Added: 4 years ago
From: u2dublindotcom
Views: 48,802
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (55)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the old U2 were damn cool , and I think they've done a good cover .

  • think some people forget this was before U2 were the band they are now.yeah they were well known but not near the same they are now..back in the days U2 actually had good songs.i remember watching this live at the time i still think they did a really good job,ill never be a huge fan but credit where its due..

  • I really do not think they want to equal Luke Kelly's version. They performed their own as a homage. It would be a nonsense if they tried to imitate Kelly's version. I think they took the right option. I prefer The Dubliners' version, but I really like this homage more than a bad imitation.

  • Fair play Bono..you might well be full of it of times.. but I reckon Luke would have appreciated the intent and your rendering of the song... dont understand the previous comment ..so no comment.. Bono is not, however, even half a singer of Luke Kelly or Ronny Drew..not even a quarter....... OMG this was 25 yrs ago !!!

  • i think bono did fantastic here! fantastic!

  • ... (continued) But The Dubliners were huge, and Luke Kelly was a brilliant artist, so Bono knew he had no business even trying to fill those shoes, hence the nervousness. That's my long winded way of saying that comments saying this was not as good a version as Luke's are missing the point. It was a tribute to Luke, and I think if he was there he would have been thrilled and would have been the first on his feet to applaud. Thanks for posting this, it brought back some great memories.

  • Comment removed

  • I was 16 when I saw this on TV back when The Late Late was on Saturday nights and I used to hate that it clashed with Match of The Day but I didn't mind that night. I remember getting chills listening to it. It's not that it's a perfectly pitched vocal, he definitely missed quite a few notes and he actually sounded nervous faced with an audience of about 150, which might sound funny for a guy about to embark on a 12 month arena tour. But The Dubliners were huge, and Luke Kelly was a brilliant a

  • U2 do their best, they could not, and never will beat the Luke Kelly version of this song. Even now that Bono thinks he's God, he still will never sing it like Luke.

  • =-'(

    This song really touched me...

    My great grandfather died from tuberculosis from the mines in Upstate Pennsylvania. I never met him.

    I love this song.

  • My parents bought this on Video (Still have the tape!), and I remember being about 4/5 years old watching this and actually being scared of Bono. Don't ask me why lol

  • I landed in Ireland this very day. Saw it on telly through very jetlagged eyes.

  • one of the best songs I have heard U2 singing. I remember hearing this live. was it really back in 1987?????

  • @golddragnet 100% with ya mateforget the politics and bono and u2 did a great job with this song.remember watching it myself..

  • one of the best songs I have heard U2 singing. I remember hearing this live.

  • this is before the joshua tree tour

  • which song do they sing? I haven't heard it before.

  • The u2 chap even says it... O_o

    Springhill Mine Disaster...

  • Get fucked zulawoo

  • Go Bono. You"ll make the Duliners if you keep on singing like this. Respect

  • Back in the fall of 1987 they played this at a concert in Buffalo, NY. Maybe because it was unknown to the crowd, you could have heard a pin drop in a place that held about 15, 000. It was amazing, the place was absolutely silent.

  • Luke was a great singer, but Bono doea a great job here too. Hey I was born proud to be Irish. There's only one thing worse than being Irish, and that's ' Not ' being Irish.

  • Infantile. Compared to Luke Kelly or Ewan McCall (who wrote it) this performance is just overwrought nonsense.

  • No one's going to measure up to Luke Kelly. But why compare them anyway?

    One of the great things about Irish singers is their own passionate characteristic singing styles.

    If you don't like Bono that's fine, but there's no reason to disrespect him.

  • Its not about liking or disliking Bono (mostly I like his singing0 its about this performance. Totally out of character.

  • This song was written by Peggy Seeger, with assistance from MacColl.

  • Comment removed

  • u2 are something very special. 4 a band 2 be so good 4 so long it takes a lot of talent and hard work. makes me proud 2 be irish, keep flyin the flag 4 ireland boys.

  • Type some decent english please.. you sound like some american pretending to be irish...

  • ooh how good bono used to look.yum!

  • Remember this when I was little - makes me proud to be Irish!

  • He does go on, but Bono / Paul Hewson HAS a beautiful voice xx

  • Watched this on the late late show dubliners tribute yesterday.... Thought it was good enough to watch again. Milford06 and poolpig you guys watch too much South Park.

  • Whoa Bono before he became a douche.

  • The world is sick, Bono make it better!

  • Oh my, so moving, can't understand the negative comments on here..tut!

  • i like it

  • Where can I find where they all sang the rocky road to Dublin at the end of the same show?

  • how dare him, whats a snog? :) I think a younger generation showing respect is good even if the cover isnt that great. so milford take the board out of your fanny!

  • Second best comrade.Nobody sings this song better than Luke Kelly.

  • Best Version ever!!

  • I remember seeing this live and It's a great performance. That whole show was really good with all these big men of Irish music, and the sing along at the end, it's nice to get to see it again, Great Stuff!

  • Its amazing how people get so jealous of people that do really well for themselfs im irish and the irish people are the worst people for being jealous.bonos not that bad, now gay byrne i hate.

  • Anyone got Jim McCann's performance of "I love the ground" from this tribute show ?

  • I just uploaded it this evening.

  • i've been looking for this vid for years so thank you dublindotcom.when i first saw this live on tv i knew they were on the verge of greatness

  • I so agree! I came here looking for this as it give me chills that night and I knew they would be huge..I emigrated to the US from Wwexford that same year and got to watch the spectacle...

  • Bono has saved lives! have you?

  • Actually, Yes!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more