Added: 5 years ago
From: salx77
Views: 130,143
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (584)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • id like to know what happened between rose and the other doctor

  • awww 10 and rose <3

  • Comment removed

  • He burned up the sun to say goodbye. He burned up the sun to say GOODBYE. He fucking burned up the sun to say goodbye to his love. Ten/Rose for eternity!

  • Watching the Doomsday goodbye broke my heart all over again. WHY COULDN'T YOU JUST SAY IT YOU DIRTY ROTTEN %$@*%$* MOTHER #%#$& #$*P$@*#&% PIECE OF #*&_$*&@_#* ANGEL?!?!?!

  • This scene has me in tears every time. My heart is totally broken.

  • this scene had me crying on the couch for an hour.haha.Rose was my favorite companion and David Tennant will forever be my favorite doctor.

  • ...its exactly the same but with black and white and music?

  • @Renbournwuzere You gotta wait until the end. Then it changes to color and voila! Doctor and Rose hug.

  • Yes. I can accept this as an ending... It would've just given him some peace. If Dr Who ended this way, I would be pleased. Rose and The Doctor were meant for eachother since day one. It would've been nice to finally see it come to light

  • I wish it had ended somewhat like this! Also, I love this song, but I prefer Gary Allan's version! (:

  • I couldn't stand Rose 'cause her eyebrows make her look stupid.

  • @MajCinematic I've given Matt the chance and he just doesn't work as the doctor! some eps he is good but I don't think its him!! its this new writer! he's Rubbish!!!!

  • now thats how it should have ended!

  • :( I miss David.. Best doctor ever!

  • thumbs up if you know that scene by heart <3

  • We all know Martha looks better than rose. Man I will rock that woman's body... with my dick. Thumbs up if you don't like this comment and you'll accept my statement in a default of just saying, "Fuck it--why not them both?".

  • @ThyReturner lol, you wild man. you are a true fan, you had me laughing for a minute or two with that comment. you, sir, are correct. both is better.

  • I think Martha was just a rebound for the Doctor, he was just lonely and needed someone to hang around and bounce jokes off of (hey, traveling through time and space can get lonely). I cried at that scene because Rose never got a chance to hear the Doctor say those four blessed words to her ("I love you, too), and she never got a chance to hear them. It wasn't a secret how much they meant to eachother, but it would have been wonderful to see it come to light at last.

  • Doctor: "Rose Tyler, I-" *Disappears into nothingness*

    Rose: "I came all the way to Bad Wolf Bay for nothing!! Oh, screw it. I'll just get with Mickey again. Oh wait, he's magically with Martha now..." >:(

  • Why on Earth would anybody in their right mind want to see the Doctor and Rose as a couple?  It would be the end of the series.

  • Why on Earth would anybody in their right mind want to see the Doctor and Rose as a couple? It would be the end of the series.

  • I wish Rose and Ten made it back together they were the best couple, BUT, I will say I hope Billie Piper finishes whatever she is doing currently and returns to the show and becomes Matt's companion, I mean he is the same man in the story, so I am still hopeful!!!! :D

  • I'm not sobbing right now or anything.

    stupid onions

  • Nine was better than Ten. Nine sacrificed himself for Rose. Ten did not.

  • @mattlewis66 ten was so in love with rose he gave her another him that she could grow old with and never have a broken heart WHILE HE HAD TO GO ON LIVING HIS DAYS WITH A BROKEN HEART, KNOWING HE IS NEVER GOING TO SEE HER AGAIN, SO YOU CAN JUST SHUT YOUR MOUTH!!!!!

  • @imahyper1 No. In love is not the same as love. Love is sacrifice. And the whole human doctor thing was odd. Human doctor is not The Doctor. It's almost as if The Doctor was just too sublime for Rose, but we know that is not true at all. Rose could see the past and what could be. Rose saw every atom of the Dalek and "I divide them." Rose looked into the heart of the Tardis and it looked into her.

  • @mattlewis66 ummmm....random stuff at the end there XD and i completely get what you are saying, but ten DID sacrifice something for rose, he gave up his happiness, and yeah, the whole clone thing was weird, but how else can rose and him be together? he'll just go on living while she grows old and eventually dies. he couldn't watch that happen and the human-doctor was the best thing he could give her, they would grow old together and have a life, but he couldn't. that was his sacrifice to her.

  • @imahyper1 Sorry about that stream of consciousness. I was trying to make the point that Rose was more than a mere human after looking into the heart of the Tardis and could herself (if they wanted to write it this way) have travelled that impassable gap to see The Doctor again.

