Gemma and Kartik

[taylorswiftfan51]

everyone listen to the mummers dance by haley westenra it should be the theme song for this movie if they make it!

[WritingFreak13]

Where did you get the song fir this video? It's an amazing instrumental version of With Or Without You! I love it so much

[October271987]

who the hell are the sexy men??? jk i know who they are my future baby daddies

[BCourt25]

I think that the actor who plays kartik should be different

P.S.:AMAZING BOOCK.. I cried as I child

[Peedletuck]

UGH! I read this series two years ago, and now I'm crying all over again! Geez, this book makes me so emotional!

The quotes were great. And I LOVED one of the guys you found for Kartik, the guy with his shirt off. It's exactly how I pictured Kartik to look.

[MITSUKIISDEAD]

And there is the little detail that Kartik is Indian which means he is Asian. ^^

Something I highly doubt Hollywood would stay true to in the movie. They would make him some white English Gentalmen.

Because Hollywood hates to have Asian sex symbols. Someone who doesn't fit into their criteria or Nerdy,Technical, skinny, and short.

No Hollywood is almost determined to never let that happen.

But anyway your video was beautiful. ^^

[AgentKAYFLY]

this is pretty kool ...love the song....kartik is smexci!!nice choice lol.....ikr the ending of the series was so disappointing....there should be a fourth book...the end all where she trys and succeeds in getting him back...

[95detty]

omg, i almost cried at the end.....:OO

grrr kartik is hoooottt. <3

[coolJessie123]

Thanks for making this, I almost cried!

[egelimm43]

woow i think kartik is very very hoottt!!!

[VeritasRose]

Rachel Hurd Wood is gorgeous, but honestly, I think that Bonnie Wright (Ginny in Harry Potter) would be a GREAT Gemma!

[sofie8894]

it's fantastic, love it soo much, i hope the third book comes out soon in Belgium, i want to read it soo badly

[dra1000]

Please tell me the name of the song that plays during the credits. I love the song during the video, also (With or Without You), but I'd love to know what the song is that plays while the credits run. MANY THANKS!!!

[1121Carol]

OMG Karticks lips are soo full i even wana kiss them

[vballrockz13]

I absolutly love this!!!! You did an amazing job with this. Gemma and Kartik are my favorite ppl in thw whole book series!!!!! :)

[raylani21qz]

Just finished the sweet far thing and bawled my eyes out at kartik's sacrifice. So naturally i've come here for a bit of solace because to be honest i hated the ending of the series but i must say i loooove this beautifully made video. So prefectly put together and like so many others are saying i agree that this song is so pretty and perfect and sooo gemma and kartik. It also made me cry again but still an instant favorite of mine :)

[moi0x0melanie]

this is a great video, i can watch it over and over again.

[becca033]

Oh Kartik...

[jennywc]

what is this song called? it's pretty

[ColaMaus93]

Jesus, i love this trailer! It's just the best ... really, i love it! Great work, great song... perfect for gemma and kartik (: *tears*

[BUTinBlue12]

@ColaMaus93 i totally agree with you!!! my fav part i guess could be the begining its totally indian style and i just love this trailer!! *sigh* i would really love this book turn into a movie!!! i<3 Kartik!!

[ColaMaus93]

@BUTinBlue12 Actually it should be turn into a movie this year, but something went wrong ... that was my latest news. And YES, I would love to see Gemma, Kartik and the others on the big screen (:

[Einhorn02]

2:47 : what movie is it?

[sialalala123456789]

achhh it's perfect.. i've got chills

[Einhorn02]

i HATE this end so much..!

[magicweaver12]

i love it

the song is amzing

[tweetybirdy10]

ok what movie is that clip at 2:22

[melissadiane86]

I loved this. I adore Rachel Hurd-Wood as Gemma. You did a really awesome job!!! I watched it twice!

[helgaedm]

This was...amazing. The end made me almost feel as sad as the end in the book did. It's just...on the edge that I didn't start crying.

Simply amazing.

