This is an aria about a young daughter who begs her father to approve her marriage or she'll abscond to Florence and throw herself in the Arno River. I'm not sure a young ten-year-old has enough life experience required to evoke such emotion. If she's just mouthing words without understanding the feeling, it's not art but a lie.
@aristopus Did you know that "Gianni Schicchi" the opera this aria comes from is a comic opera? I doubt it.
That aside, you have no way of knowing what Jackie Evancho" understands or doesn't understand. As far as conveying emotion, I'd say she reaches a tremendous number of people emotionally not just in this song but in all that she sings.
@aristopus - One doesn't need to understand the words to either evoke feeling or feel it. The music ITSELF evokes & provokes feeling (even without understanding the words). If that wasn't the case no one in country would even bother listening to Italian opera EVER - since few in this country understand Italian.
HEY ASSHOLE'S!!!!! This young lady has a great voice, and yes it's not perfect but FUCK QUIT BITCHING!!!! Her voice is still beautiful, and if my daughter could sing like that, I would beg her to sing me a song each day. Human's are so fuckin retarded, Why can't you just be happy for her. FUCKIN PUSSIES!!!
I've been an atheist for many years now. Going to my parents church every so often or the many arguments Ive had with my dad over my beliefs have never changed how I feel. It wasnt till I heard Jackie first sing on AGT that I finally questioned my beliefs. She makes me literally weep with joy and awe each and every time I play her videos. She must be an angel fallen to Earth. And if there are angels then there must be a God Im thinking.
@holywells We all have our musical tastes, this extremely talented girl just happens to not be included in mine. I was expressing an opinion, just as everybody else is on this video. There's no denying that she has a gift. Cheers.
"she's a child..and she has the voice of a well-seasoned star!".....i'm sorry, have any of you REALLY heard a "well-seasoned star"?!?!?!?!?!?! what she's doing to herself will ruin her by the age of 21.
@lck0fcolor I'm sorry, but do you know that she is now world famous for her voice? Do you know that she was THE Top-Selling Classsical Artist of last year. In addition to being the overall Top-Selling Classical Artist, she also had the #1, #3, & #4 Top-Selling Classical Albums of the year (all Billboard #s). She's currently touring in Japan. As good as this amatuer preformance is, as a pro she's MUCH better now. What's sad is that you failed to do your homework on Jackie Evancho.
@lck0fcolor What's sad is that the opera snobs are jealous and resentful of this incredibly talented young lady. They see her immense talent and they are threatened by it. She transcends traditional opera singing with her classical crossover style, and is therefore attacked by the very group that should be supporting her to promote their genre. Also, she sings below maximum capacity, and gets adequate recovery between session, so she is NOT at risk of vocal cord damage!
@HotRodder2100 HAHAHA. There are so many hysterical things about your response. 1) You are are underhandedly calling me an opera snob, which is fine. Go ahead. It's not like I went to a performing arts high school, got a degree in music, or am working towards any kind of professional career. So I clearly have no idea what I'm talking about. 2) You are implying that I am jealous of Jackie Evancho. Honestly, that's so funny that I can't even respond.
@lck0fcolor So you are jealous because you are unsuccessful in your own career, so you come on here and put down the most talented prodigy that we have ever witnessed to boost your ego. What a pathetic person you are. Having a "degree in music" does not qualify you to assess her singing potential, or her risk for vocal cord damage.
@lck0fcolor Are you aware that she is THE Top-Selling Classsical Artist of last year? In addition to being the overall Top-Selling Classical Artist, she also had the #1, #3, & #4 Top-Selling Classical Albums of the year (all Billboard #s). She's currently touring in Japan and plays at sold-out concerts internationally.
@HotRodder2100 They also speak for the idiocy of the average human. Listen to Maria Callas, Joyce DiDonato, Frederica von Stade, Diana Damrau, etc and be enlightened.
@lck0fcolor Your comment regarding "average human" tells me that you are a snob, believing that you are above the average person with your "music degree". You self proclaimed experts are sickening.
@lck0fcolor If you are not an expert, then you are not qualified to be making statements such as "i'm sorry, have any of you REALLY heard a "well-seasoned star"?!?!?!?!?!?! what she's doing to herself will ruin her by the age of 21." End of discussion.
@lck0fcolor Are you aware that she is THE Top-Selling Classsical Artist of last year? In addition to being the overall Top-Selling Classical Artist, she also had the #1, #3, & #4 Top-Selling Classical Albums of the year (all Billboard #s). She's currently touring in Japan and plays at sold-out concerts internationally.
@HotRodder2100 Are you aware that that has nothing to do with the fact that she's "talented"? It has everything to do with the fact that most people don't know what real classical singing is supposed to sound like. I'm not saying that she can't sing. I'm just saying that she's overrated.
@lck0fcolor Now I'm laughing hysterically! Do you know how idiotic you sound? She is not only popular amongst the masses, but she has been hailed by many PROFESSIONALS in the music industry as one of the most gifted prodigies we have ever seen. Check out her Wiki site and you will see what I mean. She's not overrated one bit. Only people who are jealous and resentful would make such a comment.
@lck0fcolor I never said that you were an "opera snob". I said that it is sad that "the opera snobs" are jealous and resentful. My question to you is this "Why are you equating yourself to an opera snob when I clearly did not call you one?
Where'n da fuck did she ever get a voice like that?! If you only heard a recording and saw no images of the singer, you'd swear to God she was a 60-year-old long-time opera singer! The Michael Jackson of opera - where does she go from here with a native talent far above anything natural!
@HotRodder2100 and you need to learn to not assume things. because she is on TV, and can sing, does not make her a prodigy. Coming from one who is classically trained, I was simply saying that she moves her head too much. it causes crimping in your airway and irregular air flow passing over the vocal chords. plus its a pain to watch.
@mathewanderson13 "Classical music training" does not make you qualified to assess the risk of tissue damage! Are you a physiologist or otolaryngologist? If not, your "opinions" regarding risk of vocal cord damage are meaningless. Jackie is being cared for by the best in the business, so I would suggest that you self proclaimed experts keep your opinions to yourself.
@HotRodder2100At it again having a go at everyone who has a different opinion ,the best as you say in the buisness are getting a hevty lump sum for having anything to do with her .there is a lot of money marketing this girl .Of course they will let her sing and carry on .Why are you so obssesive over this young girl singer ,seems strange you act like an obsessive fan ,and spend hours scouring for negative comments ,sad how old are you ..
@daisychain1231 What is "sad" are people who come on here and make baseless assumptions about Jackie Evancho or her family without taking into account the evidence that prove otherwise. I'm not obsessive, just a fan like many others that is willing to stand up to individuals who would unfairly criticize or otherwise make inappropriate comments without evidence. One such example is your insinuation that people who work with Jackie are fabricating things to profit from her.
@HotRodder2100 You ARE obsessive ,anyone would think you are her guardian ,or relative .Its strange that you show show such an interest in a 11 year old ,putting her on a pedestal as if she is super human being ,Shes just little girl who has good voice ,but she can make herself sound like a grown woman somehow ,its not natural .And people are worried that the genius as you call her will not keep her voice for ever .There are no singing prodigys ,they exits in other things .SHE IS JUST A CHILD
@daisychain1231 That's correct, she is just a child, and people like you that continue to attack her and her family are pathetic. She IS a child singing prodigy, and your denial of that highlights your jealousy toward this talented girl. YOU are the one who is obsessed with trying to make her and her family look bad to satisfy your own jealousy and resentment. That is NOT NATURAL.
