I wondered who that guy was, too!! Yesterday, I watched the Har[er's Island deleted scenes that came with the first DVD. There's a scene with that guy fighting Jimmy Mance. I suppose that he had a more important role at first, but they edited him out.
Henry is John Wakefields son. They kill everyone to for henry's childhood dream( to live with abby forever). the wedding was the only way to get abby back to the island. Shea and madison get of the island on a small boat while henry kills wakefield to save abby( wakefield wanted to kill her) so henry keeps jimmy so he can pin the murders on him. Abby tells henry she doesn't want him. Jimmy escapes from where he is held, saves abby, abby kills Henry. abby, jimmy, shea, and madison live. The end
great series, i cant remember his name but the guy who was born on that island was fighting off wakefeild with a penkinfe when wakefeild had a machetie lol
Henry and John wakefield were in it together. The whole Plan was to get abby mills back to the island so henry could get to her. Henry and John Wakefield killed everyone in their way but kept Jimmy alive so they could pin it on him and so henry and abby could live togther for ever( all of this was apart of henry's plan). Sully helps shea and madison off the island. Jimmy helps abby fight off henry and abby ends up killing henry. so the only people who lived were abby, jimmy, shea, and madison.
Alright, I know the show is over, but I'll explain some things.
The guy on the boat is the original actor playing JD. The director used shots from pilot for the network executives and put them into the pilot that went on the air for all CBS viewers. A few of the characters like Henry, Trish, and JD were re-cast.
I wish they were doing another one. They could. In addition to the four survivors, there's Dr. Campbell and Karena the psychic. Robin from Harper's Globe, Lucy's boyfriend Ryan.
does henry know his father of mother canany1 tell me cuz im readin this an i know now thathenryz the killer but i was just thinkin today i bet henry doesnt have a father in the show and that this wakefield is hiw father!
I kinda expected the ending. Henry always stopped Abby from killing John Wakefield. He told her it was the 'right thing to do'. And he was always the one who made the directions for people to spilt up and move to different directions.
This show had too many plot holes. It would never become mainstream with issues like that. They werent even subtle.....they were massive. Each episode had about 3-4 plot holes.
from the moment of J.D.'s murder, i knew it was henry. but what a creeded out ending! lol, poor henry, he thought they could live happily ever after. ick! great show, great ending, i'm sorry it wasn't a success, and they won't be doing another murder series next year.
It said on Maggie's profile that she had "more than a few" surprises in store for the wedding party. And, since the wedding was canceled after episode 5 and she was still alive, I assumed the "surprises" were senseless murders.
i just watched the ending too... the killer doesnt kill jimmy.... or abbey and im glad that he dnt kill madison either cuz my bff's name is madison .....................
i just saw the ending!!!!! wow....that was soo shocking i almost cried when she found jimmy by the water like half alive!!!!!! i love this show soo much im glad i know who it is but im soo mad its over!!!!!!!!! those producers are amazing!!!
when she said lots of friends she was talking about the spirits. The ones from the tarot cards obviously. And also about JW, because he kidnapped her and also J.D
i just saw it OMG i was soo suprised lol but i really i was not expecting that but i think i was kinda wierd that that said i love and i wanna live with forever since thier half brother and sister but yea i luc the show
Just saw it. Henry is Wakefields son. Tell me people why the hell did cousin Ben died. That wasnt explained in finale. I hope that CBS makes a lot of misterius series, this one was awesome.
Just saw it omg in Canada it aired earlier and Henry is wakefields sun!!!! He also helped kill lots of pppl henry is a phsycopath who kills every1 on the island except for abby cause he wants to live with her there forever even though they r brother and sister and then abby kills henry to end it it was amazing!!!!
At the end of the episode 12... when Trish and Jimmy are in the car... Jimmy says, "don't sleep with a loaded gun." Guess what he means... HENRY = LOADED GUN.
I get to see the finale tonight and I'm so fucking excited! I no longer think that Shea or Trish are the killer, I think they die instead. I think Henry is the killer, and I've thought that from the beginning. He's so unlikely, but he's also one of my fave characters :(
I love this show. Tonight is the 2 hour finale and i am so exited to see if my theories were right. In the first episode when hunter comes to the island and tried to make out with trish she says no im getting married and he replies with an are you sure. That is kind of creepy. I don't think jimmy is the killer because abbys dad died for him. I very much doubt that he would die for a killer, I think that wakefeilds kid has not been shown yet and that he is helping to kill all these people.
First the reason jimmy isnt dead yet is cuz he has a flippin gun!!! 2 thats disguisting if he is wakefields son cuz abby would be making out with her flippin half brother, and 3 watch the hottest guy [jimmy] die ggrrrrrrrrrr.[and he is there for like 9 of the killings or with abby!!!!!]
the other killer is henry... remember wen trish was visiting the physic? she said she will be betrayed by some1 close to her... since her dads dead henry is the killer
First guy is the dude who drives the boat. Cole Harkin is NOT Wakefield, as he was injured by Wakefield before the 2001 killings, and during the 2001 killings. And plus, hes dead now.
i think the killer is acually jimmy because if you think about it he is never around when anyone is killed and i think he is wakefields son. he is still alive when the boat blew up and he is outside all the time and isnt dead yet!
Read below Comment. Actually the one below that. Think of a GOOD reason to suspect Jimmy and an explanation for why the sheriff died for a guy he suspected was trying to kill his daughter and everyone else and then get back.
lets see wt henry has? he is always quiet and is last for the murders and he might have killed cousin ben bc jimmy couldnt have killed cousin ben! i did see episodes 11 and jimmy is too ovious to be the killer and so wt if he has a crinimal record! JIMMY is not the kiler
You're a 16 year old fan girl who can't spell and CLEARLY doesn't understand murder mysteries. The Mystery part of this series is over. NOW it's all a matter of seeing how they kill the killers. Sit down and shut up.
dont tell me to shut up so i am 16! how old are u??? also i can spell! if u watch the episodes again jimmy couldnt have killed anyone bc they r makin it tooo ovious for him to be the killer so the adience can think that Jimmy is the killer not Henry!
