Added: 3 years ago
From: soulfulbohemian
Views: 137,736
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (140)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • no one cares what version you like, jonathan larson hand picked Daphne Rubin Vega himself to sing HIS masterpiece. he wouldnt have picked her if he didnt think she could capture the essence and voice of his version of mimi... i say his version because he addapted RENT from Puccini's La Boheme'. mimi was a seamstress in this opera. mark was based off of a painter named Marcello and Roger was based off a poet named Rodolofo.

  • favourite song in rent! love it!

  • Roger doesn't want to get with Mimi because he doesn't want to give her AIDS and he doesn't know she already has it. But Mimi has AIDS and doesn't know that Roger does too. Mimi didn't seem to have a problem giving Roger AIDS...yikes.

  • @zTEDDYBEARz Also Roger feels bad about her girlfriend´s dead and doesn´t want to see Mimi die too

  • Comment removed

  • I adore Rosario Dawson, but honestly... she doesn't even *exist* as Mimi to me. RENT is a theater+BROADWAY masterpiece.... Rosario is by fact not a Broadway or even a theater actress. Daphne found her voice on Broadway; she is a 100% pure live-on-stage passion type gal. And Mimi is simply Daphne's character.... nobody accesses Mimi's soul like Daphne.

  • I think Daphne's voice is really good, but personally something about Rosario's voice gives me chills. It's not a contest or anything, but the movie version has my vote

  • @mike0powell I know this has nothing to do with Rent..But alot of great singers of today smoke and they sound better than the 1's who do smore for instance Adele is a smoker and her voice farts on alot artist..also Rent rocks lmfao

  • who sings for mimi's part in this?

    i think i prefer rosario dawson's version

  • without this song I'd be going insane right now;

    Thank you RENT for giving me some hope

  • Just Saw The Revival. Almost Shit My Pants When I Walked in and saw the set. It Was My First Live Rent experience.☺

  • Daphne's voice sounds ok i guess, she mostly sounds constipated though :L

  • @LGKxBEaTzxFTW It's because she was a smoker. It's really a pity when you hear the first workshop recordings to the obc soundtrack, as you can hear the difference in her voice.

  • @Mike0Powell what's even worse about the situation is that almost EVERYBODY in musical theater smokes and hardly anyone realizes it. Adam Pascal smokes. Liza Minnelli smokes. Judy Garland smoked since she was 15. Anthony Rapp smokes. Plus, this musical took place in 1989 correct? EVERYONE in the 80's smoked. She has that 80's sound in her voice. I love each version because they are all unique but it's sad that hardly anyone knows that almost EVERYONE in theater smokes/smoked

  • @BroadwayAddiction Seriously? That's a huge shame. Thanks for letting me know. BTW, like the username. :)

  • @Mike0Powell ya seriously. I smoke (and I'm not proud of it) but musical theater is too far out of my reach. I love musicals. None of the singers need auto tuning. I knew a broadway singer, Lenora Nemetz (I almost became her daughter in-law) and she told me, "Sweetheart, if you're in musical theater and you don't smoke, you're a black sheep" lol thanks =) I thought it was a cute screen name

  • i love the end part of this song where everyone sings

  • :'( My ex Allison used to sing this to me before she OD'd. RIP Allison, I love you still. Your voice was sweeter than any version i've found since.

  • What I love about Daphne is she can pour her entire soul into her voice, she could literally have just stood there during the musical and it would've been so amazing most Mimi's have to act as much as they sing to show emotion Daphne portrays all her emotion in her voce and yet she's still an amazing actress. There's a reason she's my favorite Mimi.

  • i love mimi singing

  • I LOVE Daphne's voice. Because it isn't all about the singing for her, she puts the emotions first and that's what makes her great. Although her singing is obviously great as well, Jonathan knew what he was doing when he casted her.

  • I am so sick of people saying which mimi is better! Alright, their BOTH great Mimis, Daphne was originally chosen for mimi, so it means the way she played the role and her singing were right, so what if she has a raspy voice, she can stil sing! As for Rosario, her acting skills were phenominal, nd she was also a great Mimi, nd just because her voice was recorded doesnt mean it they had to autotune it to sound good, if she couldnt sing well, why wouldnt she be casted in rent?Their bothgreat mimis

  • how can you not like this?!

