im catholic, and i dont care if someone else is an athiest or not. i personally think you should believe what you want.
but i cant STAND when an athiest HAS to push me for what i believe, and not leave me alone, as i would them. the last athiest to do that to me ended up in a hospital with 3 broken fingers and a broken rib, cause he wouldnt leave me alone. i beat the fucking shit outa him.
on my personal standpoint, I don't know or even care about what happens after death. No one has come back from being dead to talk about it yet. Geography, race, culture, and language has divided the people of this planet already...Religion divided us even further. If there are people I feel sorry for, they would have to be religious fanatics trying to hammer their beliefs unto others.
I have a question. What happens to tiny little infants that die very early? If they go to heaven, do they remain this small? they can't walk or talk, just cry. Is that what they'll be doing in heaven? As a matter of fact what about unborn children that pro-life people are so against aborting. Natural miscarriages have a soul and go to heaven as well?
What rational person believes in god? I mean seriously! Do these questions not come up?
no, he was being overly dramatic. i mean, i'm sure there are some people who think that, but in general, we just think that when we die.. we die. and thats it.
This guys isn't even funny. George Carlin at least put his points in with great humor. This guy has no punchline, just drab complaining like an old woman.
Let me know the day Dan Cook starts spouting comedy. I like jokes against atheists if they are funny...gets us publicity. South Park did a far better skit on atheists than this low grade gutter comedian.
How can a person believe in the concept of God without question? Everyone's raised that way. The belief is spoonfed on the young and there you go, he becomes part of the religion. I don't know, the more I grow up, the more I start to peel away everything my Christian elders taught me until I got down to the basics and had an open mind.
Thus I learned that whatever happens to me... It's not their God's will, it's my doing.
I can see that he's not trying to prove something, but believing a religion doesn't make it correct. If we were picking relgions for the sake of rewards, I'd probably go muslim.
That part about gesundheit offends me when he says that he feels as if he is honouring hitler when he says gesundheit, wtf? not all germans are nazis and its hypocritical of him to portray athiests as intolerant when he is displaying intolerance himself.
God is only real for people who have great lives. Try telling all the human beings that are being tortured and killed in places such as Burma that God is real and that he loves them. He sure has a funny way of showing it. Either God isn't real or he just doesn't give a crap about certain folks, and he likes to play favorites.
I don't think so. When people are being killed, that is the Devil interfering. He is powerful and it does happen. God loves everyone and tries to help them no matter what. I'm sorry if I sound rude, that's just what I believe.
It's not as simple as it seems. The Devil was one of God's angels, until he rebelled against God, and caused orignal sin, which is why we have wars, murder, ect. God sent his son Jesus to die on the cross so when we sin, we may have forgiveness. In our own way, we have some power to kill the Devil, by not sinning, and helping others to do the same. The lesser souls that go to hell, the more go to Heaven and that helps God in His quest to defeat the Devil.
lol, no, sorry if I sounded strange, I probably did. The point I'm trying to make is 9 out of 10 reasons there are wars, etc. is because of free will that we have. God could've forced us to worship Him, but He gave us free will so we could make our own descisions, which is why there is sin. In the 1 out of 10 cases, like cancer, it can be an opportuniy for you to turn to God. I know my beliefs sound strange, but if you really think about it, it makes sense.
I don't really know the situation you're in, but what I do know is that God loves each and every one of us more than we will ever know. Sometimes we make mistakes, but God still loves us. When I was growing up I had a crisis happen in my family, but since I knew God loved and wanted the best for me, it helped me get through it, and it made me a better person. If you have any more questions about faith, feel free to ask me, I'd be glad to answer them. : )
OJD101, I had a crisis in my life too. The flying spaghetti monster (FSM) helped me get through it. FSM loves me and he probably loves you more. FSM loves everyone more than they will ever know. How do I know? Because I prayed to FSM during my crisis and I got through it. that's how I know.
sorry but no he really isnt. if you want to watch a comedian who actually IS funny then i sugggest george carlin,mitch hedburg,demitri martin. dane cook is only funny to losers who thrive on chuck norris jokes and stupid college kids.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm an atheist, but i don't care. he's funny. but i wanted to give him the super finger for making fun of my beliefs. that's NOT what goes down with atheists. we don't become trees. dane cook, you silly bitch
I tried the half thing...lmfao I got windex all over the drawing i was working on...Really...If you're reading this comment....Don't try to put it half-way...Really....It's a bad idea..."Bad shit happens to good ppl" *whispers* It's true Lmfao.