[iDance625]

This video is amazing - it made me cry. I just finished the last book and I am so upset about what happened, but it was quite an ending I must admit. Gemma&Kartik<3

[SeeSaraWrite]

Just had to say this is my most favorite Gemma/Kartik video. Gives me shivers. Amazing :)

[deadbride9]

I loooveee it!! I haven't fiished the last book, so I stopped when it seemed to be getting.... yeah...

Spoilerific, as you said in the descript.

But Kartik and Gemma are my favorite literary (sp?) couple~ Karma (KARtikgemMA), as photobucket calls it.

xD I absolutely love the video and can't wait until I find my book and finish it ^-^

[ororonsnow]

SPOILER!!!!

I was so sad when i finished the third book!! It was so sad. It just ended. I almost cried. And i don`t cry often!

[x3BellaCullenx3]

oh gosh that was really good. had tears in my eyes. i was nearly crying just think ing about their lovestory. its sooo sad.

5*

[lesly5rg]

can't believe I'm crying again...

[GothGirl5689]

Great video...pretty much made me cry. I LOVE Kartik and Gemma. That was seriously a great viedo. Nice job :)

[love4mygoddess]

i thought i was the only one that read that book!! holy cow <3 <3 <3

[rayniebaby13]

that was beautiful, you should be really pleased.

[sparkiilz]

OMG i love this vid! its sooo beautiful!

i LOVE kartik! i love love love him!!!!!!!

Just they way Libba bray made them fall in love is sooooooooooooo adorable!!!!

The guy who is kartik would do good but he needs to 1.) Get buffer and 2.) Tanner.

Then he will be PERFECT!!!!!!!

[deadbride9]

@Sparkiilz: and curlier hair >.> Gemma described him as a handsome, dark eyed and skinned man with black, curly hair. xD I just think the script writers need to get their head looked at a bit better... I'm with Min. Not my ideal Kartik, but, he'll have to do. The original Kartik seemed more... mature, yet less mature at the same time. like an understanding little kid who still wants to get what he needs. no offense toa nyone, of course v.v

[HawkSong116]

haha i know! he was sarcastic, but serious at the same time. he liked teasing her cuz he just seemed to turn up at just the right moment to make a comment

[twilightfan151990]

That was a really good video!!! Good Job!:)

[magicweaver12]

what is the name of the song?

[blueIbeauty]

It seems to be some instrumental version of 'With or Without You' by U2.

[deadbride9]

@ Bluelbeauty: Yeah, from wha tI heard,k it is.

[kt27rule]

i love t hsi video it os cool and sweet

[SpiritedxAway]

oh my goodness. the little princess opening! i havent seen that in ages...

[Kuromi16]

OMG!!!! i love it sooo much 5stars!!!!

it made me wanna cry D:

when i thought i was getting over his death i had to click on this video >:O....i miss kartik T-T

[LoreShy]

ç_ç! wonderfffffffffful!!!!

[Randommininacat16]

Oh!!! I love this sooo much!!! Though my perfect Kartik would be Steven Strait.

[BUTinBlue12]

ooomg!!! your video is great though i totally love twilight and evernight gemma doyle's trylogy is on my top fav series love kartiiik! <3<3<3<3<3<3 i imagine him so sexy and grown up ... i mean who wouldnt like an indian hottie ?

[seliath]

@BUTinBlue12 I agree. Although Max Minghella isn't Indian but i still think he would be an amazing Kartik.

[FairestFruit]

best vid iv seen in while! I agree-- Screw twilight, love gemmdoyletrilogy. lovylovove

:D Ps, i cry aloting rite now

[Randommininacat16]

Same!!!

[hobbedacat]

thats so like heart wrentching i love it i wanna cry right now :( i looove ur vid ty so much for it :D

[problemsgotyadown]

grr i miss kartik! goddamn tree! pshhht trees suck...third book made me cry all throughout school i was so embarrassed.

[TNMEBDlove]

I can't wait for the movie! but they better have all of the roles down right or else I will b SO mad!!! I♥Kartik

[pinkacue27]

there is already a movie but it is very old, so i have been told

[hobbedacat]

the book isnt very old so i cant imagine there would be an old movie but i wish!!

