The reason Mariah uses a mic is because she sings with music playing at high decibel levels. It's true it would be difficult to hear her otherwise, but the same is just as true for any singer, including Opera singers.
You'd think opera lovers would be so much more mature. Look you can't really compare Mariah Carey or any pop star at that to any opera singer. In saying that, you also cannot say either are 'real singers' because both styles are so different. Sure Mariah's high notes don't have the tone or classical trained way that opera singers do but she isn't singing opera is she? no, she is singing her own songs, her own style and her own way. Not many opera singers can belt out a pop song, and vice versa.
ok. i love mariah so no offence. listen : put mariah on stage WITHOUT A MIC next to an opera singer. both could hit the the same high note but i bet mariah couldnt be heard. opera singers sing the toughest music WITHOUT ANY MIC AND BACKING SOUND MACHINE, it's just them filling an entire theatre with their voice ABOVE a whole orchestra playing. Mariah would have made a GREAT opera singer if she had received a classical training but she remains a pop singer, one of the best but still a pop singer.
@frenchviewer1994 Mariah probably can't execute her high notes as robustly as an opera singer would without a mic. But an opera singer probably can't belt a powerful ballad the way Mariah can. It's all in areas of training. Nothing is wrong with being a "pop singer" if you sound like MC. Just saying ;)....(she's more r&b imo)
@Anime00Freak Mariah can't be an opera singer, her head voice isn't strong enough to project without a mic, and opera singers don't use whistle register
This video is sooooooo good! DANG All of these ladies can sing. Mariah's opera background is obvious here because she fit right on in lol. Finally, a high note video that doesn't annoy me. It's very entertaining. Great job MCLAMB!
@DanielAvilaAGT Opera singers sing without microphones OVER AN ORCHESTRA in 2000-4000 seat theaters. OK, the theaters are built for acoustics, but opera singers sing over the orchestra - very different from a capella. They are heard even when they sing very softly. Additionally, it's not just about hitting high notes, the voice has to be even and beautiful throughout the range without audible breaks. Also, coloraturas can do trills, runs, other ornaments.
@DanielAvilaAGT Watch this: /watch?v=DvuKxL4LOqc Also this: /watch?v=Q3kzqzXHp2A -- note, this is he last act of a 3-hour opera (which was done with only one intermission), and the singer here has been on stage for most of it. This is at the Met which has 3800 seats plus standing room.
mariah's whistle notes sound so much better than opera high notes. plus, can these opera singers actually sing songs like mariah? ...either way theyre all talented in their own repects
@Dannoc100 What????!!!!!!!! How insulting!!!! Opera singers are prepared for arias (not songs [;) 1 billion times more difficult than pop music, you don't know ANYTHING about coloratura!!!!!!!!!!!! Go and listen to "Yma Sumac - Chuncho" or "Frühlingsstimmenwalzer - Erna Sack" Only then say something! An opera singer would never go to Maruah's level, that's too insulting lol And remember, Mariah whistles, opera singers sing [; You should read my 3 first posts before talking [:
@MCLAMB4LIFE1 Nonono, maybe I wasn't too clear, I said "some of the notes" she sings in whistle register,not all those notes. Some women use whistle register for a F6, some sopranos who reach that note don't use whistle register
Anyway, I want to say that all my comments were not to you, I understand (it seems) the aim of the video, only for those who keep saying "blablabla,Mariah sings better than a lyrical singer because she can reach higher notes" wow, that's pathetic
@LacrimaLunaMortua Opera singers do NOT use whistle register. Whistle Register will not project over an orchestra; hell, it won't even be heard past the first row. It is not strong enough. The chords aren't fully functioning.
@rekupp d: That's exactly what I've said, that's why many toddlers here hate me, because I've told them the truth about their whistle singers. I'm one of those who defend opera singers, check out my comment here and in other similar videos out there. I'm sure you made a mistake, I'm your mate, not your foe in this war d:
There are some videos you HAVE to watch if you want to contradict me [: (I can't post the links, so I'm going to write the names exactly as they appear on YouTube, look for them)
1. "YMA SUMAC Chuncho" Otherwordly triple trill
2. Sandrine Piau in "Nulla in Mondo Pax Sincera II" Especially from 4:30, pure coloratura
3. "Maria Callas, The 20th Century Assoluta" This video explains WHY Callas is in a MUCH superior level than Carey, the day Carey can sing 1% alike Callas did, world will end LOL!
@LacrimaLunaMortua mariah should take lessons to use her voice at full potential,not to compete with anyone,just beacuse she can do more with her voice than what she actualy does,she must use all the potential of her vocal range.
@apio9 I'm not sure she's able to improve, I mean, If she hasn't along all her career, can she do it now? Whistle register is not a difficult technique, if you compare some of the notes Mariah sings with this register, you'll be surprised because opera singers sing it with modal register. Whistle register is not a "rich" register because all the qualities, skills, etc... are lost, sometimes even vibrato, what's horrible! Children also can use this register,so we could say it's really childish :D
@LacrimaLunaMortua well for example christina aguilera has over 13 years of career but started to go to singing classes just now,maybe mariah needs someone to help her to use her full vocal range,i don't think she has used all the potential of her voice yet
@LacrimaLunaMortua yes she has to hurry up,the problem with pop is that it's a music style that don't need great voices like mariah's,whitney's,celine's,christina's and so on,so they don't use the full potential of their voices singing pop music.
@apio9 hahaha Hell Yeah! In pop you only must have a sticking voice and to be visually attractive, how mediocre (I respect people who like this music anyway, I mean, my sister loves it /: lol )
Is Mariah able to sing, act and dance (sometimes) like opera singers? Like Dessay in 2:10? And I could keep on writing but I'm not going to end lol! Please, before you say Mariah is better than opera singers listen to Yma Sumac in Chuncho (with her WONDROUS AND OTHERWORDLY TRIPLE TRILL) and ask Mariah to try to sing like her at least 10% of the song LOL! She'd die trying it! And, please, NEVER DARE to compare her with La Divina, can Mariah at least sing 1% like her?
OMG, I can't believe there're persons who think that Mariah Carey sings better than an Opera singer LOOOL!! Has Mariah got at least 10% of technique than any opera singer? WHEN has an opera singer sung with A MICROPHONE?!!! LOL, please, don't make me laugh, an opera singer must be able to sing OVER A COMPLETE ORCHESTRA FULL OF DIFFERENT INSTRUMENTS AND CHOIR (SOMETIMES) SOUNDING ALL TOGETHER WITHOUT ANY DEVICE! Has Mariah ever sung more than 2 or 3 hours in a stage like MANY opera singers?
I think its ironic how mariah was trained by her mother, who is a Opera singer. You can hear some operatic tones in her whistle. On some notes they sound very similar. The biggest difference is that opera singer do not use microphones, as their voice resonates over an entire auditorium. Mariah is still my queen though.
@MCLAMB4LIFE1 it isn't for opera singers are trained to reach these notes in full stratospheric modal explaining why they can fill audience halls without a microphone.. if they use whistle it would be too soft and sound quite bad however i know mariah can also do the same but she wants to keep her own style which is full of flageolet notes ..... so go Mariah and go Opera !!!
@Ehadurkah She did it in whistle and with a microphone. Opera singers are heard over the orchestra without microphones when they sing. Incidentally, this is an opera singer doing a C8: /watch?v=sPVrQ-wv-h8
@jewelmarkess Nice try hun but that was a C7. anyone with a Piano, tuner and Sense of pitch can tell you that. Adam Lopez is the only person person who has proved with a live vocal that he hit a C#8.
@jewelmarkess Thanks for this link. I couldn't agree more with you here! Wispering in a whistle with a microphone is just a vocal trick! Many pop singers can just make fun like that using modern technology to help them...Svetlana Feodulova is a true opera singer, and she does it RIGHT!