@HotRodder2100 Im not jelous at all ,I would hate to be a singer in the public eye ,I like others have an opinion ,and we see it strange that a 52 yer old shows such an interest on this girl attacking anyone who dares to say she is not a prodigy ,watching her every move on you tube ,.There is no such thing as a singing prodigy ,do some research ,prodigys are found in maths and sciences ,the accademics .from the brain finction ,Someone who has good vocal chords nd can sing is not .
@daisychain1231 Definition of "prodigy" from Wikipedia: "A prodigy is someone who, at an early age, masters one or more skills far beyond his or her level of maturity. One criterion for classifying prodigies is: a prodigy is a child, typically younger than 18 years old, who is performing at the level of a highly trained adult in a very demanding field of endeavor." "Prodigy" can apply to any area.
@daisychain1231 Dr. Clark Rosen, director of the UPMC Voice Center, said it is "not her lungs or vocal chords that make the difference" “What puts this all together to make this amazing voice is Jackie’s brain,” he said. “Jackie’s brain coordinates the lungs, the throat, the vocal chords and puts it all together into an amazing voice.”
@daisychain1231 “She is a prodigy; they break the rules by definition,” wrote music critic Andrew Duckenbrod in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette after seeing Jackie perform to a sold-out crowd in her hometown in October, 2011. “[Her] voice mesmerizes.”
@aristopus Actually, I was not the one claiming to be an expert. I was quoting the "EXPERTS" who have worked with Jackie, and have first-hand knowledge of her vocal cords, her abilities, etc. Your problem is that you can't deal with the TRUTH. Just as you have the right to express an opinion, I have the right to express mine, and if people are going to throw around inaccurate, derogatory remarks about Jackie and her family, then they better be prepared to deal with the consequences.
@mathewanderson13 Perhaps if you would view some of her more recent performances, and the interviews of her done by 20/20, you would discover why "HotRodder2100", and many others, regard her as a prodigy. Especially noteworthy is the PBS Great Performances concert where she was accompanied by David Foster. She is older now, has richer vocal tones, on a worldwide tour, and commands a stage presence that is usually reserved for more experienced artists. Thanks for your opinion and good day to you.
No, no..., I disagree. If she have faith in her talent, keep training, enjoy as much and as long as she can. Than she will even getting better, yet for long time to come.
And for you Jacky, your singing talent have my support for as long as I live. You are a genuent entertainer from the heart. You inspire many people around the globe, and for people like me may live longer by hearing your angelic voice.
@yourfupid Give her parents,her coaches,her manager and her doctors "some" credit.
You may not be the only one who knows something about singing and voice. If you haven't already, you may want to watch "Jackie Evancho 20/20 Interview", you can find it right here on YT.
@yourfupid Nope, you are WRONG! Vocal cord damage only occurs from "excessive" stress on the tissues that make up the cords, in combination with inadequate recovery periods, and typically in combination with contributory factors such as smoking. Jackie sings below her maximum capacity, has adequate rest between sessions, and does not have any of the contributory risk factors, so she is NOT at risk for vocal cord damage.
@yourfupid I totally agree ,but you cant argue with the obsessed fans on here they will attack you for saying anything critical about her singing ,so watch out you will get a reply from one of them soon like I did .
A charming young lady with a pretty voice. But how can the poster call Jackie an opera singer when she's never performed in a single opera in her life?
@goldenthroat86 Unfortunately Ms Evancho cannot control what others call her. PBS insists she 13, 20/20 called her super human. She herself has stated often that she is not an opera singer. Choosing to sing an aria does not make you an opera singer. But it does seem to cause just about anybody who knows the slightest bit about opera to attack you.
Many other non opera singers have recorded arias. Sarah Brightman, Sissel, Charlotte Church, Aretha Franklin, et al.
@CrystalEyesxx I'm not sure why you are telling me this. But I don't agree with you. Sarah Brightman is not an opera singer. She has sung a few arias but she has never appeared in a opera. She has been in many shows. She was married to Andrew Llyod Webber and starred in most of his musicals. Renee Flemming and Anna Netrebko are opera singers but Sarah is not.
@Laundis I don't see why you insist that she is not an opera singer. One does not need to make a career of singing primarily in operas to be an opera singer. I suppose it just depends how loosely or not you define "opera". Nearly everything she does is operatic in nature, with a new spin on it. I suppose if your definition of an "opera singer" is someone who sings and perfoms solely in operas for a career, then yeah- I'd suppose she isn't an opera singer.
@CrystalEyesxx I'm not simply trying to win here... but there is quite a distinction between someone to sings an occasional aria and someone whose whole career is oriented towards opera. There are languages to become fluent in (Italian,French,German notably), they must learn their roles and the roles of others in an opera, they must take drama lessons, they must be prepared to sing for several hours, everyday for weeks when an opera is staged for the public.
@CrystalEyesxx Cont. The techniques and methods of projecting ones voice are different from any other vocal form. So no, Sarah does not fit this mold. She would tell so herself. It is not a criticism... it is a fact.
Simply singing an aria does not make one an opera singer. Jackie is not an opera singer and she too would happily tell you so.
@Laundis I understand what you're saying, which is essentially what I pointed out. While I do agree there is a big difference between someone who literally devotes their life and career to singing performing Opera, and Sarah Brightman- I don't necessarily think that does not make her an Opera singer either. Sarah Brightman literally is her own brand of opera singer, her music is defined as popera (opera/pop), so she is technically an opera singer, just not in the traditional sense you speak of.
@CrystalEyesxx Opera singer is called an "opera singer" because they sing in operas. This is why they are called opera singers. It's a profession not style of singing. Opera is sub-genre of classical vocal music. "popera" or classical crossover is not opera, it's a very different genre; each genre has its merits and appeals to different people. Sarah Brightman could not sing in opera, and vice-versa, most opera singers couldn't sing many of the songs Sarah Brightman sings well.
@CrystalEyesxx (cont) when you expand the definition you make the term ambiguous, ambiguity leads to confusion. Why do it? Every genre has its merits, why confuse them? Opera is sub-genre of classical music, classical crossover/popera is not, the requirements are different. One of the main features of operatic singing is the ability of the singers' to project the sound so that it is heard over the orchestra without amplification; this isn't needed or done in crossover.
@1JBfanBessy It's name is "O Mio Babbino Caro". It is an aria from an opera written by the Italian composer Puccini. If you google the name you can get the lyrics.
to sing freely is nothing like preforming in an opera...the best voices in the world are in opera...it's verry hard to sing like her...to touch the notes perfectly...and at her age..wow :)
She's very good. I just feel like she should have chosen something less boring/more challenging. Something like Da Tempeste by Handel or O Zittre Nicht by Mozart.
what ever happens Jackie is pure CLASS,,lets pray to god nothing happens to her voice cos that would be a tragedy for someone who just loves pleasing other people,,if there is a god nothing will happen,,she will jus get better and better if that is possible...
Jackie remains in her head voice the majority of the time which is the safest voice for her, so as not to put too much pressure on her lungs & not to push too much air through her chords. Jackie does not "belt", this virtually puts no strain on vocal chords.
Yvie Burnett is Jackie;s coach and a Fmr Opera Singer & Jackie has been performing Operatic Arias for 3 1./2 with no major vocal problems. Bev Sills (Famous Opera Singer) sang at age 4 & had a long career.
