i have to say this is one of the finest moments in drama. I have tended towards the judgmental side with my family on more than one occasion. This scene has humbled me every time. Can dram do more, than teach the unwilling what humanity is at its bes,t and what we can become?
I agree, Diddy did not pull it off in the new version. Walter Lee's character has to be played by a very skills actor such as Sydney P. Maybe Denzel could have.
Mama slapping her daughter has to be taken in the context that she lived. '' Spare the rod and spoil the child' was what was believed. Of course, she loved Beneatha
that 'slap' was a 'wake-up' call ; and not 'child abuse' . Now kids knowall about their 'rights' - but not their RESP (ECT) ONSABILITY.
ah man i did this play in skool,,,, i was beneatha ALL the time!!! but Lindner is white, so y did danny play him??? Ruins the dramatic affect of racism, n proud people....
This is the best classic movie of ALL time for me!!!..I love the Big Momma character..so strong and wise,gr8 emotion.. My favorite line and part of the movie "You better say it..In my momma's house, there is still God"..
I'm not a fan of the remake of this, though I revere all the actors and actresses in the new one..
This was actually a play written by Lorraine Hansberryan a adapted to a movie. Plays can have a profound dramatic effect because of the emphasis on dialogue and character.
That is an extremely moving scene. And food for thought about how to love. View the scene from Imitation Of Life where Mahalia Jackson sings. It too gives you something to think about; when love does not fit into a neat little box
I love this movie! We just watched it yesterday in class, and omg, I was just so happy with the ending. It's too bad they don't make movies like this anymore.
@zenguy22 LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE this movie and play. I directed this scene for my college directing class and my scene won best scene. So so good this play is
only the mother was self rightous. Today's families would not only have taken the second chance offer but would have made a business out of going into different neighborhoods just to get bought out. Don't say they wouldn't
I saw the 2008 version just now on project free tv and was so taken by it . Mother figure is so powerful ...I loved the intorduction:dream differed....dried in the sun greatttttttt.
the 2008 movie was alright, most people are going to say they didn't like it because Diddy is no Sidney Poitier by no means..But I think all of the actors in the new one played their parts extremely well. I mean there is only one Sidney, but I gotta give Diddy and the rest of them credit where it was due..
while watching this you almost forget that this is a movie and these are actors and that they have lines. its just so real and so beautifully acted you almost get lost in it. this is when movies were good. when they evoked emotion, when they told a story and made you feel proud to be black. dang where are the powerful movies at?
I dont think that this one should be comparerd to 2008 version. Personally I really liked the 2008 version alot. It wasnt made to be better than the original or worse. I think it was a great honor to have a remake versions with the stars that people my age (17) are used to seeing. I waited a whole year to see last night's version. Dont get me wrong I must say this version is good and powerful but so was last night's version. A raisin in the sun is just a well written, powerful peice of work.
I totally agree. I'm 17 too and as great as the sydney portier version is I found that It was nice to actually recognize some of the actors in the movie. I was waiting for the 2008 version for over a year.
these actors did such a better job that the puffy combs version sorry but I saw this as a kid and it has become one of my favorite movies of all time!
i have to say this is one of the finest moments in drama. I have tended towards the judgmental side with my family on more than one occasion. This scene has humbled me every time. Can dram do more, than teach the unwilling what humanity is at its bes,t and what we can become?
BTURNER1961 3 months ago
Powerfull words, Indeed.
Laitharex 4 months ago
I agree, Diddy did not pull it off in the new version. Walter Lee's character has to be played by a very skills actor such as Sydney P. Maybe Denzel could have.
tlgcarter 4 months ago
Mama slapping her daughter has to be taken in the context that she lived. '' Spare the rod and spoil the child' was what was believed. Of course, she loved Beneatha
that 'slap' was a 'wake-up' call ; and not 'child abuse' . Now kids knowall about their 'rights' - but not their RESP (ECT) ONSABILITY.
LUCKYBROOKS 6 months ago
"My father almost beat a man to death cuz he called him some kinda name, y'know?"
"... *stares down at his own hands*"
lol, I can see that mousy white negotiator sweating bullets...