@Ehadurkah Mamma mia, do you think that Mariah Carey with her having fun and just whistling with a microphone like jewelmarkess says sings it better than a REAL opera singer! LOL She is just a pop singer making a MUSICAL JOKE! Artists are not always serious! They also make PARODIES on other genres FOR FUN! LOL
hidalgo699@ her music is a big fail??? What? Are you sick? Or just didn't yet getting breakfast before you post such ignorant comment, Dont you know that MC is a BIG hit when speaking of MUSIC SUCCESS, she is the most outstanding music succesor according to WMA, with a 200 million record sold worldwide in just only 20 years! Fastest selling female artist according to IFRI. One of the biggest selling artist in history of music industry ever. First ever Chopard Diamond awardee by an artist.
Dont you know that every single song from MC is a a record breaker? So how do you say that shit "One Sweet Day" become longest chart topper in billboard for 16 weeks, shit "All I Want For Christmas Is You" getting number 1 every year and the all time fevorite holliday song of all time, shit "Hero" most inspirational song and most overplayed song in radio, dont you know that MC has 18 number 1 hit that more than elvis presley,michael jackson,madonna or any single artist in the world.
hidalgo699@ you bullshit insecured jealous heater, what are trying to show off, your ignorant to carey's global success is so disgusting!...MC is THE BIGGEST SELLING RECORDING ARTIST OF THE NEW MELLENIUM, with an 18 NUMBER ONE HIT (most of any single artist) in the world, 17 WORLD MUSIC AWARD (most of any artist), 1 LIVING LEGEND AWARD , 1 ARTIST OF THE DECADE 90's, which only giving this every ten years. Just like michael jackson who became artist of the decade in 80's era.
@jfichter69 according to wikipedia, any note by an opera singer extend beyond high (F) F6 is considered a whistle register... Wikipedia is one of the most updated and accurate in any human knowlegde in our time today.
@jfichter69 in many amature singer that trying hard to enter the whistle register and because of lack of professionaly trained... They used it not in a proper way or wrong mechanism, that why they sound ugly as untuned violin, but when you trained hard by a professionals like adam lopez who says that he study hard to learn for 10 years just to use it in a proper way of singing, and mariah carey who mastered this technique for 30 years.
mariah relies on whistle tones to hit the high notes. the opera singers use pure modal singing... much harder. whistle tones sound like screeching violin bows to my ears. check out Madasen McGrath ascend the scale to C7 4:04
@MCLAMB4LIFE1 well, it is possible to use the vocal chords around the ranges you showed us. however any higher, like C8+ would be impossible. and head voice? that just has to do with resonance :-) not the pitch itself. mariah carey uses head voice too. mariah can only go to c#6 using modal voice, after that, she relies on whistles. just listen for the different timbres of the opera singers vs mariah
@jfichter69 I completely disagree with Mariah Carey wins of anyone she has many vocal abilities mostly chest voice. Whistle is just one more talent she has.
@jfichter69 Mariah has way more agility in the whistle range than these opera singers do, they seem to be very tense and squeezing these whistles out. They don't seem comfortable in the whistle range like Mariah does
@Jared95C compare enra sack and mariah at 3:50. erna is hitting each note clearnly without having to glissando to and fro, unlike mariah, who seemingly blends each note together.
@jfichter69 Oh, of course there's no doubt of it!! :) Each one is good in their own style, obviously classic is way beyond pop :) Happy Holidays btw!!
@jfichter69 I'd like to point out also that it is physically IMPOSSIBLE to sing to C7 in modal or even head register. Natalie Dessay pretty much takes the highest possible head notes in the human voice, and any higher is in the whistle REGISTER, but opera singers who access it tend to have a solid and crystalline sound. This is why some people tend to differentiate between whistle and super-head voices; they are in the same register of the voice, but have different placement and sound.
@jfichter69 not modal, no one speaks like that... the only type of voices whose modal and singing voices are similar are the basses and baritones, all the other voices are "produced" never modal.
@pedy19 A well trained singer or speaker can phonate two octaves or more within the modal register with consistent production, beauty of tone, dynamic variation, and vocal freedom.
@jfichter69 Still that is no modal regist. Modal means speaking regist, natural with no addition and it usually is chest voice, people don´t speak naturally in head voices, even sopranos don´t! their chest voice is higher, but still their modal voice is not head voice or anything of sorts
@pedy19 if these opera singers were singing in whistle tones, then the crowd could not hear them as the whitles are lower in dynamics. they would need microphones for it to be heard. have you ever tried to whistle and a big room and fill it with sound? a singer has to use their chords to make a big sound like these women....
@jfichter69 Huh?! you´re mixing things lol i was talking only about modal voice and talking voice, regarding your statement "I'd like to point out also that it is physically IMPOSSIBLE to sing to C7 in modal or even head register" I was just saying that modal voice is the voice you use for talking.
@pedy19 correct. it is used for talking and singing with maximum vocal tension. i think there is a mess up cause we are talking on comments lol hard to keep track of everything said
@jfichter69 loool no stress :p it´s alright. But yes operatic singers develop a specific technique, that differs from "pop" or contemporary one. :) comparing is futile it´s too different.
@pedy19 my speaking voice sits in the high 4th to 5th ocatve naturaly so please check ur facts befor u speak :) and when i gett excited its jumps into the 6th octave ppl cringe at my speakign voice,LOL i hav eto force it down when i can.,
@lathanregintree I´m sorry for not believing you. Modal voice is chest voice, therefore you won´t getting in the 5th octave, even when "Belting" people must mix a bit.
@pedy19 my speakign voice sits in head voce register,lol i dont care if u believe me,LOL!!!! :''-D my voice when talking is proof enough it self u dumb ass,LMFAO!!!!!! #DISMISSED
@lathanregintree Nop modal voice is a voice without any kind of production, a natural voice, although people might touch head voice in modal voice it does never "sit" there, unless you are a siren. No modal voice can get to the 6th octave, be realistic, you probably just scream a lot or then you swith to head / mix voice but then you no longer are in modal voice. You are dismissed sugar.
@yomamajama777 We´ll see that, I wouldn´t trust that, Mariah´s tone is something unique, the diversity of textures, and the ease she sings /used to sing (mainly until early 97) is something impossible to top ( I believe)
Are there any videos of Mariah Carey at age 10?? See Jackie Evancho rendition of "Pie Jesu" live in AGT. Even though I believe Mariah started at 5 and had an advantage of her mother (Patricia) and opera singer training her.Her ability to sing seamlessly from the lower register to her effortless upper register would also be envied by many opera singers. Whats so unusual about Jackie is her thrilling,silvery upper register, which affects the central nervous system of her fans.
Jackie is a voiceless little shit simply supported by a bunch of pedophiles with no knowledge of music. Compared to real singers she is worth less than nothing.
There are no videos of Mariah singing at age 10 because her mother is not a fame whore selling her own prepubescent daughter to make a quick buck, and because her mom took good care of her and her voice is why Mariah is one of the biggest selling female artists of all time and has more #1's than Elvis, and developed a 5 octave range.
@pedy19 i said 4th t 5th octave,LOL not 6th octave ur trying to dimiss me but you can not even read,LMFAO im done with u but feel free to reply as i know u will b/c ur a sad ugly fag with no life who likes it up the arse,lol #DIMISSED #FAIL
@lathanregintree loool honey you read your comment then. Second being a fag or not that´s my thing and someone as young as you should be instructed not to point that orientation at no one, but I see you are retarded and just a problematic girl who doesn´t deal with different opinions that well, too bad for you I say! Second let´s not start by talking about looks because I definitely look better than you.
@primohomme bitch dont fucking step to me real fucking talk with ur dirty over used pussy ass and im a guy. u are nothing more then some shit talking online hoe,LOL u wouldnt even step to me off line so bitch learn ur place and keep ur mouth on a dick where is ment to stay at all time's -_-
2- I would tell you the same here, in person, on the phone, you name it...
3- The only one sucking dicks and sitting on dicks to pay for his sex change operation is you sweetie.
4- I listened to your song "Think of you" or whatever its fucking name was. You can't sing worth shit, it was OMG so off key! with a baby prostitute whisper and a low falsetto at the end, LMAO, pathetic.
