That's where you mistake. There wouldn't be a better thing for an Israeli than to never have to deal with Palestinians. There wouldn't be a nicer thing that to spend their money on making their country even better, without worrying about defense budget. Again, what real proof do you have to say Israel (and by Israeli, do you refer to a particular soldier, the whole army, or the entire nation?) tortures, rapes and uses Palestinians for target practice? You have none, because it's not true.
As a Jew, grand-daughter of the survivors, I feel disguted by this false comparison between the Holocaust and Gaza. It is an insult to the victims of one of the biggest tragedies in history, its victims and their descendants.
@cpeigney94 the white man murdered 18 million first nations people in north america over 4 or 5 hundred years, so much for holocausts. dont beleave me ? check it out.
@tonybenn1000 You're ran out of arguments? Stop using real causes as a shield for your fake one. It takes half a brain to notice, if we wanted the extermination of all Palestinians we could have had it done, in days, a while ago. I'd say they should be thankful is not Britain, or Russia, or USA, or China, or France, or any big power in that sense, 'cause they'd be all casualties by now.
@cpeigney94 i dont know how old you are, but ive been following this since israel invaded Arub countrys in 1967. yes you could exterminate all Palestinians but, then you wouldnt be able to have fun torturing raping & using them for target practice anymore. Even with half a brain, you should know that. Heres hoping, the day will come soon, when you get yours!
great song . when will people and nations stand up for the poor people of palistine. treated like shit just to please israeli people who believe they hav a right to other peoples land.
This song is so overdramatic. This wall is merely the security the Israelis need (you can check how suicide bombings have become almost unexistent since it that wall is up, even car thievery is as low as ever for God's sake) and this wall will at the same time serve as a border between the two states, Jewish and Arab. It ain't about killing Palestinians and making them suffer.
@cpeigney94 yes, but the reason i was thinking of, is, because israel has W.M.D.s & their Palistinan victims are poor & can only fight back by taking their own lives. in other words, Israel drops bombs & their victims have no bombs or planes or tanks.
@tonybenn1000 One thing is to strap yourself in a bomb and massacring anyone around (never mind them, those pesky people daring to eat at that restaurant or going to school on that bus). Another is to be in a war, with a country's military bombing legitimate targets. Israel's position is hard, having your enemy in a crowded place like Gaza, were they conveniently attack from civilian infraestructure. Collateral damage is minimal compared to what it could be if Israel were out to get civilians.
@cpeigney94 my point is- Israel has a (very)powerfull military that drops bombs on those pesky people with their little children in Gaza massacring them in, OH, i forgot, they don't have restaurants any more. well, killing them on the school bus or in the rubble that once was their HOMES. now dont get me wrong, i know them Palistinians are a threat with all those sticks& stones they keep throughing, & those people on them boats keep trying to bring them more sticks& stones BUT i think were safe
@tonybenn1000 Do you have proof that Israel purposely goes after civilians? Because the suicide bombings thingy and the rockets make their intention very clear, no one can discuss the contrary. There is, however, plenty of proof showing the militarization of civilian and UN infraestrusture. Yeah, that's a war crime right there. No, sticks are no threats. Rocks kill, so I agree on that one. More than the rocks, is the rockets and 'martyrs' we worry the most about.
@neil67d i know of the Rachel Corrie murder. thats what Israel is good at, murdering unarmed defenseless ANGELS. i never met you my dear, but, i love you & i will NEVER stop loving you & what you did for those oppressed & (still) helpless people. DOWN WITH ISRAEL& THEIR PUPPETS in the White shit House!
David Rovics has seen this video and approves. I do see your point, but, unfortunately it seems necessary to me to still to point out that Israel is doing to the Palestinians now what the Nazis did to Jews during WW 2. Perhaps it's what the powerful will always do to the weak when we discard our sense of humanity. Peace etc.
@mukmakumkum I agree that the pictures are difficult to look at and perhaps there should be a warning, but the "hopeful peace music" is strengthened when it acknowledges the graphic reality of violence. There could have been some pictures of the wall though. There is beautiful graffiti on that horrible wall.
The message of this song is for peace. Instead, you made a slideshow of pictures of angry people burning Israeli flags. So by the pictures, it seems like your message is "throw the Jews back into the sea."
I feel that the pictures to this video misrepresent the meaning of the song. David Rovics is singing about the wrongness of the actions taken by the Israeli government of building a wall to segregate the Israeli and Palestinian people
As I wrote an article today: The Wall/Fence in Bil'in: 2005-2010, I began and ended with quoting THIS song from Rovic's, who btw-i heard live at TIKKUN's first conference for Spiritual Progressives in July 2005.
