The Ever-changing Map Of Middle East

[nomad20122]

your map is so wrong many of the empires you put lived at the same time with each other and you only but one at the time .wrong

[poupounina]

You are wrongly and misleadingly showing geographic areas as if they were precisely defined.

Where is the land of Canaan in all that, it's convenient to skip it isn't it?

[Countrygent100]

Woah up.... did I read that introduction correctly?! It said that at one time the Jews had ruled the Middle East.

You gotta be joking!

At the very biggest stretch of the imagination, the Jews never controlled more than a tiny, tiny sliver of land in the region. As ISRAELITES, under King Solomon, they controlled a somewhat larger bit of land, but hardly the Middle East!

Besides which, you ask any Muslim and he'll deny there ever WAS a time that the Jews ruled anything in the region!

[123backinyerface]

It seems those with any right to the land, are them that can defend it.

[ACORNSUCKS]

Lots of ass kicking.

[TheRahimpur]

hi man! nice video... but you forgot the split of the Kingdom of Israel to the Kingdom of Judea and the kingdom of Israe, and how the empire of Mocdon were split into the Selucid empire and to the house of Telmy. and of course you missed the Hashmonite kingdom

[JEREX101]

i think u missed out sometin though.....the split up between the northern kingdom of israel and the southern kingdom of judah anyway great movie

[ForgerOfEmpires]

persians mostly ruled middleast

[Joey6131995]

its really fascinating how the jews have stuck together for so many years, that little strip of land has been taken over and ravaged and rebelled and faught so many times it seems like they would have blended with the arabic culture around them by now. I really respect their unity.

[Arabman666]

@Joey6131995

Old post, but I'll respond.

1) The Palestinians are Israelites

2) The Jews are not an ethnic group anymore, as the University of Tel Aviv proved (along with Palestinians being real Jews) most modern Israelis are not Israelite

3) You don't comprehend the fact that ancient Jews are Arabs (i.e. Maimonedes, biggest Torah scholar of all times was from Yemen). Modern Israelis overwrote Jewish culture with Asheanzki European culture- and Modern Hebrew is barley Semite language

[NorthCitySider]

@Joey6131995

Yes, those 70 years that they've been there were really difficult.

[justinelhillow]

@Joey6131995 What are you talking about? The Jews in Israel have different cultures. Either European Jews who immigrated to Israel from European nations such as Russia, Poland German etc. Or the Arab Jews who have lived in the middle east and what I would consider pure Jews or closer to it. Those Jews have Arabic culture, and speak Arabic as well, and would sometimes identify themselves as Arabs if they did not face discrimination by the European Jews.

[tareqbatarni]

masa5eta -_- u over dd tht

[xMesopotamia]

very inaccurate

[YaNaYyyM]

before the ottomans, he forgot the mamulkes!!!!!

[TheNecropolis20]

@YaNaYyyM agree he forgot the mamulukes they rukes a empire centered on egypt from 1250 to 1517. if the maker of this vid would just make this vid longer like 5 or 10 minutes there would be a chance at showing more historical nations in middle east

[jianfongyaw]

the caliphate are perhaps how those arabs came here, but we have no choice but to let THEM (any local Arab) stay...

[Moehooper]

just to let you know arabs are the sons of ibraham so there is your answer they have been there longer then any other race like it or the jews have been there also just as long but most jews today are not jews in race but in faith and are not of middle east origins this is fact

[xgalba00]

In which program did you create it? It looks cool with that time line

[7abibiArabiya]

isreal and iran please go away!

[kreplach2]

Yes that makes sense

[mapofmiddleeast]

I give it 50 years more. Arabs will hugely outnumber Jews by then.

[yatuiig]

it already does now, but brains always wins against brawn

[VeritasTruthEmet]

you give israel 50 years, the nazis gave us 5, the romans werent able to remove israel even after 1400 years.... you must understand, if not accept, that Israel has seen the greatest powers in history rise, wage wars of extermination against us, and crumble. You probably wont remove israel from our present location but even if you do we will come back EVEN IF IT TAKES US ANOTHER TWO THOUSAND YEARS! We waited and we won, dont doubt our resolve, we will always come home again. Silly you.