@primohomme bitch u really are stupid,LOL first off i dont have a song called thinking of u 2. i am a guy,LOL its called a pretty boy which is a guy who has fem facial looks u dumb ass,LMFAO and as cute as i am i dont need a sex change,LOL girls like pretty boys which u wouldnt know of b/c ur just a ugly sad youtube person :''-D check my fb fan page u dirty pussy hoe. hoe u would never stop to me s big as i am i will crush u,XD
Sweetheart, if by "girls" you mean 12 year olds? maybe...if by "girls" you mean WOMEN, absolutely not...Women don't like little bitch boys who look more femme than they do. You look like a transexual, and you probably are.
Oh and are you so ashamed of your shitty recording "Think of you" now? It's on arkmusicfactory and on soundcloud...you really can't sing worth shit baby, you are so off key it's laughable, so pathetic.
@lathanregintree I am sorry but I also listened to this song of yours.. and you are not a good singer, your voice was whisper thin and not in a Kylie Minogue good way. It was aggrivating,the falsetto you claim is whistle is about 2 octaves short of being in whistle range and was not stable. I do think there are better singers then Mariah.. but you are not one of them.Sorry.
@lathanregintree Also I see that you deleted your comments confirming it was you but I screenshotted those as well .. I predicted a cover up and you didn't dissapoint.
@lathanregintree Also I see that you deleted your comments confirming it was you but I screenshotted those as well .. I predicted a cover up and you didn't dissapoint.
@lathanregintree Soundcloud website under your name :/ Don't be fazed by all accounts .. But really if it's that hard for you to hold a b5 and it really sounds like you are struggling then why talk about you are better then Mariah Carey. I mean you are monotone up until the b5 ..and then the b5 is not good at all. How are you going to act like you are this great singer when your voice sounds like that?
@lathanregintree It isn't like i don't like you, I don't know you personally and you may be signed,So is Rebecca Black. But my point is.. You are so out of tune in that song.. I mean.. it's monotone then you hit that b5 which sounds like a kettle boiling btw,very strange. But you are claiming to be this great singer.. you have confused the fuck out of me that is for sure because you aint no Mariah Carey or even Xtina ..
@lathanregintree Well I don't like your singing because.. You kind of talk yourself up but then.. like that recording certainly didn't deliver and .. It was only a b5, how am I suppose to beleive you sing f7 like it says on your facebook account when you struggle to stay in tune on a b5.
Once again, I don't like dislike you as a person or whatever but your singing scares me more then nightmare on elm street.
@lathanregintree Do I really need to give you a link when you can find it on google? Don't bother deleting it and pretending it isn't you either because I stole it with Audacity along with screenshots :/
not yet convince? Then listen the C7 whistle from her song "Your So Cold" at the biggining, or watch the live performance of "fly like a bird" at shelter home, and you all see,hear and feel the spirit of opera inspired to those technique of Mariah Carey.
@zucchini2007 you absolutely very right! Yes! Mariahs Mother (Patricia Hickey Carey) is a professional opera singer and a well trained vocal coach (in regiolettos) , she used to teach mariah since she was a 3 year old, since mariah was child, she always wanted to hit those highnotes not just from her mother but from her idol Minnie Riperton. Mariah has the opera technique... Dont yet convince? Then try listen the Bb6 note from her christian song "Fly Like A Bird".
G10-G12 highnotes cannot be heard by a human ears... So how do you say theres an opera sing 10 octave... Are you delutionally crazy... Must be hit low G0-G10 or G2-G12, FOR CLARRIFICATION... NO HUMAN BEING CAN HOLD EVEN IN 9TH OCTAVE BEYOND...MAYBE AN ALLIEN CAN DO THAT... The highest ever sang by an human is they G#8 by georgia brown...but that only F8 acording to analysis
the highest... Ever sang by an opera is only D7 by mado robin... Mado lowest note is D3 extend To D7... And just only cheap 4 octave range... Also mado robin become guinness world record holder at her prime hitting the last D of the piano...
@NilesMind , are you crazy or just naturally born idiot... Can you proof whos opera has 10 octave, ahahahaha, you made me laf so crazy , you know if an opera has 10 octave? Must be hit low G2 extend up to G12, in my entire my entire life , i never seen an opera hitting G12... Must be at guinness record if that happen... And not georgia brown than only has G2-F8.. Guinness holder has a 5.6 octave.
Experts says Mariah Carey is the only human has a extraordinary vocal cords, her doctor says her voice box was designed different from the other one, and its affect thats why she can hold base range from the 2nd octave low E flat (Eb2) in other one she can reach not just stratospheric but ionospheric range extend beyond high "G" from the 7th octave to the 8th octave in all full control, her mother says she hear mariah also hit E8 extend beyond highest key of piano (C8) while doing warm up.
So! Isnt Opera comparable to MARIAH CAREY the living legend, the songbird supreme, the hit maker, the queen of RnB, the queen of billbord, 2nd worlds richest female artist of all time and the biggest selling female recording artist of our mellenium.
Mariah Carey has a special vocal production that none any opera has. With the 5-6 octave vocal range that no body of opera has! Shes just out of this world! MTV and Blender Magazine said that she has the most beautiful voice and can mimic any note she can hear with perfect listening pitch! In fact shes the number one most beautiful voice in top 22 most beatiful voice in the world.
Experts says Mariah Carey is the only human has a extraordinary vocal cords, her doctor says her voice box was designed different from the other one, and its affect thats why she can hold base range from the 2nd octave low E flat (Eb2) in other one she can reach not just stratospheric but ionospheric range extend beyond high "G" from the 7th octave to the 8th octave in all full control, her mother says she hear mariah also hit E8 extend beyond highest key of piano (C8) while doing warm up.
In European classical music, the WHISTLE REGISTER is used primarily by "operatic" coloratura sopranos. Many parts in the coloratura soprano repertoire extend beyond "high C" and often extend up to high F
(F6).Although many "operatic" coloratura
sopranos use whistle tone vocal production to sing these notes. Whistle Register is the most rare register by an human voice and the mastery of using this is MARIAH CAREY placing her as one of our the greatest singer today! Source: dictionary wiki
What did you say? Whistle trick is a small trick? Well i need you to understand what is:The whistle register (also called the flageolet or flute register or whistle tone) is the highest register of the human voice, lying above the modal register and falsetto register. This register has a specific physiological
production that is different from the
other registers, and is so called because the timbre of the notes that are produced from this register is similar to that of a whistle.
@hidalgo699 who are you to say what is good or bad, mariah carey is one of the biggest selling artist in the world, if her music was shitty i dont think she would be that popular and loved....
@killerbunny123123 ignorat who? Maybe you absolutely, opera isn't comparable to MC, question? is thre any opera who became succesfull and sold more than 200+ million record just like MC? Big NO! and speaking of highnotes, is there any opera hit staccatic swift with uplomb supersonic waves like E7-G#7 up to 8 octave and belt C5-A5 with melisma run? Another big NO! is there any operas can do ROCK,RnB,POP,JASS,MOTOWN,RAP etc. Like MC? Another again BIG NO! and last, isnt opera can stil popular
@luisboricua9 Apples and oranges. Opera singers sing without microphones in an opera theater sometimes with 4000 seats like the Met over the full orchestra, or did you miss this? You wouldn't hear Mariah Carey if you take her microphone away.
Mariah Carey Won.. Her Mom Was A Julliard Opera Singer.. Taught Her Everything.. Besides Mariah Can Do More With Her Register.. Like TALK!!!!!!!!!!!! Beat That..
@plutoipresume Ok first of all this entire video is a mistake simply because you cant compare pop singing to opera singing; its like comparing a tomatoe to a watermellon! Still fruit but entirely different! Secondly, Mariah is a great inger but whistle register tricks barely count as "singing"...its more of vocalizing, AKA little voice tricks.
There's a difference between training and studying an entire life of singing (and also acting) in opera, and "pop singing". There's no compare in skill.