Hey, I'm eleven, and I can spell way better than you (who cares though, I'm smarter than Kentkillmore), but you're right, jasmeetsidhu1234, Jimmy's either not the killer or they've got a serious plot flaw. So both of you shut up, and Kentkillmore, you're acting like a much younger, much less creative fangirl. I've read Agatha Christie and Patricia Cornwell and James Patterson and all of them, so I know what I'm talking about. Why would Sheriff Mills die for Jimmy if he suspected the guy?
it is henry he was the one who killed abbys dad. Episode 10 people you see henrys hand picking up the walkie talkie its not a hand of an old man or a girl and it cant be jimmy so what is left...
does anyone know what that blue plastic thing is that's inside Uncle Marty's bag full of money? It looks like that bag contained lots of cash, a gun, that blue thing and a camera.
Trish? The killer? It's more likely to be Shay, not that I'm saying it is. Maybe they're going to pull an Agatha Christie on us and it'll be Abby. To be honest, I haven't settled on a character to suspect yet. Too much NCIS I guess - stupid Gibbs, pounding it in to every viewer's head "Don't jump to conclusions".
the criminal record on jimmy has been explained in the past. jimmy was arrested for partying on wellingtons boat. cousin ben was killed b4 the boat left Seattle, jimmy shane nikki were on the island already. the killer is henry . i think jimmy was helping the sheriff the whole time in looking for jw.
previews are misleading they are not always shown in the order things are happening. i think trish will get away from jw, run into the arms of henry and he will kill her.
hey wait i think i know who the guy in the begining is. on youtube theres a video and it shows upcoming scenes for harpers island, and the last one abby was at this tunnel thing and the lights go out and then come back on and then when they come back on theres a guy behind her screaming. he looks EXACLY like that guy only with longer hair. and the money wasnt that the same money and bag that trish's ex boyfriend that came to the wedding was seen whith before he got shot?
no its jimmy and wakefeild for sure. because i saw a preveiw for the next episode and jimmy is with wakefeild and trish then trish starts funning away and wakefeild yells shes getting away and jimmy goes running after her with a gun. and have you seen the latest episode? jimmy trys to kill trish and she and madisin fund a criminal record of him in the sherrifs addic. and he has a motive. hes working with wakefiled. his motive is abby left him and never spoke to him ever until the wedding.
no one knows for sure Jimmy was going to kill Trish in the last episode. you never know maybie he was doing what he said. "It isn't safe to sleep with a loaded gun." Hey look at Booth he died by his own gun and he wasn't even sleeping
Another thing is i just watched the previews for the finale and it doesn't show you who wakefield is with when he says trish is getting away. Jimmy does not run after her. why would they give away the 2nd killer. that's just stupid.
you wanna know what i think ? i think jimmys with wakefield. and btw. they found that journal a while ago and it said that abbys mom had a kid. if abbys not wakefields kid, i think jimmy is. that would explain him and wakefield working together. that also would mean that jimmy is abbys half brother.
trish and danny are toast in episode 12 maybe Wakefield too. abby will kill Wakefield, jimmy will kill henry, sully abby jimmy, shea and madison will survive. we will see in flash backs what made henry the killer in episode 13 I wouldn't be suprised if henry was responsible for some of the original murders too
you have a really good point about the air tank- i never noticed that.
i think jimmy is john wakefield's child and thats why he's in on it. plus, abby's mom didn't want her 'camping' with jimmy. possibly because she knew that jimmy was abby's half brother..?
I think there are three people Jimmy, Wakefield, and someon else whos still alive and was at the boat in the beginning (at seattle) because they must have been there to kill the cousin. Im so mad Cal and Chloe are dead they were my favorites.
I know. Chloe and Cal may not have been my favorites, but the way they went was horrible. How Cal sacrificed his live to save her and Chloe just gave up and killed herself to be with Cal. It was just so sad.
The promo for the final is interesting. Wakefield and his accomplice have Trish. Jimmy jumps Henry. Since Trish is wearing her wedding dress when she's being terrorized, and they hardly show Henry at all in the promo, I'll stick with Henry as Wakefields partner.
I think the child that was being referred to in wakefields diary is Jimmy. It would make the most sense. Teaming up with his father to exact revenge on the people and town that ruined their lives.... but if i am right the would probably mean that jimmy's mom is abby's mom and that together is all types of wrong seeing as how jimmy and abby are romanicly linked. maybe this whole jimmy+abby thing is a ploy so that ABBY whould trust jimmy thus letting her gaurd down....
I thought the killer was Henry, Jimmy, or Cal...... but since Cal just died he's off my list! It was so sad! First he died then Chloe jumped off the bridge!
1. Jimmy is Wakefield's son and is either working with him or will stop him.
2. Booth is Wakefield's son, he faked shooting himself, then dear old dad dug him up after being buried. I think Jimmy was helping sherrif and will save the day, or the last remaining survivor.
I say Jimmy and Shane are some where in this plan. My theory was the Charlie, Jimmy and Shane were working together. But after Charlie was killed and Wakefeild showed up, my theory changed. Now I think Wakefeild,Shane,Jimmy and Charlie, are working together! And that Charlie didnt do his job properly so Wakefeild killed him, and now Shane and Jimmy are going to finish them off. Shane because he's jealous of everyone, and Jimmy because he wants Abby back. IDK, this is just what I think.
But, who tied Cousin Ben to the bottom of the boat then?!?!?! OMG, my theory just got screwed up!!!! AAAAHHHH!!!!!!!!!! Maybe one of the wedding party is working with them too..... Who knows anymore! TRUST NO ONE SUSPECT EVERYONE!!!!!!!!!
silly coolgirlj910.... they wouldnt show the main killer before the end of the series...wakefield may have killed a few (trishs dad, the sheriff) but he is not the only killer
Holy crap! I just watched the first episode again and at the start of the scene after Jimmy pulls the rope out of the boat turbines,when theres a hotel worker pulling a trolley of the guests bags.........there's an air tank for scuba diving at the bottom of it,meaning that one of the guests is definetly the killer,not John Wakefield,and that they put cousin Ben at the bottom of the boat!
