陈楚生 齐秦 - 外面的世界 + 悬崖 - 快乐男声 - 冠军 - 终极总决赛

[jiranma]

楚生的声音也很像熊天平的。

[loveHimonly1]

cannot tell their voices apart. its like they are father and son.

absolutely love this song!

[saitomkham]

Not clear video.kao!

[hyohom]

没办法，人总是会老的。

[iceclay]

好好的一首歌，唱的也不错，全毁在吉他上了....

[killnub1]

唉，不知者无过

[118157043]

怎么黑成这样啊···



[jiaozi0323]

陈楚生唱的真难听



[charlottetsts]

齐秦英雄遲暮了

[cdyjw1990]

楚生，永远爱你。。。。

[725crysanthemum]

楚生的歌声真棒！

[maylingfung]

LOVE小弟··········

[maylingfung]

小弟加油·········

[yzlinpan]

天哪，昔日的偶像怎么老成了这样？岁月无情啊！

[kismelin]

感触好深， 齐秦老了好多。。

[eugeneismy]

真的有被感动到

[huanw467]

咋这黑了他

[googleabcd]

陈楚生唱的比齐秦好，不过齐秦毕竟老了

[jadebai]

咋这黑了他。。。

[ylpenny]

齊秦的聲音真的很棒，保持得真好!

那位小男生，聲音也不錯，但娘了一點，後部份的哭腔也重了一點。­

[hellowjp]

齐秦的声音，要注意保护啊，还有，他怎么把自己弄得这么黑呢

[alexwang49]

烟弄的。。。哎

[tekikesyo2000]

哈哈

[Mrshifengzhou]

@hellowjp 他喜欢打高尔夫 大概晒得吧

[theanitahuang]

They are both very good artists.I think Chi Chin's voice has been so nature and makes people feel so touched.I think he is a nature singer.He does't have to try hard to present himself.He is just be himself and that is the most wonderful thing.I can see he enjoys his life very much and that's the whole point,isn't it?I like you just like the way you are.Cheers!!!!!!!!

[redpepper2000]

Qi Qin is still better...He has a unique voice

that is very touching and no one can surpass or copy...

[JO1978loveCS]

齐秦老矣,楚生可畏!!

[hosehliao]

they both sing great. qiqin has a distinct voice. besides, i tink as we age, we don't loses some power. and also, i feel qiqin didn't wanna steal the limelight from chu sheng. that's a great attribute.

well done, both!

[tinyan144]

芒果台第一次選出我心目中的冠軍

好好聽!

[jirsy1981]

齐秦老了，高音上不去了，岁月不饶人啊

[redpepper2000]

That is not because he's old. It's due to too much smoking, alcohol, and spicy food...

He needs to take care of his voice/throat

so he still can sing for his fans in his "old age". 0)

[highburycatherine]

真好

[jackchenwuji]

very very good,both them are awesome!!I love them very much~~good job,extremely nice performance

[ruixi111]

哎 岁月不饶人 qi qing 老了 ，但是他是流行音乐历史上的里程碑 ~ 不是昙花一现的流星

[vincentlee3434]

Chu Sheng sings even better than QiQin!!

[die4bleach]

nice

[ange11026]

Love QiQin so much, his song takes me to return to the time of my university, 1987.

[lomas2]

两位表现太好了！！！！

[jojoelephant]

chusheng really likes qi qin~~~

[BestF111]

time goes by...I knew him in 1987!!!

[yifengsy]

michael jackson turned white, qi qin turn black

[hellowjp]

！！！XD

[adam2006singapore]

haha you r so funny

[ruixi111]

haha

[awieshaker]

Qi Qin may be looking old in this video, but his voice is still so wonderful......

such a classic,i think the young guy have a bright future

[tgimul]

man what happen to qi qin

[jing2008]

he's the prince!

[yyaa2005]

I have to say both of them did badly in this song, esp. Qi Qin. He lost the pitch in the beginning. CCS was better but not very good either.

[tanialiu]

I loved Qi Qin too. He's brilliant. But in this video,he seems to be getting old...sign.... Chusheng is the new generation.

[cocolmz]

perfect!

CS is the best one.

[szxuzhou]

great singer! I love Qi Qin. I had been hearing his son within period of my university life. I think Chusheng will have gorgeous tomorrow.

[LOVECS2]

classic!

[chuchudongren]

chusheng u r the best.

[yess5678]

thank u very much 4 uploading

[christinelx]

thx for uploading!