Difficult to judge though. Opera's singing is way more refined with strict accuracy. But Mariah is great here. She's got an airy tone in there which makes it sound sweet, mild and very interpersonal. Like when u hum "hmmmm~", u feel the ease and freedom. No one hums a clear-cut phrase, i think. So her voice really fits pop and R&B. This is what she is for.
these is so so so bias, mariah vs bunch of operas is a bias competing, but still mariah blow those ugly soundy opera shouters, opera cant belt but mariah does, opera cant hit 2nd octave but mariah can, mariah has 5 octave or more but opera has only short range, mariah can do stacatic swift E7-F7-G#7 or even 8 octave, that none anybody opera can! Intyende...
@rdmtjr Ok, first off learn the difference between "can't and "don't because they shouldn't". No one in opera does her whistle tricks cos thats not even considered singing. The "shouty" sounds are much louder simply cos they do them in head voice, not just whistling. Anyone can use whistle register. How about trying to hit a high G#6 in full head voice? Now, THAT'S a real talent, which Natalie Dessay posseses almost alone in the singing world. About "staccati" try listening to more Dessay.
@truongphan90 Well not all of their high notes and especially not the stratospheric high notes of Mado....and surely not the staccati of erna sack used in this video. And when they do not use uniquely their whistle register they use some sort of union between head and flageolet voice, commonly used by coloratura sopranos going above high C or, in Erna's and Mado's case, above high F.
Opera sounds very ugly loudy, although they not shouting but they realy sounds shouting... No melody of peace on their voice... Vibrato vibrato vibroto is sooo sooo sooo uglyyyy....
And i bet... I'm sure Most people and majority of peoply prefer MARIAH IS a better singer...
1. they only sound ugly to people who are too stupid to comprehend their level (also depends on who the singer is)
2. "No versatility"? Opera is like the Olympics of voice. If you're trained enough for that, you can sing anything in the world, try Sarah Brightman, Pavarotti, or Renee flemming.
3. If the acoustic of the room is good your ears will not get "erratated"
4. The pronounciation reguards each singer, dont generalize (go to comment #2)
@killerbunny123123 Yes, Sarah Brightman is indeed a classical crossover singer, true, but a) she didn't have that much a classical training as far as I know b) having classical training doesn't make one an opera singer. A lot of people have classical voice training - amateurs, pop singers, musical theater singers - classical training provides a good base for them. Even not all classical singers are opera singers, some perform solely chamber music in concerts but can't handle a full opera.
and then he deleted all his comments too me but little did lathanregintree know that I predicted him deleting them also and got a screenshot ...
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lathanregintree deleted the comments he made to me ,very predictable. I have those as well on screenshot :)
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
@lathanregintree deleted the comments he made to me ,very predictable. I have those as well on screenshot :)
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
The reason Mariah uses a mic is because she sings with music playing at high decibel levels. It's true it would be difficult to hear her otherwise, but the same is just as true for any singer, including Opera singers.
Seekarr 4 days ago
@Seekarr Opera singers don't use mics :/ at all. Mariah is clearly not Opera..
BrenTheGorgeous 2 days ago
You'd think opera lovers would be so much more mature. Look you can't really compare Mariah Carey or any pop star at that to any opera singer. In saying that, you also cannot say either are 'real singers' because both styles are so different. Sure Mariah's high notes don't have the tone or classical trained way that opera singers do but she isn't singing opera is she? no, she is singing her own songs, her own style and her own way. Not many opera singers can belt out a pop song, and vice versa.
JustinandCelineDC 6 days ago 3
ok. i love mariah so no offence. listen : put mariah on stage WITHOUT A MIC next to an opera singer. both could hit the the same high note but i bet mariah couldnt be heard. opera singers sing the toughest music WITHOUT ANY MIC AND BACKING SOUND MACHINE, it's just them filling an entire theatre with their voice ABOVE a whole orchestra playing. Mariah would have made a GREAT opera singer if she had received a classical training but she remains a pop singer, one of the best but still a pop singer.
frenchviewer1994 1 week ago
@frenchviewer1994 Mariah probably can't execute her high notes as robustly as an opera singer would without a mic. But an opera singer probably can't belt a powerful ballad the way Mariah can. It's all in areas of training. Nothing is wrong with being a "pop singer" if you sound like MC. Just saying ;)....(she's more r&b imo)
Angelfully 6 days ago
lol look at how opera singers stretch their faces when hitting the high notes but Mariah sings them in a leisure while smiling :)
Avri1RocksHK 1 week ago
@Stefano94x True ^^
SuperPianogirl123 2 weeks ago
@jewelmarkess Yea I'm aware of that. Thanks :))
DanielAvilaAGT 3 weeks ago
@LacrimaLunaMortua You are delusional and brain dead. *blocked* have fun in the hospital hahaha
DanielAvilaAGT 3 weeks ago
@DanielAvilaAGT Come on toddler, you can't deny facts, I can't believe there're still people like you, well, be happy in your illusory world
Hail real singers lml
LacrimaLunaMortua 2 weeks ago
@Anime00Freak Mariah can't be an opera singer, her head voice isn't strong enough to project without a mic, and opera singers don't use whistle register
SuperPianogirl123 3 weeks ago
@SuperPianogirl123 But her pianissimo vocalizations destroy... :)
Stefano94x 2 weeks ago 2
This video is sooooooo good! DANG All of these ladies can sing. Mariah's opera background is obvious here because she fit right on in lol. Finally, a high note video that doesn't annoy me. It's very entertaining. Great job MCLAMB!
(btw what media-convert program do you use?)
Angelfully 1 month ago 2
Theres another C7 whistle. its in 'bringin on the heartbreak'
She do sing live for this song before
ILoveDonuts0 1 month ago
we win!
thiagoexpress 1 month ago
POW!
mcboypower 1 month ago
@LacrimaLunaMortua Look up Mariah Carey singing Whsitle register acapella. She's doesn't need a microphone to project those whistles.
DanielAvilaAGT 1 month ago
@DanielAvilaAGT You said it, acapella, lol Go and listen to Erna Sack, there you have real singer, not Mariah, she doesn't sing [;
LacrimaLunaMortua 3 weeks ago
@DanielAvilaAGT Opera singers sing without microphones OVER AN ORCHESTRA in 2000-4000 seat theaters. OK, the theaters are built for acoustics, but opera singers sing over the orchestra - very different from a capella. They are heard even when they sing very softly. Additionally, it's not just about hitting high notes, the voice has to be even and beautiful throughout the range without audible breaks. Also, coloraturas can do trills, runs, other ornaments.
jewelmarkess 3 weeks ago
@DanielAvilaAGT Watch this: /watch?v=DvuKxL4LOqc Also this: /watch?v=Q3kzqzXHp2A -- note, this is he last act of a 3-hour opera (which was done with only one intermission), and the singer here has been on stage for most of it. This is at the Met which has 3800 seats plus standing room.
jewelmarkess 3 weeks ago
mariah's whistle notes sound so much better than opera high notes. plus, can these opera singers actually sing songs like mariah? ...either way theyre all talented in their own repects
Dannoc100 1 month ago
@Dannoc100 What????!!!!!!!! How insulting!!!! Opera singers are prepared for arias (not songs [;) 1 billion times more difficult than pop music, you don't know ANYTHING about coloratura!!!!!!!!!!!! Go and listen to "Yma Sumac - Chuncho" or "Frühlingsstimmenwalzer - Erna Sack" Only then say something! An opera singer would never go to Maruah's level, that's too insulting lol And remember, Mariah whistles, opera singers sing [; You should read my 3 first posts before talking [:
LacrimaLunaMortua 3 weeks ago
@LacrimaLunaMortua You should really do your research ! Singing Whistle Register in modal voice is physically impossible.
MCLAMB4LIFE1 1 month ago 10
@MCLAMB4LIFE1 Nonono, maybe I wasn't too clear, I said "some of the notes" she sings in whistle register,not all those notes. Some women use whistle register for a F6, some sopranos who reach that note don't use whistle register
Anyway, I want to say that all my comments were not to you, I understand (it seems) the aim of the video, only for those who keep saying "blablabla,Mariah sings better than a lyrical singer because she can reach higher notes" wow, that's pathetic
So,it was not for you [:
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
@LacrimaLunaMortua Opera singers do NOT use whistle register. Whistle Register will not project over an orchestra; hell, it won't even be heard past the first row. It is not strong enough. The chords aren't fully functioning.
rekupp 2 weeks ago
@rekupp d: That's exactly what I've said, that's why many toddlers here hate me, because I've told them the truth about their whistle singers. I'm one of those who defend opera singers, check out my comment here and in other similar videos out there. I'm sure you made a mistake, I'm your mate, not your foe in this war d:
Greetings!