  • Stupid Parallel Universe ;n; I miss Rose and David together.

  • omg the doctor and rose slept together!!! look at how happy he is when he thinks she's pregnant, if he thought it was mickey's baby he wouldn't be at all happy... :o

  • @JakeDawsonHeimer False. They never did.

  • @JakeDawsonHeimer Dude, thats not kewl at all, if anything, he was a little jelous of the thought she might of slept with mickey, because he loved her. so please dont go around saying they slept together, it ruins the series for me, personally, and i'm sure for other people too.

  • @hossluver1994 That would be an EPIC shirt. "I would blow up a sun just to say goodbye."

  • I have the line you can't hear memorized....."I blew up a sun just to say goodbye."

    *dies*

  • yay!

  • I think that in each regeneration of the doctor, there is a different soul with the same memories and intelligence. I think that each time he regenerates the current soul dies and a new one is born within him. SPOILER FOR SEASON FOUR ENDING I also think that when the tenth doctor dies and eleven is born, the soul of the tenth doctor rejoins itself in the mortal form that stayed with Rose. That way all of the Tenth Doctor gets to live out his life with Rose instead of just a bit, leaving the res

  • Is it bad that I cried...I miss them both too much...

  • I wish rose would come back into the doctors life, I Miss you David!!

  • I GOT CHILLS WATCHING THIS 8( i miss this DOCTOR SO MCUH !!!!

  • Finally someone understands!!! Noone can beat Rose

    Donna became his best friend

    Jack is well Jack

    Martha is a wanna be Rose- You can tell because the Doctor takes her to places that hes been with Rose (or places much similar), he mentions her alot & he probably did this because he missed her so.

    So to ME there is only 1 DOCTOR & LOVER/BEST COMPANION - Rose Tyler (Billie Piper) & David Tennant (Doctor 10).

    Yet I love Catherine Tate(Donna) & Jack (John Barrowman)

    I no likey Martha though

  • @EdHardy2552 I agree with you, The 10th Doctor and Rose were the best partnership since Sarah Jane Smith (Elisabeth Sladen) and the 4th Doctor which was Tom Baker. Martha was the worst companion so far, always complaining and giving dirty looks and comments whenver the Doctor mentioned his beloved Rose. Donna understood that he loved and missed Rose and the smile Donna gives when he sees Rose again is so sweet and Jack was brought back to life by Rose so he has connection with her as well.

  • @NaleyJamGalexDempsey You are probably one of the very few (if not the only one) who understands & agrees with me!!!

  • @EdHardy2552 @naleyJamGalexDempsey Thanks both for your thoughts. I am enjoying Matt Smith as 11 - However, Amy shits me to tears.

  • @NaleyJamGalexDempsey i know right martha was so mean and crabby while everyone else believed they should be together

  • Oh how I wish it really did end that way...

  • The song fits sooooo perfectly~

  • 86 people are hearless gits nd did not cry to doomsday

  • @GerbilGobler

    I laughed

  • Am I the only fan who did not cry at the end of "Doomsday"?

  • uspelled doctor wrong in the credits u said dotor

  • @KillJoyLover Thanks

  • @KillJoyLover you spelled you wrong lol

  • is it bad that I was saying all the lines with them?

  • @Kkthenerdfighter I hope not cause I was too! :P

  • :D

  • i definitely watched the ending of series two today. and am still in an emotional wreck. AHHHHHHH i was bawling through the whole ending D: D: D':

  • Oh gods, I cried my heart out the first time I saw the ending of series 2! The worst part, of course, being that he fades away right before he can say it *sniff* T_T

  • i cry everytime. :'( just thinking about it actually haha

  • I cry watching this video =( the ending was so so sad, I cried so much. Even the "new ending" is sad, because Rose has a Doctor, but the real Doctor can only think of her =/

  • I love how he gets a little scared and sad when she says "and the baby" :')

  • Am I the only one who wants to see a wibbly-wobbly-timey-whimey thing happen to make Donna and 10 somehow meet Amy, Rory, and 11? How much fun would it be to watch that! Poor Rory though if it ever were to happen...seems like he alwys gets the worse end of the deal. lols

  • I love that song, haven't heard it in ages.