I'm an atheist and I didn't have time to get offended, this is the first time I've ever listened to Dane Cook and he spends WAY too much time rambling before getting to the damn joke.
Maybe I just don't know how to appreciate comedy. XD.
this was hilarious...i used to be atheist and i didnt think that. also why would people get so offended, hes talking about 1 guy not all atheists. calm down its just a damm joke.
"There is a god he created all of us the only one who is blinded are the unsaved and stillborn everything Darwin said is wrong and evolution has never been proven and nothing is evolving now and the bible is the best book' *inhale* 'nothing in even comes close to its accuracy and if you think god's judgment is bad the devil has worse in store for all unbelievers' ...No punctuation at all in that one."
i apercate your faith but sicence and religon can live together and mix of both gives a wider view of everything i beleve darwin is wright in some ways but they can never discont that god egsits
Dude if you say everything Darwin SAID is wrong then that means that you believe in Evolution. Becuase Darwin was a Christian and believed in creation ... the only reason evolution came about was because Darwin was very professional and wrote down ALL thought no matter what he truly thought of it.
i agree with arowinmeeye. religios people are so damn aggressive and oppressive. us athiests just wanna you know learn and teach and what not, and let you guys do what ever, but while holding our dignaty, and theists( religios people) have to be all like BELIEVE ME OR YOUR FUCKED FOREVER!!!!! dude, what the hell did we do to you that you havent done to us like 10 fold?
ok captian banana pants. this is obviously a dubbed video. not the original i dont think its possible to lip-sync an entire hour and a half stand up comedy show. its probably just a delay..
im atheist and im lmao
Ashdragon89 6 months ago
lol that last bit was my favorite.
jackoffday 7 months ago
Comment removed
Alkhemist10 11 months ago
i'm jewish and i am lmao
OnlyMe8712 3 years ago
im catholic, and i dont care if someone else is an athiest or not. i personally think you should believe what you want.
but i cant STAND when an athiest HAS to push me for what i believe, and not leave me alone, as i would them. the last athiest to do that to me ended up in a hospital with 3 broken fingers and a broken rib, cause he wouldnt leave me alone. i beat the fucking shit outa him.
hl2vshalo2 3 years ago
@hl2vshalo2 so much for turning the other cheek
BackTenAndFace 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
holy sh!t that's funny...!!... im atheist too, an wen he gets the bible printed on him, i will laugh so hard at that dam bible!!
myitchypwet 3 years ago
If you don't like Dane Cook, why are you posting in his videos?
TylerPayne 3 years ago 3
HA LOLZ
sparrowluv121 3 years ago
small shrub...ha.
donut207 3 years ago
That was funny,but I am an athiest and I don't believe in coming back as a poxy tree...maybe a small shrub, but a tree...thats just stupid.
daddyrizla 3 years ago
Yeah... That's the crazy part.
TylerPayne 3 years ago
i love the printing a bible on him part
OnlyMe8712 3 years ago
Print the Bible all over him!!
Qvessnessa 3 years ago 2
milk chocalatey cluster fucks lmao
Electro519 3 years ago
on my personal standpoint, I don't know or even care about what happens after death. No one has come back from being dead to talk about it yet. Geography, race, culture, and language has divided the people of this planet already...Religion divided us even further. If there are people I feel sorry for, they would have to be religious fanatics trying to hammer their beliefs unto others.
Slayton1978 3 years ago
he used to be funnier
MrFreeman420 3 years ago
LOL! U PRINT THE BIBLE ON HIM!
JPisHOT94 3 years ago
I have a question. What happens to tiny little infants that die very early? If they go to heaven, do they remain this small? they can't walk or talk, just cry. Is that what they'll be doing in heaven? As a matter of fact what about unborn children that pro-life people are so against aborting. Natural miscarriages have a soul and go to heaven as well?