LacrimaLunaMortua 2 weeks ago
There are some videos you HAVE to watch if you want to contradict me [: (I can't post the links, so I'm going to write the names exactly as they appear on YouTube, look for them)
1. "YMA SUMAC Chuncho" Otherwordly triple trill
2. Sandrine Piau in "Nulla in Mondo Pax Sincera II" Especially from 4:30, pure coloratura
3. "Maria Callas, The 20th Century Assoluta" This video explains WHY Callas is in a MUCH superior level than Carey, the day Carey can sing 1% alike Callas did, world will end LOL!
[:
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
@LacrimaLunaMortua mariah should take lessons to use her voice at full potential,not to compete with anyone,just beacuse she can do more with her voice than what she actualy does,she must use all the potential of her vocal range.
apio9 1 month ago
@apio9 I'm not sure she's able to improve, I mean, If she hasn't along all her career, can she do it now? Whistle register is not a difficult technique, if you compare some of the notes Mariah sings with this register, you'll be surprised because opera singers sing it with modal register. Whistle register is not a "rich" register because all the qualities, skills, etc... are lost, sometimes even vibrato, what's horrible! Children also can use this register,so we could say it's really childish :D
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
@LacrimaLunaMortua well for example christina aguilera has over 13 years of career but started to go to singing classes just now,maybe mariah needs someone to help her to use her full vocal range,i don't think she has used all the potential of her voice yet
apio9 1 month ago
@apio9 Oh, yes, maybe you're right, but she has to hurry up d:
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
@LacrimaLunaMortua yes she has to hurry up,the problem with pop is that it's a music style that don't need great voices like mariah's,whitney's,celine's,christina's and so on,so they don't use the full potential of their voices singing pop music.
apio9 1 month ago
@apio9 hahaha Hell Yeah! In pop you only must have a sticking voice and to be visually attractive, how mediocre (I respect people who like this music anyway, I mean, my sister loves it /: lol )
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
Comment removed
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
Is Mariah able to sing, act and dance (sometimes) like opera singers? Like Dessay in 2:10? And I could keep on writing but I'm not going to end lol! Please, before you say Mariah is better than opera singers listen to Yma Sumac in Chuncho (with her WONDROUS AND OTHERWORDLY TRIPLE TRILL) and ask Mariah to try to sing like her at least 10% of the song LOL! She'd die trying it! And, please, NEVER DARE to compare her with La Divina, can Mariah at least sing 1% like her?
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
OMG, I can't believe there're persons who think that Mariah Carey sings better than an Opera singer LOOOL!! Has Mariah got at least 10% of technique than any opera singer? WHEN has an opera singer sung with A MICROPHONE?!!! LOL, please, don't make me laugh, an opera singer must be able to sing OVER A COMPLETE ORCHESTRA FULL OF DIFFERENT INSTRUMENTS AND CHOIR (SOMETIMES) SOUNDING ALL TOGETHER WITHOUT ANY DEVICE! Has Mariah ever sung more than 2 or 3 hours in a stage like MANY opera singers?
LacrimaLunaMortua 1 month ago
MARIAH IS NOTHING WITHOUT A MICROPHONE, AND ALSO SHE'S A SH*T BESIDE TO AN OPERA SINGER...
paulescence 2 months ago
I think its ironic how mariah was trained by her mother, who is a Opera singer. You can hear some operatic tones in her whistle. On some notes they sound very similar. The biggest difference is that opera singer do not use microphones, as their voice resonates over an entire auditorium. Mariah is still my queen though.
applmac2009 2 months ago
just to let everyone know, im not trolling mariah, just giving my honest opinion.
jfichter69 2 months ago
@MCLAMB4LIFE1 it isn't for opera singers are trained to reach these notes in full stratospheric modal explaining why they can fill audience halls without a microphone.. if they use whistle it would be too soft and sound quite bad however i know mariah can also do the same but she wants to keep her own style which is full of flageolet notes ..... so go Mariah and go Opera !!!
TheToffy8 2 months ago
oh my God i can't believe it. Mariah you the one..!!
You already!
TheAavin 2 months ago
maraih did NOT sing this. i am sure...
JayTj2 2 months ago
She Did the D-7!! none of this opera Bitches can do that!!
Ehadurkah 3 months ago
@Ehadurkah She did it in whistle and with a microphone. Opera singers are heard over the orchestra without microphones when they sing. Incidentally, this is an opera singer doing a C8: /watch?v=sPVrQ-wv-h8
jewelmarkess 3 months ago
@jewelmarkess Nice try hun but that was a C7. anyone with a Piano, tuner and Sense of pitch can tell you that. Adam Lopez is the only person person who has proved with a live vocal that he hit a C#8.
MCLAMB4LIFE1 3 months ago
Comment removed
jewelmarkess 3 months ago
@jewelmarkess Thanks for this link. I couldn't agree more with you here! Wispering in a whistle with a microphone is just a vocal trick! Many pop singers can just make fun like that using modern technology to help them...Svetlana Feodulova is a true opera singer, and she does it RIGHT!
serenaluce 3 months ago
@Ehadurkah Mamma mia, do you think that Mariah Carey with her having fun and just whistling with a microphone like jewelmarkess says sings it better than a REAL opera singer! LOL She is just a pop singer making a MUSICAL JOKE! Artists are not always serious! They also make PARODIES on other genres FOR FUN! LOL
serenaluce 3 months ago
holy shit.
i can only go up to c#6 and im alto/bass in choir
lionavids 3 months ago
There singer Mariah Carey to pass. Who knows one day her daughter is a phenomenon as is her mother or even more.
turboitalo 3 months ago in playlist Mais vídeos de MCLAMB4LIFE1
@t9993 Oh really! i will check that out!
MCLAMB4LIFE1 3 months ago
The C7 @4:23 SLAYED ALL THE OTHER ONES lol it's Mariah (1) vs Opera (dozens of opera ladies from all generations and decades)
DanielAvilaAGT 3 months ago
Mariah vs These Opera Singers..
this video just proves the versatility,The power and the range of the Queen Mariah Carey :))
GhenMariahyonce1995 3 months ago
AMAZING VIDEO !!!! you can tell that mariah has a opera backgroud (her mom) and im sure it helped her a lot with her range, amazing singers !!!!! :)
discorules2009 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hidalgo699@ her music is a big fail??? What? Are you sick? Or just didn't yet getting breakfast before you post such ignorant comment, Dont you know that MC is a BIG hit when speaking of MUSIC SUCCESS, she is the most outstanding music succesor according to WMA, with a 200 million record sold worldwide in just only 20 years! Fastest selling female artist according to IFRI. One of the biggest selling artist in history of music industry ever. First ever Chopard Diamond awardee by an artist.
rdmtjr 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dont you know that every single song from MC is a a record breaker? So how do you say that shit "One Sweet Day" become longest chart topper in billboard for 16 weeks, shit "All I Want For Christmas Is You" getting number 1 every year and the all time fevorite holliday song of all time, shit "Hero" most inspirational song and most overplayed song in radio, dont you know that MC has 18 number 1 hit that more than elvis presley,michael jackson,madonna or any single artist in the world.
rdmtjr 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hidalgo699@ you bullshit insecured jealous heater, what are trying to show off, your ignorant to carey's global success is so disgusting!...MC is THE BIGGEST SELLING RECORDING ARTIST OF THE NEW MELLENIUM, with an 18 NUMBER ONE HIT (most of any single artist) in the world, 17 WORLD MUSIC AWARD (most of any artist), 1 LIVING LEGEND AWARD , 1 ARTIST OF THE DECADE 90's, which only giving this every ten years. Just like michael jackson who became artist of the decade in 80's era.
rdmtjr 3 months ago
what is mariah's C6?