  • I reckon that the people who say they don't like Daphne are just used to Rosario :P Because I remember I was really judgemental with Wicked, I compared everyone to Idina Menzel so give them time and they'll get used to the fact that there are various different Mimis :) For now, just let them say what they want! The rest of us know that Daphne is amaizng or she wouldn't have been cast! also repsect people's opinions guys :) THAT is what Jonothan would have wanted xx

  • Comment removed

  • @JBLoveSong EXACTLY!! One of the main points of RENT is to accept people for who they are!! Not what they aren't

  • @JBLoveSong Well said, I didn't like Daphne's version at first because I was so used to Rosario. Now I prefer this xD

  • @Charliefisher1987 same. i saw the movie first and i was like whoa i love this! and then i saw the filmed live on bway and i was like i didnt think it was possible, but i love this even more!

  • YouTube is currently home to four of the most tasteless people in the world!

  • Listen to the contralto at 2:45 when she sings the word "tonight." I saw the original cast in NYC in 1996 and I've never forgotten it, particularly Daphne Rubin Vega's rough, heartfelt, brilliant emotionality. I think that in this part, she was a genius.

  • 4 people are waiting for another day.

  • I love Adam Pascal! Heehee I've only seen the movie but I'd kill to see the OBC perform it... *sigh*

  • I love rogers voice

  • best song of the musical / movie!!!

  • 4 people missed the Like button

  • I prefer the movie version. I love the contrast between the raspy rock voice of Roger with the vulnerable innocent voice of Mimi.

  • This is my absolute favorite Rent song. I can listen to it over and over again.

  • Mimis lyrics are so inspiring.

  • comparing adam's voice to then and now, he must've had voice lessons so that he could make his voice easier to manipulate instead of bashing the notes out. but the bashing sound was required for the role so i like it as much as his voice now! :)

  • I like the rawness in Adam's voice, but not in Mimi's part... This Mimi makes me picture Cyndi Lauper <-- am i right?

  • @Tuilelen lol thats so right after hearing her I've thought she sounds like someone I 've heard before and now I know who.

  • um i <3 adam pascal. so sexyyy dont veen care thats hes married

  • vanessa hudgens as mimi, no way. eww. she needs to have real vocals but honestly , i think this version is alittle horsee soundigg, i love the movie

  • I agree with everyone...I love Larson's casting of Daphne....she has passion behind her voice...i wish i could've seen the original in person.

  • I LOVE RENT THE MUSICAL!!!!!!!!!

  • Vanessa Hudgens will surprise me if she can pull this off! I'm really thinking she might ruin it!

  • @eriberri425 just bring back daphne.... the world would be a happier place.

  • @eriberri425 say what? vanessa hudgens is being mimi? NOOOOOOO!

  • O_O Those high notes are off a bit...

  • I like both of them I'm just glad I didn't go buy tickets to see Vanessa Hudgens as Mimi that might possibly ruin RENT for me (But it probably wouldn't :P) So in conclusion Rosario and Daphne are both good in their own way and brought a lot to RENT so I look up to either one :D

  • give into love or live in fear <3

  • phenomenal song! definitely favorite song in the show

  • I love listening to this. Adam's voice sounds really raw and just intense. And so does Daphne's.

  • I really like Daphne's, Rosario's and Renee's version. They all bring real emotion and something incredibly unique to the song, but I agree that it wouldn't be where it is today without Daphne setting the precedent.

  • Daphne + Rosario = Apples + Oranges

    I eat both :)

  • @TheMintyMuffin haha. Well said. lol.

  • @TheMintyMuffin

    I love your analogy! :)

  • i love the song *_* absolutely great

  • i saw tis last year when RENT was on the Broadway tour in St. Louis and this was amazing especially with Adam Pascal

  • Daphne's amazing. I think Jonathan Larson knew what he was doing much better than anyone making comments here when he cast her to be Mimi in his own musical.

    I love Rosario too, I think she played the part AMAZINGLY. They both did.

    But don't say that Daphne was not a good Mimi when she was the original, cast by the man who wrote the musical himself. He knew what he wanted and what Mimi needed to be and Daphne fit it!