@yomamajama777 Stop all attacking me on here I have faith in what Ive been told and entitled to my opinion Who knows if she will have the same voice at 18 .And by the way stop attacking anyone who sends a critical comment .and also Im not disclosing anyones name on you tube as you not suppose to privacy ect ok
@daisychain1231 If the girl keeps singing and practicing then YES she will still have the same voice...even better its going to get better i wanted to clear that up
@yomamajama777 wow ,I seem to have fans on here who think shes some GOD ,FOR god sake leave people have their say .I have faith in what I have been told so stop pumping all this knowledge down my neck ,I see you and the gang are attacking any you tuber who has concern for her voice , ,Will she have the same appeal to the world when shes 20 ,or will she have the same voice at 20 who knows ,
@daisychain1231 That's what I expected. You bring up some fictitious "professionals" that you have been talking to, to try to back up your baseless claim. I've had this discussion with numerous "vocal coaches" and "voice experts" on Jackie's sites for over a year now, and NOT one of them has been able to provide a shred of evidence for their claims of vocal cord damage. Show me some scientific evidence of your claim, and not just baseless "opinions" of self proclaimed experts.
@daisychain1231 NOPE. "Experts" will tell you? JE's NOT an opera singer...4 arias in all her perfs. She's under the best care from med. professionals, her current prod., Rob Mounsey &, most of all, her parents. She sings well within her range & never "belts." CC still has a good voice, but made some poor life choices; that'swhat had a negative impact on her voice. Suggest you do some research not only on JE, but CC. JE has PROFESSIONALS looking after her, & they're doing quite well, as is she.
@bruceh7211 But this is an operatic piece which should adds an element of risk for a 10 year old people who sing operatic pieces will agree with me its a risk for a tiny 10 year old to stretch the vocal cords to such a big operatic piece like this .
@bruceh7211 She is sttill singing a song from a very big opera ,most vocal coaches i know and are proffesionals tell me she could damage her voice from singing songs too mature for her voice and age .What her teachers are doing with her is their choice ,but there is a lot of money involved with her career now ,all the PROFFESSIONALS I know say its a risk to encourage a 1o year old child to sing opreatic pieces .I have a lot to do with school choirs and music and vocal coaches
@daisychain1231 Jackie's voice will be fine and I heard Jackie took a few lessons before but they told her to hold off and she will take formal training when she is 13 or 14, she uses her head voice. I just read that somewhere awhile ago.
@daisychain1231 Yes, as HotRodder requested, who are the "professionals" and the "top class" singer? Unless you can provide specific references, your amature analysis is without substance. You may have "a lot to do" with music & vocal coaches; however, you're not qualified to make recommendations in her singing technique. You're making a judgement based on inadequate knowledge. She's under the best of care, both medically and vocally.
@bruceh7211 And you are not qualified to attack people who leave comments regarding her voice ,are you a top class judge ,singer or vocal coach ,you are only going by what you have heard or read ,ICAME ON THIS SITE TO LISTEN TO HER VOICE AND ALL I SEE IS YOU JUMPING ON EVERY NEGATIVE COMMENT ,FED UP WITH IT ,are you an obssesed fan of hers ,?
@musicalloverful And you are not qualified to make predictions about her vocal health. Are you a physiologist or otolaryngologist? Being a judge, singer, or vocal coach does not make you an expert in the area of physiology of tissue damage. Provide some scientific evidence of your claims before posting baseless opinions.
@daisychain1231 She's not singing traditional "operatic" style. She's singing classical crossover style, with sub-maximal stress on her vocal cords. Vocal cord damage only occurs with maximal stress on the cords, in combination with inadequate recovery between sessions, and usually in combination with contributory risk factors such as smoking. Jackie sings below her maximum capacity, and gets adequate recovery between sessions, so is therefore NOT at risk of vocal cord damage!
@FUNKTHEYEARS I think she has an awsome talent ,she inspires my daughter to sing arias ,The only worry is she is taking a big risk singing opera at such a young age my daughters vocal coach is so against kids this young taking such a risk on the vocal cords that are still growing ,She is an opera singer herself and is highly qualified ,she carefully moniters my 12 year olds voice and is gradually building her vocal ability ,charlotte church ruined her voice singing opera so young .
im sorry, her voice sounds good, but the technique she learned to sing that way, will no doubt kill her vocal chords. there are safe ways to learn opera and unsafe ways to learn it. you might be going "How the hell would i know that?" well cuz i am an opera singer and my teacher even told me her voice is bs!
@akatsukigrl1990 "cuz" you're an "opera singer," and your teacher told you her voice is "bs.". True professionals do not denegrate others. Do you perform in operas? Your comment is without substance and quite juvenile.
Jackie remains in her head voice the majority of the time which is the safest voice for her, so as not to put too much pressure on her lungs & not to push too much air through her chords. Jackie does not "belt", this virtually puts no strain on vocal chords.
Yvie Burnett is Jackie;s coach and a Fmr Opera Singer & Jackie has been performing Operatic Arias for 3 1./2 with no major vocal problems. Bev Sills (Famous Opera Singer) sang at age 4 & had a long career.
@mauriciomille This "poor, manipulated, used & driven girl" is doing what she loves: living her dream & giving joy to millions. It's her dream, not her parents, who said if she wanted to quit singing tomorrow that would be fine. Sure she's driven; she's an achiever who gives her all at each performance and continues to improve exponentially. One tremendous young talent who's become a great role model for our younger generation. Perhaps do some research before posting such a sophomoric comment.
@peppzi57 No, not "too bad" at all. As Jackie matures, her voice will continue to become richer and fuller. As amazing as her voice was during AGT, it's improved dramatically since then, as shown in her recent appearances. We ain't seen nothin' yet!
Will you all just quiet yourselves with the sniping,back&forth,1-upsmanship,etc
If you've got this much time &negative energy to expend on something indisputably beautiful then,4Heaven's sake,DIRECT IT towards the contemptible creature who's UNCONSTITUTIONALLY, taken up residence in the Whitehouse
While JE is wonderful diversion-Simply enjoy it BUT
Devote primary efforts to exposing & removing THE USURPER
ART II 'natural born Citizens' are NOT...I REPEAT...NOT born of NON-U.S. Citizen fathers
People need to stop posting crap on here. It's because of that kind of childish nonsense that cause people to block comments so people who appreciate what is going on here can show their support.
This is absolutely amazing! Thank you for sharing this. It's truly a wonderful thing! God has blessed this girl with a magnificent gift. I hope she keeps going with it. She can really go somewhere in life with a voice like that.
Es tan bella la voz... que no va acorde a lo que tenemos idea por la edad... sin duda ella es bella tambien... pero se me hace dificil ver en esa pequenia ninia... una voz tan potente... Canta Bello!!! Tienes un gran futuro... sigue nunca pares...
Именно поэтому её талант настолько уникален.Крайне редко можно встретить ребёнка,поющего хорошо поставленным взрослым голосом.Не знаю как на нём отразятся возрастные изменения,но сейчас он звучит просто потрясающе!Мои комплименты Джеки !!!
@Eugenedvoynik Ну не знаю...по мне так нормально...)))Просто необычно и всё.Ладно,посмотрим что из неё вырастет.Дано её многое,но она слишком мала,что бы уже можно было делать какие то выводы - пример Робертино Лоретти весьма показателен в этом смысле.Надеюсь она всё же станет звездой в полном смысле этого слова.
@strop100 "нормально" и "гениально"- согласитесь, разные вещи, очень разные.
Я вовсе не говорил, что мне не нравится. Я сказал о личных ассоциациях и ощущениях.
