Added: 5 years ago
From: thepolonaise
Views: 481,307
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (739)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • He made some mistakes, but it was amazing.

  • this is brilliant haters step up and make a video of you playin, then you can talk trash

  • Sorry naysayers, this playing is straight up BadAss for anyone at any age, Here's a man in his 80's pulling this off, anybody who's knows anything about the difficulty of this piece and speed at which he plays and the interesting unique and gorgeous COURAGEOUS interpretation and relative accuracy know what a brilliant moment this performance represents in the history of classical music!!

  • who cares if there's mistakes, the interpretation is genius

  • So, there are like, 3 or 4 mistakes... big deal. The interpretation makes up for 100 mistakes.

  • mistakes? i've not seen mistakes! it'e perfect.... ;)

  • I don't care about what people think about this video, or about Horowitz... I just like this song and I'm happy listening to it :)

    Fuck you all

  • Honestly, this is my favourite interpretation of this piece so far. He was such an amazing pianist. (Stop hating on him!)

  • It has character by the bucketload. Enjoy it for what it is.... if everything was clinically perfect, the World would be boring/

  • It's the truth. You must be brainwashed.

  • This is not the sound of a Steinway. It sounds harsh and bangy, because the action was tampered with.

    HOROWITZING A PIANO - He used many scams to make people think that he was better then he really was. He had technicians file down the hammers, so he could play faster and louder while exerting less energy. This scam works best on octaves, but it makes the piano sound awful.

  • @6347285 lies! where did you get that idea?!?!

  • Comment removed

  • @6347285 You sound like a lunatic, or just plain envious of one long gone who played 50 times greater than you could dream of.

  • @leongatha6 You sound like your brainwashed. Being classically retarded is common.

  • @6347285 I've seen you state this in at least one other Horowitz video. Considering it's a pretty grave accusation could you provide a source?

  • This makes it sound like those mistakes were written in the music. Most beautiful performance of my brand new favorite piece.

  • Lmao at Chuck Norris comerical

  • I have yet to hear any other pianist alive or dead who matched Vladimir Horowitz's playing. He is very old in this video but still plays brilliantly, with unique phrasings & individual tonality. I can always identify his playing just by his touch. He hit each key in a precise way. His crescendos are even, graduating to a thunderous roar. He uses the pedal sparingly & in good taste. He was one of a kind & never boring.

  • Truly amazing! The wrong notes only add to the Horowitz experience - incredible pianist.

    I wish I had the chance to see him perform in person.

  • What the hell? After such a groundbreaking performance, the audience is too lazy to stand up and applaud? So disrespectful.

  • Piano arrangement of Stars and Stripes Forever that had to be heard to he believed (especially the piccolo part). I would also recommend the RCA recording of the Bacarole Op. 60 for an outstanding Horowitz interpretation of one of my favorite Chopin pieces.

    Cherio!

  • Some could play this piece with cool detachment. I suspect that Horowitz would look inside the piece to find a personal connection with the composer to create his interpretational magic. Isn't this the definition of an artist?

    True, Here he was in his eighties and did hit some incorrect notes. But if you listen to his earlier recordings, you can hear a precise and dazzling brilliance in his technique -- there is an early 50's commercial (on YouTube) he did for war bonds where he plays his p

  • Ugh, I do not like this version. He is slapping away at the chords and hitting many notes in between. I think that Rubinstein's interpretation of this piece is much accurate, precise, and musical. Horowitz performs Scriabin really well, but he isn't the greatest with Chopin.

  • Horowitz-the best

  • I like how he used two hands instead of one to start that E-D#-C#-B repetition; I would always play the big opening E major chords and then concentrate on playing the left hand as octaves...therefore I would always be thrown off on the melody because I guess I thought too much. Fact.

  • Dedicate to Arnold Miller, an Aussie,who passed away 3 years ago, aged 89, played like this.I'm sure there are more... who can play with the same temperament.

  • Scanning the responses, noting "mistakes" , this 80 something year old man made during this reading, of a few minutes, count the the "mistakes" you have made in your life time! Let us all know if anyone has made fewer. My hats off to any that can say "NO" . William

  • all y'all whining mistakes mistakes, sit down and play it yer damn self

  • Bravo!!!

