Well the bass line sounds okay, but I think the pitch on the staff with the treble clef is off a bit. You've got the notes right, and from 0:20 onwards, it's smooth sailing.
For those of you dishing out harsh comments....is there really a need for it? O_o
yeah i just think you have the treble clef about a major third too high, i'm not exactly sure on that tho. the treble and bass bass clefs in different keys until about halfay, then it's fine.
@panerudepon no… Beethoven is way better than a can in a blender (not saying that this song would be better if it was more in tune it would be way better)
you got it right again i think this sounds justl ike the theme song but it is terrible sound quality i know you have done better whats the deal with that?
another thing u should do is put it in cut time and drop the tempo by a half. it will be the same speed, it will just have more of a march like feel to it (maybe not when played in a midi, but to a performer it will)
Ooooooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh I know what you did!
The right hand is all written as it would be were it in bass clef! That explains why so much of it is a third off, and why the right hand is so much higher than it is is in the actual tune!
So yeah, I don't know how you managed that, and I don't get how after 2997 views I'm the first one to realise, but try just changing the symbol at the start to a bass clef. It should sound much better.
You got most of the rhythm right, and you're fairly close with a lot of it, but most of it's totally built on the wrong scale degree. After 21s is pretty good, although right hand is pretty much a copy of the left.
A lot of the time you're a third away, which is why it sounds pretty consonant but a bit off. Try moving everything in the right hand at the start down by a third, for example.
To be fair, you've picked a pretty hard tune. That modulation is horrible.
Sorry but that is just a ridiculous thing to say. Maybe I can do better than this, maybe I can't. It doesn't change the fact that it is an inaccurate transcription.
May I ask who wrote this? Besides being woefully incorrect, the whole rest on the first measure doesn't make sense - unless there is another instrument that is supposed to accompany this.
I wrote this music. This was done by ear, so it is obviously not completely accurate. The whole rest on the first measure is in case somebody would like to play a keyboard with the music. This is so they can press "play" and get into position before it starts. This is only the piano part, which is why it may sound strange.
There are lots of wrong notes !!!!
sonerersen 1 week ago
It actually sounds pretty good right at the end.
0903Thomas 3 months ago
@0903Thomas Because it stops?
ToniLenore159 2 days ago
@ToniLenore159 No, because it sounds a lot like the actual thing.
0903Thomas 1 day ago
Why is this in G minor? It sounds like Satan the Tank Engine more than anything.
LibertatemPopuli 6 months ago
ARRGGHH!! wtf?! did you just pick out random notes? well at least 0:20-0:21 has some sense.
hallowbe 7 months ago
This is so bad, it's great.
suntexi 8 months ago
Respond to this video... what the
kevin109able 8 months ago
new title for this, "Thomas the Tank Engine on Drugs"
naffanharrison 9 months ago
Comment removed
kylecartman10 11 months ago
out of key
KevinBeethoven 11 months ago
way to minor...
kitty0236 11 months ago
this video is good :-)
kylecartman10 11 months ago
at least 0:21 was good
kylecartman10 11 months ago
This is a vid where you can say people missed the DISLIKE button
Gdigger10 11 months ago
nice but not best
lego12323 1 year ago
OWIE that hurts this sucks like a s***
Builderman33 1 year ago
God damn this is so wrong haha
Nameless164 1 year ago
Why did you post this? :)
remcodelange94 1 year ago
Should start on a G instead of an e...thats whats putting the whole thing out
markdawsonmusic 1 year ago
Way to mess up the song...... What did it ever do to you???
GjDoctorWho 1 year ago
This is the funniest fucking video I've seen in a long time. Masterful troll panerudepon, 10/10
Xanarkand1234 1 year ago
................................ :'(
DynamoJez 1 year ago
...wrong key?
super58173 1 year ago
OH DEAR GOD HAVE MERCY ON US ALL!
makmegs 1 year ago
That's so bad it's... awful
richcolour 1 year ago
omg epic fail.