Да, девочка уникальна, и надеюсь, что во взрослом возрасте она всё же будет успешной. Робертино, всё-таки, мальчик и когда поломался голос он стал неинтересен публике. А она, всё же, девочка, и ей это не грозит.
She sounds great... may not sound so great in a few years if she keeps breathing that way, but I'm happy for her current success. That's what matters, right? Short term. Not the long term. Got it. I'm not going to bash on her expression or choice of song or the fact that she darkens her sound way too much for any singer under the age of at least twenty-three, but the one thing that is obvious is her lack of proper breath support. That can damage anyone's voice real quick.
Jackie remains in her head voice the majority of the time which is the safest voice for her, so as not to put too much pressure on her lungs and not to push too much air through her chords. Other words Jackie does not "belt" which virtually puts no strain on
the vocal chord. Bel Canto Style be around for 400 years and many young great Opera singers had long productive careers. Jackie is coach by a Yvie Burnett (Former Opera Singer). No vocal problems for 4 years.
beautiful voice but no emotion, you are asking your father to have pity but she is singing like she is skipping trough a flowerbed. Its the opera version of bubblegum pop. Maria Callas for me.
@joliefrancs "No emotion"? Are you kidding? Jackie puts more emotion in her songs than any singer alive today! Get your eyes checked because you are definitely not seeing things clearly!
@joliefrancs Really... how polished does a 10 yr old have to be to win your respect? Where do think Callas was at 10? A better question.... what were you doing at 10?
@Laundis At age 10,Callas probably wasn't singing about drowning herself in a river. You JE fans beat up anyone who expresses concern about her voice.She isn't an angel sent from god.She's a little kid with good potential who will end up without a voice if she doesn't learn good technique.BTW, are you one of her mother's many agents who prowl YT and beat up on anyone who writes the slightest negative thing? We know you people are out there.
Wow is an understatement. such an incredible voice.
jimmydcap 2 hours ago
This has been flagged as spam show
whats the name of the song
linda696100 10 hours ago
THIS SONG SUCKS BUT GIRL YOU cAN sing
TheKissantell 10 hours ago
Thumbs Up For The Song On Mr Bean's Holiday!!
MissAliceHartz 1 day ago
I can not say something positive, but one thing I can say one thing"WOW" :O
kanelbulleXD 1 day ago
That was the best singing i have ever heard from anybody honestly, i still am in denial about that singing actually being her lol
McGinaLovin 3 days ago
I WANA KNOW THE 386 PEOPLE WHO DOWNED THIS VIDEO
JoeyWorley 4 days ago
She an alien ...
JORDYRASTELLI 5 days ago
OH... MY.. GOD... She made me cry, and I'm a huge angry dude. Absolutely beautiful
TheKungfuzen 6 days ago
This is an aria about a young daughter who begs her father to approve her marriage or she'll abscond to Florence and throw herself in the Arno River. I'm not sure a young ten-year-old has enough life experience required to evoke such emotion. If she's just mouthing words without understanding the feeling, it's not art but a lie.
aristopus 1 week ago
@aristopus Did you know that "Gianni Schicchi" the opera this aria comes from is a comic opera? I doubt it.
That aside, you have no way of knowing what Jackie Evancho" understands or doesn't understand. As far as conveying emotion, I'd say she reaches a tremendous number of people emotionally not just in this song but in all that she sings.
And that is my opinion.
Laundis 1 week ago
@aristopus - One doesn't need to understand the words to either evoke feeling or feel it. The music ITSELF evokes & provokes feeling (even without understanding the words). If that wasn't the case no one in country would even bother listening to Italian opera EVER - since few in this country understand Italian.
lordbalfor 6 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please help vote “like” for this guy for idol competition:
search "RAY_LEONARD_500818_1" in youtube,
Thanks
dianamonicamh 1 week ago
Comment removed
ticklemepurple86 1 week ago
HEY ASSHOLE'S!!!!! This young lady has a great voice, and yes it's not perfect but FUCK QUIT BITCHING!!!! Her voice is still beautiful, and if my daughter could sing like that, I would beg her to sing me a song each day. Human's are so fuckin retarded, Why can't you just be happy for her. FUCKIN PUSSIES!!!
thatbigcpimpin 1 week ago
Wow...
solovey4ik 1 week ago
A beautiful creation!
MindTrek00 1 week ago
ma come faaaaaaa?
KrisKlean 1 week ago
I saw the audition on TV at the time, and Jackie still amazes me. If angles do exist, they'd look and sound like her!
xuscbs 1 week ago
Comment removed
miesermogelvogel 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I've been an atheist for many years now. Going to my parents church every so often or the many arguments Ive had with my dad over my beliefs have never changed how I feel. It wasnt till I heard Jackie first sing on AGT that I finally questioned my beliefs. She makes me literally weep with joy and awe each and every time I play her videos. She must be an angel fallen to Earth. And if there are angels then there must be a God Im thinking.
jeremybr2020 1 week ago
thumps up if your watching in 2012
ticaet 1 week ago
Esa niña esta hermosa! Y me encanta como llora!
gabardina12 1 week ago
omg!!!!!!!!!!!!
snwdaysrule85 1 week ago
@holywells We all have our musical tastes, this extremely talented girl just happens to not be included in mine. I was expressing an opinion, just as everybody else is on this video. There's no denying that she has a gift. Cheers.
mathewanderson13 1 week ago
A-do-ra-bley.
akpowell0 2 weeks ago
"she's a child..and she has the voice of a well-seasoned star!".....i'm sorry, have any of you REALLY heard a "well-seasoned star"?!?!?!?!?!?! what she's doing to herself will ruin her by the age of 21.
lck0fcolor 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor I'm sorry, but do you know that she is now world famous for her voice? Do you know that she was THE Top-Selling Classsical Artist of last year. In addition to being the overall Top-Selling Classical Artist, she also had the #1, #3, & #4 Top-Selling Classical Albums of the year (all Billboard #s). She's currently touring in Japan. As good as this amatuer preformance is, as a pro she's MUCH better now. What's sad is that you failed to do your homework on Jackie Evancho.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 what's sad is that the average human being finds her to be a true classical artist.
lck0fcolor 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor What's sad is that the opera snobs are jealous and resentful of this incredibly talented young lady. They see her immense talent and they are threatened by it. She transcends traditional opera singing with her classical crossover style, and is therefore attacked by the very group that should be supporting her to promote their genre. Also, she sings below maximum capacity, and gets adequate recovery between session, so she is NOT at risk of vocal cord damage!
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 HAHAHA. There are so many hysterical things about your response. 1) You are are underhandedly calling me an opera snob, which is fine. Go ahead. It's not like I went to a performing arts high school, got a degree in music, or am working towards any kind of professional career. So I clearly have no idea what I'm talking about. 2) You are implying that I am jealous of Jackie Evancho. Honestly, that's so funny that I can't even respond.
lck0fcolor 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor So you are jealous because you are unsuccessful in your own career, so you come on here and put down the most talented prodigy that we have ever witnessed to boost your ego. What a pathetic person you are. Having a "degree in music" does not qualify you to assess her singing potential, or her risk for vocal cord damage.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 And what are your qualifications, kind sir?
lck0fcolor 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lck0fcolor Are you aware that she is THE Top-Selling Classsical Artist of last year? In addition to being the overall Top-Selling Classical Artist, she also had the #1, #3, & #4 Top-Selling Classical Albums of the year (all Billboard #s). She's currently touring in Japan and plays at sold-out concerts internationally.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor Jackie's accomplishments speak for themselves.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 They also speak for the idiocy of the average human. Listen to Maria Callas, Joyce DiDonato, Frederica von Stade, Diana Damrau, etc and be enlightened.
lck0fcolor 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor You go listen to them if you prefer them over Jackie Evancho.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 I have, will, and do. Good lord!
lck0fcolor 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor Great! Hope never to hear from you again!
