのビデオ見て =)

    Cierto no tiene mucha expresion o desenvolvimiento en el escenario a pesar de su voz, recomiendo ver la interpretacion de Diana Damrau en videos relacionados. =)

  • Great costume, a very challenging aria but a few unfortunate pitch problems. Still, she is very believable as the Queen and may be a singer to keep an eye on for future development.

  • Total carencia de expresion al igual que en aria primera las tres damas, no solo es la expresion y que decir de la afinación de la reina de la noche en los agudos. La verdad no me gusto.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more