Is talented and even show she doesn't always sound the very best she can be she does this nearly every night while on tour think about it. He vocal chords are spent and she still sounds amazing. Better than any other crap out there.
I've seen them live and she sung live. Most of the performances I've found on youtube,however, there is too strong a presence of a pre-recording (to me, any at all is too much but even for other's standards). I saw her with Korn, so she probably knew we weren't going to abide that weak sh*t.
What?!! I did´t listen to this band (and this song) for years and now I find this! She's making playback!! I have listened 3 different versions of this song here in Youtube and all of them have the same vocal pre-recording ¬¬
@JohnFalocco trust me, she sings live, because for one, her performances are NEVER the same, they are all unique and beautiful, and if you listen closely you can tell it's not even the CD vocals (except for backup). Listen to this song during the Open Door era and you can definately tell she does sing this song live :)
@dadsbestchild Yes, but I was talking about a different vocal recording, not the studio CD vocal, do you understand? They used it in different concerts, I mean, the "professional way" to make playback. A lot of singers do the same... :S
Don't you guess they would've choosen a better recording? Just saying.
This is not her best performance live of this song, it's full of imperfections and the breath is very marked (I find it awesome, but it's not her best). It's definitely live, she changes the way she sings every single time. Which are the other gigs you're talkin' about, anyway? Just post them here, so we can judge. :)
the lights were terrible for this song, i agree, they should of had the lights match the rhythm of the guitars like during the open door tour, but this was years ago
@dadsbestchild It was easily the best live show I had ever seen. Seriously. Amy prefers smaller venues, so there were maybe 5,000 folks there, and it was very intimate. She takes the time to talk with us between shows, joke a little, give us some insight into the songs. While we were there, her husband Josh was mingling with the crowd, passing out TWLOHA literature. She took some time to talk about that.
I left that concert really feeling like I knew her, like we all had connected with her.
Hey hey hey cut her some slack Amy
Is talented and even show she doesn't always sound the very best she can be she does this nearly every night while on tour think about it. He vocal chords are spent and she still sounds amazing. Better than any other crap out there.
jwhitloctombraider 1 month ago
this guys are telling the truth she sings different in the concents and the audio quality and how near is the recorder from her
quino7898 2 months ago
nice crowd.... amy lee is the best...
JeikoZeus 11 months ago
I've seen them live and she sung live. Most of the performances I've found on youtube,however, there is too strong a presence of a pre-recording (to me, any at all is too much but even for other's standards). I saw her with Korn, so she probably knew we weren't going to abide that weak sh*t.
BluMarbleRose 1 year ago
She needs a little vocal training, apart from the high head notes (which are, like, GORGEOUS), but is amazing anyway.
Wagnerlover777 1 year ago
@Wagnerlover777
Not vocal training, but she needs to keep up on her cardio. If your out of shape you can't sing that well.
LeFemmeCrystal 1 year ago
What?!! I did´t listen to this band (and this song) for years and now I find this! She's making playback!! I have listened 3 different versions of this song here in Youtube and all of them have the same vocal pre-recording ¬¬
JohnFalocco 1 year ago
@JohnFalocco trust me, she sings live, because for one, her performances are NEVER the same, they are all unique and beautiful, and if you listen closely you can tell it's not even the CD vocals (except for backup). Listen to this song during the Open Door era and you can definately tell she does sing this song live :)
dadsbestchild 1 year ago 10
@dadsbestchild Yes, but I was talking about a different vocal recording, not the studio CD vocal, do you understand? They used it in different concerts, I mean, the "professional way" to make playback. A lot of singers do the same... :S
JohnFalocco 1 year ago
@JohnFalocco I really don't think so.
Don't you guess they would've choosen a better recording? Just saying.
This is not her best performance live of this song, it's full of imperfections and the breath is very marked (I find it awesome, but it's not her best). It's definitely live, she changes the way she sings every single time. Which are the other gigs you're talkin' about, anyway? Just post them here, so we can judge. :)
grrroupiedoll 5 months ago
Evanescence is the best band of all times and all spaces...and amy is the best :songer,songwriter,pianist,and woman of all time and spaces...
MrGogiko 1 year ago 4
she looked very pretty at this concert :)
TheDarkrai915 2 years ago
dude she was rockin out the whole bannd was i luv evanescence amy lee you rock !!!!!!
rugratalyssa 2 years ago
when she did the first chorus they should've lit the place up more to make it dramatic!
Amy Lee = Best Singer of all time!!!
Evanescence = Best Band of the all time!
DarknessUnveils 2 years ago 16
the lights were terrible for this song, i agree, they should of had the lights match the rhythm of the guitars like during the open door tour, but this was years ago
dadsbestchild 2 years ago
@dadsbestchild Have you seen them live in the TOD era? There needs to be a Grammy for live show lighting engineer, because their guy rocks.
Halo4Lyf 11 months ago
@Halo4Lyf No, i've never seen Evanescence live before unfortunately. But with this new tour for the new album, thats gonna change.
dadsbestchild 11 months ago 2
@dadsbestchild It was easily the best live show I had ever seen. Seriously. Amy prefers smaller venues, so there were maybe 5,000 folks there, and it was very intimate. She takes the time to talk with us between shows, joke a little, give us some insight into the songs. While we were there, her husband Josh was mingling with the crowd, passing out TWLOHA literature. She took some time to talk about that.
I left that concert really feeling like I knew her, like we all had connected with her.
Halo4Lyf 11 months ago
Ben AND Amy forever !!!
immortalsoloist 3 years ago
Amy lee is the BEST!
xLBPx 3 years ago 7
omg!! that was so good!! i love amy lee shes my favorit singer yay! oh yeah and the vid rocks!! ^_*
17harmony17 3 years ago 3
its cool
what can i say about it
ahmedq8154 3 years ago 2
this is the best performance of going under ive ever heard her sing lol
samarax69 3 years ago
I love this song also! xDDDD
Amy Lee rocks my mother fucking rocks!
haha xDDDDDDDDDDD
xROckXMysxOCKSx 3 years ago
This is my favorite song of all time and I love this show it's so good and she's sooo hot :D
I LOVE AMY LEE!!!!!!!
AmyChristianOli429 3 years ago 2
SOMEONE COMMENT ON THE VID! Pls lol
dadsbestchild 3 years ago