Timeless-Live Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guarini

[mysteriousnumb]

korean? whatever!!!

I love Kelly and Justin!!! I love the Movie too!!!

[mendy22cris]

Q coisa linda a boca desse homem! Q sorriso e que voooooz! *.*

[luzyanglin]

Yes the male vocal in the korean version (Junsu) is better, but hard to top Kelly Clarkson. But overall, the korean version is better. These two sound like two different people singing and screaming their lungs out, rather than doing a duet, Justin's harmony is sometimes off.

[pexinhiuDBSK]

Korean ver with xiah junsu is way better

Always keep the faith! DB5sk

[mickey123cute]

Korean ver is more passion, but Kelly sang well too

[TheDbsk005]

As good as the korean version is,its no good as long as zhang can't sing live right?:/ and blieve me,i adore the korean version..

[melitomd05]

wow!!! jang Ri In y kelly clarkson son unas muy buenas cantantes.......me gusta ambas versiones!!......pero en cuanto a la voz del chico.....me quedo con la voz de junsu!!!!,,,, seria bonito si kelly y junsu cantaran esta cancion!! seria perfecta! =)

[sportsmaniac8007]

both versions are good, but i don't think any song can beat the originals, this was from their movie (From Justin to Kelly)... back in.... 2003

[MisrssJasperHale]

This version is soooo messed up

[unfeignedfaith]

No wonder why they made Kelly win because she can maintain her singing.

[unfeignedfaith]

Put Kelly & Junsu together = wowza!

[janelleness]

i prefer xiah's voice over justin guarini.

but as much as i love zhang li yin (i love kelly too >_< in fact very much), i prefer kelly's voice.

but if you compare both versions, korean is much better because junsu tries to adjust to the voice of zhang li yin. justin guarini, he never did that =|

[msanimeluver0926]

I like the Korean version better(:

BUT, this one is good too!

[phzluminous]

this is video is original! jang ri in and junsu is just cover in Korean version.

original is the best.

[aizatkutcher]

The Original song is from korea singer by Jang Ri In and Junsu...

Kelly n Justin just singing in enlish version hehe

[nsr150sp1]

@aizatkutcher idiot!

[melitomd05]

@aizatkutcher q si??....la cancion es original d jang ri in????

[arthurthethirdxxx]

@aizatkutcher r u dumb! this is the original...

[xCrazyxChantix]

wich version is the original

this one

or the one from Jang Ri In and Junsu ???

[Bask1989]

@xCrazyxChantix This one, its in Justin's album

[arthurthethirdxxx]

@xCrazyxChantix This one lol...

[angelinabbr]

wow ...que lindoooo, me encanta que haya tantas versiones de esta cancion ...pero en mi opinon Junsu canta mejor que este chico ...es que pobre como que sufrio mucho en las notas altas u.u

[ziumara1]

mmmm la verdad mucho mejor la version de Junsu -- me pone escalofrios escuchar la version koreana!!! mucho pero mucho mejor la de Junsu!!

[unidan82]

hahaha why is he wearing a skid mark shirt? interesting.

[YonjeeRingo]

I like both versions, okay people! The English is the orginal, and the songs have different textures because of the vocals. Cassies shouldn't bash and Kelly fans shouldn't bash either. Personally, I think that the best version would be Junchan with Kelly.

[FairyNT]

kellys voice is more powerful than zhang li yins, but i like the korean version with the sad mv and the vices of li yin and xiah much more.

[myboyone1]

Junsu's voice is just magical.i love his version much better.his soft voice and innocent image is so suitable for this song

[TheCrazedy]

get these kpop comments outta here! i personally like this version better. i think junsu's voice is too gentle and mild for such a passionate song. justin's voice is deeper

[erviniacarlos]

I feel bad that Justin Cracked his voice.... I guess it's too early for him to sing :-)

Anyway Love You Kelly!!!!

[shane1987ful]

Kelly...u r awesome

[Pemuciuse]

This was performed in the morning which both explains why Justin's voice breaks in the end and partly make up for it too. Have you ever heard a high-key singing artist perform in the early morning? There is a reason for why they normally put their performances in the evening when their voices are prepared and warmed-up. Justin did good to conceal some of those breaks but of course Kelly saved him. She is a real singing-queen!

[aeenz]

i want junsu and kelly duet too...

[JunsuYoochunJaejoong]

ok im confused..ive seen junsu and jang ri in sing this song, but who r these ppl and y r they singing their song? much better with xiah and jang ri in i hav 2 say.

[aeenz]

@JunsuYoochunJaejoong the english version is the original one...