[xpez]

there is a certain bug that comes to mind when you make a description like this...

[eidius1989]

@mapofmiddleeast yes and hopefully they can all get along then.

[xMesopotamia]

@mapofmiddleeast nonononono!

When muslims will outnumber Jews in the US, then Israel will be removed! It's all about votes

[givethanks1314]

@mapofmiddleeast

The Arabs don't have 50 years man. Very little time is left before Christ's coming back and throw all muslim nations into the pit of allah of mohammed.

BTW: this map contains numerous errors. It is an illiterate joke.

[KINGD1991]

dont count on that,

remember , same words were said in 1948' 67' 73 and the list goes on,, nothing will move us out of here, so keep dreaming fella

[mapofmiddleeast]

I don't mean the Jewish people will be gone. But if there's an Arab majority and Arabs are a majority in the Knesset, it will not be a Jewish state anymore.

[ant8066]

@mapofmiddleeast This video misses alot of detail on the Middle Eastern island of Cyprus. For instance, it was a part of the Egyptian kingdom, the Hittie empire, a crusader state and gained its colonial independence in 1960. Cyprus is both geographically and culturally Middle Eastern, and it is included in most definitions of the region, including historic ones. As a colonised land, it is historically a lot closer to its fellow Middle Eastern states than Imperial, European nations.

[IronLion27]

@mapofmiddleeast Do you see that though?

Israel allows arabs to serve in their parliament, I don't see any Jews serving in the governments of Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Syria, or any other Islamic Republics.

[IronLion27]

@mapofmiddleeast Do you see that though?

Israel allows arabs to serve in their parliament, I don't see any Jews serving in the governments of Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Syria, or any other Islamic Republics.

[IronLion27]

@mapofmiddleeast Do you see that though?

Israel allows arabs to serve in their parliament, I don't see any Jews serving in the governments of Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Syria, or any other Islamic Republics.

[trog69]

@IronLion27 Avigdor Lieberman and others are calling for the Israeli Arabs to be rejected as members of Knesset. Many others are calling for the ouster of the Arabs out of Israel altogether.

[ofri75]

@mapofmiddleeast - Arab majority in Israel ? LOL - the Arabs in Israel are only 19% (including the Druze, that not all of them see themselves as Arabs) - how can they become a majority from 19%???

In any case, we in Israel respect all minorities, and so the irony is that Arab-Israelis are the only Arabs in the middle east today - who enjoy freedom, democracy, and human rights

[BlackRoof]

@mapofmiddleeast ISRAEL HAS N-O-T-H-I-N-G TO DO WITH JUDAISM!

Israel is a Zionst Juntah!

It has nothing to do with religeon at all!

Israel is a racist, terrorist state built in ETHNIC AMBITION!

It disgraces ALL Hebrews by claiming to act in the name of Judaism!

You don't believe me?

Come to my channel to see ONLY THE FACTS!

L,chaim.

[therockiscookin077]

@BlackRoof True

[lugerox]

@BlackRoof It seems like abortions are forbidden in your town.

[BlackRoof]

@lugerox Yes, my town is THE PLANET and you are the HORRIBLE MISTAKE that we are still paying for!!!

No matter!

The world needs to stop and realise the CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY committed by ISRAEL.

"Victim Israel" is a myth that no longer applies.

Israel is persecuting the Palestinian people with funding FROM AMERICA!!!

The West is turning a blind eye while Israel mimicks HITLER!!!

IT IS SIMPLY TRUE!!!!

Take one moment to see!

More info?

(click my screen name)

[shaharmos]

@BlackRoof

ENGLAND WAS CRIMES AGAINS

SCOTLAND AND WEILS

בן זונה  אנטישמי !!!!!

[BlackRoof]

@shaharmos England is NO LONGER AN EMPIRE!

