Added: 8 months ago
From: ryanseacrest
Views: 75,800
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (486)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Who cares about the order of finish thats old news.... behind them .. their futures are ahead of them not behing them..

    This was a LOT of fun .. thanks for posting this ! In addition to beling talented .. these are all really nice kids.. self confident and friendly. wonderful

  • All I hear is Haley. The true winner of S10. Love you Haley!

  • HALEY oh god can she even be more perfect?

  • God i love Haley, definitely the best this season!

  • Haley is the scat goddess in american idol

  • is that an excuse? 3:39-4:00

  • thia and haley for the girls, stefano, jacob,casey, and james for the boys

  • AMAZING :D

  • 4:50 is my favorite.

  • @Cornsnake33 same here haley should have sang this in solo. I know this is impromptu performance but it just shows haley is a true artist very versatile

  • @naborghsoj08 New singing contests should add impromptu performance to add a twist

  • I keep watching this over and over again! Just so beautiful!

    + it was uploaded on my birthday lol

  • Comment removed

  • the choir sung this song at my school today... i was like HOLY SHIT HALEY<3

  • Love that Haley is the one in the video thumbnail.

  • why is pia so quiet?

  • What a mess

  • Lauren, Scotty ... where are the winners? I can't hear you

  • Paul , are you ok ? you look sad ...

  • I want them to be friends forever, I love all of them. Best american idol group ever.

  • Freakin' Chills.  Awesome.

  • Haley Reinhart's first single will be released MARCH 1st!!

    Thumbs up! =)

  • this is what camp rock, high school musical... tries to looks like

  • Out of all of those people i see one person... that person is haley <3

  • Comment removed

  • at the beggining stephano sounds like a girl!

  • Wow, it's amazing.. they're all so talented and they can just make music like that. It's magical <3

  • Still would have loved to see james and haley sing something together...

  • Original is the best, it was crap listenin dem

  • Stefano and Pia looks good tgt O_O

  • Show some Haley Love <3 <3

  • Comment removed

  • Talented people!

  • Comment removed

  • Haley... And her backup singers....

  • Who is the man in the pink shirt?

  • @xxtasha10xx Jacob Lusk. 

  • all of them can sang, but Jacob, Haley,Thia and Stefano were always my top choices i'm hoping to audition next year. if only Stefano sang like this on stage

  • actually every one is better than at the begining, but haley is the best singer here by far!! ♥

    is she ventriloquist (0:40)?

  • Hey, I love Haley. These videos are worth watching because of her. She is the brightest in a jam session. Good luck to all. But now come on, biggest star of the season. She has to be.

  • 0:35 - 0:50 what the hell is Haley doing?

  • haley and thia made it all better

  • I love Haley:) I love them all, but Haley is greattttt!!!!

  • Haley IS SO FREAKIN HOT! Pia is hot to but Haley is even hotter.

  • HALEY+THIA=AMAZING:)

  • Comment removed

  • Haley touched the spot :')

  • Comment removed

  • Anybody else find it weird that Pia didn't do ANYTHING.

  • @thedisneygirl1234 pia at least sang paul didnt do shit

  • @76DHerrick That's cause he didn't know the song. He says that loud and clear.

  • They're all great, but three showed me lot more here than they did on the show: Stefano, Jacob, and, especially Thia. We already knew that James and Haley are amazing.

  • UGHHHH WHY COULDN'T STEFANO SING LIKE THIS ON THE SHOW -_-

  • stefano is amazing!!!

  • HALEY HALEY HALEY!!!

  • @Sharlene947 haha I know right. Although 1 person really stands out.... HALEY!!!

  • ADAM HARTMANN

  • Haley is just flawless in every way.

  • they ALL are probably going to get signed somewhere because they're AMAZING so everyone should just shut up about who they think is the "best" and just enjoy watching and listening to them! jeez.

  • I can't wait til January

  • im a halien up to eternity!

  • Omg I love Haley SOOOO much. I hope she"ll look at all these comments to see how much everyone really loves her. I saw her live and she was just....so so so Amazing!!!:) HALIEN FOR LIFE!!!!!!! -3 -3 -3 I also like James and thia!!:) -3

  • alright they all have talent. I'm tired of coming onto every freaking video with Lauren in it and having Haley fans saying she should've won. the top 3 got signed..... GAH. get over it.

  • Lauren's good, BUT it's no secret that Haley Elizabeth Reinhart should have made it in the top 2 over her. HALIEN for life here. :)<3333

    & plus, every little sound that comes from her mouth while she's singing is completely flawless. Like if you agree?

  • @JessicaKaathryn No, Haley should have won, Lauren in third, PIA in second. (No Scotty, IN MY OPINION)

  • am i the only one who came here only for Haley???

  • The techs in the studio are going to love Haley for her voice control. No need for a limiter or autotune. Her vocal dynamics are spot on...

  • Haley Reinhart= Love <3 Absolutely amazing!!

  • Haley's amazing

  • HAHA Paul McDonald didnt know the song..ahah its all good though

  • Its weird how scotty is the winner of american idol but it seems eveyone is better than him...

