Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (122)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • was david chewing gum? lol 

  • @24angiejolie he always does when he singings these days, calls it a mental crush, he says he doesn't think he sings as well without chewing cinnamon gum at the same time. LOL

  • Kradm and Cookie.... :D

  • Adam is wearing a Skingraft vest. last I looked it was on sale for $89

  • Adam Lambert = best american idol ever . . . I also LOVE Andy skib in this vid

  • Adam Lambert = best American Idol ever

  • they don't hold a candle to cookie. not with this song. cook is what american idol stars are made of.

  • Adam # 1 and then David cook :)

  • SO FRICKING SEXY!!!! I'm gonna die!!! Kris is so adorable and Adams so fabulous and I WAS THERE IT WAS MY BIRTHDAY :)

  • i love david and kris guitar. its esy to fall in love in a guy with a guitar

  • they're all God damn freakin sexy!

  • DAVID COOK FOREVER!

  • ADAM<3

  • Adam Lambert is my favorite one up there. Wow he is sexy. Too bad he is gay. The other two I like also but ADAM......... HOT

  • ADAM..... That is all I can say. LOL. David and Kris are cute also.

  • Why can't everyone just accept all of them? They're both amazing in their own way.. David is amazing at guitar and singing, Adam sings AWSOME vocally, and Kris is amazing and nice, and talented at singing.. Why can't people stop fighting over whose better?

  • @ChristineDrewFan agree , but David 's voice is the strongest  among them let alone Chris Daughtry :)

  • @arbonjovi LoL.. i guess it's just a matter of preference.. I love all of them in their own unique way, and can't choose one who sings better than the other.. But my favourite is Adam/Kris because they learn towards my kind of music.. But I love David, and I agree that he rocks everything in this..

  • You can argue all you want about who's better....but we should all agree on this: all three of them OWN the jonas brothers.

  • triplethreat789 .. i was there! they didnt even reherse i was amazed that it sounded so good. yeah kris and adam were a little confused but it was amazing anyway<3 i dieddddd. adam<3

  • It looks so funny. Do you think that they even rehearsed this? Kris is looking at David most of the time like he's waiting for a que or something.

  • i saw kris want to sing, but he didn't sing because he can't follow david cook...HAHA...

  • adam is so hot and so good!!!!a real champion!

  • woohoo! way better than the jonas brothers

  • omq would youu all leave Kris alone.! He apperently won idol for a reasonn? rightt! They are all three totally different d=sinqers and they cant pick a song all three of them can do perfectlyy!

    Iloveyouukris♥ Iqnor these HATERS!>:/

  • I thought David Cook was awesome in this. Props to him for giving such a good performance considering all he's been through these past few months. I hate how people compare the 3 and say Adam is the best or David... Kris got a really loud cheer from the audience, and that performance of "Heartless" was great. Give him some credit too. But I loved all three :)

  • yah!

  • i am the biggest adam fan ever, so dont get think i am dissing him in any way but kris CAN sing... he may not be as vocally inclined (good word choice i think) haha, as adam but come on he is really good. and i have nothing bad to say about david cook because he was my favorite last season. Adam is still the best though!

  • I like david's voice..it's kind of HOT - adam is MY FAVE of course...david's is different though I do likey......but I still wish I could hear adam more here....I don't like it when he sings with the rest cuz he has to hold back....

  • kris obiously, can't sing this song, is completely not for him and for his voice.

  • i think david cook might be a litle too manly for these two. adam's too girly and kris is too scrawny. we need a real man for this one and i think david cook is the one. sorry he wins here. kris just seems like he's just struggling to sing this song. a song he obviously can't sing on his own.

  • i agree with u lol =]

  • Comment removed

  • Kris is so awesome!!

  • I fell in love with David again...

  • i was here!!! <3

  • i think adam has better stage presence

  • u think? adam looks hot just standing around. know hes gay but damm he is hot

  • gay people cant be hot? lol

  • haha that's great.

  • but some are..

  • i was being sarcastic because someone said he's gay but he's hot, i know some gay people are hot just like some straight people are hot

  • How awesome is David Cook?! It's soo good to see him again and both Kris and Adam were good too! Thanks for this!

  • its obvious ppl in the audience like adam better. you would be stupid not to.

  • Is david cook a lefty?...He's holding the fret bar with his right hand.

  • Yep he's a lefty.

  • That's so weird, so is david archuleta XD

  • so am i :)

  • kris is so goofy lol.. he doesn't seem to know when 'not' to sing! haha.. adam's very cool.

  • The drummer looked like he was having a GREAT time! Haha!

  • ADAM is AWESOME !!!!!!!!

  • I'll take Kris over Adam any day!

  • kris allen you can't sing rock. admit it, man, david and adam are huge, you're just a lil finger on their toes. ROCK ON!

  • i fookin love kris allen! he's so cute!!!! gahh.

