Re-record yourself...finish strong with the lyrics instead of dropping the tone at the end of every lyric and I bet this will be really good. Your guitar playing is solid though, nice job.
@tylerdurden1971 You didn't say what was? There is a guy in the Pink Floyd group on myspace who's screen name is Tyler Durden. I was asking if you were him. That's all. Look I know my singing sucks. I don't have a problem with yuo saying that. But my guitar playing doesn't and I wanted to put this song up because it sounds sweet with the 12 string. I didn't feel it's a song you can put up and just strum so I gave a shot at singing it.
@mike3571 well buddy Tyler Durden is Brad Pitts character from Fight Club lol anyway the guitar playing was fine i just said you shouldn't sing,not that it wasn't a show of effort,the guitar sounded great
Gutsy performance, sir. It takes balls to sing like that for all the world to hear even though you know you're opening yourself up for abuse. Don't listen to the haters. You did something they would never do, which makes you the better man.
@mike3571 I think that's really cool that you have the confidence to sing even though you can't. I'm like that too, but I'm too afraid to record it. But really nice guitar work. And I like your singing :D
@mike3571 I think that's really cool that you have the confidence to sing even though you can't. I'm like that too, but I'm too afraid to record it. But really nice guitar work. And I like your singing :D
damn man, great job, yeah singing's a little off but to be able to play it that good and sing really shows alot. you got the feeling through it too. 5/5
Give the man a break impersonating gilmours voice is quite hard as well as rogers. Im giving you constructive criticism here but i think you shouldnt try so hard to pull off high notes with your voice just sing the song with your own spin to it. flawless guitar performance though 5/5
Thanks Eric. I don't mind people telling me I can't sing because I know I can't. I just wanted to put the song up and you really can't play this one without singing in there. I appreciate your comment!
Guy's, why wont you upload a video of you singing the song. We might be able to appreciate your voice.. should be good since your bashing on the man's one...
its not a hard song to sing. you can either sing or can not sing.
some people are not made for singing.
mate, you are great at the guitar but don't sing, or juyst take some lessons. because you quite frankly suck, and if no one tells you you're gonna just get laughs
Sounds great. The 12 string has such a nice tone. Slow the temp down just a beat. Your timing is excellent. You have a nice, pleasent voice. Try lowering your tone a little. I sense your talking voice is naturally lower tone? The song does sound really nice, you can tell you've worked hard on it. It's right there.
learn how to sing and try again
iamkuljuarenot 3 months ago
nice solo
TravelerByNight 3 months ago
nice to hear someone using a 12string for this..
JeffBend 7 months ago
Great guitar cover, but I'd just stick to Playing guitar
DalyBallin23 1 year ago
it was awsome until 49 seconds
dan197929 1 year ago
sing all you want man.. don't let anyone get you down.
joshw4884 1 year ago
Nice guitar cover. I also like the black gat with ebony neck. Flick on the black pick guard and bamm... gilmour in your house !
DrewNZ 1 year ago
maybe not so good singin, but really good playin
homerofduty 1 year ago
Re-record yourself...finish strong with the lyrics instead of dropping the tone at the end of every lyric and I bet this will be really good. Your guitar playing is solid though, nice job.
dazma22 1 year ago
Name of the guitar?
t94r84h47 1 year ago
great playing! i like the sound of the 12-string alot. 5/5
skyleredmonds 1 year ago
sorry but you SHOULD NOT sing dude
tylerdurden1971 1 year ago
@tylerdurden1971 Is this Pink Floyd group Tyler?
mike3571 1 year ago
@mike3571 what? i didn't say it was but your singing really was not good.sorry to be the one to have to tell ya but it sucked
tylerdurden1971 1 year ago
@tylerdurden1971 You didn't say what was? There is a guy in the Pink Floyd group on myspace who's screen name is Tyler Durden. I was asking if you were him. That's all. Look I know my singing sucks. I don't have a problem with yuo saying that. But my guitar playing doesn't and I wanted to put this song up because it sounds sweet with the 12 string. I didn't feel it's a song you can put up and just strum so I gave a shot at singing it.
mike3571 1 year ago 7
@mike3571 well buddy Tyler Durden is Brad Pitts character from Fight Club lol anyway the guitar playing was fine i just said you shouldn't sing,not that it wasn't a show of effort,the guitar sounded great
tylerdurden1971 1 year ago
@mike3571 Tyler Durden. you sir. just got owned..
muffintops94 1 year ago
you suck, you are making a mockery of this song.
MarcBeckK 1 year ago
dude you did pretty good, theres no such thing as a bad singing voice. Theres just different styles of singing, as well as any other instrument.
brandon101994 1 year ago
u forgot the solo
blackout449 1 year ago
@blackout449 make that solos
there is two.
MarcBeckK 1 year ago
Sounds great, mate!! . . . You cant beat that 12 string sound!! . . . Well done!!
loveguitars1 1 year ago
Gutsy performance, sir. It takes balls to sing like that for all the world to hear even though you know you're opening yourself up for abuse. Don't listen to the haters. You did something they would never do, which makes you the better man.
KatManDude 1 year ago
@KatManDude so by that logic, running naked in the streets or killing your family makes you "the better man" as well.
MarcBeckK 1 year ago
@MarcBeckK That analogy makes no sense whatsoever. Man you're a dumbass.
mike3571 1 year ago
Omg, dude. That was soooo bad. There's really some serious pitch-problems. I just had to turn off the sound..
