I have not scanned the article over at Scientific American. I says that "The vortex rotates around an axis that is perpendicular to the shower curtain." The ARD say its parallel to the water stream (and therefore parallel to the curtain).
Hm, the whole thing really seams to be not really well covered.
reading wikipedia, it seems that I hadn't understood the horizontal vortex theory to its fullest. Wikipedia reads that the vortex in itself has a lower pressure in the middle.
Theory 3 (the horizontal vortex theory, as listed by you in your video) as calculated by a computer model by David Schmidt from U Massachusetts: There is a air curl around the water stream. This circular air flow creates the Bernoulli effect.
(at least that's what the ARD Wissen Vor Acht tells us)
Theory 1 is false: Hot water rising up, making cold water come up from below the curtain. Proof: the effect occurs with cold water.
Theory 2 (=your theory) is false: The air is fast, so Bernoulli lowers the pressure. Proof: air speed would be considerably higher near the water. But one finds: It doesn't matter (as much as expected) how near the shower is to the curtain.
I have not scanned the article over at Scientific American. I says that "The vortex rotates around an axis that is perpendicular to the shower curtain." The ARD say its parallel to the water stream (and therefore parallel to the curtain).
Hm, the whole thing really seams to be not really well covered.
jhwashere 1 year ago
reading wikipedia, it seems that I hadn't understood the horizontal vortex theory to its fullest. Wikipedia reads that the vortex in itself has a lower pressure in the middle.
jhwashere 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Theory 3 (the horizontal vortex theory, as listed by you in your video) as calculated by a computer model by David Schmidt from U Massachusetts: There is a air curl around the water stream. This circular air flow creates the Bernoulli effect.
(at least that's what the ARD Wissen Vor Acht tells us)
Is this still an open question?
jhwashere 1 year ago
Comment removed
jhwashere 1 year ago
Comment removed
jhwashere 1 year ago
A German science show says the following:
Theory 1 is false: Hot water rising up, making cold water come up from below the curtain. Proof: the effect occurs with cold water.
Theory 2 (=your theory) is false: The air is fast, so Bernoulli lowers the pressure. Proof: air speed would be considerably higher near the water. But one finds: It doesn't matter (as much as expected) how near the shower is to the curtain.
jhwashere 1 year ago
Comment removed
jhwashere 1 year ago