Just realised something..........Henry could be John Wakefield's son......think about it......we've only heard people mention Henry's parents and we've never actually seen how they died or anything......this could also mean that Henry is the killer because Wakefield's killerness was passed on to him but that's not really been realistic...........:D
Also, I know CBS has stretched the censor boundries with all the murders, but with Abby/ Jimmy in love, whoever this child is, it would be her half brother or sister. I don't think CBS would go that far, of course JW could have had another child, but that's pushing it with the story line of Abby's mother having a child by JW. Guess he could be delusional and think when she was pregnant it was his, but clearly there's at least 2 killers.
I am ALMOST convinced that it's Henry. I didn't suspect him till JD's death. If Henry was the loving brother he acted, he would NEVER have left JD while he was dying. 2nd possibility is that there are 3 killers, because even if it's not Henry killing the others, he killed JD in revenge for TW..the only thing that has grabbed my attention now is I found it hard to believe the bar maid just happened to be allowed to come into the bar after all the shooting..Henry or barmaid JW's child?
This is one of the earlier promo videos. If you look at the other videos, there were some different actors portraying our beloved characters. Some have since been changed, including the guy on the boat. That was "JD", but they switched the actor playing him, but they still have all those old promos out.
haha just cause they have shown john wakefield in ep 10 does not make him the main killer..if u watched the show enough you would realise there has been two different ways of killing people..
Oh brother. Jimmy is NOT the accomplice. They have the final episode 13, which is 2 hours. Do you really think they will reveal the real accomplice next week? Use your head.
Madison is fooling Abby. That episode the culprit sent Madison a note and told her to meet him in the room. Then said to Abby did you like the game. Jimmy would not tell Madison to frame him for a trick. That's stupid.
Madison is connected to the real culprit. Case closed.
omg me and my friend say Madison is like controling the killer (not wakefeild the other one) She saw her dad get murdered! and she's just like "where's dad?" U know where he is U freak!
it could be that jimmy gained a lot of knowledge about the killings from the sherriff and basically used it as a way to set up his killing spree! why he's killing? no idea..as cute as you are jimmy i do think you're the killer :( jimmy just might be wakefield's kid!!
Jimmy cant be the killer bc he will not hurt Abby like that and he is supportin her with all of the kills goin on and he has been there for her all the time! also, jimmy is not wakefield's son i think it is henry or suilly? also, i think madison is setting up Jimmy like she set up the sheriff and tellin abby that her dad took her not wakefield?
jimmy still feels jaded after abby left! its been seven years and he cant seem to move on right? thats a HUGE reason why i think its jimmy! he wants to punish abby and besides he's wakefield's kid! :(
he loves her more then anything that doesnt mean he will hurt her? so he didnt move on some boys dont move on after the gf leaves them without telling them! he loves her so much and so does she!
Its Henry! Why? Because in episode 10 you see someone taking the walkie talkie (this person is in the car and is the one killing he sheriff/ I dont think its Wakefield) and now compere this hand holding the walkie talkie to Henrys hand in episode 2 or 3 its his hand!!!
OH EVERYONE VERY IMPORTANT the cheriff told abby that he was his father and not wakefield. BUT SOMEONE is wakefields daughter OR son and abby's mother lived on the island which means the kid was born on the island! so anyone of the locals or the wedding guests could be related to wakefield hence possibly the second killer
2-Booth. He's the only murded one that we haven't seen the body. And his death was a bit estrange, wasn't it? I think he stills alive, somewhere, and the death was only a trick to think that he's dead. In "and there were none"(i think in english is like that), Agatha Cristies most famous novels, something very close happened, in a island and the murders one by one, and the assasin was one of the already deads.
I suspected Jimmy very early on..too perfect, too cute too everything!
booth is also a great one i never thought of it that way! but malcolm did bury him and now he's dead so maybe that's why we haven't seen him? i need to know now as I am tired of waiting! my moneys on jimbo!
On episode 10, Jimmy was almost killed by an explosion, but was saved because of Sheriff Mills' agreement with John Wakefield. It is a decent possibility that he is one of the killers. In his last breath, J.D. said to Abbi "It's all about you." This could mean that Jimmy is going above and beyond to make sure Abbi never leaves him again. Also, he could be John Wakefields son, rather than Abbi being his daughter. Jimmy is teaming with Wakefield!
GUYS think about this! what if the killer is someone they think is already dead? like the girl they found in the tunnel maybe she was faking it! she could be with wakefield!
Malcom buried him? I didn't know it!... But he could perfectly pretend his death. Malcom was psicologically very bad, and after all, he said "Oh my god, I let Booth die in the middle of the wood..."
So I'm not so sure, because the scene of the shot was a bit confusing, don't you think? Suddenly there was a shot, Malcom thougth he was bleeding, but they care that Booth is the one bleeding. And then the body never appears again. And it's the only body that don't appears!
malcom went back to where he buried him, there was 4 stones in a criss cross sequence on top of it. I do still think that booth could be alive but its behind my jimmy/henry thoughts
well they have brought wakefield back into it and no way he could of tied ben to the boat..think about for a second, there has to be more than one person in on this...
The killer is obviously Henry! I know how weird it sounds but as I watch the show I keep noticing that Henry is always gone somewhere when the killings occur! The wedding planner and the sheriff were obviously killed by Wakefield but they were one timers! I know it sounds crazy but i have watched the episodes over and over again and it fits! Henry is the killer!
Ok I've watched the whole series so I know but is it just me or does the guy at :44 kinda look like Sam Winchester?
twistedapathy 9 months ago
lol at how the guy in the beginning that youw anted to know who he was, really wasn't the killer.
xembracecold 1 year ago
I heard that uncle Marty was going to invest the money to Malcolms brevery
Anttilai 1 year ago
i think the guy on the boat is Sam (jared padalecki) from Supernatural doing a cameo seeing some of the actors played in Supernatural.
Yellowman165 2 years ago
henry is the murderer
4everfifa09 2 years ago
the guy is the captain!
(sorry, i'm german^^)
rainbowfelicity 2 years ago
Is that guy Uncle Marty? :D
TheKissBanana 2 years ago
I wondered who that guy was, too!! Yesterday, I watched the Har[er's Island deleted scenes that came with the first DVD. There's a scene with that guy fighting Jimmy Mance. I suppose that he had a more important role at first, but they edited him out.
mountaincritter 2 years ago
hey, do u know how to upload things
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hi lalalalalalalala check me out on my profile ppl love ya
ladygagafanclub911 2 years ago
U know what end would really be freakin'
If Abby instead of killing Henry, killed Jimmy and lived happily ever after...;)
RoryDewany 2 years ago
I think it would have been cooler if Jimmy would have been the murderer.