MrHelliks 1 year ago
Get this fuckin video down off the internet. worst 35 seconds of my life!
michael1234321 1 year ago
EAR RAPE!!!
Pageboy72 1 year ago 2
its the wrong key lmao
justin1305 2 years ago 2
what was this program??
blekmaster12 2 years ago
oh my god
pangerinequeen 2 years ago
sounds horriable :(
n00bszpro 2 years ago 2
its missing a staff lol
CtrlAltDaLEET 2 years ago
Wow. This may be crap, but it's good crap. : >3
couchpatatoo 2 years ago
this is good shit
achinda 2 years ago
oh my
MrSportylemen 2 years ago
out of tune
kellyfortune 2 years ago 2
fucking amazing
JimHardie747 2 years ago
too high
ChelseaKate17 2 years ago
Well the bass line sounds okay, but I think the pitch on the staff with the treble clef is off a bit. You've got the notes right, and from 0:20 onwards, it's smooth sailing.
For those of you dishing out harsh comments....is there really a need for it? O_o
RustysFangirlForever 2 years ago
okay i am sorry but that sort of hurt my ears:(
rpauly12 2 years ago
Comment removed
Panda0o0 2 years ago
wrong notes and it's in the wrong key.
reedman9 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
This is fucking horrible.
dflashan 2 years ago
How many times does he have to tell you?! It's the recording, and besides it starts to sound really good at 0:20
This is a good rendition of the theme apart from the low-quality recording.
Well done!
CineSteam 2 years ago 2
tonedeaf
Pallycaster 2 years ago
yeah i just think you have the treble clef about a major third too high, i'm not exactly sure on that tho. the treble and bass bass clefs in different keys until about halfay, then it's fine.
nckallen 2 years ago
What was that?!?
Shrinax 2 years ago 4
Appalling! You are tone deaf I'm afraid
AdmiralBud 2 years ago 22
ahhh my ears are blleeding
initabath 2 years ago 25
sooooooooo out of tune ,
a cat in a bleander would sound beter
initabath 2 years ago 19
That's because a cat in a blender is better than fucking Beethoven.
panerudepon 2 years ago
@panerudepon no… Beethoven is way better than a can in a blender (not saying that this song would be better if it was more in tune it would be way better)
hipepleful 5 months ago
its the recording
you here a wierd buzz in between notes because of your speaker or the recording
if u want it fixed, copy the score and play is yourself or get a better sound card and better speakers
nooblicker228 2 years ago
Better soundcard? as if.
It's the recording software that's the problem. I had it on low quality to preserve disk space.
panerudepon 2 years ago
usually used for gaming, but you can hear music better
and yeh its prbbly the recording
gamecomparer 2 years ago
the bass and teble are played out of tune with eachother, this urts my ears
outfromtheshadows1 2 years ago
I love it!
Oh,and don't listen to those guys.
pokefreak131 3 years ago
Just wondering-what program is this?
connorross123 3 years ago
Noteworthy Composer.
panerudepon 3 years ago
I really hope sincerely that this didn't take you too long.
Pianofectionist 3 years ago
one word...F-A-I-L!!! and a epic one too!
VWman100 3 years ago
Hardly epic, but I will admit it has a certain fail to it.
panerudepon 3 years ago
you got it right again i think this sounds justl ike the theme song but it is terrible sound quality i know you have done better whats the deal with that?
sbunited5 3 years ago
ew that the heck.
kellyslaternearly 3 years ago
right notes but wrong tone. the bass was perfect.
IsaacNorman 3 years ago 2
another thing u should do is put it in cut time and drop the tempo by a half. it will be the same speed, it will just have more of a march like feel to it (maybe not when played in a midi, but to a performer it will)
Daniel4119 3 years ago
The bass line was OK, but it sounded like the top was transposed down a third.