What rational person believes in god? I mean seriously! Do these questions not come up?
dlite922 3 years ago
i am windextor!!!
lmfao! im athiest but i love dane cook.
gothicshadowangel 3 years ago
is that what you guys actually think? you will come back as a tree? just wondering not trying to be offensive
DwarfHunter28 3 years ago
no, he was being overly dramatic. i mean, i'm sure there are some people who think that, but in general, we just think that when we die.. we die. and thats it.
i0LOVE0pixar 3 years ago
dun dun dunnnnnnnnnn.... shun the non believer! Shhhhhhhhhhhhuuuunnn!! Shhhhhhhuuuuuuuuuuunn!!!
ExianProductions 3 years ago
dane cook isn't funny
piccmi90 3 years ago
This guys isn't even funny. George Carlin at least put his points in with great humor. This guy has no punchline, just drab complaining like an old woman.
animation3dfx 3 years ago
fuck you bitch your just pissed cause your a fuckin athiest and god hates you, suck a dick you comedy hating whore!
LomaV12 3 years ago
Yup....you sound like a Christian to me. Gonna face your Jebus with that mouth?...LOL
animation3dfx 3 years ago
Let me know the day Dan Cook starts spouting comedy. I like jokes against atheists if they are funny...gets us publicity. South Park did a far better skit on atheists than this low grade gutter comedian.
animation3dfx 3 years ago
yea but they mock god even worse
jv2451599 3 years ago
How can a person believe in the concept of God without question? Everyone's raised that way. The belief is spoonfed on the young and there you go, he becomes part of the religion. I don't know, the more I grow up, the more I start to peel away everything my Christian elders taught me until I got down to the basics and had an open mind.
Thus I learned that whatever happens to me... It's not their God's will, it's my doing.
Slayton1978 3 years ago
I can see that he's not trying to prove something, but believing a religion doesn't make it correct. If we were picking relgions for the sake of rewards, I'd probably go muslim.
ImTheKobold 3 years ago
Oh this guy is VERY Christian...Love thy brother...Turn the other cheek...
jaymzb1979 3 years ago
That part about gesundheit offends me when he says that he feels as if he is honouring hitler when he says gesundheit, wtf? not all germans are nazis and its hypocritical of him to portray athiests as intolerant when he is displaying intolerance himself.
tolchock1984 3 years ago
Yeah but thats the point...
most people think so...
Trickingenure 3 years ago
i'm not worried about him, i'm worried about the anal secretion applauding to this guy, what a bunch of losers.
jhonnyboy2050 3 years ago
God is only real for people who have great lives. Try telling all the human beings that are being tortured and killed in places such as Burma that God is real and that he loves them. He sure has a funny way of showing it. Either God isn't real or he just doesn't give a crap about certain folks, and he likes to play favorites.
Zeeboe 3 years ago
I don't think so. When people are being killed, that is the Devil interfering. He is powerful and it does happen. God loves everyone and tries to help them no matter what. I'm sorry if I sound rude, that's just what I believe.
OJD101Webshow 3 years ago
If God is so great, then why doesn't he just kill the Devil?
Zeeboe 3 years ago
It's not as simple as it seems. The Devil was one of God's angels, until he rebelled against God, and caused orignal sin, which is why we have wars, murder, ect. God sent his son Jesus to die on the cross so when we sin, we may have forgiveness. In our own way, we have some power to kill the Devil, by not sinning, and helping others to do the same. The lesser souls that go to hell, the more go to Heaven and that helps God in His quest to defeat the Devil.
OJD101Webshow 3 years ago
Do you read what you type? You actually believe that? It sounds like a fairy tale to me. Tell me, do you believe in hobbits too?
Zeeboe 3 years ago
lol, no, sorry if I sounded strange, I probably did. The point I'm trying to make is 9 out of 10 reasons there are wars, etc. is because of free will that we have. God could've forced us to worship Him, but He gave us free will so we could make our own descisions, which is why there is sin. In the 1 out of 10 cases, like cancer, it can be an opportuniy for you to turn to God. I know my beliefs sound strange, but if you really think about it, it makes sense.
OJD101Webshow 3 years ago
Not really, no. It sounds like a way to get people to obey the rules.
Zeeboe 3 years ago
To me it sounds like God wanting people to return to Him because God loves everyone more than they will ever know.