Much gratitude to thatssamhesgreat for great rendition.
Are the germans a crazy people? Is germany in trouble with any country? But the jews are again under hate!! Why is that so!! Their bad behave has already create more hate for some centuries to come. There are no difference betwin the Warsov gheto and the Gaza stripe. I become to wonder that the jews must have had some reason to have been so much hated in Europe in the 30's. Today it is becoming understendable, when we see the atrocities they do.
"Israel loves children so we will infact not try to lessen colleteral damage and instead bomb residental areas and use white phosphorus and let our snipers wear T-shirt that claim that shooting children is ok since they will turn out to be terrorists anyway"
That's where you mistake. There wouldn't be a better thing for an Israeli than to never have to deal with Palestinians. There wouldn't be a nicer thing that to spend their money on making their country even better, without worrying about defense budget. Again, what real proof do you have to say Israel (and by Israeli, do you refer to a particular soldier, the whole army, or the entire nation?) tortures, rapes and uses Palestinians for target practice? You have none, because it's not true.
cpeigney94 2 months ago
As a Jew, grand-daughter of the survivors, I feel disguted by this false comparison between the Holocaust and Gaza. It is an insult to the victims of one of the biggest tragedies in history, its victims and their descendants.
cpeigney94 3 months ago
@cpeigney94 the white man murdered 18 million first nations people in north america over 4 or 5 hundred years, so much for holocausts. dont beleave me ? check it out.
tonybenn1000 3 months ago 2
@tonybenn1000 You're ran out of arguments? Stop using real causes as a shield for your fake one. It takes half a brain to notice, if we wanted the extermination of all Palestinians we could have had it done, in days, a while ago. I'd say they should be thankful is not Britain, or Russia, or USA, or China, or France, or any big power in that sense, 'cause they'd be all casualties by now.
cpeigney94 3 months ago
@cpeigney94 i dont know how old you are, but ive been following this since israel invaded Arub countrys in 1967. yes you could exterminate all Palestinians but, then you wouldnt be able to have fun torturing raping & using them for target practice anymore. Even with half a brain, you should know that. Heres hoping, the day will come soon, when you get yours!
tonybenn1000 3 months ago 2
great song . when will people and nations stand up for the poor people of palistine. treated like shit just to please israeli people who believe they hav a right to other peoples land.
MrWolftone1 3 months ago
what the fuck. Some pictures should not be shown. Dumb cunt!
ZOMBIExDUBZ 3 months ago
This song is so overdramatic. This wall is merely the security the Israelis need (you can check how suicide bombings have become almost unexistent since it that wall is up, even car thievery is as low as ever for God's sake) and this wall will at the same time serve as a border between the two states, Jewish and Arab. It ain't about killing Palestinians and making them suffer.
cpeigney94 4 months ago
@cpeigney94 ever wonder, why there are no Israeli suicide bombers ?
tonybenn1000 3 months ago 2
@tonybenn1000 Because in a civilized society, it is unacceptable and deeply discouraged.
cpeigney94 3 months ago
@cpeigney94 yes, but the reason i was thinking of, is, because israel has W.M.D.s & their Palistinan victims are poor & can only fight back by taking their own lives. in other words, Israel drops bombs & their victims have no bombs or planes or tanks.
tonybenn1000 3 months ago 3
@tonybenn1000 One thing is to strap yourself in a bomb and massacring anyone around (never mind them, those pesky people daring to eat at that restaurant or going to school on that bus). Another is to be in a war, with a country's military bombing legitimate targets. Israel's position is hard, having your enemy in a crowded place like Gaza, were they conveniently attack from civilian infraestructure. Collateral damage is minimal compared to what it could be if Israel were out to get civilians.
cpeigney94 3 months ago
@cpeigney94 my point is- Israel has a (very)powerfull military that drops bombs on those pesky people with their little children in Gaza massacring them in, OH, i forgot, they don't have restaurants any more. well, killing them on the school bus or in the rubble that once was their HOMES. now dont get me wrong, i know them Palistinians are a threat with all those sticks& stones they keep throughing, & those people on them boats keep trying to bring them more sticks& stones BUT i think were safe
tonybenn1000 3 months ago 3
@tonybenn1000 Do you have proof that Israel purposely goes after civilians? Because the suicide bombings thingy and the rockets make their intention very clear, no one can discuss the contrary. There is, however, plenty of proof showing the militarization of civilian and UN infraestrusture. Yeah, that's a war crime right there. No, sticks are no threats. Rocks kill, so I agree on that one. More than the rocks, is the rockets and 'martyrs' we worry the most about.
cpeigney94 3 months ago
@cpeigney94 or should rthat be 'Painy'- what an idiot you are.