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor Your comment regarding "average human" tells me that you are a snob, believing that you are above the average person with your "music degree". You self proclaimed experts are sickening.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 I never said that I was an expert, nor that I am above the average person.
lck0fcolor 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lck0fcolor If you are not an expert, then you are not qualified to be making statements such as "i'm sorry, have any of you REALLY heard a "well-seasoned star"?!?!?!?!?!?! what she's doing to herself will ruin her by the age of 21." End of discussion.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor Are you aware that she is THE Top-Selling Classsical Artist of last year? In addition to being the overall Top-Selling Classical Artist, she also had the #1, #3, & #4 Top-Selling Classical Albums of the year (all Billboard #s). She's currently touring in Japan and plays at sold-out concerts internationally.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 Are you aware that that has nothing to do with the fact that she's "talented"? It has everything to do with the fact that most people don't know what real classical singing is supposed to sound like. I'm not saying that she can't sing. I'm just saying that she's overrated.
lck0fcolor 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor Now I'm laughing hysterically! Do you know how idiotic you sound? She is not only popular amongst the masses, but she has been hailed by many PROFESSIONALS in the music industry as one of the most gifted prodigies we have ever seen. Check out her Wiki site and you will see what I mean. She's not overrated one bit. Only people who are jealous and resentful would make such a comment.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@lck0fcolor I never said that you were an "opera snob". I said that it is sad that "the opera snobs" are jealous and resentful. My question to you is this "Why are you equating yourself to an opera snob when I clearly did not call you one?
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
awsome soooooooooooooooooooo awsome
fptink2011 2 weeks ago
Where'n da fuck did she ever get a voice like that?! If you only heard a recording and saw no images of the singer, you'd swear to God she was a 60-year-old long-time opera singer! The Michael Jackson of opera - where does she go from here with a native talent far above anything natural!
junkdeal 2 weeks ago
its amazing
mehdihasan20005 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
CeceandRockyAddicts 2 weeks ago
she 's wonderful
kaliopi1989 2 weeks ago
simply amazing how such a powerful voice is being belted out of such a small package WOW!!!
vwchick24 2 weeks ago
O--O
marianatsumi 2 weeks ago
wowsers
dtroitredwings22 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 and you need to learn to not assume things. because she is on TV, and can sing, does not make her a prodigy. Coming from one who is classically trained, I was simply saying that she moves her head too much. it causes crimping in your airway and irregular air flow passing over the vocal chords. plus its a pain to watch.
mathewanderson13 2 weeks ago
@mathewanderson13 "Classical music training" does not make you qualified to assess the risk of tissue damage! Are you a physiologist or otolaryngologist? If not, your "opinions" regarding risk of vocal cord damage are meaningless. Jackie is being cared for by the best in the business, so I would suggest that you self proclaimed experts keep your opinions to yourself.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago 13
@HotRodder2100At it again having a go at everyone who has a different opinion ,the best as you say in the buisness are getting a hevty lump sum for having anything to do with her .there is a lot of money marketing this girl .Of course they will let her sing and carry on .Why are you so obssesive over this young girl singer ,seems strange you act like an obsessive fan ,and spend hours scouring for negative comments ,sad how old are you ..
daisychain1231 2 weeks ago
@daisychain1231 What is "sad" are people who come on here and make baseless assumptions about Jackie Evancho or her family without taking into account the evidence that prove otherwise. I'm not obsessive, just a fan like many others that is willing to stand up to individuals who would unfairly criticize or otherwise make inappropriate comments without evidence. One such example is your insinuation that people who work with Jackie are fabricating things to profit from her.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 You ARE obsessive ,anyone would think you are her guardian ,or relative .Its strange that you show show such an interest in a 11 year old ,putting her on a pedestal as if she is super human being ,Shes just little girl who has good voice ,but she can make herself sound like a grown woman somehow ,its not natural .And people are worried that the genius as you call her will not keep her voice for ever .There are no singing prodigys ,they exits in other things .SHE IS JUST A CHILD
daisychain1231 2 weeks ago
@daisychain1231 That's correct, she is just a child, and people like you that continue to attack her and her family are pathetic. She IS a child singing prodigy, and your denial of that highlights your jealousy toward this talented girl. YOU are the one who is obsessed with trying to make her and her family look bad to satisfy your own jealousy and resentment. That is NOT NATURAL.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@HotRodder2100 Im not jelous at all ,I would hate to be a singer in the public eye ,I like others have an opinion ,and we see it strange that a 52 yer old shows such an interest on this girl attacking anyone who dares to say she is not a prodigy ,watching her every move on you tube ,.There is no such thing as a singing prodigy ,do some research ,prodigys are found in maths and sciences ,the accademics .from the brain finction ,Someone who has good vocal chords nd can sing is not .
daisychain1231 1 week ago
@daisychain1231 Definition of "prodigy" from Wikipedia: "A prodigy is someone who, at an early age, masters one or more skills far beyond his or her level of maturity. One criterion for classifying prodigies is: a prodigy is a child, typically younger than 18 years old, who is performing at the level of a highly trained adult in a very demanding field of endeavor." "Prodigy" can apply to any area.
HotRodder2100 1 week ago
@daisychain1231 Dr. Clark Rosen, director of the UPMC Voice Center, said it is "not her lungs or vocal chords that make the difference" “What puts this all together to make this amazing voice is Jackie’s brain,” he said. “Jackie’s brain coordinates the lungs, the throat, the vocal chords and puts it all together into an amazing voice.”
HotRodder2100 1 week ago
@daisychain1231 “She is a prodigy; they break the rules by definition,” wrote music critic Andrew Duckenbrod in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette after seeing Jackie perform to a sold-out crowd in her hometown in October, 2011. “[Her] voice mesmerizes.”
HotRodder2100 1 week ago 4
@HotRodder2100 that you self proclaimed experts keep your opinions to yourself.>>>
This is a Youtude forum and expressing opinions is precisely what it's for.
aristopus 1 week ago
@aristopus what you said doesn't make sense... you (whoever) keep your opinions to yourself
because.... a Youtude forum and expressing opinions is precisely what it's for.
Laundis 1 week ago
@aristopus Actually, I was not the one claiming to be an expert. I was quoting the "EXPERTS" who have worked with Jackie, and have first-hand knowledge of her vocal cords, her abilities, etc. Your problem is that you can't deal with the TRUTH. Just as you have the right to express an opinion, I have the right to express mine, and if people are going to throw around inaccurate, derogatory remarks about Jackie and her family, then they better be prepared to deal with the consequences.
HotRodder2100 1 week ago
@mathewanderson13 Perhaps if you would view some of her more recent performances, and the interviews of her done by 20/20, you would discover why "HotRodder2100", and many others, regard her as a prodigy. Especially noteworthy is the PBS Great Performances concert where she was accompanied by David Foster. She is older now, has richer vocal tones, on a worldwide tour, and commands a stage presence that is usually reserved for more experienced artists. Thanks for your opinion and good day to you.
holywells 2 weeks ago
it so cool
NonaChannel 2 weeks ago
Sad to see your comment:
No, no..., I disagree. If she have faith in her talent, keep training, enjoy as much and as long as she can. Than she will even getting better, yet for long time to come.