CrabTastingMan 6 months ago
brilliance!!
gplus46 8 months ago
O' how I love this movie.... The truth never dies.... Classic
TayLadiiP 9 months ago
I kinda feel sorry for the white guy. You can tell all he wants to do is get the hell outta there!
ccipollini1984 1 year ago
Whats the part where he says how come you college boys wear them faggity looking white shoes. they look funny as hell.
druha10304 1 year ago
Awesome movie...great direction, writing and acting. And quite the historical document!
stepilon 1 year ago
Great scene!
Steven Risman
GDBLESSAMERICA 1 year ago
I disagree, I LOVED the new one too. P. Diddy did a GREAT job.
Gordonjackson007 1 year ago
This movie is the best performance of the play I've ever seen. Everyone is on one accord and the acting is spectacular.
snugglebear09 2 years ago
ah man i did this play in skool,,,, i was beneatha ALL the time!!! but Lindner is white, so y did danny play him??? Ruins the dramatic affect of racism, n proud people....
LaD13aSh 2 years ago
danny didnt play lindner. he played walter. linder was white.
oppositeofwar 2 years ago
well qot the movies confused,,,, thx 4 the update
LaD13aSh 2 years ago
no prob!
oppositeofwar 2 years ago
linder IS piglet
jchoz013 2 years ago
who is the littel boy is a Tupac XD
KingCiho24 2 years ago
Linder Sounds like Piglet LOL
impscal 2 years ago
yh he does lol.
RSDjam17 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He's the same actor who voiced him
MikeKrysta1 1 year ago
the linder in the other version with DANNY GLOVER sounds like piglet too. could it be the same person?
kookie2100i 2 years ago
Yeah, Linder is Piglet, his voice actor at least.
chuobio 2 years ago
@chuobio
Never noticed that. I just know him from 12 Angry Men...
GunterJPN 1 year ago
He's the same actor who voiced him
MikeKrysta1 1 year ago
This is the best classic movie of ALL time for me!!!..I love the Big Momma character..so strong and wise,gr8 emotion.. My favorite line and part of the movie "You better say it..In my momma's house, there is still God"..
I'm not a fan of the remake of this, though I revere all the actors and actresses in the new one..
Thnx 4 posting!!!
destined4mo 2 years ago
This was actually a play written by Lorraine Hansberryan a adapted to a movie. Plays can have a profound dramatic effect because of the emphasis on dialogue and character.
ael196999 2 years ago
Omg that was wonderful!
Mykimoto 2 years ago
The finest speech of the entire play. Mama demonstrates the compassion of God here. Love this.
Lazarusrizing 2 years ago
is that the grandma from "roll of thunder, hear my cry"? there needs to also be a movie for "let the circle be unbroken" (mildred d. taylor).
hisboo911 2 years ago
You damn right. That series was wonderful. I had to read roll of thunder for school and ended up reading all the series even the mini-books.
imperallady 2 years ago
@hisboo911 It sure is.
Akee1990 1 year ago
they just dont make mameokas or aunt jamimas anymore
HIPHOPCHAMBER 2 years ago
that's John Fiedler as Linder--he originated the role on Broadway, and played the role again in the 1989 Danny Glover tv version.
smichelle65 2 years ago
I would kiss the feet of all those black ladies to show them my respect.
Me = Mexican American
FRANKMANNACO700 2 years ago
then she hugs her
masterix6 2 years ago
One of the greatest plays in american literature.
Tonyman182 2 years ago 4
Sidney was stunning from the beginning.
EGlVM 2 years ago
That is an extremely moving scene. And food for thought about how to love. View the scene from Imitation Of Life where Mahalia Jackson sings. It too gives you something to think about; when love does not fit into a neat little box
KowKowCalqulator 2 years ago
Mr. Linder hahahahaHAHAHA!!!!!
greencity127 2 years ago
Mama on here was scary but powerful.
greencity127 2 years ago
have this classic , on dvd ,and i watch it twice a year every year...!!!
my favorite film EVER..!!!!
mvp13klb59 2 years ago
I love this movie! We just watched it yesterday in class, and omg, I was just so happy with the ending. It's too bad they don't make movies like this anymore.
hyuugafan88j4 2 years ago
hey did tupac really play the role of that lil boy?
lakersownsuns 2 years ago
Comment removed
MelanieLouM 2 years ago
No...Tupac was born in 1971...this movie is from 1961. ^_^
MelanieLouM 2 years ago
yeah my frend was telling me that and i didnt believe him.. i knew it! tis was a great film
lakersownsuns 2 years ago
haha damn i wish. im going to pretend its him.