  • I will always state my opinion, anyone has the right to disagree with me, but when you make it personal, well I don't let that go. You made it personal, so I replied to that. If you didn't want a fight, why did you make it one? I won't reply anymore to this, I said I liked all three, never said one bad thing about David, Adam or Kris. Others did........wonder who? :(

  • lets see. adams not an idol bcuze he didnt win =( and kris is no idol bcuze hes just not a very good singer. but david won and he can sing great, therefore he's the idol =P

  • despite how many records DC has sold, just look back to all of his "idol performances", each track he did he's done it like his own while others were mostly doing "karaoke"! No comments on Adam or Kris but DC? He's the BEST !!!! Subject closed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Just because you said subject closed don't make it so! Adam's performances were never Karaoke. I won't get into a discussion any longer about this, I did vote for David Cook and I also voted for Adam Lambert. I think they BOTH will be just fine. There is no reason to put one down to make the one you like "look" better, what is this HighSchool?

  • Just like Simon always says: Just an opinion! And that's what we are all doing here, right? No body's putting anyone down or pinpointing anyone who's doing karaoke but aren't we all have the right to reflect how we feel after seeing the performance? If anyone remembers the comment Simon gave to DC after his performance of "always be my baby" then one should know what i mean to say. Don't get personal, just an opinion!

  • Yeah ok, you do have the right to reflect your opinion and I do respect that. I just got carried away by another in what I felt got personal with my opinion, so its all good.

  • adam and kris sang two lines...listen david cook is no where near as popular as ADAM LAMBERT...and he will never be..btw i like david cook

  • Adam is the ONLY star there.. No one can outshine him because he´s the biggest &brightest star..

    He´s extremely awesome... and hot by the way

  • Cook outshined Kris and Adam? Maybe because they almost did not sing? LOL!

  • i know that david cook's album is in a stage of platinum record since he guest in AI last season,,i hope his album goes to double platinum or a diamond album,,,!! david cook rocks!

  • Kris IS a cutie. He just needs more practice with his stage presence. I still see him as having a lot of potential. Time will tell and I hope he surprises us all.

  • I wish all three had had more time to rehearse. Kris looked at home on David's stage. Adam looked awkward. No one was holding Adam back from "getting into the song". Adam did that to himself. David outshone him. That's all. IMO and a lot of others who were at the concert and have seen the videos.

  • Yeah it is your opinion. I have looked at the video and so has alot of others I know too as you say, and Adam looked at home just as much if not more than David or Kris. Adam didn't hold back, he has respect for David since he was the one singing the song, so of course he could have took it over, and I am SURE rocked it out, but he isn't like that, so if that to you is David outshining him, then ok. David Cook did great, so did Adam and Kris with what they were given. NOONE outshone anyone.

  • On the other hand, to me David's voice is soothing even when he's belting it out in his upper register. I never hear his singing as wailing or shouting. I've barely heard a false note from David. I've listened to a lot of his music and most recently his live performances.

  • Yes I love David's voice! He is a great performer too, I've seen him in concert a couple of times.

  • ilovedrums71: There is no disputing differences in tastes. I find Adam's voice thin and strident in the upper register. I really dislike the sound of his wailing. I do think his performance of Starlight was well controlled. Just doesn't move me.

  • Kris's rocking out is adorable

  • -the only thing that was good was the guitar playing IF I had to find something good. Even my younger son agrees with me. Darn, I expected much more from David Cook! Adam and Kris have been on tour every other day and are very tired, so this is understandable!

  • Well, ilovedrums71 you are certainly entitled to your opinion. Everyone has one as "they" say. I didn't hear any major pitch problems. And I didn't hear a whole lotta screaming either. But, just to keep you and everyone else who may not be as informed as I in the know, DC's been on the road singing at least 12 to 14 songs every night since mid-February on his Declaration Tour where he has to carry the load. The night before GMA he played to a sold-out Nokia in NYC. Just sayin'.

  • im sorry but I have to say ur so wrong when you say cook was very pitchy..This performance was spot on. I like Adam and Kris both.but cook totally outshined them both on this. And he should have.he sings this all the time on tour. I truely believe you were in the minority when you say cook was screaming and pitch. Its funny cuz ive seen so many comments coming from adam and kris fans saying how amazing cook was on this..they have even been coming to his website and saying this..

  • I am sorry but I totally disagree with you. How can you even say David Cook outshine Adam and Kris on this? Because of course he did, this is HIS song and he sang most of it. What part Kris and Adam did was great and spot on. No screaming, no holding back like you say. When someone is singing their own song, and singing most of it, of course you would say they shined on it, but outshine? NOWAY!

  • Did you say, "this is HIS song"? . . . as in . . . David Cook's?  he may be singing lead, but this is a cover tune. It is NOT his. Can you say Fleetwood Mac?