123buffylover 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@jfichter69 according to wikipedia, any note by an opera singer extend beyond high (F) F6 is considered a whistle register... Wikipedia is one of the most updated and accurate in any human knowlegde in our time today.
And if have douth, you must argue with them...
rdmtjr 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@jfichter69 in many amature singer that trying hard to enter the whistle register and because of lack of professionaly trained... They used it not in a proper way or wrong mechanism, that why they sound ugly as untuned violin, but when you trained hard by a professionals like adam lopez who says that he study hard to learn for 10 years just to use it in a proper way of singing, and mariah carey who mastered this technique for 30 years.
rdmtjr 3 months ago
mariah relies on whistle tones to hit the high notes. the opera singers use pure modal singing... much harder. whistle tones sound like screeching violin bows to my ears. check out Madasen McGrath ascend the scale to C7 4:04
opera singers WIN
jfichter69 3 months ago
@jfichter69 in this video they are using Head Voice it would be impossible to sing that high in Modal voice.
MCLAMB4LIFE1 3 months ago 6
@MCLAMB4LIFE1 well, it is possible to use the vocal chords around the ranges you showed us. however any higher, like C8+ would be impossible. and head voice? that just has to do with resonance :-) not the pitch itself. mariah carey uses head voice too. mariah can only go to c#6 using modal voice, after that, she relies on whistles. just listen for the different timbres of the opera singers vs mariah
jfichter69 3 months ago
@MCLAMB4LIFE1 that guy is a total dumb ass!!!LOL he should hae deleted his comment,SMH LMFAO
lathanregintree 2 months ago
@jfichter69 I completely disagree with Mariah Carey wins of anyone she has many vocal abilities mostly chest voice. Whistle is just one more talent she has.
turboitalo 3 months ago in playlist Mais vídeos de MCLAMB4LIFE1
@jfichter69 Mariah has way more agility in the whistle range than these opera singers do, they seem to be very tense and squeezing these whistles out. They don't seem comfortable in the whistle range like Mariah does
Jared95C 3 months ago
@Jared95C compare enra sack and mariah at 3:50. erna is hitting each note clearnly without having to glissando to and fro, unlike mariah, who seemingly blends each note together.
jfichter69 3 months ago
Respond to this video... i imagine as like shooting bullets out her mouth.
jfichter69 3 months ago
@jfichter69 I agree and the whistle register doesn't have any musical value to b honest... I still love Mariah's.
charmedone43 2 months ago
@charmedone43 i agree. mariah is a good singer, but in terms of technique, opera singers blow her out the water
jfichter69 2 months ago
@jfichter69 Oh, of course there's no doubt of it!! :) Each one is good in their own style, obviously classic is way beyond pop :) Happy Holidays btw!!
charmedone43 2 months ago
@jfichter69 I'd like to point out also that it is physically IMPOSSIBLE to sing to C7 in modal or even head register. Natalie Dessay pretty much takes the highest possible head notes in the human voice, and any higher is in the whistle REGISTER, but opera singers who access it tend to have a solid and crystalline sound. This is why some people tend to differentiate between whistle and super-head voices; they are in the same register of the voice, but have different placement and sound.
Wagnerlover777 2 months ago
@jfichter69 not modal, no one speaks like that... the only type of voices whose modal and singing voices are similar are the basses and baritones, all the other voices are "produced" never modal.
pedy19 2 months ago
@pedy19 A well trained singer or speaker can phonate two octaves or more within the modal register with consistent production, beauty of tone, dynamic variation, and vocal freedom.
jfichter69 2 months ago
@jfichter69 Still that is no modal regist. Modal means speaking regist, natural with no addition and it usually is chest voice, people don´t speak naturally in head voices, even sopranos don´t! their chest voice is higher, but still their modal voice is not head voice or anything of sorts
pedy19 2 months ago
@pedy19 if these opera singers were singing in whistle tones, then the crowd could not hear them as the whitles are lower in dynamics. they would need microphones for it to be heard. have you ever tried to whistle and a big room and fill it with sound? a singer has to use their chords to make a big sound like these women....
jfichter69 2 months ago
@jfichter69 Huh?! you´re mixing things lol i was talking only about modal voice and talking voice, regarding your statement "I'd like to point out also that it is physically IMPOSSIBLE to sing to C7 in modal or even head register" I was just saying that modal voice is the voice you use for talking.
pedy19 2 months ago
@pedy19 correct. it is used for talking and singing with maximum vocal tension. i think there is a mess up cause we are talking on comments lol hard to keep track of everything said
jfichter69 2 months ago
@jfichter69 loool no stress :p it´s alright. But yes operatic singers develop a specific technique, that differs from "pop" or contemporary one. :) comparing is futile it´s too different.
pedy19 2 months ago
@pedy19 i think they're both beautiful in their own ways, i was just giving my opinion since i thought the uploader was doing a competition.
jfichter69 2 months ago
@pedy19 my speaking voice sits in the high 4th to 5th ocatve naturaly so please check ur facts befor u speak :) and when i gett excited its jumps into the 6th octave ppl cringe at my speakign voice,LOL i hav eto force it down when i can.,
lathanregintree 2 months ago
@lathanregintree I´m sorry for not believing you. Modal voice is chest voice, therefore you won´t getting in the 5th octave, even when "Belting" people must mix a bit.
pedy19 2 months ago
@pedy19 my speakign voice sits in head voce register,lol i dont care if u believe me,LOL!!!! :''-D my voice when talking is proof enough it self u dumb ass,LMFAO!!!!!! #DISMISSED
lathanregintree 2 months ago
@lathanregintree Nop modal voice is a voice without any kind of production, a natural voice, although people might touch head voice in modal voice it does never "sit" there, unless you are a siren. No modal voice can get to the 6th octave, be realistic, you probably just scream a lot or then you swith to head / mix voice but then you no longer are in modal voice. You are dismissed sugar.
pedy19 2 months ago
@pedy19
Well Jackie evancho will outdo Mariah in 6 years, Her range,pitch and tone
exceeds her when she was 10 years old. Mariah was fortunate to trained by
her mother Patricia Carey ( Former Opera singer)
yomamajama777 2 months ago
@yomamajama777 We´ll see that, I wouldn´t trust that, Mariah´s tone is something unique, the diversity of textures, and the ease she sings /used to sing (mainly until early 97) is something impossible to top ( I believe)
pedy19 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@pedy19
Are there any videos of Mariah Carey at age 10?? See Jackie Evancho rendition of "Pie Jesu" live in AGT. Even though I believe Mariah started at 5 and had an advantage of her mother (Patricia) and opera singer training her.Her ability to sing seamlessly from the lower register to her effortless upper register would also be envied by many opera singers. Whats so unusual about Jackie is her thrilling,silvery upper register, which affects the central nervous system of her fans.
yomamajama777 2 months ago
@yomamajama777
Jackie is a voiceless little shit simply supported by a bunch of pedophiles with no knowledge of music. Compared to real singers she is worth less than nothing.
primohomme 2 days ago
@primohomme
yo mama
BITCH!
Where's Mariah video at age 10, Her mama is a former Opera singer!
Bitch!
yomamajama777 1 day ago
@yomamajama777
There are no videos of Mariah singing at age 10 because her mother is not a fame whore selling her own prepubescent daughter to make a quick buck, and because her mom took good care of her and her voice is why Mariah is one of the biggest selling female artists of all time and has more #1's than Elvis, and developed a 5 octave range.
primohomme 1 day ago
@pedy19 i said 4th t 5th octave,LOL not 6th octave ur trying to dimiss me but you can not even read,LMFAO im done with u but feel free to reply as i know u will b/c ur a sad ugly fag with no life who likes it up the arse,lol #DIMISSED #FAIL
lathanregintree 2 months ago
@lathanregintree loool honey you read your comment then. Second being a fag or not that´s my thing and someone as young as you should be instructed not to point that orientation at no one, but I see you are retarded and just a problematic girl who doesn´t deal with different opinions that well, too bad for you I say! Second let´s not start by talking about looks because I definitely look better than you.
pedy19 2 months ago
@lathanregintree
g3rl you can't sing worth shit, take a seat
primohomme 2 days ago
@primohomme bitch dont fucking step to me real fucking talk with ur dirty over used pussy ass and im a guy. u are nothing more then some shit talking online hoe,LOL u wouldnt even step to me off line so bitch learn ur place and keep ur mouth on a dick where is ment to stay at all time's -_-
lathanregintree 2 days ago
@lathanregintree
1- You are not a guy, you are a pre op tranny
2- I would tell you the same here, in person, on the phone, you name it...
