Nope, sorry Patty, courageous attempt but Waits owns this one in every respect. But if you like to sing it, by all means do so. The sound quality here doesn't help, though. As for going off key, the original hits bum notes often, but it never seems to matter with him.
"I will leave behind all of my clothes I wore when I was with you" - the way this line is written & sung gets me every time. BTW - I love Tom Waits, this is a good version but Toms is another world.
I have seen Patty Griffin 3x. Her voice makes me think of the angels who will be singing if I ever make it through the gates of Heaven. Thanks for the post , I'm in love with Patty Griffin.
Thanks so much for posting Patty's beautiful cover and allowing me and others to discover it. Her voice always touches me, but she really connects with this one. Great showcase for a phenomenal talent!
Tom Waits is a great performer, this song is his and yes, Patty brought he own strength to it but, Tom Waits' tears your heart out through his own when he sings it.
Unbelievable...you all need to get off the Tom Waits high horse and realize good music and talent and raw emotion like this...Yes, Tom Waits is AMAzing, but you must let people interpret others music how they feel it...I think Patty Griffin is one of the best artists who knows how to capture emotion out there. This is an amazing cover!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Not a good cover at all. Tom Waits is the only human creature capable of singing this song as it should be heard . If you are looking for pretty , look elsewhere , Toms an angel but he's never gonna sound like one there's more to his songs than the sadness and the beauty . there is truth and you can't cover that , ever .
Omg! Who killed Tom...?
matseman46 1 month ago
Amazing cover of a great song. One of the rare times when the cover is as good or better than the original.
wetredstain 2 months ago
Her naturally sad voice makes this just heartbreaking...such a beautiful version
BGirlJessi 3 months ago
Nope, sorry Patty, courageous attempt but Waits owns this one in every respect. But if you like to sing it, by all means do so. The sound quality here doesn't help, though. As for going off key, the original hits bum notes often, but it never seems to matter with him.
EwolDJ 7 months ago
@EwolDJ Of course it didn't matter with him, what he does is barely singing. He's a great song writer, don't get me wrong but he is a crappy "singer"
BadFluffy 6 months ago
The only decent cover of this song to date. My favourite Waits song.
Toedoog 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
MillieMoomin 1 year ago
They need to leave this song to it's creator, Tom Waits....No one else can put the emotion in it. She even went off key a few times.
benkit49 1 year ago
Song makes me cry, her version or his.
wheatonna 1 year ago
@wheatonna me too.
jimmymcclukcluk 1 year ago
Oh ! not good
HomesOfShimizu 1 year ago
Patty is one of my favorite singers of all times - she does a fantastic version of this song .
doogleandalix 1 year ago 2
I agree Pattyfan. I love Tom Waits version but I think Patty's is just as good and is just as emotional!
nikkitrueblue 1 year ago
fantastic version! she got me into Tom Waits!
Trsh3r 1 year ago
I'm a fan of NANCI GRIFFITH's version as well.
thrillkillkub 2 years ago
"I will leave behind all of my clothes I wore when I was with you" - the way this line is written & sung gets me every time. BTW - I love Tom Waits, this is a good version but Toms is another world.
MillieMoomin 2 years ago 3
Tom Waits can write the most beautiful, heartbreaking songs and then hide them in quirky musical instruments and a tuberculosis sounding voice.
gmartinz01 2 years ago 7
Pain, sorrow, and regret are not pretty. Waits' voice is perfectly suited to the emotions he expresses.
asy4 1 year ago
My first song I heard Patty Griffin sang. It is so emotional...
wojciechurban 2 years ago
Потрясающе !
Gracefully !
billysbandcom 2 years ago
does anyone have this song as an mp3?
Sweavers 3 years ago
yeah i do but tom waits version and i couldnt get it for another month...
warterquarter 2 years ago
I have seen Patty Griffin 3x. Her voice makes me think of the angels who will be singing if I ever make it through the gates of Heaven. Thanks for the post , I'm in love with Patty Griffin.
freetickeys 3 years ago
Thanks so much for posting Patty's beautiful cover and allowing me and others to discover it. Her voice always touches me, but she really connects with this one. Great showcase for a phenomenal talent!
jeffvinthewc 3 years ago
Incredible. Tom Waits is a great songwriter, but it's Patty's heartbreaking tone that makes this just beautiful.
johnyoutrip 3 years ago 2
Tom Waits is a great performer, this song is his and yes, Patty brought he own strength to it but, Tom Waits' tears your heart out through his own when he sings it.
ut00bvor 3 years ago 2
try to find her version of Tom's "Take it With Me". Great version.
LoPro8 3 years ago
Unbelievable...you all need to get off the Tom Waits high horse and realize good music and talent and raw emotion like this...Yes, Tom Waits is AMAzing, but you must let people interpret others music how they feel it...I think Patty Griffin is one of the best artists who knows how to capture emotion out there. This is an amazing cover!
pattyfan22 3 years ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Not a good cover at all. Tom Waits is the only human creature capable of singing this song as it should be heard . If you are looking for pretty , look elsewhere , Toms an angel but he's never gonna sound like one there's more to his songs than the sadness and the beauty . there is truth and you can't cover that , ever .
blucat3 3 years ago
I like her cover, but I love Megan Mullally's version best of all.....
cmays637 4 years ago 2
Yeah, I think Megan Mullally's version is the best also. She sings the song so clean, as I like to hear it.
MyannaErDejlig 3 years ago
I love Megan's version best also but can't find it on youtube.Can anyone tell me if it is in fact on YT?
chelpydog 2 years ago
No, it's gorgeous and patty is brilliant. tom waits is good writer but his voice makes me want to crawl away and die. patty's voice is beautiful
pelefirespark 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
good try but covering tom waits is impossible anytime i hear his songs covered it just sounds shit,cos well it,s tom waits
aranmpy 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
completely agree.....this should be illegal.
kenrubes 4 years ago
WOW...that is as good as it gets. I've never heard of Patty Griffin or this song, but it is fantastic.
musiclvr030 4 years ago
thanks for posting. i'm always to busy drooling to video her. beautiful!!!!!!!!!
feralcat212 4 years ago
Thanks for the blast from the past, great video. Thanks Roy!
-Kelsea
KelseaC 4 years ago
fucking gorgeous
pelefirespark 4 years ago
Thanks Roy
Murph
indminer 4 years ago
Great post! thanks
jimmyc034 4 years ago