Hipzu 2 years ago
Henry is John Wakefields son. They kill everyone to for henry's childhood dream( to live with abby forever). the wedding was the only way to get abby back to the island. Shea and madison get of the island on a small boat while henry kills wakefield to save abby( wakefield wanted to kill her) so henry keeps jimmy so he can pin the murders on him. Abby tells henry she doesn't want him. Jimmy escapes from where he is held, saves abby, abby kills Henry. abby, jimmy, shea, and madison live. The end
blueeyedchick33 2 years ago
Comment removed
blueeyedchick33 2 years ago
i missed like the last parts... can someone tell me, what happend who is the killer, did everyone die.... tell me everything.
The last scene i saw was when henry's brother died....
DanniG93 2 years ago
henry was the secondary killer, his dad John wakefield is the main killer, and nearly everyone died
djkonix69 2 years ago
great series, i cant remember his name but the guy who was born on that island was fighting off wakefeild with a penkinfe when wakefeild had a machetie lol
Tomkins1802 2 years ago
Shane.
DeityZiex 2 years ago
shane
lloyd1234100 2 years ago
It was not a machetie, it was a Boarding Knife, sorry I'm picky lol :P
tiger111189 2 years ago
Oh, i thought he went into the bar thing with a big knife, i thought the boarding knife was like a spear with a big blade.
I remember Henry threw a Boarding Knife into the sea at the end.
Tomkins1802 2 years ago
4 ppl got away abby, her bf, flower girl and sum uther guy
camahazy1 2 years ago
*spoiler*
Abby, Jimmy, Madison(girl) and Shea(her mom).
DeityZiex 2 years ago
Henry and John wakefield were in it together. The whole Plan was to get abby mills back to the island so henry could get to her. Henry and John Wakefield killed everyone in their way but kept Jimmy alive so they could pin it on him and so henry and abby could live togther for ever( all of this was apart of henry's plan). Sully helps shea and madison off the island. Jimmy helps abby fight off henry and abby ends up killing henry. so the only people who lived were abby, jimmy, shea, and madison.
blueeyedchick33 2 years ago
@DanniG93 Killer: John Wakefeild
Co-Killer: Henry Dunn
Survivors: Abby Mills, Jimmy Mance, Shea Allen, Madison Allen
BratzBoy101 1 year ago
i know what happen to muffin they just left her out :( buu huu
JezXoXo 2 years ago 2
what ever happened to muffin?
BRITTG111 2 years ago
R.I.P SHANE AND J.D :/
forggetit 2 years ago 2
That girl from 2:34 is from According to Jim.
1xxCoolGuYxx1 2 years ago
My only question is will they ever find the nerd that killed himself and the cousin ben guy? ha
Eivan10R 2 years ago
i know jimmy was so close to finding the body hahaha but i thought it was weird when madision was standing by her moms bed weird
meg5493 2 years ago
Alright, I know the show is over, but I'll explain some things.
The guy on the boat is the original actor playing JD. The director used shots from pilot for the network executives and put them into the pilot that went on the air for all CBS viewers. A few of the characters like Henry, Trish, and JD were re-cast.
FuturamaFanatic825 2 years ago
i just realized the sack of money in uncle marty's place was in the boat where hunter was found dead and i thought he was paid in a check
embla36 2 years ago
I wish they were doing another one. They could. In addition to the four survivors, there's Dr. Campbell and Karena the psychic. Robin from Harper's Globe, Lucy's boyfriend Ryan.
TomCruiseCloneTwo 2 years ago
haha.....BIG TWIST NO ONE EXPECTED lol THE RETURN OF......GIGI!
Yeah they really should have done something with the dog.
HopperKlutzChica 2 years ago
lol what I want to know is what ever happened to the dog?
HopperKlutzChica 2 years ago 7
does henry know his father of mother canany1 tell me cuz im readin this an i know now thathenryz the killer but i was just thinkin today i bet henry doesnt have a father in the show and that this wakefield is hiw father!
scanlon69r 2 years ago
I kinda expected the ending. Henry always stopped Abby from killing John Wakefield. He told her it was the 'right thing to do'. And he was always the one who made the directions for people to spilt up and move to different directions.
fakecrime 2 years ago
i new it was henry all along. having it be jimmy would have been too clear. its a shame more people didn't watch this show.
pantherfan352 2 years ago 2
This show had too many plot holes. It would never become mainstream with issues like that. They werent even subtle.....they were massive. Each episode had about 3-4 plot holes.
neilp4453 2 years ago
from the moment of J.D.'s murder, i knew it was henry. but what a creeded out ending! lol, poor henry, he thought they could live happily ever after. ick! great show, great ending, i'm sorry it wasn't a success, and they won't be doing another murder series next year.
resgirly4VA 2 years ago 3
I hated the ending. Hated it. I thought the killer was Maggie Krell!
TomCruiseCloneTwo 2 years ago
why her? my "off the wall" pick was nikki the bartender.
LovingWhoIReallyAm 2 years ago
It said on Maggie's profile that she had "more than a few" surprises in store for the wedding party. And, since the wedding was canceled after episode 5 and she was still alive, I assumed the "surprises" were senseless murders.
TomCruiseCloneTwo 2 years ago
and they still didn't even show what her surprises were right?...lots of things still left unsaid.
LovingWhoIReallyAm 2 years ago
i just watched the ending too... the killer doesnt kill jimmy.... or abbey and im glad that he dnt kill madison either cuz my bff's name is madison .....................
Laura73371 2 years ago
i just saw the ending!!!!! wow....that was soo shocking i almost cried when she found jimmy by the water like half alive!!!!!! i love this show soo much im glad i know who it is but im soo mad its over!!!!!!!!! those producers are amazing!!!
lilripp3114 2 years ago
now henry just killed wakefield and made it look like he isnt working with hime but abbey knows he is the killer but it is all below......
