Here Without You (Carth & Revan)

[SionnachieMel]

I would've never thought of it, but this song *is* a perfect fit for that story. Wow. "When the last one falls, when it's all said and done, it gets hard, but it won't take away my love," pretty much sums up what Carth is about,why KotOR was so heartbreaking, and why the guy has such an army of female fans. The footage from the battle of Telos, implying her presence in his mind even in the middle of the firefight was particularly affecting.

[ThePadawanK]

I really love Carth. I want him to marry me.

[TheTotallyEvil]

I am really glad I'm not the only one who really likes a Cartoon Character!!!!!!!

[lordrevan12]

bravo this was a good video

bravo questa era una buona video

[Hailegirl256]

God who doesnt want a Carth Onasi in their lives? I would totally give up my bf for Carth. Damn KOTOR for having such an irrestible pilot...I cry everytime I watch it.

[LadyRevan7]

man, i wish i had one!!

[icookie3]

Oh,,,awesome video...

I LOVE CARTH AND REVAN!!

xDD

[LadyRevan7]

whenever i hear this song now i think of Carth and Revan. :)

btw, where did you get the poem/quote at the end? did you make it up or is it a quote from somewhere? i'd like to put it in my favorite quotes on Facebook if you don't mind

[Tinwelindon]

It's Shakespeare... from Hamlet, I think :)

[LadyRevan7]

oooh ok, thank you! ^_^

[Joisan08]

@Tinwelindon Yep, it's Hamlet

[daddysg1rl]

OMG!!!! this is awesome!!! The funny thing is, I just heard this song for the first time a couple days ago, and the first thought to pop in my head was 'gee this would be PERFECT for Carth/LSF Revan', then I get on here and lo and behold you beat me to it =) inner fangirl so veeery happpy!!!

[carth101]

Carth is the man!! Carth Forever

[hollycallison7]

You made me cry and add another song to my Carth/Revan collection. Good video

[sethrulz117]

omg this almost made me cry! carth and revan 4ever! ^.^ and dont listen to the ppl who say that revan hsould ALWAYS BE A MALE. yea canaly he is but u dont have to make revan a male. anyway great vid! cant wait for more! ^.^

carth+revan=<3 4ever!

[LadyRevan7]

awesome!! it almost made me cry..

Revan and Carth 4ever! ^_~

[TheShadowcil]

Carth + Revan <3

I'm curious if Bioware will make a KOTOR 3 and if they do, it would be reallly sweet if the main character was Revan again. Or, in a way play the Exile and Revan both at once.

I wish the Carth Revan romance could have been more detailed. =(

I like the song and it's sad, poor Carth. =(

[JJmakesfunofu]

Yes they are infact making Kotor 3 right now and when it does come out im going to kill to get it XD

[luckycharmer711]

Great video. It's sad, but fabulous.

How did you get Carth in the training cutscene? I'm sort of jealous.

[olie266]

if ur a guy in kotor u think carths a bit of a twa* rlly

[luckycharmer711]

Sounds like you would have a lot in common.

[Tatooine92]

Lovely video. ^_^

[relyna123]

Dang it! Now I got that song stuck in my head! And it's probably gonna stick in my head for the next couple of days...or longer. LOL! :p I'm just kidding. Great video! Love it!

[solidsnake1209]

i still like the vid tinwelindon good job

[KatKlaw3]

YAY CARTH <3 =D

[DaughterofRevan]

love this one! carth and revan are such a great couple!

[Tinwelindon]

Huh, I finally managed to upload the corrected version... hopefully there won't be a problem with that too, or I'll go crazy :D

[SoulCatcher12]

Hey,I have an idea.How about remaking the video,but having like 10 seconds of nothing added to it.So the extra part gets cut and we can hear that awesome ending!

[Tinwelindon]

I'm very busy at the moment, but I promise if I have a little time I'll remake it :)

[tehPrincessJ]

This is beautiful.

[MyLifeUncut88]

this vid is amazing!! i could watch it again and again!