  • majestuosooo!

  • no me gusta su principio es muy muy corto

  • What up dudes? Within the last ten pages of comments, lots of people, with uncontrollable rages, criticize the interpretation for mistakes...do you know it's entirely possible for an 84-year-old virtuoso to make mistakes on accident?

  • @ThePVGS1 I agree. It is impertinent and ungracious to point to minor mistakes committed by a supreme maestro in what is advanced old age. Rather than nit pick it is proper to enjoy superb piano works played by a great.

  • Oh my god, Bravo, old man! Bravo!

  • Was that an entire orchestra I just hear playing?

  • he looks so matter of fact while playing this

  • Superb! TY thepolonaise for listing

  • Beautiful, thank you!

  • Omg! I love this, Chopin is a genuis and Horowitz only makes it better!! :) I love his face after he's done playing! 

  • this isn't dubbed properly his fingers don't land when the music is played -.-

  • mistake at 2:14 (hit both F#/Gb and F instead of just F alone)

    mistake at 4:04 (unsure of the Ab pickup, but on my copy of this polonaise, the pickup note is not there)

    However, dispite the two (only two! I can't make it with less than...twenty five?) mistakes, this is the best interpretations of this piece I have ever heard.

  • @TheApplePi shut up

  • @TheApplePi at the age or 80+ making these mistakes ? give the man a break, dude.

  • D:

  • This was his, recorded, concert in Moscow, later he played almost the same in "het concert gebouw" in Amsterdam, I'm still glad that I saw him their life. His last concert before he died. It was a great piano player.

  • I love this melody so much!!!! YEAH!!!!!!

  • grandissimo Horowitz

  • SIMPLY F___KING AMAZINGLY THE BEST PIANIST PERIOD..............

  • One of the most colourful renditions I ever heard

  • This is very good,my favourite piece of chopins work! Bravo!!

  • I love you master!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Ah, this is Horowitz !

  • 2:15 wrong note ?

  • @Dukemaphakdeewong He makes a lot of mistakes in this version but his bravura, coloration, and unique interpretation more than makes up for it。 Remember he was very old.

  • The best technic ever... Bravo Mr Horowitz!!!

  • 28 justin bieber fans were here..

  • I will miss good old horowitz :)

    Died in his good old 80's a while ago, about 20-30 years. I will miss him :)

  • i love listening to fast pieces played brilliantly like here but i hate playing them lol

  • @ratchet5ify I totally agree with you! :P

  • a masterpiece

  • altro che rubinstein, quello horowitz se lo mangia a colazione!

  • Amazing...

  • @ClassicalMusicPL I understand your point, but I really don't want to listen to the performer alone. I really want to enjoy the genius that is Chopin, you get what I'm saying? I just don't think Horowitz does a good job with that. I'm sorry if I offended anyone...

  • I was never really a fan of Horowitz's style in playing. I'm not saying I could do better, but he over-exaggerates the use of the pedal, and slams into keys with his fingers at awkward times in a piece of Chopin music. I personally think he does not do a good interpretation of Chopin's music.

  • @SilenceTheQuiet Horowitz is the god music you fool !

  • @vaseintibet Try listening to Rafal Blechacz's interpretation of this one and you might agree with me... Its actually listed in the suggestions column, the vid. posted by luisguilhermeolbertz (dang, weird name!): Chopin - Polonaise As-Dur op 53 "Heroique" . And I am not a fool! Jerk!

  • @SilenceTheQuiet I understand, not everyone likes the same thing....

    1,137 likes, 26 dislikes ~~

  • @SilenceTheQuiet I agree, Chopin was a very expressive player, and although Horowitz is GREAT at dynamic contrast and inputting his own take on the pieces he plays, I don’t think that he was an expressive player. But he still is AMAZING!!!

  • @Randomness0014 And that is really my only point. He really is a good player... just not really at Chopin! :)

  • but there not, and thats why noone listens to this style anymore

  • Comment removed

  • This is wonderful playing... Such expression put into it...

    Just one thing... His 4:52 - 5:50 ... His thumb looked like a P**ni***s

  • how many times can this performance make me feel chills up my neck! I've lost count!

  • 4:28

    If there were such things as 'hardstyle basslines' in classical music , this is it.