GazaMhara 4 weeks ago
Remeber Rachel Corrie. She was only one American girl murdered, but symbolic of what Apartheid does.
neil67d 1 year ago 2
@neil67d i know of the Rachel Corrie murder. thats what Israel is good at, murdering unarmed defenseless ANGELS. i never met you my dear, but, i love you & i will NEVER stop loving you & what you did for those oppressed & (still) helpless people. DOWN WITH ISRAEL& THEIR PUPPETS in the White shit House!
tonybenn1000 3 months ago 2
David Rovics has seen this video and approves. I do see your point, but, unfortunately it seems necessary to me to still to point out that Israel is doing to the Palestinians now what the Nazis did to Jews during WW 2. Perhaps it's what the powerful will always do to the weak when we discard our sense of humanity. Peace etc.
thatssamhesgreat 1 year ago 4
If you want peace, please replace these hateful pictures, or if you're for war, replace the hopeful peace music. Thank you for your consideration.
mukmakumkum 1 year ago
@mukmakumkum I agree that the pictures are difficult to look at and perhaps there should be a warning, but the "hopeful peace music" is strengthened when it acknowledges the graphic reality of violence. There could have been some pictures of the wall though. There is beautiful graffiti on that horrible wall.
Ecdysiast96 1 year ago
The message of this song is for peace. Instead, you made a slideshow of pictures of angry people burning Israeli flags. So by the pictures, it seems like your message is "throw the Jews back into the sea."
mukmakumkum 1 year ago
@mukmakumkum only the ones runing things in israel
tonybenn1000 3 months ago
I feel that the pictures to this video misrepresent the meaning of the song. David Rovics is singing about the wrongness of the actions taken by the Israeli government of building a wall to segregate the Israeli and Palestinian people
mukmakumkum 1 year ago
As I wrote an article today: The Wall/Fence in Bil'in: 2005-2010, I began and ended with quoting THIS song from Rovic's, who btw-i heard live at TIKKUN's first conference for Spiritual Progressives in July 2005.
Much gratitude to thatssamhesgreat for great rendition.
little sister,
xoxe
eileenfleming 1 year ago
Free Palestine NOW!!
ladylaylove 2 years ago
very emotional song... really love it
jusxanovaxgurl 2 years ago 2
Are the germans a crazy people? Is germany in trouble with any country? But the jews are again under hate!! Why is that so!! Their bad behave has already create more hate for some centuries to come. There are no difference betwin the Warsov gheto and the Gaza stripe. I become to wonder that the jews must have had some reason to have been so much hated in Europe in the 30's. Today it is becoming understendable, when we see the atrocities they do.
airesfebecker 3 years ago
Comment removed
airesfebecker 3 years ago
Ah, now I see. It's the Palestinians made the Israels kill the children. The excuse of all bullies.
Be good to yourself and try love instead of hate for even five minutes.
Best Regards etc.
thatssamhesgreat 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dumb fuck
the film shows that he is helping the kid move to a more secure side.
They hide behind children
WHO ARE THE CHILDREN... It is their own children they try to protect them from FUCKING NAZIES LIKE YOU
search you tube for the movie
israel love peace. israel love childrens
and let the whole world see for themselves who is the FUCKING NAZI TERRORISTS
ALSO search for "occupation 101"
zizo5558 3 years ago
@zizo5558
"Israel loves children so we will infact not try to lessen colleteral damage and instead bomb residental areas and use white phosphorus and let our snipers wear T-shirt that claim that shooting children is ok since they will turn out to be terrorists anyway"
WhimsicalQuandary 2 years ago
" وَلَنَبْلُوَنَّكُمْ بِشَيْءٍ مِنَ الْخَوْفِ وَالْجُوعِ وَنَقْصٍ مِنَ الْأَمْوَالِ وَالْأَنْفُسِ وَالثَّمَرَاتِ وَبَشِّرِ الصَّابِرِينَ"
[ ولا تَهِنُوا ولا تَحْزَنُوا وأَنتُمُ الأَعْلَوْنَ إن كُنتُم مُّؤْمِنِينَ
alaa0324 3 years ago