[Achrones]

Me too! :D

[Hailegirl256]

Omg can you believe all the people who love Carth? My little sister has a HUGE crush on him! She wont stop talking about him! I regret letting her watch me play KOTOR now....

[stargate12345678]

lolm rofl loll sorry man just funny

[SoulCatcher12]

Have you ever thought of remaking the the vid

so that the last part of it be included.

It's like that one phrase completes this awesome vid!

[Tinwelindon]

I've done that all right, tried to upload, too, but youtube still left out the quote...dunno what to do then :S

[Hailegirl256]

One of the best Vids I have seen! Sorry I cant stop commenting though  (its addicting = P) But anyway BEST VID EVR!

[heihachi89]

Tin, you are a brilliant, remarkable, talanted person. First youtube clip I ever saw, and the was a year ago. And I STILL love this clip.

Go you good thing!

[Tinwelindon]

Thank you very much :D

[truebeliever94]

great video!

[Hailegirl256]

It doesnt matter what the hell Revan was supposed to be! That is why they gave the choice! NO ONE CARES IF REVAN WAS A GUY OR GIRL! but anyway I think it is better with Carth because he doesnt bitch as much as Bastila

[sirius1606]

Good job... Nice video.. But.. I checked on starwars/wiki.. Its agreed that Revan was a Male.... I dont know if I like it.. Whats better? Bastila With Revan or Carth?

[truebeliever94]

since I'm a girl, I don't want to be a male and fall in love with Bastilla, so I think its either way, just because to people who made it were like: well its going to be a male, but hey, lets make it a girl too! so the users can decide.

its fine, hes a guy to the men and a woman to the women.

I just like playing it as a her, much more fun to me, even tho I haven't played it as a guy

[SubasatheNinja]

In the books, Revan was written as a dude. But not to worry, in the second game, the Jedi Exile is supposed to be a girl. They allow you to choose just so that you aren't forced to play and what's awesome is that they have different storylines for each gender and faction(Sith or Republic).

[badazz5001]

what books?!!!!!

[SubasatheNinja]

Darth Bane: Path of Destuction

Darth Bane: Rule of Two

The Offical Star Wars Chronology

[Hailegirl256]

This has to be one of the best vids I have seen on here if not the best! The whole Romance between Carth and Revan fit this song really good and how you substituted Carth for Bastila walking through the courtyeard with Revan was genius

[Tinwelindon]

thanx:)

[truebeliever94]

so sad!!!!

[littleaya]

I love this even though it makes me cry. i love to listen to this and you did an awsome job!

[Tinwelindon]

Thanx :D

[Hailegirl256]

i cant believe its comming out! finally! i cant believe it! i love the games i know more about them than anyone i know! if anyone wants to see who knows more email me about it

[Hailegirl256]

is march 09 yr or day?

[beastitup11]

friend works for kotor studioes release "cough" march 09

[GermanPrincess88]

This is so sad. I hope they get reunited in kotor 3...if it comes out one day

[Hailegirl256]

Best work ever! when Carth and Revan are walking through the jedi enclave on Dantooine he looks so real!

[Hailegirl256]

Gees i luv this vid.... if they would only make a kotor3......

[folsom90]

all i heard  star wars knight of the old republic 3

jide exali from kotor 2 looking for revan

and seva shr/him or kill revan on unknown regions thet all i know abuot it

maybe playing at revan again in

star wars knight of the republic 3

that i whet to see but tall me whet day is

star wars knight of the old repulic 3 coming out i need to know

[gbaileyonline]

i blubered like baby watching this. *hugs carth*

[WRLstark]

This almost made me cry

Best Work Ever!

[WRLstark]

KOTOR 3 is coming out

my dad is friends with a producer of it

dont know which company

but its rumored that Revan comes back from the Unkown Regions of Space

i find the storyline sad though

Revan left behind all who he loved to go fight the true war

[Angelkat95]

I think i found out about kotor 3's story line!!! Revan leaves carth and the republic, and travels to the unknown regions, to find out about the true sith!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I heard Revan returns to carth (or Bastila).