OJD101Webshow 3 years ago
Well, if God is real he doesn't love me. So I don't love him.
Zeeboe 3 years ago
I don't really know the situation you're in, but what I do know is that God loves each and every one of us more than we will ever know. Sometimes we make mistakes, but God still loves us. When I was growing up I had a crisis happen in my family, but since I knew God loved and wanted the best for me, it helped me get through it, and it made me a better person. If you have any more questions about faith, feel free to ask me, I'd be glad to answer them. : )
OJD101Webshow 3 years ago
Im tired of that same fairy tale :-)
jv2451599 3 years ago
What do you mean?
OJD101Webshow 3 years ago
lol Oh im just saying im tired of that fairy tale thats it.
jv2451599 3 years ago
OJD101, I had a crisis in my life too. The flying spaghetti monster (FSM) helped me get through it. FSM loves me and he probably loves you more. FSM loves everyone more than they will ever know. How do I know? Because I prayed to FSM during my crisis and I got through it. that's how I know.
Please! Use a brain cell or two!
dlite922 3 years ago
i'm atheist, and i don't really care if someone says "god bless you"
a person's religion is their own business and shouldn't really go around advertising it
Snowwolf444 3 years ago
am i the only who who googles "snarky"?
lol
iwreckriots 3 years ago
"I am Windextor, I will clean your soul." It was all funny, but for some reason that part just made me laugh unbelievably hard.
OJD101Webshow 3 years ago
Dane Cook is amazing!... enough said =)
rottgirl164 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
¡ʍoɥ sʎɐs ʇı lǝuuɐɥɔ ʎɯ ʇno ʞɔǝɥɔ ¿sıɥʇ op oʇ ʍoɥ ʍouʞ oʇ sʇuɐʍ oɥʍ
gamedude334 3 years ago
3:35 someone boos listen closely
thebigeasy87 3 years ago
What a dick.
IHvADD 3 years ago
kidding me this guy is halarios
chillen200 3 years ago
nuggety fuck lol
iceboy4511 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DANE COOK IS NOT FUCKING FUNNY!!!!!
DigitalBuddah13 3 years ago
yeah he is
koski786 3 years ago
sorry but no he really isnt. if you want to watch a comedian who actually IS funny then i sugggest george carlin,mitch hedburg,demitri martin. dane cook is only funny to losers who thrive on chuck norris jokes and stupid college kids.
DigitalBuddah13 3 years ago
praise dane cook fucking athiests
11spy 3 years ago 2
Come to my channel for fred, family guy, american dad, south park, SNL, and dane cook!
ScottyFilms 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mack3108
you're a dumb ass..
learn how to spell
atheist before you try to talk
about us.
only people who DO NOT think deeply
believe in god.
it's not real
williamsmorenike 3 years ago
fuck you athiest bitch
chillen200 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate when people get defensive about religion, atheiest for the win
mack3108 3 years ago
snarky on the Web:
sarcastic and irreverent, usually out of irritation
elvis92795 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he sucks hes not funny and all he does is steal stuff from other people
imnotheretobelittle 3 years ago
give me an example of something hes stollen.....and just so you know hes not a fav. comedian either (im not trying to be "snarky" im just curious.
sn2727 3 years ago
lol funny dude
loridori 3 years ago
once hes paper u print the bible on him LOL THIS DUDE IS AWSOME
gogohappy8 3 years ago 3
dane cook is praised by the lord for all his awesomness
Headbanger1226 3 years ago
the best part is the best
fish4lifeFTW 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm an atheist, but i don't care. he's funny. but i wanted to give him the super finger for making fun of my beliefs. that's NOT what goes down with atheists. we don't become trees. dane cook, you silly bitch
profotoswindseer 3 years ago
God rocks...peace be with you
loridori 3 years ago 9
@loridori and also with you :)
heromaly 3 months ago
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhh HILARIOUS!!!!!
I LOVE IT!
onepersontwoperson 3 years ago
lmao. he is pretty much the funniest guy ever :]
i laugh so hard at all of his videos!
chelsx3jonas 3 years ago
haha i bet that pissed off the athiests
unfortunesoull 3 years ago
hahahaha=D
XximapenguinxX 3 years ago
aha, Dane cook is a silly bitch XD
XvolcomXradXplaidX 3 years ago
over-rated
lookatyourself99 3 years ago
I tried the half thing...lmfao I got windex all over the drawing i was working on...Really...If you're reading this comment....Don't try to put it half-way...Really....It's a bad idea..."Bad shit happens to good ppl" *whispers* It's true Lmfao.
skittlesareme 3 years ago 3
ROFL!!!