  • Haley is inspiration. <3

  • Haley Reinhart is perfection.

  • We all comment about Haley in the hope that she might stumble across this video and know just how adored she really is.

  • i love how most of the comments are about haley <3

  • i hope they all get togther to record b/c this iss really impressive

  • Ok enough about haley. How about the fact that all 11 of them are extremely talented! This was my favorite season of idol because everyone was so good and so fun to watch.

  • @thedisneygirl1234 don't get mad because every one loves them some Haley Reinhart!

  • i love pia and thia <3

  • Haley is obviously the best, but i just re watched this and noticed that Thia is really good at improvising too.

  • 'sposed 2 be 'PierceAbrams'

  • I can think of something more recent by Haley for scatting.. Just a little 'sumptin posted by Casey Abrams (PiercedAbrams) 5 days ago on Youtube - Haley at Irvin Mayfeilds Jazz Club in New Orleans 11 minutes not 2 be missed...'nough said

  • stefano's hymn is AMAZING all of them actually!

  • 2:28 Holy crap Haley is so good. =)

  • i luv u lauran <3

  •  Oh, hey talent, I haven't seen you very much in the 21st century, nice to see your close with these 11 people(:

  • 3:01 - 3:05 Thia is smiling at Haleys amazingness! :)

  • I <3 Jacob Lusk!

  • You Can Not, Tell me Haley Isn't the best. ♥

  • wow!!!!!11 dey are FREAKIN GREAT

  • someone help me... I can't stop listening to Haley's scat 4:46-5:00! I love you Haley!

  • I like all three scats, but Haley's was the most refreshing for me cause it's subtle.

    Loud and high notes are annoying and obnoxious when it's without any musical value. "Look how high I can sing! Screw the melody!"

  • Haleys harmony is amazing! She doesn't have to try to sing over everybody to sound amazing

  • @jaffemaster I'm not bashing Stefano but it's just that I like Haley the most. Bro

  • didn't even hear a note from the top 2...completely drowned by all the talent around them...

  • The best singers are clearly the ones who sung the most!

  • so wheres Scotty in this oh right nowhere he has one element and thats all he could sing in

  • @jaffemaster beat her at her own game??? Okay you must not know scatting at ALL because Haley did it from the heart and stefano well .. He tried but it sounded a little forced to be honest with you...

  • James didn't deserve to be there, honestly. Haley and Jacob were my absolute favourites.

  • Was anybody actually playing guitar, or just sliding their fingers up and down the neck and patting the body!

  • oooooHHHH  HALEY WOW!

  • They all are really good! I wish they would've done this song on tour though...

  • I love how Haley and Casey put their soul when ever they sing. You can feel it in this song.

  • 4:46 - 5:00 Says it All! LOVE HALEY <3 Im glad she didn't win that way she'll get to be way more FAMOUS. I'm a Halien

  • Comment removed

  • @jaffemaster Ouch... not at all. Stefano's scat was horrifically sharp and off-key, especially at the beginning of it. I'd hardly even call it a scat, it was forced and ugly. That's not what scatting is about. I like Stefano, don't get me wrong, but that scat was awful. No big deal, he's not a jazz singer.

    She's studied jazz, she knows how it's done. Haley dominates!

  • @gnarlyincubus no that wasn't she, because i didn't heard all of them, but i really liked the guy in the right with guitar.

    Sorry i i'm gramaticaly wrong))

  • Thia you are amazing!!

  • im not a haley fan but she clearly outshined everyone here...

  • 0:55 - 1:00 goodness gracious how i love haley

  • I am a hard core Haley fan, but I will say that watching this video reminded me why i was so excited to watch Idol this year, there is so much amazing talent and they are all different and special in their own unique way, i love listening to them all :)

  • i think its awesome how haleys scatting just flows out of her, the other guys who did it looked like they were about to pass out afterwards lol

  • 0:36 haley looks so cute when looking around to see who's gonna start first. She is subtle and just perfect in this session.

    I hope I made all the haley haters sick to their stomach by her name being mentioned again. lol.

  • Oh yeah and one more thing, I totally loveeeeeeeee how all the haley fans out there are defending for Haley here and in many other videos, there are too many to name let's continue this!! Waiting for her album... !!!

  • @amarah55 HEY! How can you say that Haley fans are annoying?! We are just speaking the truth and defending our idol, I don't see anything wrong with that. I think you are jealous bcos your 'idol' doesn't get as much attention as Haley.

  • @jessegirl10 I love how ALL and when I say ALL I mean ALL, the comments here are about HALEY! And they are all positive comments. So I guess you should just pack your bags and leave cause this is only for Haley fans to enjoy not for YOU. So just F*** off, you have no right to hate Haley here go somewhere else!

  • @0345Lollipop how bout no i dnt have 2 so shut up k

  • @jessegirl10 oh right whatever i don't care, you are just a retard and i don't wish to spend my time on you.