MasterMuffinMan 3 years ago 2
fail
nanoquaver 3 years ago
i agree
GamerKid165 3 years ago
here here that was the right tune but all the wrong notes
FinalFreek 3 years ago 2
you changed key half way through. Better luck next time
DoctorTankEngine 3 years ago 3
He changed it to the right key half way through, redo it with the key you used at the end at the start!
ParodysTributePage 3 years ago
this sonds like the bass + second treble line (not the actual solo line) - and some minor errors on top of that :p
okwestern 3 years ago 2
The ending sounds more like the actual theme, but the rest is not good at all.
johnnytheidiotengine 3 years ago 5
this was out of key, but you had the right idea.
MistaMeltonio 3 years ago 2
thanks for posting this,i know the original version really well,just cos this was a midi people think it sucked,theyre wrong! :D
youre a genius! :)
hartnell114 3 years ago
well, your 100 subscirbers have bad ears
and so do you
giroman42 3 years ago
I don't see your "version" of this sheet music. If you were to play this on an instrument, it would sound different anyway.
panerudepon 3 years ago
that verson SUCKED!!!
Hear the original song, and then you listen to this one, It's a bad verson
giroman42 3 years ago 2
My 100 subscribers disagree.
panerudepon 3 years ago
what programme did you use to make this?
sodorsno1 3 years ago
Noteworthy Composer.
panerudepon 3 years ago
thank you. i'm trying my hand at doing similar myself
sodorsno1 3 years ago
Another really good one is Finale Notepad 2008.
ctmajka 3 years ago
Ooooooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh I know what you did!
The right hand is all written as it would be were it in bass clef! That explains why so much of it is a third off, and why the right hand is so much higher than it is is in the actual tune!
So yeah, I don't know how you managed that, and I don't get how after 2997 views I'm the first one to realise, but try just changing the symbol at the start to a bass clef. It should sound much better.
slonzor 3 years ago
I'm sorry
This is really wrong
You got most of the rhythm right, and you're fairly close with a lot of it, but most of it's totally built on the wrong scale degree. After 21s is pretty good, although right hand is pretty much a copy of the left.
A lot of the time you're a third away, which is why it sounds pretty consonant but a bit off. Try moving everything in the right hand at the start down by a third, for example.
To be fair, you've picked a pretty hard tune. That modulation is horrible.
slonzor 3 years ago 4
wow.... um pretty bad haha. you got the bass line alright.. but the melody.... OH MAN hahaha, maybe this could be like the evil haunted thomas
theme
trainzvideo08 3 years ago 5
... :(
panerudepon 3 years ago
Well, where's your version then?
RayTheTrainEngine 3 years ago
Sorry but that is just a ridiculous thing to say. Maybe I can do better than this, maybe I can't. It doesn't change the fact that it is an inaccurate transcription.
Phyte 3 years ago
If you think you can do better, you're welcome to try.
panerudepon 3 years ago
@panerudepon i could do better with if i was deaf and blind, sorry to say but this is an epic fail of the highest order!!!
makmegs 1 year ago
@panerudepon we all could and we all would
Yamsareverytasty 1 year ago
great work
jordanschepis 3 years ago
Oh my god, that is just so very awesome!! =D
RayTheTrainEngine 3 years ago
May I ask who wrote this? Besides being woefully incorrect, the whole rest on the first measure doesn't make sense - unless there is another instrument that is supposed to accompany this.
cudak888 3 years ago
I wrote this music. This was done by ear, so it is obviously not completely accurate. The whole rest on the first measure is in case somebody would like to play a keyboard with the music. This is so they can press "play" and get into position before it starts. This is only the piano part, which is why it may sound strange.
panerudepon 3 years ago
It sounds a bit off key.
donaldengine9 3 years ago 4
...well I don't see your Thomas the Tank Engine music... so... there...
panerudepon 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Very childish
MaximumCheeseage 3 years ago
VERY AWESOME JOB
RiccardoDistefano55 3 years ago