Laura73371 2 years ago
uh im watchin rhe fanale and henry is wakefield's son and they killed everyone except abbey and jimmy. now the coast guard is coming!
Laura73371 2 years ago
when she said lots of friends she was talking about the spirits. The ones from the tarot cards obviously. And also about JW, because he kidnapped her and also J.D
jkj1244 2 years ago
real mature!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
all i wanted to knw wasa were they going to air the episodes together
but when i went to the page it said ##### is the killer ha ha ha
dsjj251 2 years ago
Wikipedia Sucks
dsjj251 2 years ago
shea and madison survive with jimmy and abby
Henry kills trish and sully
and he kills wakefield
then wakefield kills danny
abby kills henry
usmaniscrazy 2 years ago
it was henry
riguy99 2 years ago
i just saw it OMG i was soo suprised lol but i really i was not expecting that but i think i was kinda wierd that that said i love and i wanna live with forever since thier half brother and sister but yea i luc the show
1breyerhorsegurl 2 years ago
Just saw it. Henry is Wakefields son. Tell me people why the hell did cousin Ben died. That wasnt explained in finale. I hope that CBS makes a lot of misterius series, this one was awesome.
The ending was expected, though
spockatier 2 years ago
Just saw it omg in Canada it aired earlier and Henry is wakefields sun!!!! He also helped kill lots of pppl henry is a phsycopath who kills every1 on the island except for abby cause he wants to live with her there forever even though they r brother and sister and then abby kills henry to end it it was amazing!!!!
Dguy95 2 years ago 2
i saw it too, the ending was shocking .. lol
and to me, it was really unexpected.
gemmaasantos 2 years ago
i would have been soo mad at you if i hadn't read the spoilers already LOL.
LovingWhoIReallyAm 2 years ago
haha i put it up on the blog website and the ppl spazed at me :P
Dguy95 2 years ago
You are probably in the states i live in canada. In canada it's tonight
XxxmrsjeffhardyxxX 2 years ago
At the end of the episode 12... when Trish and Jimmy are in the car... Jimmy says, "don't sleep with a loaded gun." Guess what he means... HENRY = LOADED GUN.
rsPlumber 2 years ago 9
I get to see the finale tonight and I'm so fucking excited! I no longer think that Shea or Trish are the killer, I think they die instead. I think Henry is the killer, and I've thought that from the beginning. He's so unlikely, but he's also one of my fave characters :(
MsPeace1 2 years ago 2
how can you see it tonight?
koko5444 2 years ago
I love this show. Tonight is the 2 hour finale and i am so exited to see if my theories were right. In the first episode when hunter comes to the island and tried to make out with trish she says no im getting married and he replies with an are you sure. That is kind of creepy. I don't think jimmy is the killer because abbys dad died for him. I very much doubt that he would die for a killer, I think that wakefeilds kid has not been shown yet and that he is helping to kill all these people.
XxxmrsjeffhardyxxX 2 years ago
how is it tonight?
koko5444 2 years ago
Theres different time zones, -.-.
shadowknoll 2 years ago
First the reason jimmy isnt dead yet is cuz he has a flippin gun!!! 2 thats disguisting if he is wakefields son cuz abby would be making out with her flippin half brother, and 3 watch the hottest guy [jimmy] die ggrrrrrrrrrr.[and he is there for like 9 of the killings or with abby!!!!!]
COOKIES12824 2 years ago
the other killer is henry... remember wen trish was visiting the physic? she said she will be betrayed by some1 close to her... since her dads dead henry is the killer
jacketoff13 2 years ago
First guy is the dude who drives the boat. Cole Harkin is NOT Wakefield, as he was injured by Wakefield before the 2001 killings, and during the 2001 killings. And plus, hes dead now.
matthoenn 2 years ago
Its The guy with the blonde hair, and wakefield
iAmSilverlucas 2 years ago
i think the killer is acually jimmy because if you think about it he is never around when anyone is killed and i think he is wakefields son. he is still alive when the boat blew up and he is outside all the time and isnt dead yet!
xxbritbrit96xx 2 years ago
Read below Comment. Actually the one below that. Think of a GOOD reason to suspect Jimmy and an explanation for why the sheriff died for a guy he suspected was trying to kill his daughter and everyone else and then get back.
savieandkay 2 years ago
is that fishing guy Jimmy? he is fucking adorable.
think im dying here man! haha: D
slangdigivaggen 2 years ago
hes the captian of the boat
anniebannani93 2 years ago
John Wakefield and Jimmy. Those are the killers.
Kentkillmore 2 years ago
JW and HENRY are the killers not jimmy it is tooo ovious
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
Seriously? What motives does Henry have? None! Jimmy doesn't want Abby to leave again. Did you see episode 11?
Kentkillmore 2 years ago
lets see wt henry has? he is always quiet and is last for the murders and he might have killed cousin ben bc jimmy couldnt have killed cousin ben! i did see episodes 11 and jimmy is too ovious to be the killer and so wt if he has a crinimal record! JIMMY is not the kiler
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
You're a 16 year old fan girl who can't spell and CLEARLY doesn't understand murder mysteries. The Mystery part of this series is over. NOW it's all a matter of seeing how they kill the killers. Sit down and shut up.
Kentkillmore 2 years ago
dont tell me to shut up so i am 16! how old are u??? also i can spell! if u watch the episodes again jimmy couldnt have killed anyone bc they r makin it tooo ovious for him to be the killer so the adience can think that Jimmy is the killer not Henry!
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
Old enough to know that you have NO idea what you're talking about.