  • 4:48 haley <33

  • jacob has a really powerfull voice

  • I LOVE HALEY!!!!!!! Anyway, even though I can't stand Jacob, his scatting was great

  • Oh how Jacob stand out when the group sings<3 I feel like next season won't be nearly as good as this group(:

  • @jessegirl10 u might hate Haley but some people don't and by starting fights on YouTube isn't gonna help the fact that you think ur better than her!! I mean we watch videos to enjoy them not to post comments like u do and when people write comments like u wrote on this video that means there spoiled lil jerks who don't have the guts to respect other people!!!

  • Comment removed

  • haley is easily the best what a amazing creature

  • when haley sings her part: chills.

  • pshhh haley has done it again. no surprise. her voice is like pure silk.

    shoutouts to thia, james, casey and stefano too.. this is pretty good stuff :)

  • Whenever I listen to this it makes me happy....I LUV U JAMES!!!

  • Jacob's scat was too out there. It didn't fit the song, it was really extravagant. Haley's scat fit perfectly with the song. That's why it worked. She's more musically inclined when it comes to jazz. JMO.

  • James should have won!

  • @hnnhbear i so agree ur my new friend i luv u ur the best

  • @jessegirl10 Haha, your pretty awesome yourselfff<3 haha love you too! :p

  • @hnnhbear ikr he was awesome

  • WHY DIDNT THEY SING THIS ON TOUR =(

  • HALEY <3

    

  • @xxXXyvonnegrayXXxx wht, r u people crazy i hate haley shs so bad god

  • Someone tells Jacob it's a group performance and not his "yegadayegada" solo performance. Scaths (all) were also terrible.

  • i cant help going back and listening too all those scats... they're so cool! Haley, Stefano and Jacob! and Thia's voice just resonates with so much ease.... wow.

  • This woulda been cool on tour! as one of the final songs!

  • These people are awesome. But I still think Haley/Casey > everyone else. 

  • Haley Reinhart, I dare you to stop being so perfect.

  • man they shoulda done this on tour...

  • 0:36-0:18 Hayleys looks sooooo confused lol....but i stilll love here

  • HALEY REINHART YOU BEAUTIFUL SINGER/PERSON.

  • hayley's and thia's voices are sooo extraordinary, AMAZING

  • It seems like Pia is in her own little world being in the corner....

  • I love it when Haley scats <3

  • Awww @2:19 :) I love how close they all are. :) Watch Thia and Haley and you'll see what i'm talking about.

  • Awww 2:19:) I love how close they all are. :)

  • I hate how everyone is fighting for one idol here! Can't you all just enjoy the fact that their like a big family, and they have all have a bond that allows them to make music this way?! It's incredible, and yes, some have stronger spots than others, but thats not the point! They are enjoying themselves! Stop trying to make it into a big competition!

  • @horseluver51000 But then that takes all the fun out of it because without competition there would be no american idol, & the fan wars are never going to end as long as the show is on no matter what you say & no matter how annoyed we get with certain fanbases & I know some can get a bit out of hand but without them we would'nt have anything to talk about plus it gives you a chance to put ignorant people in their place(not naming names), it's all part of the entertainment, get used to it!!

  • @cmfan26 Trust me, I'm on your side when American Idol is actually on T.V and running, but this moment here on this video is supposed to be about all of them singing togther, not a competition to see who is better or who has more solos, you know? Idol is over,a winner was announced,and yes, there is more than "one" winner. But I feel like now it's time to lay off the faves. Sorry, I just had to vent lol. I wish people could appreciate their family-like bond and the fun that they are having here.

  • @horseluver51000 Because when you put everyone together, it's even more obvious that some (such as Haley + others) are more musically inclined than others, and some (not going to name names but it's pretty obvious) seem pretty clueless and out of key

    And then we get to the center of the problem, which is the voting system. If it were one vote per person instead of unlimited votes, I promise you it'd be a different outcome especially when you see how many fans of certain contestants there are.

  • @gnarlyincubus I know, but this is my opinion: It's not the point who is "better" because not matter how hard anyone tries to put it, they are all great singers- they all made it to Top 11 week. Okay, I'm done typing, thats all I was trying to say. They have a great bond and people have to go trying to ruin it.

  • @horseluver51000 I get what you're saying. But I was just trying to say that obviously the person who actually has the most talent in this "talent contest" does not always win. And that's why people feel the need to support them. I liked everyone in their own way. I don't bash other contestants, but I like to support the most talented and unique.

    No offense to anyone, but based on talent alone, Haley was the best. Her range, tone, and musciality are far superior to the others.

  • @gnarlyincubus I agree, I love Haley too.

  • @horseluver51000 ok whtever shes veary bad when i look at her my face starts 2 burn and it hurts

  • @jessegirl10 ?? Sorry, I don't listen to haters.

  • @horseluver51000 Trust me I do why do you think I made a comment about how annoying haleys fans are? because everytime I watch one of these videos they are always on here to state how much better haley is & someone even went as far as to say that scotty fans are closed minded & don't appreciate real music as if haley is the only one who does real music but the truth is they are all real musicians or else they would'nt have made it on the show otherwise!!

  • @cmfan26 Yes, that's exactly what I'm saying. Finally, someone who isn't out for only one Idol here. Anyway, love this video!

  • Pia seems drunk lol xD