    And of course, The Doctor and Rose. <3 Ahh, how I still wish things had ended differently. Hopeless romantic here, I can't be happy knowing poor Ten was all alone in the end. He got to see her though, one last time, so yeah. At least something. :(

  • @JanuaryWonder till that bloody dalek went and tried to ruin the whole thing... This parting though, it almost killed me when I saw it for the first time. SO sad

  • good song :D yay it worked out eventually :D XD

  • It's sad that at the end of the fourth season He takes her back to Bad Wolf Bay and LOSE DONNA TOO!

  • rose was the best companion ever and david tennant is the greatest doctor ever. no1 can ever replace him. we going to miss you david.

  • @DrummerGirlLolly Yeah, ever since Tennant left, it just hasn't felt quite like Doctor Who. Even in Series 6, it didn't feel... right. Maybe it's because Davies also left, and I find it that he gave it that "Doctor Who" feeling. It could also be the complete lack of cheesy graphics and such.

  • @DrummerGirlLolly well the good news is, sometimes Doctors of the past just appear randomly. I personally wouldn't mind a 10th and 11th doctor collision. The jokes practically write themselves.

  • @DrummerGirlLolly @EdHardy2552 personally I liked Ace and 7 more than 10 and Rose but I just liked Aces overzealous love of explosives!

  • @DrummerGirlLolly Ur a bit emotional due to the music and images.... give matt a chance he is really quite good.

  • @DrummerGirlLolly Meh, I liked the 9th doctor :P

  • rose was the best companion ever and david tennant is the greatest doctor ever. no1 can ever replace him. we going to miss you david

  • NAW, worlds biggest diddums right there! xxxx :) <3

  • I have the Journal of Impossible Things (got it from GayMart) and there's two pages where he talks about Rose. It's really sad. He can't remember her name exactly but he knew it was something to deal with roses. It made me sadface.

  • why could'nt the people who make doctor who make him say to heri love you? sometimes i hate doctor who(jk)

  • This is so lovely! After all this time, I still love Rose SO much. Martha was eh, Donna was funny but annoying, I quite like Amy, and I can't stand River (I think my disgust with her goes back to the name thing...which I still haven't figured out, but I'm sure there's a lot more to that story.) Anyway, Rose outshone them all.

  • Of course he loved Rose more than anybody else, she's the only companion the Doctor has come close to saying I love you to and the only one he's cried over.

  • @Oopie6 He loved Romana too!

  • Just wanted to ask - and I am only asking you because yours is the latest video I've seen - what do you mean by "No copyright intended"? Everyone seems to put that. First - it should say ,"No copyright infringement intended" and second you have violated copyright whether you intended to or not. That's like robbing a store and then saying, "but I didn't intend to"

    Anyway, I'm not complaining, I just find it funny that everyone keeps using the wrong phrase.

  • When David Cries my heart breaks and goes mushy <3

  • if you watch on DT video diary I think it is. After filming this scene Billie walks over to David and he grabs her and holds her as she just cries into his shoulder well chest really. He just hugs her and comforts her till she gets over it. It is really quite sweet on his part.

  • @TheJaeTee awwww thats sweet :)

  • awwww that was real sweet.

  • That was great! I love me some Rose Tyler and the Tenth Doctor was great!!! Waiting for regeneration!

  • WHY DIDN"T THIS REALLY HAPPEN?!?!?!?!?! I cryed so hard in the real series

  • I must say I'm a Doctor/River fan but I LOVE the whole Doctor/Rose thing too. I felt so sorry for the Doctor...

  • I still say there are only 3 options for Rose's future.

    A: She finds a way back to our universe for good and rejoins the Doctor,

    B: Copies of the 2 of them are pulled into a third universe where they live as we all know they should (least favorite and least plausible), Or

    C: She becomes the first of the New Time Lords in her universe and builds a new TARDIS with latent knowledge and abilities from her exposure to the TARDIS core. (most likely to happen as hinted at by BBC Prod team)

  • Just need to say that the episode at the end with the hug is my FAVORITE! I'm saving it on DVR forever because Tennant and Piper make the CUTEST noises in the world when they finally see each other again!

  • You killed me with your song choice. :( This episode broke my heart.

  • I really would have liked that to happen but we would have had to see Rose die if that happened evenmore heartbreaking :(

  • The song fit perfectly! That would have been a great ending.

  • River will get married to the Doctor and then kill him

  • @LXflash River is The Rani. Bet you anything.

  • the new doctor and amy pond are better that roses and the 10th doctor

  • @LXflash Are you on crack? Amy is such a slut and she has a husband like come on! He deserves someone better then whiney Amy!

  • that would have been a brilliant ending.