And for you Jacky, your singing talent have my support for as long as I live. You are a genuent entertainer from the heart. You inspire many people around the globe, and for people like me may live longer by hearing your angelic voice.
monob52 2 weeks ago
This is sad to see because this child will never be able to have career past what she is doing here because it will destroy her voice.
yourfupid 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
Laundis 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@yourfupid Give her parents,her coaches,her manager and her doctors "some" credit.
You may not be the only one who knows something about singing and voice. If you haven't already, you may want to watch "Jackie Evancho 20/20 Interview", you can find it right here on YT.
Laundis 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@yourfupid Nope, you are WRONG! Vocal cord damage only occurs from "excessive" stress on the tissues that make up the cords, in combination with inadequate recovery periods, and typically in combination with contributory factors such as smoking. Jackie sings below her maximum capacity, has adequate rest between sessions, and does not have any of the contributory risk factors, so she is NOT at risk for vocal cord damage.
HotRodder2100 2 weeks ago
@yourfupid I totally agree ,but you cant argue with the obsessed fans on here they will attack you for saying anything critical about her singing ,so watch out you will get a reply from one of them soon like I did .
daisychain1231 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
tunanorth 2 weeks ago
She looks bait like a younger version of Sarah Michelle Gellar!
alicecullenvampyre 2 weeks ago
I LIKE IT YU VOICE!!
saioflove1 3 weeks ago
A charming young lady with a pretty voice. But how can the poster call Jackie an opera singer when she's never performed in a single opera in her life?
goldenthroat86 3 weeks ago
@goldenthroat86 Unfortunately Ms Evancho cannot control what others call her. PBS insists she 13, 20/20 called her super human. She herself has stated often that she is not an opera singer. Choosing to sing an aria does not make you an opera singer. But it does seem to cause just about anybody who knows the slightest bit about opera to attack you.
Many other non opera singers have recorded arias. Sarah Brightman, Sissel, Charlotte Church, Aretha Franklin, et al.
Laundis 3 weeks ago 4
@Laundis Sarah Brightman is an opera singer. Or rather all of her music is classical/operatic as far as her voice goes.
CrystalEyesxx 2 weeks ago
@CrystalEyesxx I'm not sure why you are telling me this. But I don't agree with you. Sarah Brightman is not an opera singer. She has sung a few arias but she has never appeared in a opera. She has been in many shows. She was married to Andrew Llyod Webber and starred in most of his musicals. Renee Flemming and Anna Netrebko are opera singers but Sarah is not.
Laundis 2 weeks ago
@Laundis I don't see why you insist that she is not an opera singer. One does not need to make a career of singing primarily in operas to be an opera singer. I suppose it just depends how loosely or not you define "opera". Nearly everything she does is operatic in nature, with a new spin on it. I suppose if your definition of an "opera singer" is someone who sings and perfoms solely in operas for a career, then yeah- I'd suppose she isn't an opera singer.
CrystalEyesxx 1 week ago
@CrystalEyesxx I'm not simply trying to win here... but there is quite a distinction between someone to sings an occasional aria and someone whose whole career is oriented towards opera. There are languages to become fluent in (Italian,French,German notably), they must learn their roles and the roles of others in an opera, they must take drama lessons, they must be prepared to sing for several hours, everyday for weeks when an opera is staged for the public.
Laundis 1 week ago
@CrystalEyesxx Cont. The techniques and methods of projecting ones voice are different from any other vocal form. So no, Sarah does not fit this mold. She would tell so herself. It is not a criticism... it is a fact.
Simply singing an aria does not make one an opera singer. Jackie is not an opera singer and she too would happily tell you so.
Laundis 1 week ago
@Laundis I understand what you're saying, which is essentially what I pointed out. While I do agree there is a big difference between someone who literally devotes their life and career to singing performing Opera, and Sarah Brightman- I don't necessarily think that does not make her an Opera singer either. Sarah Brightman literally is her own brand of opera singer, her music is defined as popera (opera/pop), so she is technically an opera singer, just not in the traditional sense you speak of.
CrystalEyesxx 1 week ago
@CrystalEyesxx Opera singer is called an "opera singer" because they sing in operas. This is why they are called opera singers. It's a profession not style of singing. Opera is sub-genre of classical vocal music. "popera" or classical crossover is not opera, it's a very different genre; each genre has its merits and appeals to different people. Sarah Brightman could not sing in opera, and vice-versa, most opera singers couldn't sing many of the songs Sarah Brightman sings well.
serrateresa 6 days ago
@CrystalEyesxx (cont) when you expand the definition you make the term ambiguous, ambiguity leads to confusion. Why do it? Every genre has its merits, why confuse them? Opera is sub-genre of classical music, classical crossover/popera is not, the requirements are different. One of the main features of operatic singing is the ability of the singers' to project the sound so that it is heard over the orchestra without amplification; this isn't needed or done in crossover.
serrateresa 6 days ago
das ist doch kein gesang xD so ein scheiß !!!!!
MAXI131326 3 weeks ago
what is this song called.???
1JBfanBessy 3 weeks ago
@1JBfanBessy It's name is "O Mio Babbino Caro". It is an aria from an opera written by the Italian composer Puccini. If you google the name you can get the lyrics.
Laundis 3 weeks ago
Happy New Year to all the Fans Of miss jackie Evancho blessings from The All mighty
weedlers7 3 weeks ago 3
to sing freely is nothing like preforming in an opera...the best voices in the world are in opera...it's verry hard to sing like her...to touch the notes perfectly...and at her age..wow :)
KusanagiKyo17 4 weeks ago
She's very good. I just feel like she should have chosen something less boring/more challenging. Something like Da Tempeste by Handel or O Zittre Nicht by Mozart.
MrDajx 4 weeks ago
@MrDajx
Maybe the reason the she cannot perform more challenging pieces is to protect
her voice! She is a light lyrical mezzo-soprano. Search Youtube for Handel's "Ombra Mai Fu".
Enjoy!
yomamajama777 4 weeks ago
BEAUTIFUL
antulioruiz 4 weeks ago
for me is a fake....100%
Pi3791Casso 4 weeks ago
@musicalloverful
It is a free country (U.S.A) and we can have a civil debate. Challenging someones opinion attacking Jackie and her family is not bullying.
If Jackie was your daughter, I would also do the same thing. Especially if it is a
defenseless 11 year old kid.
So get over it !!!
Be a Man !!! or Woman!!!
Be Strong !!!
yomamajama777 1 month ago
sry aber Caroline Costa ist 10000 mal BESSSERRRR des isch eine eingebildete schlampe xD
Girlsstyler 1 month ago
@Girlsstyler die Welt nicht mit Ihnen überein, und sie ist nicht eingebildet.
Laundis 1 month ago
W O W . *_*
janabelieber 1 month ago
That ain't lip syncing honey, that's pure talent.
mizzy12998 1 month ago
oh! i saw this on the news n i gotta say she has an amazing voice!! :D
soranotenshiful 1 month ago
Beautiful voice.........
vsneeley 1 month ago
what ever happens Jackie is pure CLASS,,lets pray to god nothing happens to her voice cos that would be a tragedy for someone who just loves pleasing other people,,if there is a god nothing will happen,,she will jus get better and better if that is possible...
FUNKTHEYEARS 1 month ago
Comment removed
daisychain1231 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@daisychain1231
Jackie remains in her head voice the majority of the time which is the safest voice for her, so as not to put too much pressure on her lungs & not to push too much air through her chords. Jackie does not "belt", this virtually puts no strain on vocal chords.