3- The only one sucking dicks and sitting on dicks to pay for his sex change operation is you sweetie.
4- I listened to your song "Think of you" or whatever its fucking name was. You can't sing worth shit, it was OMG so off key! with a baby prostitute whisper and a low falsetto at the end, LMAO, pathetic.
5- You are obviously schizophrenic, how sad...
primohomme 2 days ago
@primohomme bitch u really are stupid,LOL first off i dont have a song called thinking of u 2. i am a guy,LOL its called a pretty boy which is a guy who has fem facial looks u dumb ass,LMFAO and as cute as i am i dont need a sex change,LOL girls like pretty boys which u wouldnt know of b/c ur just a ugly sad youtube person :''-D check my fb fan page u dirty pussy hoe. hoe u would never stop to me s big as i am i will crush u,XD
lathanregintree 2 days ago
@lathanregintree
Sweetheart, if by "girls" you mean 12 year olds? maybe...if by "girls" you mean WOMEN, absolutely not...Women don't like little bitch boys who look more femme than they do. You look like a transexual, and you probably are.
Oh and are you so ashamed of your shitty recording "Think of you" now? It's on arkmusicfactory and on soundcloud...you really can't sing worth shit baby, you are so off key it's laughable, so pathetic.
Have a seat, talentless schizophrenic tranny.
primohomme 1 day ago
@primohomme thansk for trying to ride my dick :-D but ull have to find another to spread ur dirty pussy STDS to,LOL :''''-D
lathanregintree 2 days ago
@lathanregintree I am sorry but I also listened to this song of yours.. and you are not a good singer, your voice was whisper thin and not in a Kylie Minogue good way. It was aggrivating,the falsetto you claim is whistle is about 2 octaves short of being in whistle range and was not stable. I do think there are better singers then Mariah.. but you are not one of them.Sorry.
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
Comment removed
lathanregintree 1 day ago
Comment removed
lathanregintree 1 day ago
@lathanregintree Also I see that you deleted your comments confirming it was you but I screenshotted those as well .. I predicted a cover up and you didn't dissapoint.
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lathanregintree Also I see that you deleted your comments confirming it was you but I screenshotted those as well .. I predicted a cover up and you didn't dissapoint.
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
@lathanregintree Soundcloud website under your name :/ Don't be fazed by all accounts .. But really if it's that hard for you to hold a b5 and it really sounds like you are struggling then why talk about you are better then Mariah Carey. I mean you are monotone up until the b5 ..and then the b5 is not good at all. How are you going to act like you are this great singer when your voice sounds like that?
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
Comment removed
lathanregintree 1 day ago
Comment removed
lathanregintree 1 day ago
@lathanregintree It isn't like i don't like you, I don't know you personally and you may be signed,So is Rebecca Black. But my point is.. You are so out of tune in that song.. I mean.. it's monotone then you hit that b5 which sounds like a kettle boiling btw,very strange. But you are claiming to be this great singer.. you have confused the fuck out of me that is for sure because you aint no Mariah Carey or even Xtina ..
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
@lathanregintree Your tired voice really? Most people would record it on another day if their voice is really that badly ..er 'tired'..
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
Comment removed
lathanregintree 1 day ago
@lathanregintree Well I don't like your singing because.. You kind of talk yourself up but then.. like that recording certainly didn't deliver and .. It was only a b5, how am I suppose to beleive you sing f7 like it says on your facebook account when you struggle to stay in tune on a b5.
Once again, I don't like dislike you as a person or whatever but your singing scares me more then nightmare on elm street.
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
Comment removed
lathanregintree 1 day ago
@lathanregintree Do I really need to give you a link when you can find it on google? Don't bother deleting it and pretending it isn't you either because I stole it with Audacity along with screenshots :/
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
Comment removed
lathanregintree 1 day ago
@primohomme He deleted all his comments to me, I screenshotted those too.. predictably removed evidense confirming that was his dreadful singing.
BrenTheGorgeous 1 day ago
@jfichter69 ur a complete idiot,LOL u know nothing about vocal's,XD
lathanregintree 2 months ago
Comment removed
jfichter69 3 months ago
Comment removed
jfichter69 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
not yet convince? Then listen the C7 whistle from her song "Your So Cold" at the biggining, or watch the live performance of "fly like a bird" at shelter home, and you all see,hear and feel the spirit of opera inspired to those technique of Mariah Carey.
rdmtjr 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@zucchini2007 you absolutely very right! Yes! Mariahs Mother (Patricia Hickey Carey) is a professional opera singer and a well trained vocal coach (in regiolettos) , she used to teach mariah since she was a 3 year old, since mariah was child, she always wanted to hit those highnotes not just from her mother but from her idol Minnie Riperton. Mariah has the opera technique... Dont yet convince? Then try listen the Bb6 note from her christian song "Fly Like A Bird".
rdmtjr 4 months ago
According to Wikipedia, Mariah's mom was an opera singer! Now you know where her magnificent voice comes from!
zucchini2007 4 months ago
G10-G12 highnotes cannot be heard by a human ears... So how do you say theres an opera sing 10 octave... Are you delutionally crazy... Must be hit low G0-G10 or G2-G12, FOR CLARRIFICATION... NO HUMAN BEING CAN HOLD EVEN IN 9TH OCTAVE BEYOND...MAYBE AN ALLIEN CAN DO THAT... The highest ever sang by an human is they G#8 by georgia brown...but that only F8 acording to analysis
rdmtjr 4 months ago
the highest... Ever sang by an opera is only D7 by mado robin... Mado lowest note is D3 extend To D7... And just only cheap 4 octave range... Also mado robin become guinness world record holder at her prime hitting the last D of the piano...
rdmtjr 4 months ago
@NilesMind , are you crazy or just naturally born idiot... Can you proof whos opera has 10 octave, ahahahaha, you made me laf so crazy , you know if an opera has 10 octave? Must be hit low G2 extend up to G12, in my entire my entire life , i never seen an opera hitting G12... Must be at guinness record if that happen... And not georgia brown than only has G2-F8.. Guinness holder has a 5.6 octave.
rdmtjr 4 months ago
i still go with mariah..her whistle is just too magical and beautiful..and its not hurting my ears.hahahaha
MrDjoleen 4 months ago 12
@jewelmarkess funny lots of singers are classically trained... That means they sang opera.
NilesMind 4 months ago
@rdmtjr actually it's called female whistle. It's actually common. And there are opera singers with twice her range. The largest range is 10 octaves.
NilesMind 4 months ago
what was mariah's C6?