Kentkillmore 2 years ago
Hey, I'm eleven, and I can spell way better than you (who cares though, I'm smarter than Kentkillmore), but you're right, jasmeetsidhu1234, Jimmy's either not the killer or they've got a serious plot flaw. So both of you shut up, and Kentkillmore, you're acting like a much younger, much less creative fangirl. I've read Agatha Christie and Patricia Cornwell and James Patterson and all of them, so I know what I'm talking about. Why would Sheriff Mills die for Jimmy if he suspected the guy?
savieandkay 2 years ago
it is henry he was the one who killed abbys dad. Episode 10 people you see henrys hand picking up the walkie talkie its not a hand of an old man or a girl and it cant be jimmy so what is left...
goslaw 2 years ago
does anyone know what that blue plastic thing is that's inside Uncle Marty's bag full of money? It looks like that bag contained lots of cash, a gun, that blue thing and a camera.
littleredhenrietta 2 years ago
no the guy on the boat is j.d. they recast the actors and forgot to edit in the new j.d
jency211 2 years ago
the 2nd kiler is trish
idk9998 2 years ago
Trish? The killer? It's more likely to be Shay, not that I'm saying it is. Maybe they're going to pull an Agatha Christie on us and it'll be Abby. To be honest, I haven't settled on a character to suspect yet. Too much NCIS I guess - stupid Gibbs, pounding it in to every viewer's head "Don't jump to conclusions".
savieandkay 2 years ago
the criminal record on jimmy has been explained in the past. jimmy was arrested for partying on wellingtons boat. cousin ben was killed b4 the boat left Seattle, jimmy shane nikki were on the island already. the killer is henry . i think jimmy was helping the sheriff the whole time in looking for jw.
josephga 2 years ago
previews are misleading they are not always shown in the order things are happening. i think trish will get away from jw, run into the arms of henry and he will kill her.
josephga 2 years ago
hey wait i think i know who the guy in the begining is. on youtube theres a video and it shows upcoming scenes for harpers island, and the last one abby was at this tunnel thing and the lights go out and then come back on and then when they come back on theres a guy behind her screaming. he looks EXACLY like that guy only with longer hair. and the money wasnt that the same money and bag that trish's ex boyfriend that came to the wedding was seen whith before he got shot?
xxtwilight2nightxx 2 years ago
my prediction.
Sully- Lives escapes on the boat with Shea and Madison
Trish- Dies at the hands of Henry first hour.
Danny- Dies killed by JW
Abby- Lives walks off into the sunset with Jimmy
Madison-Lives escapes on the boat with Shea and Sully
JW- Dies Abby kills him
Jimmy- Lives walks off into the sunset with Abby
Shea- escapes on the boat with Sully and Madison
Henry- Dies , Henry is the second killer Jimmy kills Henry
josephga 2 years ago
I am with you on that one
goslaw 2 years ago
no its jimmy and wakefeild for sure. because i saw a preveiw for the next episode and jimmy is with wakefeild and trish then trish starts funning away and wakefeild yells shes getting away and jimmy goes running after her with a gun. and have you seen the latest episode? jimmy trys to kill trish and she and madisin fund a criminal record of him in the sherrifs addic. and he has a motive. hes working with wakefiled. his motive is abby left him and never spoke to him ever until the wedding.
xxtwilight2nightxx 2 years ago
no one knows for sure Jimmy was going to kill Trish in the last episode. you never know maybie he was doing what he said. "It isn't safe to sleep with a loaded gun." Hey look at Booth he died by his own gun and he wasn't even sleeping
emmettisahottie 2 years ago
Another thing is i just watched the previews for the finale and it doesn't show you who wakefield is with when he says trish is getting away. Jimmy does not run after her. why would they give away the 2nd killer. that's just stupid.
emmettisahottie 2 years ago
I wish:)
energizer61bunny 2 years ago
you wanna know what i think ? i think jimmys with wakefield. and btw. they found that journal a while ago and it said that abbys mom had a kid. if abbys not wakefields kid, i think jimmy is. that would explain him and wakefield working together. that also would mean that jimmy is abbys half brother.
moonkayzRus 2 years ago
which the sheriff would've known about, and then why would he want abby and jimmy to be together?
doomroe3 2 years ago
maybe there are different killer killing different victim as there seems to be a conspiracy inthe family and friends.
The silliest death is Booth and i think Trish is in it too (for not shooting Wakefield in the Cannery scene).
shanessy666 2 years ago
if u noticed when they ar epushing the luggage cart tehres an oxygen tank
zodythekuraikodomo13 2 years ago
trish and danny are toast in episode 12 maybe Wakefield too. abby will kill Wakefield, jimmy will kill henry, sully abby jimmy, shea and madison will survive. we will see in flash backs what made henry the killer in episode 13 I wouldn't be suprised if henry was responsible for some of the original murders too
josephga 2 years ago
IS this a fact, or what you think will happen?
Laurensworlds 2 years ago
you have a really good point about the air tank- i never noticed that.
i think jimmy is john wakefield's child and thats why he's in on it. plus, abby's mom didn't want her 'camping' with jimmy. possibly because she knew that jimmy was abby's half brother..?
sillychuckles 2 years ago
she would have put up more of a fight then
ubersamtron 2 years ago
good ponint. and i just now noticed the air tank to. it was on the marina when the explosion happend.
xxtwilight2nightxx 2 years ago
yay thats not right cause cal got stabed
GetSmart135 2 years ago
I think there are three people Jimmy, Wakefield, and someon else whos still alive and was at the boat in the beginning (at seattle) because they must have been there to kill the cousin. Im so mad Cal and Chloe are dead they were my favorites.
marikiki17 2 years ago
I know. Chloe and Cal may not have been my favorites, but the way they went was horrible. How Cal sacrificed his live to save her and Chloe just gave up and killed herself to be with Cal. It was just so sad.
Shikamaru1487 2 years ago
The promo for the final is interesting. Wakefield and his accomplice have Trish. Jimmy jumps Henry. Since Trish is wearing her wedding dress when she's being terrorized, and they hardly show Henry at all in the promo, I'll stick with Henry as Wakefields partner.
DreadVane 2 years ago
I agree. He protected them by distracting John.
He got stabbed in the stomach, hanged, and I think John cut his arms off.
HatakeKakashi1 2 years ago
I cant believe Cal is fead!!!
That jerk I cant believe he killed him!!
The Chloe jumped!!
I hate to say it I rlly do but I think Jimmy has something to do with the killings......
derekhough123 2 years ago
i think the killer and wakefields son is henry. and i was so sad when cal died then chloe jumped off the bridge for him :(
xoxodevin95 2 years ago 2
I think the child that was being referred to in wakefields diary is Jimmy. It would make the most sense. Teaming up with his father to exact revenge on the people and town that ruined their lives.... but if i am right the would probably mean that jimmy's mom is abby's mom and that together is all types of wrong seeing as how jimmy and abby are romanicly linked. maybe this whole jimmy+abby thing is a ploy so that ABBY whould trust jimmy thus letting her gaurd down....