[JunsuYoochunJaejoong]

@aeenz isnt it illigal to take someones song? did sm buy it? sry 4 being stupid..

[TheGeorge00001]

Lol their waving hi. HEY U LOSERS FOR NOT INVITING ME! F*** U

[random5587]

marvellous and amazing song

[amulik15]

best song

[Emerald214]

agree, Kelly sings live better than Ri In. That's true totally.

[YuneTube]

this song is just plain messy at the end.

[SuperMsTifa11]

Way better in korean!! -.-

And it doesn't interests me if kelly performed it first or not.

It's just better in korean

[SyafiqClarkson]

@SuperMsTifa11 I still prefer the original which is in english. But hey, everyone are entitled for their own opinion.

[LuluHeeNim]

it feels weird listening to this song in English version...korean is better

[thu9121]

Baby come close, let me tell you this In a whisper my heart says you know it too Maybe we both share a secret wish And you're feeling my love reaching out to you

[hpatdt2]

this virson is original?

[iheartwuchun]

@hpatdt2

composers of this song def. not Korean :)

[Oliviaparful]

i kept replayinq itt :)

[TaniLPA]

IT'S BETTER SINGED FOR XIAH IN KOREAN VERSION!

[Kimchi08]

who made this song first? kelly Clarkson ?? or Junsu and Zhang Li lin ??? IM really confused....... :(

[JKKN95]

@Kimchi08 I stand to be corrected, but I actually believe this song was first performed or "made" by Tina Arena & Kane Alexander. I reserve all rights to be wrong though.

[proud2bkcfan]

@Kimchi08 Kelly clarkson did. It's from the movie From Justin to Kelly

[100supernaturalfreak]

Whenever i hear this song either English or Korean i wanna cry and i get the chills <3

[zee606]

kelly clarkson is the only person can sing this song perfectly!! the korean version is well..lets say I don't like it...at ALL!!

[ilaremy07]

they r both great but i love the korean's mv

[josued09]

funny how justin looked so confident at the beginning, and when 3:09 came around it look like he wanted the song to be over. its just hard to do a duet with kelly, that girl just has a powerful voice.

[sweetypie2811]

they were do doing really well unti 3:00 then they both fell apart...but Kelly did kinda save it a little......but Justin u need some help

[jeff0301]

kelly, you're so talented, you're my idol.

[dbskey]

They lack chemistry.. Kelly atleast tried to make connection with the dude but he's like acting as if it's his solo stage or smth..

[YoutuBingMusic]

i like the original better just sayin but this is bad

[daysfan15yrs]

Love Kelly & Justin!! Wish they would have released this song as a single Promo for the movie. Awesome sons! They both have amazing voices

[Clausita26preciosa]

It would be nice if Junsu and Kelly sung this song

[Clausita26preciosa]

Kelly Clarkson is so talented... but still I love the korean version

[LPaige14]

They are both incredible singers.

[raycdaddy]

3:09 holy shit. justin, that was probably the worst voice crack ive ever heard in my life

[sexytrunks]

to woahwoahbitch!! you are stupid to say crap korean!!! you don't have a clue about Korean people, they have theyre own style in Breakdance and Singing and everything you want!!! Just because you didn't see theme on your stupid Television on MTV doesn't mean they are not even famous stupid asshole!!!!

Xiah Junsu his voice don't need power he sings with emotions and feelings. i hear to much screaming when Justin and Kelly sings this... my opinion sorry but like the both versions... peace out!!!

[k4g3m4n3]

this version is good but i still prefer the korean one... junsu and zhang li yin have more chemistry and passion when they sing. >.< 

[laloki5]

@k4g3m4n3 I think the same!

[RyoutaKai]

as much as i love this song, i love it a whole lot better in korean. just the way the music is revised makes it sound better then the harmony is definitely tighter in the korean version. justin and kelly did a great job and so junsu and zhang li yin

[Amara843]

they sound great but jason chen & jenny suk's cover of this song blows them outta the water. I like the korean version more too. love kelly though. =)

[fanfare78]

kelly sings way better than him

[woahwoahbitch]

nope justin is way better that the jin su guy, fuck him justin is singing wit powerful notes not like that crap korean crap

[jasdeviel]

Junsu + Kelly Clarkson would be the perfect combo for this song lololol Cuase Junsu blows Justin out the game, and Kelly well, she makes for Zhangs Li Yins weakness in singing live. I love this version too, but I think because of Junsu, the other version is betta lolol *Obviously a Xiah fangirl * lol.....Eh.... this is missing something... hmmmm Oh!!!

XIAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!­! <3 <3 <3

[locachicabell]

@jasdeviel umm excuse me she sounds awesome live .. (Junsu) What are you talking about ?!?!?!

[jasdeviel]

@locachicabell lolololol (Junsu) is a korean singer. Him and a girl called Zhang Li Yin sung the korean version of this song. And btw in cause your confused bout it too, I was talking about kelly clarkson, she sings well live and I meant that she makes up for Zhang Li weakness in singing live lol

[locachicabell]

@jasdeviel yea thats where i got confused about there names but i was talking about the girl Zhang Li Yin ... she sounds awesome live !

[DBSKforeveras5]

Korean version beats original version. It has more feeling and they sing it better live. Even the harmony is better between Junsu and Zhang Li Yin. She has a fantastic voice too! Just like Kelly, but both singers are better in the Korean version, sorry! >.<

[yuazchan]

Junsu is more better i think,, the girL is powerfuLL waaaaw Zhang Li Yin aLso great for this :D

but i prefer Junsu-Zhang Liyin

[roxanaphantom]

as much as i love kelly let me say that xiah and jiang ri sint this waaaaaayyyy better

[lionclaw77]

K-pop fans are always so hardcore with their opinions and I'm saying this as an american who happens to enjoy k-pop a lot. This preformance may not be the best but the recored version is better than Zhang Li Yin's and Xiah. Both couples are good singers but the emotion of the original is hard to put into words.

[Eunhae161]

@lionclaw77 HELL YEAHH WE HARDCOREEEEEE! Hahhaa

[musicguy713]

YES a live performance of this song! Kelly nailed the F5!

[joongielover]

junsu ftw

[nadroky]

no offense, but i do agree that Junsu sings better than Justin...

buh both Kelly and Zhang r amazing!!!!

so i like both versions, buh i'm biased more towards the Korean one!

[fujimulia]

Prefer English version....

Korean? nah....

[TheKaineHill]

A pretty good version of this song is the one of Kim JunSu and Jang Ri In!

You just have to watch that! There are even more emotion in it than in this one, I think ^^ But I like this one as well.

[BeBo0o1000]

آحب هالاغنيه كثثثير

[withnyforever]

kelly rocks !!!!!!!!!!!! I love her !!!!!!!! but the guy! naaaa

I prefer the korean version is more emotional!

[BlueDubuJJang9]

I agree about Junsu.. and, in fact, I prefer the kvers., but damn, Kelly clarkson is good! And I'm not even her fan xD LiYin was not good when she sang this song, though she sings awesomely well now.

[jtaustindog]

who originally made htis song?

[Aqua1Dakemura]

@jtaustindog The english version by Kelly Clarkson and Justin is the original. I hope that helps.

[JunMaine19]

korean version is way BETTER for me..!! i meann.. Junsu and zhang li yin gave meaning to the song (although i dont know what they were saying coz its korean) .. korean version got the emotion and...

IT'S JUST KOREAN version for me! :))

but im singing this song with this lyrics!! hahha.. lol :p

wait may i ask? WHAT'S THE ORIGINAL ONE?? KOREAN or THIS?^^

[Aqua1Dakemura]

@JunMaine19 This is the original version. C: The Korean version was made after this song was released with different lyrics.

[JunMaine19]

@Aqua1Dakemura ohhh.. ok ok .. thanks!

[shocksterette]

so is this the english version of zhang li yin and junsu's Timeless or is that the korean version of this?which one's the original?

[seanievortex]

@shocksterette Kelly's version is the original one. She makes the song awesome. The other guy almost spoiled it :D

[desireepy]

Kelly is awesome

[phoungdeleon]

original is still the best!

[enggot08]

kelly sings properly in this song... her voice doesn't sound broke or something static...

[GroficaOdMetropole]

Wish someone would make remix with Junsu and Kelly,that would kick ass!

[christillocovers]

kelly has more control over her vocals when it comes live...

watch zhangliyin.. live and see if it sounds better

[scralm06]

I personally think that the Korean version is way better than the American (even though I'm a fan of Kelly). Both Zhang Li Yin and Xiah Junsu have soothing voice's that makes me feel the meaning of the song and I just can't stop listening to it! haha ^^

[choooerer]

oh so there r only korean around here? i admit that korean version is good but claerly not better. btw i'm asian. not korean and no bias.

[petitechatte07]

the TIMELESS Korean song is better..

[maritaferreyra]

Me gustaria tener la traducion en castellano, es hermosa la melodia.