[DarthJebus05]

Thats KOTOR 2's story line...

[LovingYouForever4455]

OMG!!!! You did such a good job on this vid!!! Keep up the good work =]

[dhtrofisis]

Nice Video! Absolutely lovely and I liked the use of Mods you put in there (I'm pretty sure Cjt deserves a fangirl medal for her mod :p). You know if you ever tweak it the only thing that could make it better is having Carth say his K2 quote at the end. "Simple tell her that Carth Onasi is waiting for her" Aww I'm all mushy now.

[kingu9]

i like female revan its unexpected lol

[Darthtraya89]

Shit man Carth and revan make a bad couple only revan and bastila or exile and handmaiden or Visas or Female exile with atton and disciple are good....

[atracin]

although Revan was supposed to be a guy, this vid is nice. Still wierd to see revan as a girl.

[Malestorm87]

SUCK ICE, I TELL YOU!!!

[Malestorm87]

but yes, the third jedi would SUCK ICE!

[Malestorm87]

Apparently, Obsidion and Bioware are making one right now. should be oyt for christmas, or middle next year. but I hope for the entire game you sort of flick between the stories of Revan and the Exile. That way, I get both of my Fav fly boys, Atton and Carth

CARTH AND ATTON RULE!

[Centurion480]

I hate to burst your bubble but you must of heard a rumor. Bioware said they will NOT make another game. Obsidian said they would but so far Lucasarts hasnt given the initiative.

The third game is NOT currently being made.

[Angelkat95]

damn right(carth seems gay!!!)

[LeahXGaara]

that would SUCK if they make you play as ANOTHER new character, i hope you play revan the most, or at least get a REALY good ending movie about revan and carth (or bastila if you play a dude)

[MaggOnasi]

That would suck, if there even was a next game

[Malestorm87]

The theory about the next game is this:

You return as another jedi after encounterind t3-m4 looking for one to re-unite the pary members of Revan and the Exile for one last stand beyond the outer rim. Ouch, that gotta hurt. Brilliant vid. It makes me cry. You should make one about the Exile and Atton, or, if your desprate, the Exile and disiple. I don't think very highly of Disiple. I think he's a nancy boy who doesn't deserve the Exile.

[Hutu58]

Waaahhh! It's so sad! The song fits perfectly...

[LovingYouForever4455]

great vid! U made me cry dang it!

[dhtrofisis]

Another great video, your editing is really top notch. And is that uniform mod a lifesaver for Carth fans or what? Red armor... *shudders* Good job and I think i shall trot over to your page to look for more Kotor goodness.

[solidsnake1209]

i still watch this its a good vid ^_^

[solidsnake1209]

carth and reven better get a happy ending lol other then that good vid

[Zolorocks4192]

that is SOOOO COOL!!!!

[CloudPimp]

if revan and carth dont get a happy ending I'm gonna SCREAM

[MaggOnasi]

Tinwelindon curse you!! I cant stop watching this super coolaide video I love it sooo much!!!

[OnamiKitty]

I know this is lame but this vid makes me cry every time I see it. I have to congratulate you for making this from the very depths of my heart. Thank you.

[Linkforlife199]

This is one of the, if not the best KOTOR videos I have seen!! You should make more like this!!

[laughingaussie90]

Cool video.

I think i prefer the male version of revan though.

[KraytSithLord]

You know Tinwelindon, you are going on my top favorites, my suscribers, my friends, and you are invited to my stream cus of this vid. Im sorry that alot of assholes like calhall4892 keep insulting you like that. They must have had too much too drink. Or they were born assholes, but tell me what band this is from

[WeirdActress]

lol this is one of the best video's about Kotor ive seen. Tinwelindon, you did a super job with this video

[lamaina]

OMG calhall! How could u say that?

This video is awesome. Please do me a favour:

go home and ........... Ok?! Thanx!!!

[KraytSithLord]

Seriously, he acts like a 2 yeer old......

[dru15]

Calhall!!

Go to hell. Bunkó, világít a szádban a negró!!!!

