The Manfred Mann Earth Band performed the song like it was an original release....No disrespect to Bruce & the E street band, but Bruce's version ( the original ) comes across as an Interpretation of how Bob Dylan would have done it
I do not understand why people get so much invested into who's is best. I like Manfred Mann's version much better than this one but why make a big deal over it? I someone likes The Boss more then so be it.
One can like both.
As an example I will say that "Turn The Page" is two on my favorite songs ever.
for a guy that cant sing, let me see now he's won 20 Grammy's , 1 Academy award,
2 Golden Globes, and 1 Emmy, gee, not bad for a dude like Bruce to not know how to sing, or maybe write a good song. and dont forget put Manfred Mann's Earth Band on the Map of Rock and Roll Fame. Dream on!
@csny19691 Manfred Mann were a UK covers band and so they owed their success to creating more "commercial" versions of other people's songs. This was covered by them in 1977 - they had much earlier success - in 1964 they had the No 1 spot in the US with a cover of "Do Wa Diddy" - so you can't possibly say that Bruce put them on the map.
@csny19691 yes, reference the awards he's earned in the highly political entertainment biz, that'll sure change my opinion, lol. if those awards meant anything then they wouldn't be so controversial every year.
I'm actually not a very big Springsteen fan but I've gotta say this is my favorite song of his, and I believe it is far superior to that Manfred Mann version. I think this song needs the funky swing to it, and Bruce's rapid fire delivery works better with the lyrics that no one really understands anyway. One thing about the Manfred version that I really love though is the effects laden guitar solo, but then the "chopsticks" part later in the song makes me cringe and change the radio station.
we all know BRUCEs career is gold, manfred will never ever be able to hold a Candle to bruce over a lifetime, but just this one time,,, manfred holds the crown,, even if its only for a single song,,, give them their day in the sun,, cause they knocked it out of the park, and even bruce will admit it,,,,, although bruce is still the BOSS
gotta say, bruce is one hell of a song writer, but that bastard just can not sing that good at all. it's better than most better on planet earth, but it definitely doesn't live up to his song writing or fame. fantastic song though, especially when manfred manns earth band absolutely created one of the greatest recordings on the history of music! i HATE keyboards in 70's and 80's music, but their use in this song was absolutely perfect!
@RockNRolla1996 His voice might be shakey & raw, but it's pure, emotional & honest. Not like today's "singers", all processed, digitized, electronically auto-tuned/harmonized, ie ALTERED, etc. 1 thing he does have that NO machine can duplicate, (at least not yet) is his unique accent, & diction, & also his tone/tonal quality.
@RockNRolla1996 LOL nowadays you get singers that can't sing well and are helped out by the "music machine" aka the music industry and all it's electronics and machines and techniques and spin. Springsteen can sing his signature sound well. He's not from the pop machine; not manufactured.
Bruce's voice may not be that polished, but this song, sung by him, is a perfect example of the ridiculous raw energy that is present in most of his songs from the 70s. The rambling, nonsensical lyrics he wrote(that none the less told a story), plus the depth of feeling he showed when he sang made him great. His best music, best lyrics and best singing, in my opinion.
@ChrisnSnoop you know, i considered that, but then i found that there are a lot of people that happen to agree with me. statistically speaking, your statement is unlikely to be true :P
@funkengruvenful lmao, i'm sorry, did i offend you? you gonna go cry? my apologies, but my opinion - in the public arena that is the internet - stands.
@steve66oh Yea man I know haha... why not?! I always like it vinyl. And this LP has been used since like 1973 so it's been around. I just thought it would be cool just to put up all the vinyls... kinda like a blast to the past with bad quality(: Hahaha!
It definitely sounds like you need to adjust the turntable speed, its going a little too fast. Its why I like my AC motor belt driven table. Perfect speeds for the life of the motor as long as the belt doesn't stretch.
Wow.Springsteen has a Dylanesque ability to write songs that he can't play well.No wonder even some of his biggest fans have never heard his pre-Born To Run work.
P.S.: Did this come from a bad copy,or did someone hold a tape recorder up to the speaker while an old LP played?