adrastea 2 years ago
please please please upload the whole movie. i can't find the clip anywhere on youtube where sidney poitier is talking to his wife about his plan.
daphnechase 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i never like sydney poitier, the only black actor i never appreciate.
but i love this film so much.
waffiki 2 years ago
"i never like sydney poitier, the only black actor i never appreciate"
WTF?!
jgar6 2 years ago
Mr Lindner=The original voice of Piglet from Winnie the pooh
bigjoy 3 years ago 2
when hes talking about the six generations it givez the whole concept and meaning of plant they have in the backyard it is the "rasin in the sun"
COURTNEYXCORAL 3 years ago
This is acting 101. This is better then the newer one. Marvelous!
zenguy22 3 years ago 22
@zenguy22 THIS IS SO RIVETING..I FEEL THE GO AHEAD'S!!!!
TheAWGemini 1 year ago
@zenguy22 LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE this movie and play. I directed this scene for my college directing class and my scene won best scene. So so good this play is
RSDjam17 7 months ago
Mama in the book A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry is a very positive and idealistic character
SoldSeparatly 3 years ago 3
i watch this classic at least twice a year ..its #1 as my favorite movie ever!!!!
1:07-1:16 gets me everytime,someone hand me a tissue......great scene
1CinemaLover 3 years ago 3
I feel ya man, I feel you.
vaizards 3 years ago 2
I LOVE THIS
BadBoylXXX 3 years ago
I think Ruby Dee is his SISTER.. not his wife..
jazzybee1 3 years ago
no, ruby dee is his wife. the self-righteous chick is his sister
drlove1972 3 years ago 2
yeah you're right. I always thought his sister was played by Ruby Dee. I'm sorry. Thanks IMDB
jazzybee1 3 years ago 2
only the mother was self rightous. Today's families would not only have taken the second chance offer but would have made a business out of going into different neighborhoods just to get bought out. Don't say they wouldn't
etrax2000 3 years ago
What exactly is it that you're babbling about?
drlove1972 3 years ago
I saw the 2008 version just now on project free tv and was so taken by it . Mother figure is so powerful ...I loved the intorduction:dream differed....dried in the sun greatttttttt.
suskky 3 years ago
amazing scene im loving it im reading this book in my school right now
jj3best 3 years ago 2
just did this play. most amazing, moving, powerful play you can watch or be in.
btw, didn't like 2008 version. espeacially diddys " damn these eggs and damn all the eggs that ever was" line.
if17cr7 3 years ago
the 2008 movie was alright, most people are going to say they didn't like it because Diddy is no Sidney Poitier by no means..But I think all of the actors in the new one played their parts extremely well. I mean there is only one Sidney, but I gotta give Diddy and the rest of them credit where it was due..
jazzybee1 3 years ago
while watching this you almost forget that this is a movie and these are actors and that they have lines. its just so real and so beautifully acted you almost get lost in it. this is when movies were good. when they evoked emotion, when they told a story and made you feel proud to be black. dang where are the powerful movies at?
vytorin678 3 years ago 3
i have to play as asagai
subscribemebitches 3 years ago 2
The white guy sounds like a woman.
alumnagirl 3 years ago
you know who he is right? He did the voice of piglet in Winnie the Pooh! haha
pmb2193 3 years ago 3
This version cannot campare to the others it is the greatest version of all time! the acting is just awesome I loved it as a kid!
fruityblack 3 years ago 4
I dont think that this one should be comparerd to 2008 version. Personally I really liked the 2008 version alot. It wasnt made to be better than the original or worse. I think it was a great honor to have a remake versions with the stars that people my age (17) are used to seeing. I waited a whole year to see last night's version. Dont get me wrong I must say this version is good and powerful but so was last night's version. A raisin in the sun is just a well written, powerful peice of work.
paigestrong 3 years ago 2
I totally agree. I'm 17 too and as great as the sydney portier version is I found that It was nice to actually recognize some of the actors in the movie. I was waiting for the 2008 version for over a year.
Misty15big 3 years ago
very powerful
GSTurk1905 3 years ago 2
these actors did such a better job that the puffy combs version sorry but I saw this as a kid and it has become one of my favorite movies of all time!
fruityblack 3 years ago
yea diddy is a horrible actor.
GSTurk1905 3 years ago 11