[Gramenna]

Calhall4892!!!!! If you don't like the video, watch something else. I don't care. Why are you so shit-kicker? IT IS THE SHAME THAT INSTEAD OF YOUR AGE YOU ARE SPEAKING LIKE THIS!! Furthermore the music is very good, and the video is well-made.

I understand that you are old and burnt-out but you shouldn't speak like this. Think about it!!!

[datataco]

ur a major loser if u insut the dude who made this it's 1 of the best i've seen ur pathetic if u don't like it just shut up and leave!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[KraytSithLord]

Shut up, this video is one of my top favorites, you should be ashamed. Going around and being an asshole for no reason. Go and insult your mom, cuz she fucks with me every night!

[DARKTIGERKAT148]

ok is this game from the computer version of KOTTR cause i have the Xbox and game and maybe if this one is from Xbpx then can you tell me some hints throught the game cause i know there are parts of the game i havent completed yet, even though i rapped the game a few times too.

[Tinwelindon]

Why was Mandalore there? I don't know:-)I liked that scene, so I put it in.

[WeirdActress]

at 3:16 why was Mandalor there?

[WeirdActress]

It's a mod you can download

[chris26moss]

Hum..seems there are many differances between the xbox and pc 1..starting with carths uniform

[Allronix]

Some REALLY sweet use of modding here! I'm gonna need to glom some of that.

[Padawanmage]

Where can I get the mod where they kiss?

[reikutoukijin]

Do a search for Carth Romance fix. That should get you there, no problem.

[Padawanmage]

Cool! I'm doing a visual walkthrough of the game and I'll be sure to use this to show what a kiss is really all about. Thanks!

[WeirdActress]

Play it on PC and download it

[TikiTyler9]

Do they really kiss in the game? I've played it a couple times as a girl and I never got a kiss! LOL

[Allronix]

It's a mod - CJ102 did a little tweak of the animation in that scene to give us girls a kiss.

[WeirdActress]

We played the same people FINNALY!!!

[Tinwelindon]

Says you. I know female is non-canon, but I'm a girl, so I play with a female character, because it's easier for me. There are a lot of arguments about this topic, but everybody can play as they want to.

[ThoraxeRMGSAMA]

Too bad Revan is TRULY A male.

[Padawanmage]

Geez, get over yourself. Play as you want and let others play as they want. Make your own vids and post them as well.

[WeirdActress]

HOWD U GET CARTH AND REVEN TO KISS????

[SWMaster1]

0 0 Wow. Awesome vid! That there, my friends is talent o

[Tinwelindon]

Yes, it's an Elvish word.

[YenLedaSade]

Beautiful video, so sad...makes me cry everytime that I see it.

Thanks for the vid Tinwelindon.

A question, your nick is something that has to do with Tolkien? n,n

[SoulCatcher12]

so...beautiful...

*crying*

[dru15]

Oh my god!! Tinwelindon it's really good.

Oh mio Dio!! É perfetto. Mi piace molto.

[liz7890]

it's ok, and thanks! ^,^

[Tinwelindon]

I don't mind =)

Carth says: "Simply tell her, that Carth Onasi is waiting for her." I think it suits well at the end of the vid, and I'm really sorry that it had left out.

[liz7890]

umm... I know that you put a quote in but I only hear "simp-" At least that's what I think I hear. What is it supposed to say? If you don't mind.

[Tinwelindon]

No problem :-)Thank's, anyway.

[KotorBrokensaints]

Maybe I didn't notice it earlier. My mistake. The video is awesome.

[Tinwelindon]

I did finish this video with a quote from Carth, but somehow it left out. I noticed it after the update. My PC plays the whole vid, so I don't know what's the problem.

[KotorBrokensaints]

I saw the quote, my mistake. The video is awesome.

[KotorBrokensaints]

That was nicely done. If you do this again with another style video it may be cool if you finish off the video with a quote from one of the characters, something deep and meaningful. Though I'm sure you might have already thought about that.

[Dashbored]

good, I liked it.