  • due grandi: un compositore unico. affiancato da un interprete magico!

    lauril1 aprile

  • due grandi: un compositore unico. affiancato da un interprete magico!

  • The piano sounds like thunder.

  • Every time I hear this, it's like I'm hearing it for the first time...

    amazing.

  • Is 18 years old the right age to appriciate a beautiful piece of art enchanting your ears ? :)

  • Comment removed

  • @ph03n1xamb1t Do you have personal problems ? Seriously ....I don't know why you are insulting me  , when I'm only appraciating a music. And I'm not a Faggot ... Maybe you are one who don't wanna admit it . And ... Go Fuck Yourself !

  • @XCutePupa

    Fuck you you asshole. Why don't you try taking a look at the cunt that stares back at you in the mirror when you look at it. You fucking cretin. Die Cunt

  • @ph03n1xamb1t Hahahah Thank You baby , I love You ! :D

  • my question is when are these classical guys gonna start adding fresh ideas to this music. reharm that shit or something!! a creative guy like chopin wouldnt be trying sit down an listen to his music played over an over the same way if he was still around today

  • @zackthemack Show us how it's done and when u get famous for it we'll see u here

  • @zackthemack reharm this polonaise... lol you could only make it worse by doing that. why waste your time tampering with perfect pieces, chopin would move on and compose new masterpieces and thats what these "classical guys" should be doing

  • SO GOOD :D

  • Masterpiece!!! I'm not as old as you other posters but I know good music when I hear it.. It's sad good music is so unappreciated in my generation.. I feel like am outcast when I mention Chopin or Robert Schumann to my peers.. What a truly remarkable piece showing the soul of the early romanticist.. A sense of lost happiness and a longing for it back is the feel that this piece gives out.. 4:34 breathtaking!

  • @thatkidpeter i know exactly what you mean...

  • он гений!

  • My piano teacher once "stood" in line overnight, in January, to get tickets to see Horowitz play at Carnegie Hall. I was privileged to go.... Chopin's Polonaise in A flat maj was experientially beyond indescription ! As someone who grew up in the 60s and 70s, and attended my share of rock concerts, Horowitz's it's still the most memorable concert I ever experienced........and, I loved his big grin each time he stood...

  • one of my favorite classical music <3 vladmir horowitz is amazing!

  • 3:15 Start that lawnmower!!

  • @kingvictory2003....LOL

  • @kingvictory2003 LMAO-ROFL

  • @kingvictory2003 darn, I regret having seen your comment, coz now everytime I listen to this on my ipod and that part comes up, I can't get the thought of horowitz starting a lawnmower out of my mind!

  • @kingvictory2003 lol funniest comment ever

  • @kingvictory2003 i don't see why you put that.. he was truly into the music he was playing. so keep your stupid comments to yourself.

  • @kingvictory2003 LOL (I just pictured horowitz starting a lawnmower)

  • @kingvictory2003 :):) I can imagine Mr Horowitz managing to draw such a sound out of  a lawnmower!

  • That doesn't look like his piano. Maybe it is.

  • 25 people accidentally clicked thumbs down because they were concentrated on listening to this amazing pianist

  • Make that 25.

  • 泣いた!!!!!すばらしすぎる!!!!!

    

  • I love the build up around 4:30. The whole piece gives me chills, though.

  • 24 people apparently don't know a true genius at work when they see it...

  • Does anyone know where I could find a playlist for History 1?

  • apparently 24 people are completely retarded.

  • 2:15 bad

  • Es ist einfach erstaunlich.! Auch wenn er richtig laut und kraftvoll spielt, sehen sein Hände so aus als würde er die Tasten nur zart antippen.! Einfach genial.

  • my only complaint with this interpritation is how he (im sorry to use such a... strong word but its the only way i can explain my feelings for this) absolutely MURDERS the pedal usage. but of course horowitz is still the man!

  • descending scale (4 notes) sounds like setzer's theme in FFVI... this could maybe be one of uematsu's influences? :)

  • Ever since I heard it, I can't stop hearing "till the end of time" as I listen to this...

  • Amazing ... Fantastic ... Very Fast

  • horowitz manages to be impossibly elegant, yet grand, at the same time

  • Comment removed

  • @MrRagtimer Go back to the dark pit from whence you came.