@Syddric wrote: "Springsteen has a Dylanesque ability to write songs that he can't play well."
If it's safe to assume that that applies to singing as well as instruments, it's the best music commentary I've heard or read in years. Years, I tell you.
And i'm pretty sure the songwriting royalties that made Bruce millions of dollars had him loving the hell out of Manfred Mann's version too...; )
rweghg3 7 hours ago
The Manfred Mann Earth Band performed the song like it was an original release....No disrespect to Bruce & the E street band, but Bruce's version ( the original ) comes across as an Interpretation of how Bob Dylan would have done it
rweghg3 8 hours ago
one of his best. i have no problem w/ the quality neither. it needed to be done.
pbrick6301 3 months ago
I think the fact that every comment on this video is about manfred's cover, positive or negative, shows that manfred won..
connorc1323 5 months ago
criticizing Springsteen's voice is akin to complaining about Mozart's brush. Get over yourself.
dmsfree 7 months ago
@dmsfree LOL. Well put.
I do not understand why people get so much invested into who's is best. I like Manfred Mann's version much better than this one but why make a big deal over it? I someone likes The Boss more then so be it.
One can like both.
As an example I will say that "Turn The Page" is two on my favorite songs ever.
judsonkr 5 months ago
I like this longer version than Manfredd Manns :)
BullshitsMike 8 months ago
I Love this song and more specifically prefer this version over Manfred Manns cover...still looking for a high quality version though -__-
MusiqMan127 8 months ago 3
@MusiqMan127 You can find one on the right hand side? Lol
RockNRolla1996 8 months ago
@MusiqMan127 your choice maybe because its orig by bruce but idk manfreds sounds so much better
whipownsu 8 months ago
yer trippin bruce is a cool singer
bobindica 9 months ago
for a guy that cant sing, let me see now he's won 20 Grammy's , 1 Academy award,
2 Golden Globes, and 1 Emmy, gee, not bad for a dude like Bruce to not know how to sing, or maybe write a good song. and dont forget put Manfred Mann's Earth Band on the Map of Rock and Roll Fame. Dream on!
csny19691 10 months ago
@csny19691 Manfred Mann were a UK covers band and so they owed their success to creating more "commercial" versions of other people's songs. This was covered by them in 1977 - they had much earlier success - in 1964 they had the No 1 spot in the US with a cover of "Do Wa Diddy" - so you can't possibly say that Bruce put them on the map.
RCbeastly 9 months ago
@csny19691 yes, reference the awards he's earned in the highly political entertainment biz, that'll sure change my opinion, lol. if those awards meant anything then they wouldn't be so controversial every year.
RyTrapp0 9 months ago
Hate to say it but Manfred Mann does Bruce Springsteen better than Bruce Springsteen ! And has one hell of a better voice .
kbdevo1962 11 months ago
I wonder how many other Bruce Springsteen songs we can improve?? ALL of them!!!!! Sorry, Bruce!!! You are a GREAT songwriter--
mtfune 1 year ago
I'm actually not a very big Springsteen fan but I've gotta say this is my favorite song of his, and I believe it is far superior to that Manfred Mann version. I think this song needs the funky swing to it, and Bruce's rapid fire delivery works better with the lyrics that no one really understands anyway. One thing about the Manfred version that I really love though is the effects laden guitar solo, but then the "chopsticks" part later in the song makes me cringe and change the radio station.
magtownrep 1 year ago 2
we all know BRUCEs career is gold, manfred will never ever be able to hold a Candle to bruce over a lifetime, but just this one time,,, manfred holds the crown,, even if its only for a single song,,, give them their day in the sun,, cause they knocked it out of the park, and even bruce will admit it,,,,, although bruce is still the BOSS
IRONSEAN7 1 year ago 6
gotta say, bruce is one hell of a song writer, but that bastard just can not sing that good at all. it's better than most better on planet earth, but it definitely doesn't live up to his song writing or fame. fantastic song though, especially when manfred manns earth band absolutely created one of the greatest recordings on the history of music! i HATE keyboards in 70's and 80's music, but their use in this song was absolutely perfect!