    <3

  • Also, Mimi is not the Mimi we know without Daphne. She designed the character. That is something that Jonathan Larson wanted from his original cast. He wanted it to be real.

  • mimi has the second best voice in the movie. first is joanne.

  • Joanne was Tracie Thoms. They were so impressed by her that she joined the Broadway cast and was in the final performance.

  • ^^ I love this song... it's so cute!

  • Daphne sounds rough. Rosario is definitely a better Mimi.  She's got a much nicer voice to listen to. Adam just rocks. I think the movie casting was perfection.

  • it was the 90s, voices like Daphnes was great at the time. And Rosario is just the movie Mimi, shes a great actress but is nothing compared to Tamyra Gray, Jaime Lee, or Renee Goldsberry.

  • Probably because he's straight

  • his voice is really high is all I meant

  • @MrsAwesome2016

    I still don't understand what you're saying. Lots of guys have really high voices without sounding gay. I.E. Jeremy Camp, Freddy Mercury, Adam Pascal, David Cook.

    High range does not equal high tone. Freddy Mercury had a 7(maybe 8) octave range, the largest I've ever heard of. Yet he didn't sound gay or have a really high tone.

  • ...that's because he's not gay.

  • dont dis meme

  • The way Adam Pascal sings this song, like he's confused and frustrated, is the way this song should always be. And for Daphne, I don't think it matters what her voice sounds like, I think it matters the emotion in it, and she has a lot of emotion in her voice

  • daphne has this weird voice...i mean, don't get me wrong, i like it, it's just...weird.

    but i LOVE adam. <33333

  • It's funny, Adam Pascal's voice has aged very well, he sounded even better on the motion picture soundtrack than on the original cast recording.  He's definitely an artist that has gotten better with time.

    As for the debate, both Daphne and Rosario did very well with the role, and both of them deserve mad props. That's a really difficult part to pull off, but they were both amazing.

  • Rent is incredible. I saw it live twice this summer, once from the front row with the rush tickets :D It's so moving; I cried harder than I ever have at anything. This song is really poignant to me right now...annoyingly so, actually...

  • ugh

    This was my high school boyfriend and i's song...............i was mimi............i was always messin' up.......and he had baggage too......but we still loved eachother

    man

    nostalgia. love rent!

  • um... i just wish people would stop comparing daphne and rosario.

    they are completely different and cannot be compared.

    rosario was great for the movie.

    jonathan chose daphne, which means she is his vision of mimi.

    (and let me just add, DO NOT DEFY JONATHAN'S DECISIONS! lol)

  • Yeah DO NOT FLAME DAPHNE!!!!!!!!! FLAMING DAPHNE IS FLAMING JONATHAN!!!!!!

    R.I.P. Jonathan Larson

  • @PercyJacksonfan01

    How is flamiing anyone but Jonathan flaming Jonathan? you need to stop talking for Jonathan, he wouldnt have complained.

  • @PercyJacksonfan01 prefer daphnie or someone else isn't that fine ? Music is personal

  • yeah plus rpsario had machinery help daphne di all of her stuff live in front of hundreds even thousands of pple they r both totally different but both r AMAZING!! im more a fan of rosario but i respect daphne and think she has a great voice also i just saw rosario befoore i heard daphne so i was biased lol

  • there is something about daphne that makes me whanna keep listening. her voice is unique and different. i love it.

  • ook so how about i fuckin love rent and it's the best musical ever and rentheads rule? how bout that? can i get an amen? ^^

  • AMEN!

  • thank you!!!

  • the Broadway play is waaaaaaayyyyyyy better

  • i l-ov-e this movie

  • i prefer rosarios voice, but hers is... ok i guess....

  • I personally enjoy both versions. I mean, how much better can you get than an original?? Nothing can beat original. I love their harmony in this song but also, in the film, there seems to be more "Umph" in it if ya know what I mean....more bass definitely in the beginning of the song when it comes to the movie version but this is ORIGINAL broadway cast....nothing beats original. This is pure. Her voice is beautiful just like Rosario's =)

  • So raw and vigorous! The purity and sincerity in his voice makes the character what it is. The 2008 revival cast was very good! The man who portrayed the role of Rogger didn't have as good a voice... but he was a FANTASTIC actor. He overcompensated with pure emotion. Its great. If you have not seen it you should definitely give it a look. If you are a RENTHEAD I believe you will be pleasantly Surprised.