  • Go back to your mom loser. LOL Somebody ain't going to heaven.

  • Horowitz is a very expressive player.

  • @MrRagtimer

    Ok, if you can play it better, or if you can define the "understanding of the piece," then please show/tell me.

  • @MrRagtimer lol. funniest joke ive heard in 2010.

  • @KelticaTheo No problem. I hope you'll get a chance to listen to other interprets of this piece one day.

  • All hail Horowitz. But all hail Chopin. Let's not forget the composer, without whom it wouldn't be possible. Right?. Having said that, one senses the hands of Chopin in Horowitz.

  • eloquent

  • to me, this seems somewhat of a vulgar interpretation...

  • interpretation of an old man...

  • 1'10 to 1'55 PERFECTION.

  • I still get goosebumps every time I listen to this. Sheer brilliance!

  • I like to think of His playing as what it would have been like to have seen Chopin himself play...if he'd lived to 86 and not 39, of course.

  • His left hand is just so powerful, yet so intimate when it comes to the weak sound.

  • His left hand is just so powerful, yet so intimate when it comes to the weak sound.

  • oliver cromwell lord protector of england

  • Horowitz is the best about CHOPIN for me..a real master...

  • was liszt homosexual?

  • @meesbroersen i dont think liszt was a homosexual.

  • WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @goodguysdoll we are not brainwashed, your just a boring, artistically backwards minded, turd

  • @egrosz

    I heard his concerts many times in New York, and he was simply the greatest among the greats. Emotion, and a singing sound from lyrical to thinderous but always in control. Forget the wrong notes....no one could play with this consistent quality and feeling. .

  • gotta say this is the best interpretation of this piece I have ever heard in my life!!!

  • And the greatest pianist is... Wilhelm Kempff !!!

  • Thank you so much, the paulonaise. To me, this concert was the best of latest Horowitz’s period. And the 53 he owned as never.

  • It's amazing how fast his fingers can move!! Horowitz is amazing... it's so cool to actually watch this particular piece being played rather than just listening to it. Thanks!

  • By far my favorite interpretation on YouTube. Sure, he makes mistakes--everybody does. But the emotion and passion he puts into this piece is truly breathtaking.

  • what a humble man...his hands moving softly like autumn clouds,

    the piano sometimes singing, sometimes roaring thunder.

    amazing old man ! this video is best piano lesson many

    of us could see in life. thank you !

  • holy cow.. is that really what he said. hahaha 

    "there are three types of pianists.

    Jewish pianists.

    Homosexual pianists.

    and bad pianists." -Vladimir Horowitz

    so.. is he Jewish?

  • @fliick720 That was a joke on his part, but he fits into two of those three types.

  • impressive.!!!

  • I love this interpretation. Horowitz is the master!

  • This is my favorite from Chopin and the way Horowitz, the master, plays it always brings tears to my eyes!

  • sound isn't cear, to bad for us, the pianist is genius

  • tears to my eyes...

  • Woah, I hope I can play like that one day.

  • @pegasus2503

    dream on...maybe in your next life, as this guy's reincarnation.

  • najwybitniejszy pianista XX wieku

  • @kuktafonisko

    "the best pianist of XX century"

    I thought the same, when I was watching him playing. It sad this kind of music is not so popular like years ago. but Im sure Horowitz is part of this great history of classical music.

  • You listen to his Japan concert and know and understand that he was ill at the time with his medication - and then return to this time after time to hear the 'comeback' he did. What I'd give for a time machine and to be there in the front row!!

  • A wonderful music. One can hear it and always enjoy.. Arellad

  • The master interpreter of this great piece.

  • i love how rubenstein plays it, but my GOD does Horowitz give this life!! Those small pauses into the thunderous rubato.. really makes my neckhairs stand at attention!

  • in the end he stole me a BIG SMILE =) happened spontaneously

  • Hr makes ot look so easy

  • Unsurpassed. Nobody in the history of recorded music has yet come close in interpretation, depth, and seeming effortlessness.

  • i love his flat finger stype of playing. his hands look like webbed feet

  • @cirosuperiore Stevie Wonder also!

  • He made me cry...