Ohmygod. That was hilarous.
SinsNotTragedies95 3 years ago
I'm an atheist and I didn't have time to get offended, this is the first time I've ever listened to Dane Cook and he spends WAY too much time rambling before getting to the damn joke.
Maybe I just don't know how to appreciate comedy. XD.
DrowSwordsman 3 years ago
I agree, waaaaay too much development time before the reaches the damn punchline.
This is not a personal afront to any of you, but this is possibly the most boring comedian I've ever seen.
Dave Chappelle, there's a man who understands comedy!
yoakamae 3 years ago
thats the point
chillen200 3 years ago
I meant the guy that booed fucktard....
IHvADD 3 years ago
Painfully unfunny!
Weewawoowah 3 years ago
One of the most over-rated standup comedians in the past 3 decades, he's up there with Carlos Mencia.
simplelife88393 3 years ago 2
I put it half-way today and this was all I could think about...I really thought a ghost would come out...
diamehikoru2 3 years ago
i'm an atheist and i found this extremely funny
LMAO!!!!!!!! this shit was hilarious
metroidgus 3 years ago
Dude I'm an atheist too and it is funny! But it's atheists like the one in this joke that give other atheists bad names.
micha1293 3 years ago 3
yeah you're right man. people have to see that you can't group a whole bunch of people because of the actions of one person
metroidgus 3 years ago
haha
he turn towards me....
and he sneezes like this....
"PUHHHHHH!!!"
LOL
thats great!
ORlver 3 years ago
dopeycanadian2 im canadian too. where you from?
thekanadiankousin 3 years ago
So what,
it's comedy.
Don't take it personal...
Girl0mezelf 3 years ago 5
@Girl0mezelf amen bro. everyone has their own beliefs. im cathlic
Thedomonater234 7 months ago
this was hilarious...i used to be atheist and i didnt think that. also why would people get so offended, hes talking about 1 guy not all atheists. calm down its just a damm joke.
paula666egpk 3 years ago 2
lmfaoo im not that religious
nor am i atheist.
i do believe in god, dont read the bibile
this shit is HILARIOUS!
"and once hes paper, print the bible on him."
LOL
PshtChea 3 years ago 2
2. snarky A word that should be googled to find the definition as per direction from Dane Cook. It means short tempered or irritable.
"He was being very snarky with me. Yeah, snarky. Its a word, google it." -Dane Cook Yep...i googled it
cheyennehomie 3 years ago
Ha all these atheists are going "THIS IS NOT FUNNY CUZ HE MAKING FUN OF ME >:(" Big whoop.
DaGarebear 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow, eh... Not funny!
jhonnyboy2050 3 years ago
JOHNNY WEEPING WILLOW OVER HERE
ExXerMecH 3 years ago
Only people with down syndrome think this is funny, more than a visual insult this mother fucker is like a terrorist attack to the human pupil.
jhonnyboy2050 3 years ago
lol im athiest and i think this is halourios
dom1785 3 years ago 5
LOL Dane cook is awsome!!
ebspurlin02 3 years ago 2
ummm this was hilarious
soothuglifesmile 3 years ago 2
wooo athesits =]
boshankwa 3 years ago
Me and a bunch of friends did the windex thing xD
LifeDuxMuffinNuts 3 years ago
nice
IB0imbetter 3 years ago
oh man....you should video that shit!....that would be awesome.....
FlyingVurtical 3 years ago
"I WILL CLEAN YOUR SOUL MWAHAHAHA"
Hunteress90 3 years ago 3
I AM WINDEXTOR
LemonHohoLuvr 3 years ago 2
lol a ficus?
LMAOOOOOOO!