And to Eric111999, why should anyone impersonate another artist? Why not create your own style?
abotoft 1 year ago
@abotoft I know I can't sing, so whatever man. I'm not going to play this song and just sit there and strum.
mike3571 1 year ago
@mike3571 I think that's really cool that you have the confidence to sing even though you can't. I'm like that too, but I'm too afraid to record it. But really nice guitar work. And I like your singing :D
travisnightmaretv 1 year ago
@travisnightmaretv Thanks Travis!
mike3571 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mike3571 I think that's really cool that you have the confidence to sing even though you can't. I'm like that too, but I'm too afraid to record it. But really nice guitar work. And I like your singing :D
travisnightmaretv 1 year ago
@mike3571 Well, i can't dance, so I don't upload any videos of me dancing.
It could be much cooler making an arrangement without singing then...
abotoft 1 year ago
nice nice!
Silas13100 1 year ago
That guitar sounds amazing !
videosenders 1 year ago
damn man, great job, yeah singing's a little off but to be able to play it that good and sing really shows alot. you got the feeling through it too. 5/5
flaminguitar94 1 year ago
Give the man a break impersonating gilmours voice is quite hard as well as rogers. Im giving you constructive criticism here but i think you shouldnt try so hard to pull off high notes with your voice just sing the song with your own spin to it. flawless guitar performance though 5/5
eric111999 2 years ago 2
Thanks Eric. I don't mind people telling me I can't sing because I know I can't. I just wanted to put the song up and you really can't play this one without singing in there. I appreciate your comment!
mike3571 2 years ago
Guy's, why wont you upload a video of you singing the song. We might be able to appreciate your voice.. should be good since your bashing on the man's one...
Well done Mike3571!
bigDD73D 2 years ago 2
strange voice ^^ but anyway good taste man
pedracaneta 2 years ago
a little fast, but good.
thedudeperson 2 years ago
what guitar are you using?
guitarplayer0007 2 years ago
It's a 12 string Alvarez
mike3571 2 years ago
great guitar playing. It sounds great on a 12 string. .....But.... leave the singing to Roger Waters. 5/5
StrumTheStrings 2 years ago 9
Thanks for commenting. It's actually David Gilmour who sings it though.
mike3571 2 years ago
Oh, well, Syd, Roger, David, I lost track. haha
StrumTheStrings 2 years ago
@StrumTheStrings actually you mean David Gilmour
chordize 1 year ago
@StrumTheStrings DAve gilmour you fucking clown, This is Gilmours signiture vocal song. It would kill it if Roger sang it
rickheyes0 1 year ago
the 12 string gives this a real sweet sound
ChocolateButterr 2 years ago
u can play da guitar well .but u cant sing
k9punkass 2 years ago 3
I'm sorry but I have to agree with k9punkass great sound on the guitar but you need voice lessons
boanerges144 2 years ago
Do more Pink Floyd lessons! I used your Goodbye Blue Sky lesson to learn it, and you taught it great.
jacobg2000 2 years ago
it is a hard song to sing, i think u would make it sound better with a deeper pitch. u did a good job.
jeffumz100 2 years ago
Good job man. Ignor the negative comments. It's a hard song to sing.
Goldminer63 3 years ago 2
dear Goldminer63
its not a hard song to sing. you can either sing or can not sing.
some people are not made for singing.
mate, you are great at the guitar but don't sing, or juyst take some lessons. because you quite frankly suck, and if no one tells you you're gonna just get laughs
C00Lcat69 2 years ago
great guitar dude!, and singing was ok too
aviy93 3 years ago
good guitar job.... well... the voice... but really good guitar job anyway ^^
eddolini 3 years ago
12 strings are the shiz for this song good job... singing not so much, but hey my voice is ba..a..ad :)
DrewNZ 3 years ago
Good job. Keep up the good work.
UnknownGuitarGod 3 years ago
I think you should go on the x factor,i think you have a great voice,when are you bringing an album out.
kribensis1990 3 years ago
Honestly... stick to guitar. just being honest. but over all great job.
Somethingicanremeber 3 years ago
guitar was excellent,you should maybe try a capo on the 2nd or 3rd fret,it may help your singing.hope im not too forward...joe.
blagger17 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
singing is dreadful just stick to guitar man
proctor03 3 years ago
almost had it ,great job though ,im buy me a12 string!
jslinko 3 years ago
Ok the singing was so off but your guitar playing is amazing.
Singing and playing is hard to do at the same time.
bboyjiraiya 3 years ago
what a great sound..i like it:D
mmmaaarr0121 3 years ago
It's kinda fast, and yes, work more on the singing
kyoshintama 3 years ago
work more on the singing cause your guitar is well done
rock0ut42 3 years ago
very nice i love 12 strings! I think your cover is better than mine. I cant sing as nice as you. if youd like to check out my cover of the song.
supersteubie 3 years ago
awesome! one of my favorite songs. u rock man!
GodOfGuitar3020 3 years ago
Sounds great. The 12 string has such a nice tone. Slow the temp down just a beat. Your timing is excellent. You have a nice, pleasent voice. Try lowering your tone a little. I sense your talking voice is naturally lower tone? The song does sound really nice, you can tell you've worked hard on it. It's right there.
archambault65 3 years ago 5
Thank you very much. And thanks for checking some of my vids out!
mike3571 3 years ago
dude that sounds awesome. I play that on my acoustic all the time, but I only have a 6 string so it doesn't sound nearly as good
saedin7k 3 years ago
sounded great thank you
minimoose1223 3 years ago 2