  • yeah.. it would be a great ending :)

  • sorry dudes, but the only woman who Doctor reveals his own name is River. Anybody remenber this little detail? Not Rose, not Donna, not Sara Jane yet! River will be married with the Doctor... in a next future. Maybe the Eleventh... who can say?

  • This is so good.

  • haha

  • Rose & The Time Lord never again; How sad that ship has sailed. He never said he loved her; if he had, she would had clung to hope, never having a normal life. Rose ended up with her Doctor, one free to show his love, to grow old with her. One that might see the end of her life, but not one who would suffer that loss through eternity; The Time Lord would. He said that he could love her all of her life, but she couldn't love him all of his. Old and wise, THE Doctor.

  • Very good job on this. I really like it.

  • I don't like the music or the color and yes I would love to have seen this as the ending

  • you could tell hee loved her, he burnt a sun just to say goodbye

  • It's just so sad how they get seperated and plus everyone knows what he's going to say at the end..... " Quite right too, And I suppose... if it's my last chance to say it, Rose Tyler..." It's supposed to be I Iove you DUH!!!

  • Even without words, this clip still gets me all choked up. There is a lone tear making its way down my cheek right now. No lies.

    Oh, and beautiful song to pair with the clip.

  • Lol how the flip did she get in the TARDIS of it was traveling around a supernova?! XD

  • give me a thumbs up if you HATE River Song.

  • @missSJAfan What if one dislikes both River Song AND Rose? Personally, I feel the companions are much better when they're NOT being offered to us as potential love interests, so that might be why I'm partial to Donna of all the new companions. I'm probably too old, but I really miss the days when the show was about adventure, the days of Leela, Jamie MacCrimmon, Susan, or Sarah Jane (and Harry Sullivan--though a doofus, how cool was he?!).

  • I loved Rose and the Doctor. Together, they were the best couple ever created on T.V. I just loved what they had together, that made me cry so much, no matter how many times I see it, every single time I start balling my eyes out. Rose was the best companion by far, Martha was the worst. I liked Martha, but she loved the Doctor, and he didn't love her, so they couldn't be together. And then with Donna...well who couldn't love Donna? She was brilliant <3

  • You can totally tell the Rose was his favorite, because whenever he talks about her, he gets all choked up. Also, in Voyage of the Damned, when he goes to the party, he doesn't even really mention Martha at all. Even when he does, he doesn't look at all sad about it. He does miss Donna, though. I would too :)

  • @becca3ff

    i agree with you, the Doctor really loved her just like you said. he wanted her to live a normal, happy life and knew he couldnt give her that so left her with someone exactly like him to be with her even though it hurt his heart terribly.....to protect her......and show he really did love her. it makes me cry since my life cant ever be like that. =,(

  • I hate Amy. Rose was the best companion. Hands down. So pretty and charming. The rest are just obnoxious.

  • The ending if we where hypertheticaily deaf and colour blind -_-

  • Thanks for your insightful comment there!

  • @salx77 welcome :)

  • @salx77 no he's just jealous that David Tennant got to kiss her =D

  • @AnimeDudeXD what ever

  • @AnimeDudeXD I prefer Rose over Billie Piper though.

  • @Aure217 billie r rose or whoever looks much better blonde than with brown hair...

  • @AnimeDudeXD then you are alone ahhaa

  • So wait, we wanted to see it in black and white?

  • I hate Rose.

  • lol

  • i cried at this episode

  • Lolz. Good video, but funny how abrupt it is, with her randomly running in with no explanation of how she got back to the 'normal' dimension. Good vid though.

  • on family of blood you can tell he loved rose more than any companion because in his book of the dreams he had he drew rose and dreamt of her and also on the page it says sweet rose perfect rose <3 i think he loved her so much he gave up his love and happienes for her to have a normal life with someone the same as him who could do what he couldnt xxx <3

  • @becca3ff I hope nobody kills me for this.

    I really didn't like Rose.

  • @degubamboo I didn't like Rose either. My faviroute companion was Donna.

  • That's beautiful...

  • @becca3ff but the girl he got was butt ugly compared to rose lol

  • @becca3ff I also love how he doesn't know what the TARDIS is, which is not only his time machine he's traveled with for centuries, but also in many ways a friend, since the TARDIS is a sentient being (at least I _think_ that's canon... correct me if I'm wrong, I read so many fanfics I get confused) yet he remembers Rose. Well, he remembers her face, and that he loves her. :D But he forgets the TARDIS and Gallifrey.

  • @becca3ff and now that version can have a life with her

  • Ignore all the anti-Rose peeps. They have small penises or crusted twats.