123buffylover 4 months ago
After listening this video, specially Mariah Carey, I have a headache.
gonzaloponte2011 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Experts says Mariah Carey is the only human has a extraordinary vocal cords, her doctor says her voice box was designed different from the other one, and its affect thats why she can hold base range from the 2nd octave low E flat (Eb2) in other one she can reach not just stratospheric but ionospheric range extend beyond high "G" from the 7th octave to the 8th octave in all full control, her mother says she hear mariah also hit E8 extend beyond highest key of piano (C8) while doing warm up.
rdmtjr 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
So! Isnt Opera comparable to MARIAH CAREY the living legend, the songbird supreme, the hit maker, the queen of RnB, the queen of billbord, 2nd worlds richest female artist of all time and the biggest selling female recording artist of our mellenium.
rdmtjr 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Mariah Carey has a special vocal production that none any opera has. With the 5-6 octave vocal range that no body of opera has! Shes just out of this world! MTV and Blender Magazine said that she has the most beautiful voice and can mimic any note she can hear with perfect listening pitch! In fact shes the number one most beautiful voice in top 22 most beatiful voice in the world.
rdmtjr 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Experts says Mariah Carey is the only human has a extraordinary vocal cords, her doctor says her voice box was designed different from the other one, and its affect thats why she can hold base range from the 2nd octave low E flat (Eb2) in other one she can reach not just stratospheric but ionospheric range extend beyond high "G" from the 7th octave to the 8th octave in all full control, her mother says she hear mariah also hit E8 extend beyond highest key of piano (C8) while doing warm up.
rdmtjr 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
In European classical music, the WHISTLE REGISTER is used primarily by "operatic" coloratura sopranos. Many parts in the coloratura soprano repertoire extend beyond "high C" and often extend up to high F
(F6).Although many "operatic" coloratura
sopranos use whistle tone vocal production to sing these notes. Whistle Register is the most rare register by an human voice and the mastery of using this is MARIAH CAREY placing her as one of our the greatest singer today! Source: dictionary wiki
rdmtjr 4 months ago
What did you say? Whistle trick is a small trick? Well i need you to understand what is:The whistle register (also called the flageolet or flute register or whistle tone) is the highest register of the human voice, lying above the modal register and falsetto register. This register has a specific physiological
production that is different from the
other registers, and is so called because the timbre of the notes that are produced from this register is similar to that of a whistle.
rdmtjr 4 months ago
Comment removed
hidalgo699 3 months ago
@hidalgo699 who are you to say what is good or bad, mariah carey is one of the biggest selling artist in the world, if her music was shitty i dont think she would be that popular and loved....
discorules2009 3 months ago
@hidalgo699 hahaha!! ur a mess,lol not that i agree with ur opinion which u are free to have but do find u funny ^_^ no ill will intended
lathanregintree 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@killerbunny123123 ignorat who? Maybe you absolutely, opera isn't comparable to MC, question? is thre any opera who became succesfull and sold more than 200+ million record just like MC? Big NO! and speaking of highnotes, is there any opera hit staccatic swift with uplomb supersonic waves like E7-G#7 up to 8 octave and belt C5-A5 with melisma run? Another big NO! is there any operas can do ROCK,RnB,POP,JASS,MOTOWN,RAP etc. Like MC? Another again BIG NO! and last, isnt opera can stil popular
rdmtjr 4 months ago
Mariah killed it she looks like nothing when whistling and the opera singers u can see their necks force!! So I go with Mariah :))
luisboricua9 4 months ago
@luisboricua9 Apples and oranges. Opera singers sing without microphones in an opera theater sometimes with 4000 seats like the Met over the full orchestra, or did you miss this? You wouldn't hear Mariah Carey if you take her microphone away.
jewelmarkess 4 months ago
Mariah Carey Won.. Her Mom Was A Julliard Opera Singer.. Taught Her Everything.. Besides Mariah Can Do More With Her Register.. Like TALK!!!!!!!!!!!! Beat That..
plutoipresume 4 months ago
@plutoipresume Ok first of all this entire video is a mistake simply because you cant compare pop singing to opera singing; its like comparing a tomatoe to a watermellon! Still fruit but entirely different! Secondly, Mariah is a great inger but whistle register tricks barely count as "singing"...its more of vocalizing, AKA little voice tricks.
There's a difference between training and studying an entire life of singing (and also acting) in opera, and "pop singing". There's no compare in skill.
killerbunny123123 4 months ago
Difficult to judge though. Opera's singing is way more refined with strict accuracy. But Mariah is great here. She's got an airy tone in there which makes it sound sweet, mild and very interpersonal. Like when u hum "hmmmm~", u feel the ease and freedom. No one hums a clear-cut phrase, i think. So her voice really fits pop and R&B. This is what she is for.
PairJaNaJa 4 months ago
did someone put the kettle on???
geobruf123 4 months ago 9
They are different... Not a balance comparison since Mariah used mic and operas didn't. But both beautiful, although I prefer opera singers.
Luiloo1989 4 months ago
What was the song at 0:27?
xaver1011 4 months ago
these is so so so bias, mariah vs bunch of operas is a bias competing, but still mariah blow those ugly soundy opera shouters, opera cant belt but mariah does, opera cant hit 2nd octave but mariah can, mariah has 5 octave or more but opera has only short range, mariah can do stacatic swift E7-F7-G#7 or even 8 octave, that none anybody opera can! Intyende...
rdmtjr 4 months ago
@rdmtjr Ok, first off learn the difference between "can't and "don't because they shouldn't". No one in opera does her whistle tricks cos thats not even considered singing. The "shouty" sounds are much louder simply cos they do them in head voice, not just whistling. Anyone can use whistle register. How about trying to hit a high G#6 in full head voice? Now, THAT'S a real talent, which Natalie Dessay posseses almost alone in the singing world. About "staccati" try listening to more Dessay.
killerbunny123123 4 months ago
@killerbunny123123 Mado Robin and Erna Sack can sing higher notes than Dessay, in full head voice :)
truongphan90 4 months ago
@truongphan90 Well not all of their high notes and especially not the stratospheric high notes of Mado....and surely not the staccati of erna sack used in this video. And when they do not use uniquely their whistle register they use some sort of union between head and flageolet voice, commonly used by coloratura sopranos going above high C or, in Erna's and Mado's case, above high F.
killerbunny123123 4 months ago
mariah got destroyed, but still held up pretty good for a pop singer against opera
wushish 4 months ago
Was Mariah singing opera in the beggining, or she was dubbed?
RomuloVideos2 4 months ago
@RomuloVideos2 It was mimed for a movie! You can tell because its not her tone.
MCLAMB4LIFE1 4 months ago
Opera singers won this, obviously. But Mariah held her own.
Stefano94x 5 months ago
mariah sounds angelic clean soft peacefully beautifull...
Opera sounds very ugly loudy, although they not shouting but they realy sounds shouting... No melody of peace on their voice... Vibrato vibrato vibroto is sooo sooo sooo uglyyyy....
And i bet... I'm sure Most people and majority of peoply prefer MARIAH IS a better singer...
rdmtjr 5 months ago
MARIAH CAREY - Win
Why?
1. Sounds clean and soft/gentle to our ears
2. Effortless and full control
3. Versatility in any kind of music
4. Melodically beautifull
5. Can do vibrations even in 7 octave
6. Can do higher and lower than any opera singer from E2 base to G#7 dolphin register
7. Mariah vs. Bunch of Operas - but still unbeatable
8. Theres only one and only MARIAH CAREY
rdmtjr 5 months ago
Bunch of opera - Loose
Why?
1. Sad but true - they sounds totaly ugly
2. Opera is only in opera - no versatility
3. Loudy voice can make our ears erratating
4. Cant even pronounce words in high notes
5. Cant do vibration in 7th octave
6. They Sounds very ancient and they not suitable for today music and forever
7. Opera is many... They all similar and no uniqueness.
Those opera fan... I'm not intend to hurt your feeling but that true right... And accept it ok... No hurt feelings OK.
rdmtjr 5 months ago
@rdmtjr (comment #1) haha you are so ignorant.
1. they only sound ugly to people who are too stupid to comprehend their level (also depends on who the singer is)
2. "No versatility"? Opera is like the Olympics of voice. If you're trained enough for that, you can sing anything in the world, try Sarah Brightman, Pavarotti, or Renee flemming.
3. If the acoustic of the room is good your ears will not get "erratated"
4. The pronounciation reguards each singer, dont generalize (go to comment #2)
killerbunny123123 4 months ago
@killerbunny123123 Sarah Brightman is not an opera singer. I agree with the rest of your comment.
jewelmarkess 4 months ago
@jewelmarkess well she is a classical crossover singer, meaning she did have classic singing training.
killerbunny123123 4 months ago
@killerbunny123123 Yes, Sarah Brightman is indeed a classical crossover singer, true, but a) she didn't have that much a classical training as far as I know b) having classical training doesn't make one an opera singer. A lot of people have classical voice training - amateurs, pop singers, musical theater singers - classical training provides a good base for them. Even not all classical singers are opera singers, some perform solely chamber music in concerts but can't handle a full opera.
jewelmarkess 4 months ago