This didn't sound terrible. Just not as good as some Mimis that I have heard. I still stand by Tamyra Gray being the best one I've seen :) Her performance was amazing based on the videos I watched. Does anyone have any other footage of Melanie's performance? I'm interested to see her in other songs.
No. I actually thought that she was perfect for the role, having envisaged her in it even before she was cast. But I ended up hating her performance because she sucks at singing while dancing.
mimi is my dream role haha... im not sure mel b would be good.. my favorite mimi is the renee chick, shes amazing! and im tired of like, people from sucessful bands,or movies or such getting these roles on Broadway. there are hundreds of talented people getting pushed away because theyre not famous hollywood people... just my opinion though! :)
rent is not about 'being young in new york' that's the biggest load of bullSHIT i've ever heard. has this guy even read a description of the show? i guess not or else he'd know better....my god...
@steveonewingedangel well i agree out of all of them vanessa is at the bottom of the list but i personally find that she did ok. it's just my opinion but yeah...
This didn't sound terrible. Just not as good as some Mimis that I have heard. I still stand by Tamyra Gray being the best one I've seen :) Her performance was amazing based on the videos I watched. Does anyone have any other footage of Melanie's performance? I'm interested to see her in other songs.
DWSMusic93 2 months ago
People says that she's bad just because she was a Spice Girls .___.
MrShuncito 2 months ago
@MrShuncito
No. I actually thought that she was perfect for the role, having envisaged her in it even before she was cast. But I ended up hating her performance because she sucks at singing while dancing.
Chibbykins 2 months ago
mimi is not a plastic ,disney's barbie.
colourpinwheel 2 months ago
@Taylorsstuffandstuff cause black is more slimming on her GIANT arse.
CassieChoirGeek 2 months ago
Melanie B and Vanessa Hudgens...seriously are they trying to ruin a perfectly good musical.
HOTEvilActing101 4 months ago
@HOTEvilActing101 no they did not
zanessababy34 1 day ago
bwahahaha "being young in new york"
So that's how all the teenagers live there, huh?
soso104 4 months ago
Mel B isn't a bad Mimi, but I will always prefer the original cast.
iCanbEYOURrUKIA 7 months ago
I swear she is probably the second worst Mimi ever.
AutumnsEatingMyHair 7 months ago
My God that was horrible and that was only a snippet of the song...
RavenChaos21 9 months ago
mimi is my dream role haha... im not sure mel b would be good.. my favorite mimi is the renee chick, shes amazing! and im tired of like, people from sucessful bands,or movies or such getting these roles on Broadway. there are hundreds of talented people getting pushed away because theyre not famous hollywood people... just my opinion though! :)
thejordistar 9 months ago 3
HOLY FUCK!!! I didn't know Mel B had been Mimi!!!! That's like two worlds colliding lol
ShotAcrossTheSky 11 months ago
Shes not that bad
Koabarr 1 year ago
HOLY SHIT THE URGE TO PUNCH THE NARRATOR IN THE FACE IS SO OVERWHELMING
xBananaSurferx 1 year ago 13
I LOVE her voice! She makes a great Mimi.
melsxaxfag 1 year ago
Like her
2davie3 1 year ago
Like her
2davie3 1 year ago
Like her
2davie3 1 year ago
rent is not about 'being young in new york' that's the biggest load of bullSHIT i've ever heard. has this guy even read a description of the show? i guess not or else he'd know better....my god...
AlphieThropp 1 year ago 58
@AlphieThropp I thought the exact same thing as he said that. If I could I would have smacked him.
Vampirephantome 1 year ago
This is............. not so good.
robinstraatman 1 year ago
the worst Mimi ever.
leehudgensbouvier 1 year ago
@leehudgensbouvier no, the worst mimi ever would be....VANESSA HUDGENS darling, no doubt about that.
steveonewingedangel 1 year ago 94
@steveonewingedangel well i agree out of all of them vanessa is at the bottom of the list but i personally find that she did ok. it's just my opinion but yeah...
powerpulse4 2 months ago
"Spices up the cast of rent!"?? More like stinks up the cast
Piccolo13 2 years ago
Always loved it!
Sija2004 2 years ago 2