Britain maintains the Commonwealth which is a group of countries who WANT to be affiliated with us.

But the "Empire" ended one century ago and was completely gone by the end of World War 2.

EVERYBODY KNOWS THAT ISRAEL HAS IMPERIAL AMBITIONS but that time has gone. It ended long ago.

YOUR IMPERIAL AMBITIONS ARE BUILT ON BLIND NATIONALISM AND VIOLENT, RACIST, SUPREMACIST, ETHNIC AMBITION.

Hah!

Do you want to be the master race, cave man?

[shaharmos]

@BlackRoof

you are realy ANTI SEMITIC !!! .

and yes ;

the bible said that israel will be

A GREAT EMPIRE after the world war 3

and RETURN all of the JEWISH TERRITOY

BACK TO THE JEWS

from RIVER NILE TO EUPHRATES

[shaharmos]

@BlackRoof

you are realy ANTI SEMITIC !!! .

and yes ;

the bible said that israel will be

A GREAT EMPIRE after the world war 3

and  RETURN all of the JEWISH TERRITOY

BACK TO THE JEWS

from RIVER NILE TO EUPHRATES

[BlackRoof]

@shaharmos England is NO LONGER AN EMPIRE!

Britain maintains the Commonwealth which is a group of countries who WANT to be affiliated with us.

But the "Empire" ended one century ago and was completely gone by the end of World War 2.

EVERYBODY KNOWS THAT ISRAEL HAS IMPERIAL AMBITIONS but that time has gone. It ended long ago.

YOUR IMPERIAL AMBITIONS ARE BUILT ON BLIND NATIONALISM AND VIOLENT, RACIST, SUPREMACIST, ETHNIC AMBITION.

Hah!

Do you want to be the master race, cave man?

[lemonlime1600]

@KINGD1991 your religion will rule you out because you havent said blessed is he who comes in the name of the christ you had your chance and missed the boat but its not to late there are millions of jews for jesus coonverting the fig tree is ripe the jews are a little arrogant jesus said you sahall not see me here in the house of david until you cry blessed is he who comes in the name of the lord, jews are my oldest brothers in my catholics faith, dont look down on people look up to god

[JEREX101]

@KINGD1991 true

[JEREX101]

@KINGD1991 true

[000simsim000]

@KINGD1991 as far as I know, in those years Israel illegaly occupied more and more palestenian land. Its not something to be proud of you know,not even if you are jewish.

You claim to have been prone to so much injustice in your past and won the nations sympathy by your stories, but to me you deserve what ever happens to you, because you are just hippocrits who claim to be a peacfull nation...by invading a defenceless country.

[longliveegypt1]

@KINGD1991 we kicked your ass in 73 and in 67 we did not really fight it was just an air strike with the help of americans

we also kicked your ass too in 56

[kreplach2]

Ahmadinedejad shares your setiments.

[MrDark141]

@Khvito75

you see you say "State", you can't reconized israel. you're fucking pig.

don't worry it won't happent, not in 50 years not in 100 and not in 200.

and another thing,

dream about getting Jerusalem assholes

[givethanks1314]

@Khvito75 you know who will be wiped out from the map? ALL nations except Israel! Israel will become the Kingdom of Christ at His 2nd advent.

Don't believe me? wait and see. It won't take 50 years. lol

[xxsoroushxx10]

@Khvito75 i hope so no one likes jews

[olegsher]

@Khvito75 you can only dreame .. keep living in France as dirty immigrant...You arabs with all lands can't build even one normal country.. Only dreeaming how to destroy others...

[Khvito75]

@olegsher I'm an international student from Saudi Arabia not an immigrant :). I only want Israel destroyed :)

[olegsher]

@Khvito75

just wait when oil will ends.. you will destroed immidiatly.. For example by France..))

and keep dreaming )))

[ScabbyArse]

if the map of the middle east is changed once more the poor fuckers will never see peace

[kreplach2]

Who has seen peace anywhere?