[issyking1]

i agree, zhanliyin and junsu version its much better, i love junsu´s voice and liyin its a great singer

[JinuGirL]

lol this song was so popular in korea because the song featured one of the most popular idols there. he has an AMAZING voice,too

[lychandesu214]

hmmm~ OMG! noooo~ the korean version is much better~ <3 no offense...~

[envyonfire]

I think this song fits Koreans taste more then Americans, that's why it was more popular in korea instead (:

[digiworld1989]

damn kpop fans can you bitches get the fuck off all these videos? tired of you bitches saying korean version is better if you think the shit is better dont come here on this video to comment about it. thanks have a nice day. yes i am a kpop fan but i am not a dumb ass

[lionclaw77]

@digiworld1989

Lol. I agree with everything you just said.

[FarewelI]

Zhang Liyin sings it so much better than Kelly Clarkson.. No offense but Kelly's voice just gets annoyin over time loal

[bolkie15]

Ohh OOhh Justin made his voice chap in 3:09-3:10 he revive the song but he cant practice perfectly before he sing this song...

[bolkie15]

and the part 3:27

[radics6801]

nagyon jó szerelmes szám

[Veronoona]

XIah Junsu sing this song much better!!!  Justin sucks..!!!!

[BABYFAYYYCE]

love to hear junsu singing it..

[luvyenz]

more love the koreans version. Xiah Junsu's voice more touching

[Pattifish]

The most gorgeous, breathtaking, passionate song, ever.

[AlphonseCel]

Oh mai gosh that Justin Guarini totally ruined this performance. I have no idea how he got 43% of the votes on American Idol in the finale. He's WAY worse than even the recent Idol contestants...pfft.

[dbskfightting]

xiah junsu sing this song is better

[TheLeejineui]

kelly and junsu!!! yay!! please!!

[loveyousallu]

i don't know why but i prefer the korean guy voice than justin "don't know his name" but the girls both are great

[yili9]

his voice is anoying no offence junsu's so much better

[kimrrivera]

I don't know why but I think Justin sucks live.

[annxiong]

Dear fans of Junsu & Jang Ri,

Please stop spamming this damn video. Thanks. Bye.

[The4Romantics]

Beautiful Duet by Kelly & Justin....

Bob&Robby

[soldierx2051]

you people are silly, yea junsu is good, in his own freaking language O.o, if he tried to sing in english like justin considering its not his first language it would sound horrible and flat and blah blah haha, trust me junsu is an awesome singer but there again ***In his OWN language***, ever heard its easier to sing in different languages and the ability of a persons voice can sound better in almost any other language learnable as aposed to english singing, its harder to sound good in english

[zallx]

@soldierx2051 Actually he can sing perfectly fine in japanese too, considering that thats not his first language either :P

[jussmittin]

@soldierx2051 wut does singing in english or singing in another language has to do with anything. if a person is a good singer then they're a good singer. so ur sayin that if justin sang in korean he wuld totally own junsu cuz he sounds ok in english? ur logic doesnt sound rite.

[soldierx2051]

@jussmittin My logic doesnt sound right to you because you probably not musically inclined like I am, and I didnt say if Justin sang better in Korean he would sound better, just ment like I dont know or speak spanish but i can sing it wel, just saying as english is considered the hardest language to learn, singing in english and it not being your first language it would sound odd, so junsu sings good in his language , and justin sings better than junsu in his language. easy concept

[jussmittin]

@soldierx2051 wel i cnt sing for crap n either english or spanish or ne other language. if u compare the two singers dnt think bout the language cuz at the end of the day it rly dont matter. there r ppl out there that speak a different language nd cn blow alot of english speakers out of the water. if u think Justin sings better than that's one thing (evn tho i dnt think so) but to think its has a lot based on language i beg to differ. btw im very musically inclined.

[bananatea]

@soldierx2051 he can sing in english,jap and korean fyi. and pretty damn well doing it.

[tomcaat1]

don't know anything about the rest of their music, but they definitely bring it with some serious talent here....starting around 3:34 justin just about goes a bit flat... but recovers professionally , check out the look he gives kelly at the end... whew!

great job kiddos!

[gosipgrl515]

korean is better. cuz junsu has a voice and talent that no one can copy. same with jang ri. this is good, but i think that Junsu would also do well if his english was really good. junsu and kelly dont match ppl. sorry, i dont think that way. unless u mean a duet for both, i disagree a linking of love

[epicWINlol]

I'm sorry, and no offense to Kelly's or Justin's fans, but Junsu and Jang just own this song <3

[annxiong]

@epicWINlol Umm. There's a reason Kelly won AI.