  • I can say Fleetwood Mac, I speak English, how about you? His song, as in he sings it in his concerts, his song as in he is singing it. Never said as in he wrote it or anything. Can you say Duh? lol

  • Who cares if you disagree with me.I sure dont.  I like all three of them, but I happen to think Cook looked like the star here.and he should have he has sang this song a million times. To the person below who said adam and kris are the stars and are more famous than cook..I laugh at that statement cuz, if you dont know it already, idol fame is fleeting. Sure they have alot of fans now, but most move on the next idol next year. REALITY. Cook has sold way over a million albums, and more downloads.

  • I am glad you don't care if I disagree with you. But here is a REALITY CHECK for you! Of course Cook has sold way over a million on his albums, he has a year on Adam and Kris. Just wait in a year, then see where Adam and Kris are. Of course David Cook looked like a Star, like you said he has sung that song a million times, Kris and Adam have not, yet to me they shone as well.

  • Gawd, who cares..I will not get in the stupid little fight of "my idol is better than yours" nah nah nah....so stupid..like I said I love them all....cook being my favorite. why cant you like all three.I think Adam has a spectacular voice and I hope he does very well. I love Kris and hope he does good also. David Cook has had nothing but raving things to say about adam and Kris. Hes really a stand up guy.

  • You are so right. They are all insanely talented. Cook is my favorite, too, but they all deserve success. They are all different so they will appeal to different people. But there's enough good stuff to go around and I want them all to be incredibly successful.

  • This was a CAMERA REHERSAL. You Do you know that?

  • Umm, yeah I do know it was a rehearsal. Ive seen the original too, just as Im sure you have. This is so hilarious. Its just like season 7 all over again. The archie and cook fanwars. geez...I like Adam and Kris..I will buy both of their records. Im just saying Cook looked liked the real star here. Do you adam fans think nobody else can shine except adam...? that nobody else can be remotely good? Please..

  • damn i agree luvablegurl89

  • david cook is the one man show, the other 2 are just fadding

  • It's adorable how Kris REALLY gets into the song!

    He'll be even more amazing when he has his own band that he's 100% comfortable with. Can't wait for his album! <3

  • David Cook truly rocks in the stage

  • My boy David steals the show. That dude can ROCK.

  • for those of you interested the original version of this song is by Fleetwood Mac. listen to the comparison

  • this original version of this song is one of my favorites and now that Kris, David, AND Adam sang it I love it even more!!!!!!!!!!!

  • adam and david <3

  • This is the soundcheck and apparently the only rehearsal they had. The actual performance was a lot better and would have been even better with more preparation.

    Kris looks so tiny standing between Adam and David. Bless him, so cute.

  • please i want this video to download :)

  • Oh yeah and this is the sound check - rehearsal. The final is on GMA. Kris goes to Neal Tieman's side of the stage. It's totally diff.

  • If you go to GMA Summer Concert Series, the sound is much much better, esp for Kris and Adam. That video is great for all 3 of them. This video is good, but a little distant from Kradam.

  • okay these guys were doing this cold as someone pointed out. which i think is pretty good that the three of them managed to pull it off.

    think of what would have happened if they would have actually worked longer? maybe then kris and adam wouldn't look so akward.

  • Kris rocking out has to be the strangest......cutest thing i've ever seen haha!! These are my 3 favorite idol guys so I can't say much bad about it.

  • LOL it is pretty funny. :)

  • kris seems kinda confused

  • totally! lol

  • Why were Kris and Adam basically singing backup!!!! I no David has a good voice, but that seems unfair to have Kradam up there most of the time doing nothing!!!!

  • i agree.. not enough KRADAM for my taste..:-(

  • I believe this is the SOUND check version, not the final version they posted on the GMA website -- you should check that on out on GMA. David is doing this song in concert -- since this was probably their ONLY chance to practice, they had to keep the group sing thing pretty simple and they did.

  • hmm. because they were singing backup?

    maybe next year for idol finale they can try this again. lol but it would be like three VERY different voices and unless (scream singing is involved..) David probably would naturally outsing them. Their voices are all WAY too different to compare

  • And why the fuck are they singing backup.

  • This was obviously David's performance, putting Kradam in there made it awkward. Not their type of song.

  • The song rocks at 1:22

  • Kris and Adam look a little ... ummm akward.

  • I agree. I don't think Kris' mic was working well as all b/c whenever him and David sing the chorus I can't hear him at all. and he goes out of frame too much.

    oh well it sounded amazing. David rocks. It was almost like he was trying to let Kris take some spotlight.

  • Yeah, and i thought it was hilarious that David was rocking out and Adam and Kris looked like they were holding back.

  • too many hotties in plaid here for me... LOL :P DC rocks

  • Adam has one line and he STEALS the song!!! SO hot!!

  • I LOVE David's voice and Kris's also, (along with his adorable rocking out!)

  • DUDE!

    adam sounds like ted neeley and looks like elvis presley here...cool!

    kris is adorable and david is awesome too!

  • lOL! tHIS IS lITTLE LIES THAT KRIS IS WINNER!

  • David sounds amazing!

  • aww kradam rockin out

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more