秋去秋來 葉德嫻

[jameslo2009]

因為越泥越鐘意deanie，

感嘆自己唔係生於多姿多彩的80s

[viviansflam]

It is a real enjoyment listening to this version. Deanie's rendition makes my heart ache. Original is not always better.

[viviansflam]

I miss 林振強 who wrote such beautiful lyrics.

[dillonfanisthebest]

我想我是生錯了年代，為什麼我要生在在這個世俗不懂好音樂的年代­，如果70 80 90年代的好音樂能伴我成長就好了。

[meict3]

喜歡這版本.

[lammiutube]

Her voice is so touching!!!

[1230124]

不得了!

聽到心低暗暗地痛的感覺!

[aw05172001]

連葉德嫻都唔識，唔好同人講自己聽香港音樂，咩叫這個女人，連尊­重都沒有

[TheVictornwolf]

葉德嫻奪影后 華仔跪下頒獎 (22:49pm) - Taiwan 第48屆金馬獎

[wingwing0404]

個人好鍾意sally既version, 但係葉德嫻既聲線令到首歌多左一份更深既淒涼感覺, 感情更能流露.

只係我比較唔鍾意係後面既既和音.

[theleonardlau]

。。。轻轻的，真真实实的，沙沙声的，把整个故事诉出来；就如无­力的秋风，把你的心坎，你的疼，都一一的握出来。。：）

[theleonardlau]

This is an amazing and truthful delivery of the song by 葉德嫻

[victornwolf]

点解突然間咁多人講Deanie嘅? 因為佢'紅'咗? : P : P : P

Anyway, 無興趣講边個好D, 只想講Deanie唱歌方式在香港係少有嘅! 佢後生唔係學技巧, 而係跟菲律賓樂手學唱感情表達, 所以趙增熹話佢唱歌好自由, 而我覺得佢唱歌懂得利用歌詞的停顿位宣洩她的感情. 利用透氣位, 尾音注上感情而自成一家, 不信? 請聽1:18掛, 1:57酸, 2:31你, 3:18你... Those who like Deanie will understand what I say! 由於佢声沙, 一般人未必聽得倒那種味道, 也由於佢声沙, 佢唱怨曲好啱key, 佢無揀錯歌唱! 只是香港主流聽眾聽掛'菲菲之音'...欢迎音樂人, 錄音師見這留言指教我, thx!

(ps Good that people take notice of her regardless good or bad. At least people do it!!!)

[akrack]

@victornwolf Agree...當日聽Deanie就發覺佢唱歌技巧了得...­利用換氣時候加上豐富的感情...平日沒發覺的, 注意 1:57酸, 容易理解些. 至於Deanie有特色的聲線, 帶點哀怨的味道, 唱出甚麼歌都好動聽... 當然, 這是個人感覺...不必要比較Sally或Deanie...

突然好多人講Deanie, 因為佢最近紅...but我一直好欣賞Deanie, 紅唔紅都咁支持...

[sandyyzhou]

sally's voice is definitely more suitable for this song , and i really really like her version cux sally is able to bring out the emotions . deanie is not bad , though her voice isnt good for the song , she does an excellent job in catching the emotions and feelings of this song . bravo to both singers !

[mangoyellow1951]

經典詮釋

[powering111]

我同意原唱者葉倩文好聽好多! 但葉德嫻都很多首本名曲, 別人唱也唱不出她的味道來, 都係唱番自己既歌好了!

[seeseeso89]

正! 真係好有味道! 唱出那種傷懷、慨嘆 的 秋去秋來 ^_^ Thanks for posting ^_^

[083wxv]

如泣如訴



[iamasmallpotato2]

有味道的歌聲

[oscar661bmt]

It's fantastic!

This version is unique, a totally different way from the original, love this one even better!

Thank you for uploading this song.

[hk96006345]

大陸人聽過赤子,倦,的先至講喇, 同葉倩文根本兩個style.

[Ann73500]

deanie係我Idon 她少女時有少女昧 中年有女人味 我真是非常喜歡她 希望deanie姐無意地打開這個綱頁 看看你的Fans讚你的説話

[meict3]

多謝上傳, 好聽到無話可說.

[tgrrd]

唔明o個D人爭辯甚麽! 唱歌除咗把聲外, 重有講性格, 技巧, 手法等... 你o地可以話唔欣賞deanie嘅聲線, 但唔可以話佢唱得差!上網睇吓有Do乜影壇樂壇人物將deani­e作為偶像先講啦啦, 朋友! 不須在此講多無謂!

[stayawakehk]

This is so beautiful - the original 秋去秋來 has never struck me as very special (just a typical Canto-pop even though Sally Ip is a fantastic singer).

But the emotion that Deanie conveys in this cover version takes the meaning of the original song/lyrics to a new height.

Thanks for posting -

[mjjonathan]

吓...如無意外, 他的感情, 演繹都可以令人感到那種無奈

唔係話Sally唔好, 根本是兩種風格

又何必事事比較

[1988ahyu]

So nice. Thx for posting!

[1988ahyu]

一句講哂, 鐘意傳統手法嗰D唔會like deanie嘅, 由得佢哋! Hohoho....

[hehehahawowawo]

唔鍾意

唔好聽>^<

[bonanza2331]

同一首歌﹐葉倩文的版本無論演譯和唱功都高幾籌

[beangreat]

@bonanza2331

唔好意思, 若單單用sally 姐嗰首live比較, 你只可話Sally 姐音色甜美動人, 論演釋手法, 感情投入及編曲技巧, 她比不上Deanie姐版本!

[777heron]

@bonanza2331 叶倩文唱的最好的，秋意浓浓，感情丰富，无人能比。这个女的像是­念过去的，我都你唱的好些，呵呵