[jjangchoo]

is it just me or does kelly clarkson's voice sound sorta disconnecting... like it skips cuz she runs our of breath

[KiidCatherineTM]

English Version; Kelly Is Better Than The Dude.

Korean Version; The Guy Is Better Than The Lady.

They Should Really Sing Together;

Korean Guy&Kelly Clarkson! :)

<3

[toothylove]

@KiidCatherineTM the korean guy's name is Junsu

[gosipgrl515]

@KiidCatherineTM the korean guy is xiah junsu. isnt he awesum? i luv him!

[nicole9726]

@KiidCatherineTM totally agree~~~ I feel the same.

[Veronoona]

@KiidCatherineTM The name of the "Korean boy" is XIAH JUNSU...u_u

[nickjonasbigfan]

@KiidCatherineTM The "Korean Guy' name is Kim Junsu. :3

[Clausita26preciosa]

@KiidCatherineTM xiah junsu!!!

[widyafilan]

@KiidCatherineTM yes yes yes! and the Korean guy is Xiah Junsu! lol

[LiMona7]

@KiidCatherineTM his name is xiah junsu :)

and i totally agree with you ^^

[jocel031]

nice voice...

[sourpatch22]

now we know why kelly won instead of justin :)

[Milkaricias]

noooooooooo......noooooooooooo­ooo...noooooooooooo.....JUNSU.­..canta muchisimo mejor que este rulitos!!!! aunque kelly canta lindo pero...noooooooooo...noooooooo­oooo.......... yo opino!!! que debe haber un cambio!! Xiah y Kelly y la chinita con el rulitos.....JUNSU FIGHTING!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[bluesoul889]

the koran version that zhang li yin sung is not bad either . . .

[Tsua12ve]

Are you kidding...Justin sounds great and so does Kelly. They may have been upset with each other as this song should be sang close together - but they sure stayed apart.  Check out Justin's other music and you will see he sings rings around this other guy you're mentioning. Looks like the Koreans responding on this post may be a little racist towards anyone not Korean. Stay real.

[AmeliaLA136]

the guy aint that good

[itversion]

oh my gosh ,who sang timeless song??whre xiah n my sister.haha

[ihya13]

Oh man Justin messed up..I rlly love this song

[awwnism]

This feels a bit emotionless compared to the Korean version. And even though Kelly Clarkson is great singer you can't compare her and Zhang Li Yin. We all know who has better voice. And i'm not going to say anything about that Justin. Junsu can sing like million times better. No offence but this was kinda bad... xD

[Tanishaluvzmumbai]

I like the version in the movie better so studio version is better n hwayobi version

[see2045]

OMG!!!! justin is horrible!

[bwittwins]

the koreans made this song popular

[yhc91]

@bwittwins so true

[shinthiaH]

@bwittwins um...sry but i don't think it did.....this song was pretty popular wen it came out in the movie nd it was playing in the radio....but i DO admit the korean version is just as good....Kelly's voice has more range nd strength (i've been singing for 10 years) while jang ri in's has this soft, subtle power.... both versions have totally different textures

[DarkVampireHime]

@bwittwins absolutely,,, alot of people know this song exist cuz of the korean ver. ,,, including me XD

[xiaouyen2412]

i like xiah li yin version better

[ysmoco]

Well.I Fell well.

[vietmauzzzy1]

uhm...that was bad....

[Ettawen]

I like the Jang Ri freat. Kim Junsu one better, they seem to have more emotion while singing it then these two.

[Pink3Cello]

omg no offense, but junsu sings a thousand times better than this guy. junsu owns every song he sings

[iiitsfuckinme]

@Pink3Cello no.

[Pink3Cello]

@iiitsfuckinme watcha mean no? cant except the fact or sumthin? lol

[princessworlds]

@Pink3Cello yess!!!! really, junsu is better than justin. love this song in korean version, the original version.. no offence too, but korean version is the best...

[Pink3Cello]

@princessworlds i kno ryt! the only reason y i listen to this song is because my susu sings it lol

[FullofAwesomeness101]

Justin is usually better than that....he was obviously just having vocal troubles that day...Kelly didn't even sound as amazing as usual

[TripleSargentina]

Prefiero la version de Junsu y Zhang Ri =)

Cual es la version original de este tema? la coreana o esta?

[sharonfarts]

@TripleSargentina La version original fue cantado por Justin y Kelly en el año 2003. Yo creo que Zhang Ri-In la cantó por 2007.

[yonglaihuang]

justin sucked so bad here

[KRISTIE827]

Justin sucks!!

[Mahotisa]

ahhhh ahi deberia estar junsu

3:12 - my god, Justin, that was NOT a good