Yvie Burnett is Jackie;s coach and a Fmr Opera Singer & Jackie has been performing Operatic Arias for 3 1./2 with no major vocal problems. Bev Sills (Famous Opera Singer) sang at age 4 & had a long career.
yomamajama777 1 month ago
@daisychain1231
Charlotte Church did not ruin her voice !!!
Charlotte still sings pop and Broadway tunes. she went through a rebellious period
such as chain smoking, drinking, partying and had kids.
yomamajama777 1 month ago
Comment removed
daisychain1231 1 month ago
@daisychain1231
Roger Love Professional Vocal coach stated on MSNBC Alex Witt's show
that Jackie performs safely using her "Head Voice" and does not "belt"
which vritually puts no strain on the vocal chord. Google the video as
evidence. Jackie has been performing for 3 1./2 years with no strain or injury
on record. Jackie perforrms "Bel Canto Style", like Rene Flerming (Opera Star)
and she's been singing for 40 years (started at 11 yrs old)
Who is this top class singer ????
yomamajama777 1 month ago
@yomamajama777 Stop all attacking me on here I have faith in what Ive been told and entitled to my opinion Who knows if she will have the same voice at 18 .And by the way stop attacking anyone who sends a critical comment .and also Im not disclosing anyones name on you tube as you not suppose to privacy ect ok
daisychain1231 1 month ago
@daisychain1231 If the girl keeps singing and practicing then YES she will still have the same voice...even better its going to get better i wanted to clear that up
andreacorona78 3 weeks ago
@yomamajama777 wow ,I seem to have fans on here who think shes some GOD ,FOR god sake leave people have their say .I have faith in what I have been told so stop pumping all this knowledge down my neck ,I see you and the gang are attacking any you tuber who has concern for her voice , ,Will she have the same appeal to the world when shes 20 ,or will she have the same voice at 20 who knows ,
daisychain1231 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@daisychain1231
I see all you Hater's like to foretell doom on our Golden Child "Jackie "
All children are Angels, even yours if you have a child or sibling.
Jesus said, “Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these.”
Matthew 19: 13-14
You got a problem with Jesus pray to him!!!
He may forgive you !!!
yomamajama777 1 month ago
@daisychain1231 Name the "professional vocal coaches" you are refering to.
HotRodder2100 1 month ago
@HotRodder210 I do not disclose anyones name on here ,for privacy reasons ok ,THIS IS YOU TUBE .
daisychain1231 1 month ago
@daisychain1231 That's what I expected. You bring up some fictitious "professionals" that you have been talking to, to try to back up your baseless claim. I've had this discussion with numerous "vocal coaches" and "voice experts" on Jackie's sites for over a year now, and NOT one of them has been able to provide a shred of evidence for their claims of vocal cord damage. Show me some scientific evidence of your claim, and not just baseless "opinions" of self proclaimed experts.
HotRodder2100 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@daisychain1231 NOPE. "Experts" will tell you? JE's NOT an opera singer...4 arias in all her perfs. She's under the best care from med. professionals, her current prod., Rob Mounsey &, most of all, her parents. She sings well within her range & never "belts." CC still has a good voice, but made some poor life choices; that'swhat had a negative impact on her voice. Suggest you do some research not only on JE, but CC. JE has PROFESSIONALS looking after her, & they're doing quite well, as is she.
bruceh7211 1 month ago 3
@bruceh7211 But this is an operatic piece which should adds an element of risk for a 10 year old people who sing operatic pieces will agree with me its a risk for a tiny 10 year old to stretch the vocal cords to such a big operatic piece like this .
daisychain1231 1 month ago
@bruceh7211 She is sttill singing a song from a very big opera ,most vocal coaches i know and are proffesionals tell me she could damage her voice from singing songs too mature for her voice and age .What her teachers are doing with her is their choice ,but there is a lot of money involved with her career now ,all the PROFFESSIONALS I know say its a risk to encourage a 1o year old child to sing opreatic pieces .I have a lot to do with school choirs and music and vocal coaches
daisychain1231 1 month ago
@daisychain1231 Jackie's voice will be fine and I heard Jackie took a few lessons before but they told her to hold off and she will take formal training when she is 13 or 14, she uses her head voice. I just read that somewhere awhile ago.
My7571 1 month ago
@daisychain1231 Yes, as HotRodder requested, who are the "professionals" and the "top class" singer? Unless you can provide specific references, your amature analysis is without substance. You may have "a lot to do" with music & vocal coaches; however, you're not qualified to make recommendations in her singing technique. You're making a judgement based on inadequate knowledge. She's under the best of care, both medically and vocally.
bruceh7211 1 month ago
@bruceh7211 And you are not qualified to attack people who leave comments regarding her voice ,are you a top class judge ,singer or vocal coach ,you are only going by what you have heard or read ,ICAME ON THIS SITE TO LISTEN TO HER VOICE AND ALL I SEE IS YOU JUMPING ON EVERY NEGATIVE COMMENT ,FED UP WITH IT ,are you an obssesed fan of hers ,?
musicalloverful 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@musicalloverful
Jesus said, “Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these.”
Matthew 19: 13-14
I am appreciate God Given talent, especially in these perilous times.
Thats why many fans weep when she performs, it is a Gift.
Let's separate obsession and appreciation.!
Are you a top class judge ,singer or vocal coach. We enjoy freedom of speech!
Especially bruceh7211 who served our country with distinction
yomamajama777 1 month ago
@musicalloverful And you are not qualified to make predictions about her vocal health. Are you a physiologist or otolaryngologist? Being a judge, singer, or vocal coach does not make you an expert in the area of physiology of tissue damage. Provide some scientific evidence of your claims before posting baseless opinions.
HotRodder2100 1 month ago
@daisychain1231 She's not singing traditional "operatic" style. She's singing classical crossover style, with sub-maximal stress on her vocal cords. Vocal cord damage only occurs with maximal stress on the cords, in combination with inadequate recovery between sessions, and usually in combination with contributory risk factors such as smoking. Jackie sings below her maximum capacity, and gets adequate recovery between sessions, so is therefore NOT at risk of vocal cord damage!
HotRodder2100 1 month ago
@FUNKTHEYEARS I think she has an awsome talent ,she inspires my daughter to sing arias ,The only worry is she is taking a big risk singing opera at such a young age my daughters vocal coach is so against kids this young taking such a risk on the vocal cords that are still growing ,She is an opera singer herself and is highly qualified ,she carefully moniters my 12 year olds voice and is gradually building her vocal ability ,charlotte church ruined her voice singing opera so young .
daisychain1231 1 month ago
what ever jackie does in the future,,good luck to her,,thank you for the experience...
FUNKTHEYEARS 1 month ago
im sorry, her voice sounds good, but the technique she learned to sing that way, will no doubt kill her vocal chords. there are safe ways to learn opera and unsafe ways to learn it. you might be going "How the hell would i know that?" well cuz i am an opera singer and my teacher even told me her voice is bs!
akatsukigrl1990 1 month ago
@akatsukigrl1990 "cuz" you're an "opera singer," and your teacher told you her voice is "bs.". True professionals do not denegrate others. Do you perform in operas? Your comment is without substance and quite juvenile.
bruceh7211 1 month ago 7
@akatsukigrl1990
Jackie remains in her head voice the majority of the time which is the safest voice for her, so as not to put too much pressure on her lungs & not to push too much air through her chords. Jackie does not "belt", this virtually puts no strain on vocal chords.