DracoBabe88 2 years ago
I thought the killer was Henry, Jimmy, or Cal...... but since Cal just died he's off my list! It was so sad! First he died then Chloe jumped off the bridge!
sakurafan45 2 years ago
when is the next episode going to be?
elifbabyy 2 years ago
11th of july is the 12th and 13th episode together
djkonix69 2 years ago
I love how people say that the second killer is working WITH Wakefield... Who says there can't be a friendly competition between two serial killers?
Or, not so friendly O.o Lmao.
LupisNero 2 years ago
I am pissed that Cal died, he was my favorite
GameKid3358 2 years ago
I have 2 theories.
1. Jimmy is Wakefield's son and is either working with him or will stop him.
2. Booth is Wakefield's son, he faked shooting himself, then dear old dad dug him up after being buried. I think Jimmy was helping sherrif and will save the day, or the last remaining survivor.
salefamily 2 years ago
I told you, people. It is Jimmy. He was in prison with uncle Marty. That is why Uncle Marty was the first victim.
spockatier 2 years ago
Uncle Marty wasnt the first victim....Trish's cousin ben was:)
robincrazy 2 years ago
Comment removed
tyminush 2 years ago
The show is on Saturdays right??
And i guess there not showing it next week?
Lol
derekhough123 2 years ago
I'll stick with Henry as the killer working with Wakefield.
DreadVane 2 years ago
man... cousin ben's death is scary.... I mean, did you see those lifeless eyes?? Brr...
TheZampard 2 years ago
I say Jimmy and Shane are some where in this plan. My theory was the Charlie, Jimmy and Shane were working together. But after Charlie was killed and Wakefeild showed up, my theory changed. Now I think Wakefeild,Shane,Jimmy and Charlie, are working together! And that Charlie didnt do his job properly so Wakefeild killed him, and now Shane and Jimmy are going to finish them off. Shane because he's jealous of everyone, and Jimmy because he wants Abby back. IDK, this is just what I think.
JasperHale4Life 2 years ago
But, who tied Cousin Ben to the bottom of the boat then?!?!?! OMG, my theory just got screwed up!!!! AAAAHHHH!!!!!!!!!! Maybe one of the wedding party is working with them too..... Who knows anymore! TRUST NO ONE SUSPECT EVERYONE!!!!!!!!!
JasperHale4Life 2 years ago
There goes my plan...again, now Shane's dead! Im actually really sad about that :'(. I still think Jimmy is in there somewhere, I can feel it!
JasperHale4Life 2 years ago
hey did anyone see the 10th ep of this show cause john wake field is back so it him who is doing all the killing just watch it and ull see
coolgirlj910 2 years ago
silly coolgirlj910.... they wouldnt show the main killer before the end of the series...wakefield may have killed a few (trishs dad, the sheriff) but he is not the only killer
djkonix69 2 years ago
Holy crap! I just watched the first episode again and at the start of the scene after Jimmy pulls the rope out of the boat turbines,when theres a hotel worker pulling a trolley of the guests bags.........there's an air tank for scuba diving at the bottom of it,meaning that one of the guests is definetly the killer,not John Wakefield,and that they put cousin Ben at the bottom of the boat!
ValkyrieSky66 2 years ago
i think its jimmy
but killing ben would have been going too far
i mean h wouldve had to travel to seatlle and all..
ayumunarumi15 2 years ago
Just realised something..........Henry could be John Wakefield's son......think about it......we've only heard people mention Henry's parents and we've never actually seen how they died or anything......this could also mean that Henry is the killer because Wakefield's killerness was passed on to him but that's not really been realistic...........:D
ValkyrieSky66 2 years ago
OMG!!!!!!! You could be right, I thought Nikki could've been Wakefeild's kid, but that actually makes sense.
JasperHale4Life 2 years ago
Also, I know CBS has stretched the censor boundries with all the murders, but with Abby/ Jimmy in love, whoever this child is, it would be her half brother or sister. I don't think CBS would go that far, of course JW could have had another child, but that's pushing it with the story line of Abby's mother having a child by JW. Guess he could be delusional and think when she was pregnant it was his, but clearly there's at least 2 killers.
resgirly4VA 2 years ago
I am ALMOST convinced that it's Henry. I didn't suspect him till JD's death. If Henry was the loving brother he acted, he would NEVER have left JD while he was dying. 2nd possibility is that there are 3 killers, because even if it's not Henry killing the others, he killed JD in revenge for TW..the only thing that has grabbed my attention now is I found it hard to believe the bar maid just happened to be allowed to come into the bar after all the shooting..Henry or barmaid JW's child?
resgirly4VA 2 years ago
This is one of the earlier promo videos. If you look at the other videos, there were some different actors portraying our beloved characters. Some have since been changed, including the guy on the boat. That was "JD", but they switched the actor playing him, but they still have all those old promos out.
ariyana9501 2 years ago
The killer is wakefield but i reckon abbi is not his daughter that he has a son and the 2 have gone on a spree together to avenge his years in jail
ledd55 2 years ago
where'd u get these clips????
BookWorm5510 2 years ago
from the episodes...
djkonix69 2 years ago
the killer is john wakefield. did u guys see espiode10? john killed abbys dad. u dumb fucks also the black guy aka danny, he was a power ranger
powerangerwwe 2 years ago
haha just cause they have shown john wakefield in ep 10 does not make him the main killer..if u watched the show enough you would realise there has been two different ways of killing people..
djkonix69 2 years ago
Oh brother. Jimmy is NOT the accomplice. They have the final episode 13, which is 2 hours. Do you really think they will reveal the real accomplice next week? Use your head.
Madison is fooling Abby. That episode the culprit sent Madison a note and told her to meet him in the room. Then said to Abby did you like the game. Jimmy would not tell Madison to frame him for a trick. That's stupid.
Madison is connected to the real culprit. Case closed.
bklyngalNY 2 years ago
omg me and my friend say Madison is like controling the killer (not wakefeild the other one) She saw her dad get murdered! and she's just like "where's dad?" U know where he is U freak!
