You'd that that a real programmer would be able to spell things like "programmer" and "you." I would also imagine they could form a coherent sentence . I love when people get all fanboy and act like idiots.
Wrong; you've obviously never used Blender. For instance, if you did, you would know that you can completely change Blender inside it's engine as it is ALL Python.
I am amazed that some people just waste their time posting this kind of videos. Gorw up kids. Who cares what program you use. I used all programs from 3ds to Houdini, including blender, Maya, Cinema 4d, Lightwave and more and always found one to be better at something else than the other.
Any software can produce good results nowadays. It is just a matter of being able to use them correctly.
@TheForestMan1977 umm true.. but also not true.. maya uses other system's then Blender, I am a programer and maya shatter is very slow but I used mell to make it much faster.. that's why I use maya but most of the people here on youtube don't understand. Blender is fun for home, because it's all made for u but if something in maya is very slow I can twick it up, Blender can't not with that amount of speed that's why u have to pay for maya 60.000 and that's why Blender is free..
It's funny the blender guys would even try to defend blender against Houdini..
Houdini is ridiculously more powerful than blender, easier to use, better thought out and creates better animation.. Houdini is pretty much superior in every way.
Blender I do like but Houdini is the program they use for CGI in Hollywood.. and it's also free to students, Blender just doesn't compare
@SethiXzon u don't understand the concept this means goodbye Blender because this person want's to do more with animation Blender is fun for Home the engine behind houdini and maya or xsi or max is beyond Blender's level Blender can't reach that also for programers I can program very easy inside of maya, u youtuber's can only build a box in Blender with the simple dropdownlist but did u ever programed in Blender ? u did't because u are not a real programer or 3d animator, Blender is very basic
@dreamerboy1231 I think you've never used Blender; Blender utilizes Python instead of actually forcing you to learn a language that you'll only use with one program. Blender IS a real program, dumbass, and the results are based upon who uses it. 3DS Max, Maya, XSI, Houdini, Cinema4D (and I have all of these programs) will not instantly make good results by doing nothing. Try looking at the movies created with them.
@SethiXzon u saying that u have all those program's but what can u do with it ? Blender is great but Blender is to slow and I know because I am a programer and in maya I can rebuild the wholl system like if I give u maya u can't do nothing with it because u can't program, and u'r not a animator, u can only use the basic stuff. maya shatter is very slow see my channel what I rewritte with maya shatter can u do that with Blender ? it take years to know 1 software, don't aruge with me
It is not the fact that Blender community is so poroud or some times arrogant
It is not the ideology of open source.
It is the fact that Blender upgrades come in numbers of 0.01 but offer 10 times more functionality that upgrades in commercial applications.
Blender is like a volcano , it is slowly rising , seem kind of cute and interesting but when it will explode it will just devastate everything and revolutionize how 3d is made.
@thekilon u don't know what u'r talking about, I explain this a 1000 time's blender will never never ever gonna be used in a hollywood movie why ?, because first the programming it use python script.. C++ C# is 1000 times better then old Python script.. that's 1, 2 Blender is to slow the GUI s horrobile and I am a maya user and, the power behind houdini or max or maya is far beyond Blender can ever be. u are not a programer so u don't understand.
@dreamerboy1231 actually blender has been used in amovie. "Spiderman 2" , one of the best selling movies of all time. Actually you are unlucky, because I am a programmer and you are even more unlucky because I am a python programmer. By the way, python is used for maya and 3d studio max. Python can be as slow as fast it wants to be. Its true that some commercial apps, are better in some are compared to blender, but vice versa, blender is also better at some areas.
good news for you - it doesn't cost 1000$. you can download the current version (new bugfix releases daily!) for free, everything included with it (no renderman output of course), render in video resolution, small watermark in the corner, otherwise it's absolutely free. or you can buy the "starving artist edition" which costs 100$, HD resolution renders, no watermark, non-commercial projects only. now, that is sweet.
damn, no, i won't go back to maya, i'm fed up with that
I know you just didnt say that? Blender more flexable? LOL, come on man. If you think tht you have no experience. Houdini is procedural. You can do things blender and maya only dream of like letting particles inherited shaders and many other things. Houdini is NOT SIMPLIAR than blender AT ALL. Its render, mantra, is revolutionizing. Its fluids and particles are top notch in line with real flow. Blender is good but houdini is in a league of its own. Houdini pipeline integration is way better too.
Great! Maybe you send this to the morons who still think Blender is the greates App out there (and it`s not)Ok, i might be unfair to compare free OpenSource to a Commercial App, but Blenders Interface is just unusable.
I just downloaded Houdini 9.5 Demo two days ago. I too use Blender, but I won't not use Blender anymore. I'll use Blender for modeling, and Houdini for animation and simulation and rendering, probably. But I still will create projects entirely out of Blender too. So I'll use both programs.
@etuber21 i think you better move to 3ds max, i can do better animation then yours in 3ds max in less than 2 minutes... but i am also a blender user, both 3ds max and blender are so cool....