Yvie Burnett is Jackie;s coach and a Fmr Opera Singer & Jackie has been performing Operatic Arias for 3 1./2 with no major vocal problems. Bev Sills (Famous Opera Singer) sang at age 4 & had a long career.
yomamajama777 1 month ago
Poor manipulated, used and driven Girl
mauriciomille 1 month ago
@mauriciomille This "poor, manipulated, used & driven girl" is doing what she loves: living her dream & giving joy to millions. It's her dream, not her parents, who said if she wanted to quit singing tomorrow that would be fine. Sure she's driven; she's an achiever who gives her all at each performance and continues to improve exponentially. One tremendous young talent who's become a great role model for our younger generation. Perhaps do some research before posting such a sophomoric comment.
bruceh7211 1 month ago
@bruceh7211 I didn't mean about her parents, I meant about America's got talent and BGT
mauriciomille 1 month ago
Responder a este vídeo... What they do is control their " careers " .... If it would be a real career may it last at least 30 years
mauriciomille 1 month ago
@mauriciomille
I look to another American prodigy Beverly Sill who started at age 4 and had a long productive career as a Great Opera performer.
Are you a vocalist or music teacher?
yomamajama777 1 month ago
unbeliVable not unbelibable
abdessamed29 1 month ago
WTFFFFFFFFF THAT'S AMAZING, for the love of god
yannastasia 1 month ago
That was great
monquie1ful 1 month ago
Amazing voice, my Lord God bless my swwet child....
InfoBet 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Made the 2nd FUN TRIBUTE for JACKIE! Just click on my name to view. ENJOY!
Gevreet45 1 month ago
wow
airasweetie 1 month ago
whats up with the clouds at her feet.
wowinlife 1 month ago
Too bad she will outgrow that voice.
peppzi57 1 month ago
Comment removed
Laundis 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@peppzi57 How do you know she won't grow into it? Do you always try to look to the dark side?
Laundis 1 month ago
@peppzi57 No, not "too bad" at all. As Jackie matures, her voice will continue to become richer and fuller. As amazing as her voice was during AGT, it's improved dramatically since then, as shown in her recent appearances. We ain't seen nothin' yet!
bruceh7211 1 month ago 10
Will you all just quiet yourselves with the sniping,back&forth,1-upsmanship,etc
If you've got this much time &negative energy to expend on something indisputably beautiful then,4Heaven's sake,DIRECT IT towards the contemptible creature who's UNCONSTITUTIONALLY, taken up residence in the Whitehouse
While JE is wonderful diversion-Simply enjoy it BUT
Devote primary efforts to exposing & removing THE USURPER
ART II 'natural born Citizens' are NOT...I REPEAT...NOT born of NON-U.S. Citizen fathers
kiiifute1 1 month ago
@kiiifute1 Take your political diatribe elsewhere.
Laundis 1 month ago
"I'm about to burst into tears"....and her eyes are dry as a desert.
macroevolve 1 month ago
sweeeeettttt
coooookidd 1 month ago
this was unexpected..
thefuture067 1 month ago
FAKE!
elfaba128 1 month ago
@elfaba128 fake your ass asshole
kmalobe1 1 month ago
People need to stop posting crap on here. It's because of that kind of childish nonsense that cause people to block comments so people who appreciate what is going on here can show their support.
This is absolutely amazing! Thank you for sharing this. It's truly a wonderful thing! God has blessed this girl with a magnificent gift. I hope she keeps going with it. She can really go somewhere in life with a voice like that.
Silversnapdragon 1 month ago
@Silversnapdragon She went.
Laundis 1 month ago
Es tan bella la voz... que no va acorde a lo que tenemos idea por la edad... sin duda ella es bella tambien... pero se me hace dificil ver en esa pequenia ninia... una voz tan potente... Canta Bello!!! Tienes un gran futuro... sigue nunca pares...
360tms 1 month ago
А мне как-то жутковато от её голоса.. От несостыковки детской внешности, внешности ребёнка с таким хм... далеко не детским голосом...
Eugenedvoynik 1 month ago
@Eugenedvoynik
Именно поэтому её талант настолько уникален.Крайне редко можно встретить ребёнка,поющего хорошо поставленным взрослым голосом.Не знаю как на нём отразятся возрастные изменения,но сейчас он звучит просто потрясающе!Мои комплименты Джеки !!!
strop100 1 month ago
@strop100 Ну звучит-то он потрясающе,да. Красиво очень.
Но мне лично как-то не по себе от такого несоответствия внешности с голосом. Как-то жутковат мне этот голос.. Мурашки по коже.
Eugenedvoynik 1 month ago
@Eugenedvoynik Ну не знаю...по мне так нормально...)))Просто необычно и всё.Ладно,посмотрим что из неё вырастет.Дано её многое,но она слишком мала,что бы уже можно было делать какие то выводы - пример Робертино Лоретти весьма показателен в этом смысле.Надеюсь она всё же станет звездой в полном смысле этого слова.
strop100 1 month ago
@strop100 "нормально" и "гениально"- согласитесь, разные вещи, очень разные.
Я вовсе не говорил, что мне не нравится. Я сказал о личных ассоциациях и ощущениях.
Да, девочка уникальна, и надеюсь, что во взрослом возрасте она всё же будет успешной. Робертино, всё-таки, мальчик и когда поломался голос он стал неинтересен публике. А она, всё же, девочка, и ей это не грозит.
Eugenedvoynik 1 month ago
there is a jakie evancho doll at toys r us laredo texas :D
mermaidlopez 1 month ago
She sounds great... may not sound so great in a few years if she keeps breathing that way, but I'm happy for her current success. That's what matters, right? Short term. Not the long term. Got it. I'm not going to bash on her expression or choice of song or the fact that she darkens her sound way too much for any singer under the age of at least twenty-three, but the one thing that is obvious is her lack of proper breath support. That can damage anyone's voice real quick.
ShelbyKlawonn 1 month ago
@ShelbyKlawonn
Jackie remains in her head voice the majority of the time which is the safest voice for her, so as not to put too much pressure on her lungs and not to push too much air through her chords. Other words Jackie does not "belt" which virtually puts no strain on
the vocal chord. Bel Canto Style be around for 400 years and many young great Opera singers had long productive careers. Jackie is coach by a Yvie Burnett (Former Opera Singer). No vocal problems for 4 years.
yomamajama777 1 month ago
she's mad cocky though -_-
girlswithbuttsrsexii 1 month ago
:)
Megatvasquez 1 month ago
beautiful voice but no emotion, you are asking your father to have pity but she is singing like she is skipping trough a flowerbed. Its the opera version of bubblegum pop. Maria Callas for me.
joliefrancs 1 month ago
@joliefrancs "No emotion"? Are you kidding? Jackie puts more emotion in her songs than any singer alive today! Get your eyes checked because you are definitely not seeing things clearly!
HotRodder2100 1 month ago
@joliefrancs Really... how polished does a 10 yr old have to be to win your respect? Where do think Callas was at 10? A better question.... what were you doing at 10?
Laundis 1 month ago 2
@Laundis At age 10,Callas probably wasn't singing about drowning herself in a river. You JE fans beat up anyone who expresses concern about her voice.She isn't an angel sent from god.She's a little kid with good potential who will end up without a voice if she doesn't learn good technique.BTW, are you one of her mother's many agents who prowl YT and beat up on anyone who writes the slightest negative thing? We know you people are out there.
pucciniverdi777 1 month ago
@pucciniverdi777 What I'm about to say has been repeated here ad nauseum. Jackie has her vocal and medical