Donna performed wonderfully live. Lets remember that Donna is also 62 years old. Not need to make comparisions. Many singers can't carry a song in a paper bag at her age.
People people stop fighting, let's put this pointless argument to rest. Karen Carpenter's version is was and will always be the definitive best. , period. The fact that Donna's voice is flat and sharp on some notes immediately takes her out of even hoping to compete with the great Karen Carpenter along with a host of other reasons that make this nice polite attempt nothng more than exactly that.
@responsemedia ya have to remember of the age ..........if these ladies were the same age ......and by listening to donna's redistion..........there would be no contest ......62 being compared to a 20 sumin year old is just dumb....Donna Wins!!
These types of arguments are pointless. It's one of the great pop songs of all time. Both ladies sing it beautifully. Just chill out and enjoy one of the most amazing tunes ever penned.
Karen Carpenter live - Groupie, Superstar. and keep in mind this is even when KC was battling the disease that took her life,no comparison between these at all !!!
donna can sing, but her voice lacks the magic of karen's. and karen sings this song with a darkness and a sadness that can't be matched. as one poster on youtube once said, "karen had a teardrop in her voice." just lovely. i'm glad that donna is covering a carps song, but this song really does belong to karen, just as "rainy days and mondays," "for all we know," "yesterday once more," "goodbye to love," and many other melancholy songs do.
@siciliansummer listen to Karen Carpenter on this song live and then tell me is donna is anywhere near what Karen's version was with limited resouces she had to use in concert and not the Hollywood bowl.
get over youself already...you prefer karen's version and others prefer donna's version. "limited resources" is that because she is dead? i mean seriously, you are acting like a 10 year old.
@pinayho u MAD?? Sure sound like it lolol. Sorry truth hurts.Limited resources cause her song was 35 yrs ago without the equipment of today or the hollywood bowl symphony.
@valkour22 You're really ignorant and make no sense. True talent doesn't need high tech equipment and there isn't any on display here. Why don't you go starve to death?
"We could learn a lot from crayons; some are sharp, some are pretty, some are dull, while others bright, some have weird names, but they all have learned to live together in the same box." DoNNa SuMMeR
Thank You Donna, Beautiful job as usual. WHAT A VOICE! Now all I need to hear her sing is "Neither One Of Us" (wants to be the first to say goodbye). Thanks for posting!!!
Donna performed wonderfully live. Lets remember that Donna is also 62 years old. Not need to make comparisions. Many singers can't carry a song in a paper bag at her age.
david61accord 9 months ago
People people stop fighting, let's put this pointless argument to rest. Karen Carpenter's version is was and will always be the definitive best. , period. The fact that Donna's voice is flat and sharp on some notes immediately takes her out of even hoping to compete with the great Karen Carpenter along with a host of other reasons that make this nice polite attempt nothng more than exactly that.
responsemedia 11 months ago
@responsemedia ya have to remember of the age ..........if these ladies were the same age ......and by listening to donna's redistion..........there would be no contest ......62 being compared to a 20 sumin year old is just dumb....Donna Wins!!
zanna90 6 months ago
These types of arguments are pointless. It's one of the great pop songs of all time. Both ladies sing it beautifully. Just chill out and enjoy one of the most amazing tunes ever penned.
raelraven2 1 year ago
Karen Carpenter live - Groupie, Superstar. and keep in mind this is even when KC was battling the disease that took her life,no comparison between these at all !!!
valkour22 1 year ago
donna can sing, but her voice lacks the magic of karen's. and karen sings this song with a darkness and a sadness that can't be matched. as one poster on youtube once said, "karen had a teardrop in her voice." just lovely. i'm glad that donna is covering a carps song, but this song really does belong to karen, just as "rainy days and mondays," "for all we know," "yesterday once more," "goodbye to love," and many other melancholy songs do.
No1KCfan6 1 year ago
She definitely improved the original.
siciliansummer 1 year ago
@siciliansummer your kidding right? Karen will always owe this song,you cant in no way compare this to Karen's
valkour22 1 year ago
@valkour22 In my opinion, this is much better.
siciliansummer 1 year ago 2
@siciliansummer listen to Karen Carpenter on this song live and then tell me is donna is anywhere near what Karen's version was with limited resouces she had to use in concert and not the Hollywood bowl.
valkour22 1 year ago
@valkour22
get over youself already...you prefer karen's version and others prefer donna's version. "limited resources" is that because she is dead? i mean seriously, you are acting like a 10 year old.
pinayho 1 year ago
@pinayho u MAD?? Sure sound like it lolol. Sorry truth hurts.Limited resources cause her song was 35 yrs ago without the equipment of today or the hollywood bowl symphony.
valkour22 1 year ago
@valkour22 You're really ignorant and make no sense. True talent doesn't need high tech equipment and there isn't any on display here. Why don't you go starve to death?
pinayho 1 year ago
@pinayho sry u mad
valkour22 1 year ago
@valkour22 thumbs up
jonkr385 1 year ago
If you like "Superstar" by Karen Carpenter, here's Donna Summer singing it with Richard Carpenter back in June..love Youtube for these clips.!
edells1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"We could learn a lot from crayons; some are sharp, some are pretty, some are dull, while others bright, some have weird names, but they all have learned to live together in the same box." DoNNa SuMMeR
ДОННОЙ САММЕР
ドナ・サマー
欧美女歌手
ดอนนา ซัมเมอร
์ Дона Самер
THE QuEEN oF DiVaS
zetvierzehn 1 year ago
I know I should have gone now.
mrrandy1 1 year ago
Thank you for posting this video and for the phenomenal camera work!
ebomze 1 year ago
Thank You Donna, Beautiful job as usual. WHAT A VOICE! Now all I need to hear her sing is "Neither One Of Us" (wants to be the first to say goodbye). Thanks for posting!!!
bhonda3 1 year ago
Donna is so much better than Karen...
viabergamo 1 year ago
@viabergamo What? Put down the crack pipe.
JP5466 1 year ago
@JP5466 you need to put yours down first.
siciliansummer 1 year ago 2
@viabergamo karen will never be matched ever!!!!
liljon71 1 year ago
@liljon71 thumbs up
jonkr385 1 year ago
Her voice is in good shape. Still, it makes you long for Karen and wonder if she would be revered now for the singer she was.
Branner 1 year ago
This is awesome. Donna's voice is so beautifully powerful after all these years!
liveandmore 1 year ago
no esta este video de mas cerca es precioso
DONASAMER 1 year ago