ORlver 3 years ago 2
cluster fuck= peanut and fuck
Soap688 3 years ago
windextor lol
deRegulater 3 years ago
snarky. lol
butters574 3 years ago
lol,when you die nothing happens
DarkSasuke15 3 years ago
full of peanuts and FUCK XD
ktluvaxx 3 years ago
that was so funny i almost pee my pants
nincompoopsofdeath 3 years ago
"There is a god he created all of us the only one who is blinded are the unsaved and stillborn everything Darwin said is wrong and evolution has never been proven and nothing is evolving now and the bible is the best book' *inhale* 'nothing in even comes close to its accuracy and if you think god's judgment is bad the devil has worse in store for all unbelievers' ...No punctuation at all in that one."
lol, Dan Cook's a retard
wckosara 3 years ago 5
i apercate your faith but sicence and religon can live together and mix of both gives a wider view of everything i beleve darwin is wright in some ways but they can never discont that god egsits
arrowinmeeye 3 years ago
wow, arrowinmeeye you need to work on your spelling.
Pwned1123 3 years ago
yer i know lol
arrowinmeeye 3 years ago
Dude if you say everything Darwin SAID is wrong then that means that you believe in Evolution. Becuase Darwin was a Christian and believed in creation ... the only reason evolution came about was because Darwin was very professional and wrote down ALL thought no matter what he truly thought of it.
Just throwing that out there.
CommyEli 3 years ago
eehh, i was being sarcastic by the way....
wckosara 3 years ago
kind of hard to be sarcastic over the internet, don't u think?
Sputnik1337 3 years ago
i believe in the theory of evolution
Sputnik1337 3 years ago
yeahh.. that Jim Carrey ripoff really is a retard.. Dane Crook
CausesSideEffects 3 years ago
i agree with arowinmeeye. religios people are so damn aggressive and oppressive. us athiests just wanna you know learn and teach and what not, and let you guys do what ever, but while holding our dignaty, and theists( religios people) have to be all like BELIEVE ME OR YOUR FUCKED FOREVER!!!!! dude, what the hell did we do to you that you havent done to us like 10 fold?
profotoswindseer 3 years ago
dont even pull the oppression card..but cause you already did i wont address that topic
my issue is you say all you wanna do is learn and teach
BY ALL FUCKING MEANS! TEACH! TILL YOUR HEARTS DESIRE! LEARN ALL THE LITERUATURE ON THE PLANET!
just dont come in my face talkin mess for what i believe
i aint done nothin to nobody
dumbcube69 3 years ago
I laughed so hard when the ghost came out
WINDEXTOR
evenj2 3 years ago 4
hahahaha..."snarky."
and no this is not a dubbed video, the audio is just behind [i know because i've watched this on television.]
xxCapricious 3 years ago
ok captian banana pants. this is obviously a dubbed video. not the original i dont think its possible to lip-sync an entire hour and a half stand up comedy show. its probably just a delay..
drunkinyoda 3 years ago
hes just cocked and PHUUUUHH!
DEBRIS CAME OUT! LMAOOOO
Bahahaha I am Windextor I will clean your soul! hahaha
buddyrocks88 3 years ago
this was awesome!!! but sometimes his mouth didnt move to his words...
captianbananapants 3 years ago 2
I love Dane Cook. He is sooo funny. lol :)
BreakingDawnLuver 3 years ago 2
bahahah! pound him down into paper and print the bible on him(x
GabsterGangster 3 years ago 3
"full of peanuts and FUCK.....nougety FUCK" rofl!
nukester 3 years ago 3
"Hahaha I Am Wendextor Hahaha I Will Clean Your Soul Hahaha!!" lmao you gotta love it
AshleyXa7x 3 years ago 3
he just cocked and PHUUUH!
XD
xeffjry 3 years ago 2
GOD BLESS YOU!
Twobit333 3 years ago 3
PRINT THE BIBLE ON HIM! XD he is so funny
Nickelbackrox104 3 years ago 6
dane cook rocks
MooosMin 3 years ago
that was a good robot
RiceThing01 3 years ago 2
What a waste. No one will read that bible. I guess that was the insult.
/s
omidood 3 years ago
johnny weeping williow over here!
I'M WINDEXOR ILL CLEAN YOUR SOUL!!!
deangirl626 3 years ago 2
Love this vid
LittleNuf3 3 years ago
HE SNEEZED...DEBRIS...MOVEMENT...
ReapressofDeath 3 years ago