  • Even without the sound that scene gets me every time.

  • good god me too. :(

  • @madscullyx13 i was saying the words with it, is that sad. I was still crying tho while chocking out the lines lol.

  • I know that this is the way Rose Fans would have loved to have seen it end but how would Russell or Stephen explain Billy Piper's pregnancy?

  • argh it should have changed to when Rose snogs the doctor in the finale of season 4. he whispers he loves her in her ear and yeah. that would have been SO much better ;)

  • The Doctor sure got into that orange space suit awful fast!

  • he sure did :O

  • Nope, not me, I wouldn't like

  • Nobody gives a shit what you like.

  • I don't give a fuck what you think. Obviously few people on this page give a fuck what you think. Now go wank off to pics of Stephen Moffat.

  • I love Doctor and Rose's love.

    It's so amazing and great :D

    They deserve each other - 100%

  • Awesome vid, definately how I'd have liked to have seen it end...but even though Rose got her human doctor, the real doctor never gets Rose...so it's a bit unfair really...:(I saw journey's end recently and felt so sorry for the dr...

  • yeh but after series 4 the extra doctor stayed with Rose as a Human as he only had 1 heart.....so who knows what their life would be like,,,,,would have been great to see that

  • great video. loved it. btw, wats all this bout rose being pregnant?

  • She's not. Her famous, "there's five of us now; mum, dad, Mickey... and the baby" line during Doomsday was reffering to the fact that her mother was pregnant.

  • yeah, i always thought his face fell when he thought it might be hers..

  • at around 2:58 you can see the doctor starting to well up :(

  • see what I really want to know is why the doctor looked so happy when he thought rose was pregnant? I mean she wasn't away for that long and couldn't have gotten pregnant that quickly in the other universe...maybe we are missing something me thinks ;) love the video really wished it had happened that way

  • I think they were gone longer than we think... but you could be right! I think that would add an interesting twist :)

  • He actually looked more shocked than anything. I thought he looked about ready to cry when she said the word "baby". His face fell if you look closely T_T

  • Actually she was gone for a few months I think. When she said she was pregnant he thought it was Mickey's.

  • Yeah, I thought he looked sad. I think he thought it was Mickey's. I dunno, the only reason I think it would make him happy is because the he'll know that Rose has actually moved on, like he wants her too, but it would also make him sad. And personally, I don't think that Rose and the Doctor ever... well... you know... 'cause it seemed like a big deal for them to kiss, and I don't think their love was something they ever fully admitted to themselves until the very end

  • Well said. The Doctor's main concern was her hapiness. Although I don't doubt Rose loved him as much as he did her she was a bit more selfish. That may come from her young(er) age.

    But then again, completely selfless love can be annoying. (Ex: Xiao Longnu [Little Dragon Girl] and Yang Guo) -_-

  • Yeah, you're right. their love was different. I feel that they both really loved each other, but the Doctor's love was more... mature? I dunno if that's the right word, but I think your right that it's their age difference.The Doctor is SO self sacrificing. incredibly self sacrificing, and we see it multiple times, like how he just walks away without even saying goodbye in Journey's End. And I think that shows how much he loves Rose- he's ready to give up all his happiness for her.

  • you just tricked me into watching something i swore never to watch again!!!!!!!!!! it makes me so sad... : (

  • i know, i just cried again!!! of course, i also cried at the "happy" season 4 ending because that wasnt nearly good enough so...waaaah!!!!

  • i know!!!!!! the human doctor just isnt good enough, just isnt the same!!!!!! surely him and rose could never be truely happy, and meanwhile, yet again, the doctor is so alone!!!!! he needs somebody.... : (

  • NO SHIT!!!! and totally obviously not the same, i mean, he told her what the doctor always says needs not be said, HE NEVER SAYS IT ROSE, GO WITH THE TIME LORD!!!! *cries so very hard*

  • I mean, surely half his attraction is his very time lordness itself?? you're right.... he couldnt say it.... she let him down so much by taking the easy option : (

    And omg, the middle pic above? of him smiling but crying? every time i come back to reply it breaks my heart a little more.

  • well i can see being happy if the doctor was still himself but TURNED human, but....how many times did he not finish that sentence to turn around and love the one who does??? poor doctor!!! and yeah, i start tearing up just from thinking of this song now...and i liked this song....

  • and what pic?

  • would have been nice but we must move on.

  • I wish.....

  • martha never really left lol she just was ded angry w/n the doctor. she was in torchwood last time i watched it