Awesome goodbye and such a clear demonstration how Houdini compares to Blender. I'm guessing you're using the 9.5 Beta shatter and debris tools for this?
I prefer Windows MovieMaker!
morgothFLOW 1 month ago
36 people are cheap.
PotadoTomado 2 months ago
Houdini...use maya, you actually have to work to make things look good
TechGuyTuts 7 months ago
can you use that animation in after effects?
guitarrecord101 8 months ago
why are you all arguing about software preference?
Just grab your tool and run with it.
I myself prefer open source ANYTHING over monopolies.
a2zhandi 8 months ago
facking noob
savromat 9 months ago
the most sh!t fracture i have seen ... blender is awesome and free and houdini is the biggest piece of balls... anyone disagree... i thought so =)
Something31337 9 months ago
I prefer Blender...
sharlowidalot 9 months ago
You'd that that a real programmer would be able to spell things like "programmer" and "you." I would also imagine they could form a coherent sentence . I love when people get all fanboy and act like idiots.
Tzuqris 10 months ago
yea blender doesn't even compare.
truth3712 10 months ago
Yes, that can easily be done in Blender. Does Maya have a powerful game engine? No, it does not.
SethiXzon 10 months ago
Wrong; you've obviously never used Blender. For instance, if you did, you would know that you can completely change Blender inside it's engine as it is ALL Python.
SethiXzon 10 months ago
I'm diggin' it. Cold you post a quick tutorial for newbs?
oluaxs 1 year ago
I am amazed that some people just waste their time posting this kind of videos. Gorw up kids. Who cares what program you use. I used all programs from 3ds to Houdini, including blender, Maya, Cinema 4d, Lightwave and more and always found one to be better at something else than the other.
Any software can produce good results nowadays. It is just a matter of being able to use them correctly.
TheForestMan1977 1 year ago
@TheForestMan1977 umm true.. but also not true.. maya uses other system's then Blender, I am a programer and maya shatter is very slow but I used mell to make it much faster.. that's why I use maya but most of the people here on youtube don't understand. Blender is fun for home, because it's all made for u but if something in maya is very slow I can twick it up, Blender can't not with that amount of speed that's why u have to pay for maya 60.000 and that's why Blender is free..
dreamerboy1231 11 months ago
It's funny the blender guys would even try to defend blender against Houdini..
Houdini is ridiculously more powerful than blender, easier to use, better thought out and creates better animation.. Houdini is pretty much superior in every way.
Blender I do like but Houdini is the program they use for CGI in Hollywood.. and it's also free to students, Blender just doesn't compare
mikeysa 1 year ago
(This shattering looks so fake)
vcspy 1 year ago
This is possible in two clicks as well via a script in Blender.
Click one: Add the object
Click two: Execute the free FractureMe script.
SethiXzon 1 year ago 2
@SethiXzon u don't understand the concept this means goodbye Blender because this person want's to do more with animation Blender is fun for Home the engine behind houdini and maya or xsi or max is beyond Blender's level Blender can't reach that also for programers I can program very easy inside of maya, u youtuber's can only build a box in Blender with the simple dropdownlist but did u ever programed in Blender ? u did't because u are not a real programer or 3d animator, Blender is very basic
dreamerboy1231 11 months ago
@dreamerboy1231 I think you've never used Blender; Blender utilizes Python instead of actually forcing you to learn a language that you'll only use with one program. Blender IS a real program, dumbass, and the results are based upon who uses it. 3DS Max, Maya, XSI, Houdini, Cinema4D (and I have all of these programs) will not instantly make good results by doing nothing. Try looking at the movies created with them.
SethiXzon 11 months ago
@SethiXzon u saying that u have all those program's but what can u do with it ? Blender is great but Blender is to slow and I know because I am a programer and in maya I can rebuild the wholl system like if I give u maya u can't do nothing with it because u can't program, and u'r not a animator, u can only use the basic stuff. maya shatter is very slow see my channel what I rewritte with maya shatter can u do that with Blender ? it take years to know 1 software, don't aruge with me
dreamerboy1231 10 months ago
can make better now with blender's frature addon ;)
jackred5 1 year ago
Comment removed
MonkeyOnMyShoulder 1 year ago
I see but it doesn't really look good... No friction on the surface?
KebleTar 1 year ago
Why not do this?
USE BOTH.
SethiXzon 2 years ago 2
Use weight paint with the explode modifier in blender, and you will get something similar.
Neptutron 2 years ago
Well lucky you! lol
Blender is still awesome for being freeware, I'd bet it would be comparable to Houdini, if not as good. But still, lucky you!
Asdam12 2 years ago 5
the software is only as good as the artist using it.
SomeFunkyDude79 2 years ago 35
It is not the fact that blender is free
It is not the fact that Blender community is so poroud or some times arrogant
It is not the ideology of open source.
It is the fact that Blender upgrades come in numbers of 0.01 but offer 10 times more functionality that upgrades in commercial applications.
