@aim786 Akhi I suggest you shouldn't waste your time refuting these stubborn, arrogant people. I mean truth is clear from falsehood and if they choose to follow their Desires then let them be
Where is your evidence that Mutta existed prior to Islam. Try and be consistent, And if you dont know what he is talking about then your are willfully ignorant of Islam and Mohameds sunna!
@Notgoingnowhere its not proving that mutah is haram. i know exactly what mutah is.. a lot more than u do. im not going into the one night stand issue with u..mutah let alone is something u dont understand. So are u insulting the companions who did do mutah in the Prophets (s) time? When they were away from their wives for such a long time? Even IF it was haram, it was still halal during the prophet's time so dont insult mutah in that way cuz u insult the companions who did do it.
I know it mentions it in the Qur'an that the Prophet is not allowed to make haram something that is made halal for the people..eventhough it might of been revealed at a certain point Allah says it for everything.
@ayasalman Are you seriously stupid?? The Prophet is not not allowed to make something haram out of his OWN desires. If Allah SWT makes it haram, It is haram. Allah also says Quran: "He does not speak from his whims and desires, it is merely and inspiration given to him". This means that everything about the deen is perfect. Have you heard of the law of abrogation? Allah had allowed alcohol before but then banned. The same can be said about Mut'a. These were both from Jahiliyyah (before Islam)
@aim786 how dare u insult a sister in islam? Now who has the insults? If Allah (swt) made it haram it would say so in the Qur'an..but it doesn't say its haram in the Qur'an. That verse is in regards to when he talks about Islam the religion and how to teach ppl about daily life..but if its something personal,etc. yes he can speak on his own accord, if it was the cause that everything was Allah's words from him than he'll never be judged by Allah on the Day.
@ayasalman what sister did I insult? Listen you really don't understand the idea of abrogation in Islam. For example the punishment for stoning the adulterer is not in the Quran but it is part of the shari'ah because we take it from the sunnah. Just as we take the prohibition of Muta'a from the Sunnah. Are you saying that Prophet would say something about Islam that is not from Allah? I hope not , but that is what your implying by your statements.
@aim786 what sister did u insult? ME. I am ur sister in Islam whether u like it or not. I understand full well of abrogation in Islam. Talking about stoning what i dont get is not all countries do that..yeah they may do stoning too but for the same crime they could hang, shoot u,etc. so where did hang or shoot u come into being or with teh sword,etc. I am not arguing there im just asking a q that is what i dont get.
@aim786 no its u that is saying that the Prophet said something abou tIslam that is not form Allah (swt) and thats about banning Mutah. Prophet cant make haram something Allah made halal.
@ayasalman Yes and the command to obey the Prophet what he ordered you is in the Quran as well. So If the Prophet (S) prohibits somethings, it is haram.
@aim786 And it says in the Qur'an that the Prophet (s) can not forbid something which Allah has made halal..Allah made mutah halal thats why the Prophet allowed his companions to do mutah when they were away from their wives,etc.
@aim786 Akhi I suggest you shouldn't waste your time refuting these stubborn, arrogant people. I mean truth is clear from falsehood and if they choose to follow their Desires then let them be
Mansoor2108 3 months ago
Where is your evidence that Mutta existed prior to Islam. Try and be consistent, And if you dont know what he is talking about then your are willfully ignorant of Islam and Mohameds sunna!
dickknows 4 months ago
Everyone please watch these videos (other parts are coming) by a former Iranian shia Sayed explaining the prohibition of Muta in great detail:
watch?v=FYQSLpYKJn4
AbuMuslimKhorasani 9 months ago
@AbuMuslimKhorasani Akhi you can post that video as a response to this video and I will approve it for everyone to see insha Allah.
aim786 9 months ago
@aim786
Salam brother,
that video is not mine, ask him and he will do it. Inshallah!.
AbuMuslimKhorasani 8 months ago
@aim786 who are you to approve? so what ever you say is going to be 100% right and everyone else is wrong? ..ignorance
HaraketBeydoun 7 months ago
Muta is even haram according to shia Ahadeeth from Ali bin abi Talib (ra) but the shia accuse him of Taqqiyah. (ayazubillah)
Moreover, Allah (swt) clearly says that it is "...Unlawful to have SECRET relations(lovers)..."
AbuMuslimKhorasani 9 months ago
@Notgoingnowhere its not proving that mutah is haram. i know exactly what mutah is.. a lot more than u do. im not going into the one night stand issue with u..mutah let alone is something u dont understand. So are u insulting the companions who did do mutah in the Prophets (s) time? When they were away from their wives for such a long time? Even IF it was haram, it was still halal during the prophet's time so dont insult mutah in that way cuz u insult the companions who did do it.
ayasalman 9 months ago
I know it mentions it in the Qur'an that the Prophet is not allowed to make haram something that is made halal for the people..eventhough it might of been revealed at a certain point Allah says it for everything.
ayasalman 9 months ago
@ayasalman Are you seriously stupid?? The Prophet is not not allowed to make something haram out of his OWN desires. If Allah SWT makes it haram, It is haram. Allah also says Quran: "He does not speak from his whims and desires, it is merely and inspiration given to him". This means that everything about the deen is perfect. Have you heard of the law of abrogation? Allah had allowed alcohol before but then banned. The same can be said about Mut'a. These were both from Jahiliyyah (before Islam)
aim786 9 months ago
@aim786 how dare u insult a sister in islam? Now who has the insults? If Allah (swt) made it haram it would say so in the Qur'an..but it doesn't say its haram in the Qur'an. That verse is in regards to when he talks about Islam the religion and how to teach ppl about daily life..but if its something personal,etc. yes he can speak on his own accord, if it was the cause that everything was Allah's words from him than he'll never be judged by Allah on the Day.
ayasalman 9 months ago
@ayasalman what sister did I insult? Listen you really don't understand the idea of abrogation in Islam. For example the punishment for stoning the adulterer is not in the Quran but it is part of the shari'ah because we take it from the sunnah. Just as we take the prohibition of Muta'a from the Sunnah. Are you saying that Prophet would say something about Islam that is not from Allah? I hope not , but that is what your implying by your statements.
aim786 9 months ago
@aim786 what sister did u insult? ME. I am ur sister in Islam whether u like it or not. I understand full well of abrogation in Islam. Talking about stoning what i dont get is not all countries do that..yeah they may do stoning too but for the same crime they could hang, shoot u,etc. so where did hang or shoot u come into being or with teh sword,etc. I am not arguing there im just asking a q that is what i dont get.
ayasalman 9 months ago
@aim786 no its u that is saying that the Prophet said something abou tIslam that is not form Allah (swt) and thats about banning Mutah. Prophet cant make haram something Allah made halal.
ayasalman 9 months ago
@aim786 and the alcohol issue is mentioned in the Qur'an..banning of muta' is not.
ayasalman 9 months ago
@ayasalman Yes and the command to obey the Prophet what he ordered you is in the Quran as well. So If the Prophet (S) prohibits somethings, it is haram.
aim786 9 months ago
@aim786 And it says in the Qur'an that the Prophet (s) can not forbid something which Allah has made halal..Allah made mutah halal thats why the Prophet allowed his companions to do mutah when they were away from their wives,etc.
ayasalman 9 months ago