RyTrapp0 1 year ago
@RyTrapp0 Yea man I know Bruce's voice is shakey but you don't get guys like him these days!
RockNRolla1996 1 year ago
@RockNRolla1996 His voice might be shakey & raw, but it's pure, emotional & honest. Not like today's "singers", all processed, digitized, electronically auto-tuned/harmonized, ie ALTERED, etc. 1 thing he does have that NO machine can duplicate, (at least not yet) is his unique accent, & diction, & also his tone/tonal quality.
gjc82071 11 months ago 8
@gjc82071 Your right brother!
RockNRolla1996 11 months ago
@RockNRolla1996 LOL nowadays you get singers that can't sing well and are helped out by the "music machine" aka the music industry and all it's electronics and machines and techniques and spin. Springsteen can sing his signature sound well. He's not from the pop machine; not manufactured.
qewr4231 8 months ago
Comment removed
lollielass 1 year ago
@RyTrapp0
Bruce's voice may not be that polished, but this song, sung by him, is a perfect example of the ridiculous raw energy that is present in most of his songs from the 70s. The rambling, nonsensical lyrics he wrote(that none the less told a story), plus the depth of feeling he showed when he sang made him great. His best music, best lyrics and best singing, in my opinion.
lollielass 1 year ago
@lollielass
You're right, he's a great singer and songwriter... But his lyrics are far from nonsensical...
ChrisnSnoop 1 year ago
@RyTrapp0
I don't think there's a problem with his singing, I think the flaw is your perception in what good singing really is.
ChrisnSnoop 1 year ago
@ChrisnSnoop you know, i considered that, but then i found that there are a lot of people that happen to agree with me. statistically speaking, your statement is unlikely to be true :P
RyTrapp0 1 year ago
@RyTrapp0 douchebag
funkengruvenful 9 months ago
@RyTrapp0 fucking douche
funkengruvenful 9 months ago
@RyTrapp0 u fuckhole
funkengruvenful 9 months ago
@funkengruvenful lmao, i'm sorry, did i offend you? you gonna go cry? my apologies, but my opinion - in the public arena that is the internet - stands.
RyTrapp0 9 months ago
@RyTrapp0 Wrong. Bruce is one of the best vocalists. His voice is pure emotion.
ohcalcutta81 9 months ago
@ohcalcutta81 thank you for stating this fact, as i had not known it was one before this comment
RyTrapp0 9 months ago
Oh Crap, I stii love it
lisbon67gjm 1 year ago
LP vinyl... skips at 0:53... running too fast (yo, pitchy, dog..).... why bother?
steve66oh 1 year ago
@steve66oh Yea man I know haha... why not?! I always like it vinyl. And this LP has been used since like 1973 so it's been around. I just thought it would be cool just to put up all the vinyls... kinda like a blast to the past with bad quality(: Hahaha!
RockNRolla1996 1 year ago
@RockNRolla1996
It definitely sounds like you need to adjust the turntable speed, its going a little too fast. Its why I like my AC motor belt driven table. Perfect speeds for the life of the motor as long as the belt doesn't stretch.
Erdrick68 1 year ago
thats when he was appealing.
outakontroll 1 year ago
Wow.Springsteen has a Dylanesque ability to write songs that he can't play well.No wonder even some of his biggest fans have never heard his pre-Born To Run work.
P.S.: Did this come from a bad copy,or did someone hold a tape recorder up to the speaker while an old LP played?
Syddric 1 year ago
@Syddric Yea man, it's LP, vinyl sorry for quality
RockNRolla1996 1 year ago
@Syddric wrote: "Springsteen has a Dylanesque ability to write songs that he can't play well."
If it's safe to assume that that applies to singing as well as instruments, it's the best music commentary I've heard or read in years. Years, I tell you.
thegrammarfairy 1 year ago 2
manfred mann's version is wayyyy better!
zero10689 1 year ago
@zero10689 But this is where he got it from man. Give Bruce some props ;D Hahaha
RockNRolla1996 1 year ago
@zero10689 Like Bruces better he says " Deuce " Coupe Car.. !
njmaple 1 year ago