  • A True classic. My favorite msuical. EVER!

  • best broadway play ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    along with the wiz and wicked of course

  • im with rentluvers! im a renthead!!!!!! C: and im proud of it!

  • I LOVE THIS MOVIE!!!!!

  • I love the lyrics in Mimi's part.

  • Rent is awesome no matter what version. I love the songs La vie boheme, Another day, Finale B, and seasons of love.

  • As one who saw Adam perform in Rent I must say he is AMAZING hands down. Now between Rosario and Daphnie I must say that Daphne originated Mimi, and must be respected and commended, whereas Rosario was more age-appropraite, and pulled off her embodyment well.

  • And Rosario got a great voice O,o truly

  • this is not her this is the original cast member

  • I definitely liked....no. I definitely LOVED the broadway version waaaay better than the movie. Its more pure.

  • i personally like both versions. they both have their own pros and cons, which i think makes them equal in certain ways.

  • yeah your right. I still am obsessed with them both! I dont care what my friends say about me being obsessed because you know what? I am obsessed!

  • RENT IS AMAZING!!!!!!!!

  • finally a recording of the original great job soulfulbohemian!

  • one of my favorite songs because i can actually sing it very well.

    YAY! :D

  • i like daphne when i saw her at broadway...

    but when the movie came out, rosario IS mimi.

    don't get me wrong daphne is goood, rosario(in my opinion) is amazing

  • i like rosario for the movie role, but even the strain in daphnes voice sez somthin about her character... it shows tht shes gone through hard times and easy times and really does live her life. rosario was a great mimi, also, because when she was little, she livd like this.

  • no offense,but I'm really glad they got Rosario Dawson as mimi...this one's good,but her voice is too strained.

  • her name is daphne rubin-vega and she is just as good as rosario. (in my opinion)

  • Personally, both Daphne and Rosario make excellent Mimis. Daphne captures Mimi's character. Mimi's been through a lot, and the strain in Daphne's voice pretty much reflects that. Rosario on the oother hand sounds a bit more Mimi's age, and let's face it, she looks exactly as I'd picture Mimi.

  • mmm. daphne certainly introduced a more realistic mimi, but i liked rosario's portrayal better -- not only did daphne seem too old, but i LIKED that rosario wasn't quite realistic. i thought it was cool that she made mimi into an almost surreal character -- an angel among the unwashed, so to speak. and besides, she was only 19 and rosario provided her with some of that youthful naivete that daphne neglected. daphne has a very emotional voice tho, which i ADORE.

  • i mean great song ***

  • =D great comment

  • Um, yeah, probably not.

  • 1:04 is one of the best parts!!!!!

  • Lol, I love that part.

  • i love this ong!! i got to see this musical this summer and it was sooo good!! and i think the best part was that i got to meet rodney hicks who plays benny!! my old neighbor is on broadway andwent to nyu and rodney was like his mentor!! he was sooooooo sweet!!!!!!! I LOVE RENT!!!!

  • "Forget regret, or life is yours to miss...no day but today." I love this song!

  • Me and My friend got that quote from Another day tattooed on our hands =).

  • I love this song! But why's the tempo so slow?

  • I thought the same thing, it was much faster when I saw it....

  • love this!

  • how is it thte insperation to ur screenname

  • This song is the inspiration for my screen name. =]

  • Definitely one of my favorites! Love Adam Pascal!!

  • 2.40 is the best part!

  • no 3:09 is

  • this song is sooooooo so super fantastic

  • the ending of this song is amazing, and all in all it's definitely one of my fave songs in the whole musical.

  • I love this song sooooo much!!!!!!!!!!!!! Adam Pascal is the absoult greatest singer ever!!!!!!!

  • this song is amazing! :)

  • great song.

    :]

  • "Another day" is the best song in the musical

    it's so rockish and i love the "Reprise" of it in the finale just before the song "your eyes"

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more