Blender is like a volcano , it is slowly rising , seem kind of cute and interesting but when it will explode it will just devastate everything and revolutionize how 3d is made.
thekilon 2 years ago 33
oh and I agree its GUI does suck big time... but I am sticking to blender.
thekilon 2 years ago 5
@thekilon u don't know what u'r talking about, I explain this a 1000 time's blender will never never ever gonna be used in a hollywood movie why ?, because first the programming it use python script.. C++ C# is 1000 times better then old Python script.. that's 1, 2 Blender is to slow the GUI s horrobile and I am a maya user and, the power behind houdini or max or maya is far beyond Blender can ever be. u are not a programer so u don't understand.
dreamerboy1231 11 months ago
@dreamerboy1231 actually blender has been used in amovie. "Spiderman 2" , one of the best selling movies of all time. Actually you are unlucky, because I am a programmer and you are even more unlucky because I am a python programmer. By the way, python is used for maya and 3d studio max. Python can be as slow as fast it wants to be. Its true that some commercial apps, are better in some are compared to blender, but vice versa, blender is also better at some areas.
thekilon 10 months ago
good news for you - it doesn't cost 1000$. you can download the current version (new bugfix releases daily!) for free, everything included with it (no renderman output of course), render in video resolution, small watermark in the corner, otherwise it's absolutely free. or you can buy the "starving artist edition" which costs 100$, HD resolution renders, no watermark, non-commercial projects only. now, that is sweet.
damn, no, i won't go back to maya, i'm fed up with that
villain42 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
dont kill my suzanne
gauravanim 3 years ago
This saddens me.
Another Blender community member falls for the trap of simplicity.
Houdini may be simple, but not as flexible.
xXxBlender3DxXx 3 years ago
I know you just didnt say that? Blender more flexable? LOL, come on man. If you think tht you have no experience. Houdini is procedural. You can do things blender and maya only dream of like letting particles inherited shaders and many other things. Houdini is NOT SIMPLIAR than blender AT ALL. Its render, mantra, is revolutionizing. Its fluids and particles are top notch in line with real flow. Blender is good but houdini is in a league of its own. Houdini pipeline integration is way better too.
AppleShakeGuru 3 years ago
I agree. Houdini is the most complex 3d software out there. Calling it simple means that you dont know about it much. Download the demo.
etuber21 3 years ago
Too bad houndini was in the movie transformers and poor old blender wasnt
xXxShadowAxelxXx 2 years ago
uhauhauahuahauhah
This was Sadic
im now using houdini too
3ds Max -> blender -> Maya -> Houdini
But i Still use all softwares :D
All are good ;)
Sorry for my bad english :)
ThrashmasterX 3 years ago
I have nothing against the program, I've seen other examples of what it can do, but that didn't seem that realistic...
I dunno. For the moment (and money) I'll let it be.
GlacierAnimation 3 years ago
lol, your judging houdini and what an at home youtube artist can do with it? LOLOLOL
AppleShakeGuru 3 years ago
Um... yes, I am...
I'm just saying, at home youtube artists have done pretty amazing things with pure Blender that I would suggest are better than this.
But, I've seen other cool things done with Houdini, so I know it can do cool things.
GlacierAnimation 3 years ago
how much costs you those 2 minutes?
Tatucik 3 years ago
FREE
AppleShakeGuru 3 years ago
Great! Maybe you send this to the morons who still think Blender is the greates App out there (and it`s not)Ok, i might be unfair to compare free OpenSource to a Commercial App, but Blenders Interface is just unusable.
GreyZone7 3 years ago
yes. it takes two clicks to do that.
etuber21 3 years ago
Was this made in the Apprentice version?
Gruntshooter 3 years ago
Was the shatter predefined?
Asdam12 3 years ago
I just downloaded Houdini 9.5 Demo two days ago. I too use Blender, but I won't not use Blender anymore. I'll use Blender for modeling, and Houdini for animation and simulation and rendering, probably. But I still will create projects entirely out of Blender too. So I'll use both programs.
CheeseSample 3 years ago
made in less than 2 minutes. render not included.
etuber21 3 years ago
render? lol, i rendered out a flouid sim in houdini that took 7 hours, lol for 260 frames
AppleShakeGuru 3 years ago
@etuber21 How long did the render take?
josephrawlins 11 months ago
@etuber21 i think you better move to 3ds max, i can do better animation then yours in 3ds max in less than 2 minutes... but i am also a blender user, both 3ds max and blender are so cool....
SquickyPantsy 7 months ago
made in 2 minutes including rendering?
blower05 3 years ago
yes, shatter and debris of course. :)
etuber21 3 years ago
Awesome goodbye and such a clear demonstration how Houdini compares to Blender. I'm guessing you're using the 9.5 Beta shatter and debris tools for this?
etr9j 3 years ago
made in 2 minutes counting the blender model export and import into houdini. the actual setup takes only a few seconds.
etuber21 3 years ago