BookWorm5510 2 years ago
She didn't see her dad get murdered.
evilprincess5 2 years ago
the glass was tinted because it was nighttime
HatakeKakashi1 2 years ago
it could be that jimmy gained a lot of knowledge about the killings from the sherriff and basically used it as a way to set up his killing spree! why he's killing? no idea..as cute as you are jimmy i do think you're the killer :( jimmy just might be wakefield's kid!!
LovingWhoIReallyAm 2 years ago
Jimmy cant be the killer bc he will not hurt Abby like that and he is supportin her with all of the kills goin on and he has been there for her all the time! also, jimmy is not wakefield's son i think it is henry or suilly? also, i think madison is setting up Jimmy like she set up the sheriff and tellin abby that her dad took her not wakefield?
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
jimmy still feels jaded after abby left! its been seven years and he cant seem to move on right? thats a HUGE reason why i think its jimmy! he wants to punish abby and besides he's wakefield's kid! :(
LovingWhoIReallyAm 2 years ago
why wil jimmy punish the girl he loves it is not possible
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago 2
dont forget that jimmy could possibly be wakefields son!
lavendermom3 2 years ago
that is indeed what i think it is...jimmy is so clearly the killer.
LovingWhoIReallyAm 2 years ago
also, he is not the killer or wakefield son
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
because he is still obsessed with her...he should have moved on but hasn't its obvious he is still mad at her...after what...7 years??
LovingWhoIReallyAm 2 years ago
he loves her more then anything that doesnt mean he will hurt her? so he didnt move on some boys dont move on after the gf leaves them without telling them! he loves her so much and so does she!
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
Its Henry! Why? Because in episode 10 you see someone taking the walkie talkie (this person is in the car and is the one killing he sheriff/ I dont think its Wakefield) and now compere this hand holding the walkie talkie to Henrys hand in episode 2 or 3 its his hand!!!
Can you also see it?
goslaw 2 years ago
hmm yes i do see that aswell, and also..when watching jd and henry in ep2 henry takes some of jd's drugs which could explain katherines death
djkonix69 2 years ago
Katherine died from being stabbed in the back with hegde clippers.......
ValkyrieSky66 2 years ago
the cheriff told abby she was his child
slashisgod9299 2 years ago
OH EVERYONE VERY IMPORTANT the cheriff told abby that he was his father and not wakefield. BUT SOMEONE is wakefields daughter OR son and abby's mother lived on the island which means the kid was born on the island! so anyone of the locals or the wedding guests could be related to wakefield hence possibly the second killer
slashisgod9299 2 years ago
I have two suspects(Wakefield appart)
1-Jimmy. He can be perfectly the other killer.
2-Booth. He's the only murded one that we haven't seen the body. And his death was a bit estrange, wasn't it? I think he stills alive, somewhere, and the death was only a trick to think that he's dead. In "and there were none"(i think in english is like that), Agatha Cristies most famous novels, something very close happened, in a island and the murders one by one, and the assasin was one of the already deads.
lovelyshoes94 2 years ago
I suspected Jimmy very early on..too perfect, too cute too everything!
booth is also a great one i never thought of it that way! but malcolm did bury him and now he's dead so maybe that's why we haven't seen him? i need to know now as I am tired of waiting! my moneys on jimbo!
LovingWhoIReallyAm 2 years ago
On episode 10, Jimmy was almost killed by an explosion, but was saved because of Sheriff Mills' agreement with John Wakefield. It is a decent possibility that he is one of the killers. In his last breath, J.D. said to Abbi "It's all about you." This could mean that Jimmy is going above and beyond to make sure Abbi never leaves him again. Also, he could be John Wakefields son, rather than Abbi being his daughter. Jimmy is teaming with Wakefield!
lavendermom3 2 years ago
GUYS think about this! what if the killer is someone they think is already dead? like the girl they found in the tunnel maybe she was faking it! she could be with wakefield!
slashisgod9299 2 years ago
that girl was most defiantly cut in half. but maybe!
mhill975 2 years ago
think about Booth;
He's the only one that he's body isn't found yet. And his death was a bit extrange, don't you think? He was shoot by himself or what happened?
Read "And there were none" by agatha Cristie, "Diez negritos" in spanish,,
Something very similar happened, and I think this tv show is based in that book a bit.
lovelyshoes94 2 years ago
dude booth shot himself in a very vital leg artery. if you get shot there you have about a minute to live. besides he was buried.
slashisgod9299 2 years ago
Malcom buried him? I didn't know it!... But he could perfectly pretend his death. Malcom was psicologically very bad, and after all, he said "Oh my god, I let Booth die in the middle of the wood..."
So I'm not so sure, because the scene of the shot was a bit confusing, don't you think? Suddenly there was a shot, Malcom thougth he was bleeding, but they care that Booth is the one bleeding. And then the body never appears again. And it's the only body that don't appears!
lovelyshoes94 2 years ago
malcom went back to where he buried him, there was 4 stones in a criss cross sequence on top of it. I do still think that booth could be alive but its behind my jimmy/henry thoughts
djkonix69 2 years ago
yah i like cal too he is in bad shape right now tho :/ oh well he might live
slashisgod9299 2 years ago
it totally isn't jimmy because ben was tied to the boat in seattle before they left and jimmy was all the wayyyyy in harper's island
Bam9696 2 years ago
well they have brought wakefield back into it and no way he could of tied ben to the boat..think about for a second, there has to be more than one person in on this...
djkonix69 2 years ago
but the cbs website says there is one killer from the 25 suspects and wakefield isnt one of those suspects
Bam9696 2 years ago
The killer is obviously Henry! I know how weird it sounds but as I watch the show I keep noticing that Henry is always gone somewhere when the killings occur! The wedding planner and the sheriff were obviously killed by Wakefield but they were one timers! I know it sounds crazy but i have watched the episodes over and over again and it fits! Henry is the killer!
ValkyrieSky66 2 years ago
Comment removed
resgirly4VA 2 years ago
Yeah but it wont be too obvious that the killer it wakefield. I dunno maybe its wakefield with another person :|. I hope cal dont die D:
Lelithaa 2 years ago
I totally forgot, I think that maybe nikki is a suspect too. *O*
Lelithaa 2 years ago
nikki is hell suss
djkonix69 2 years ago