[problemsgotyadown]

pshhhht screw twilight this is now my favorite series.. *sobs* for sob reason this vid made me cry.

ps if kartik were real and gemma wasn't i'd have dib s=)

[CFAithsweetie]

one thing... that guy does not look indian... lol. hey hey hey. i love the actress for gemma. i think it would be perfect. i adore kartikkk.

[edwardcullenrocks21]

o my gosh that was sooo good!

i was literally crying

i dont really like her as gemma but i love him as kartik!

[bobbles471]

my favorite fan video for this series yet!

that's insane!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ahhh. loved it.

[escape4eva]

WHY does everyone think of Rachel Hurd-wood as Gemma! They don't have to just be able to look the part they have to act the part and to me personally i think she is a horrible actress!

[Minxie18]

I've seen RHW's movies and I think she's a perfectly good actress :).

[escape4eva]

well do you think she is a good actress for gemma? does she have that strong yet unsure feeling to her acting

[Minxie18]

She's never played a character quite like Gemma, but that doesn't mean she couldn't do it. She's a capable actress because she brings something different to each of her roles (even when they are similar characters in similar situations, like in Perfume and AAH, they are distinctive people). Which makes me think she has the acting chops to be Gemma.

[escape4eva]

well i dont think they should be making this into a movie anyways. when i read books a movie is going in my head. i dont need someone to ruin it and put it onscreen

[problemsgotyadown]

i kind of agree with that and whenever ppl make movies they cut out some good scenes...

[QueenofDiamonds1391]

@Minxie18 not in The Picture of Dorian Gray. i think shes kinda a snob. and i love Dorian so i just dont like her for capturing his heart and causing his distruction (also i blame lord henry)

[kt27rule]

i love this video it so cool and so sweet

[ColaMaus93]

Great! Really, really, really great!

I love the books so much and i cried when kartik 'died'.

The Vid is perfect, cause you know how to show the right lines of the book with the right clips of movies.

Oh My Goood ... I need something to dry my eyes *crycrycrycry* xD

So, very cool. You did a good job =)

Looove it ^^

[inulover333]

i just cryed . i loved it ^.^ but im still tearing up cause of kartik . i love the books to but i guess nomatter how hard you wish there can never be a true happy ending only half of one

[schoolxanswer]

I love it! The way you've used the clips, the music, the quotes... everything <33

God, the final... it's a beautiful and sad final... I hate and love it xD I cried when I read it, when I re-read it (I couldn't believe it T.T), I will cry when I read it again and I've cried with this.

Amazing tribute by the way :)

[pr1ncess1945]

OMG I LOVE THIS VIDEO

actually love doesnt even begin to describe how much i like it!

its really great!

whos the guy at 2:52?

because i would like to marry him :)

[nobellybutton1432]

That was amazing!!!!

[Aravis17]

I cannot believe I just cried. I didn't cry the first time I watched this back when you first uploaded it, but now I did. It just became all too real, the episode in TSFT. I'm going to go sit in my room with a single candle lit and cry now.

Marvelous job.

[ellieb09]

OMG your Kartik is sooooooo handome! And the girl is a perfect Gemma. But seriously...kartik is...woah......

[LoveIsJustALieXX]

I LOVE this video :)

[stantonluvr]

well gosh.. i'm just a mess right now.. darn it! i should have put on waterproof makeup before i watched this! eug.. the black streaks down my face look awful!! never the less, you did an amazing job with this video! you put the quotes in excatly the right order and spacing ... everything was perfect... even if i do look like i was attacked by an octopus right now.. great job!

[Raye2345]

I love this :)

[DreamFateHope]

I love this one. The music is amazing. The video in itself has great quotes, ones not often used.

Oh and this is a compliment in case it doesn't come off as one--I don't like RHW as Gemma in the least, yet this video didn't make me cringe with her being used.

Beautiful job.

I think the song did it for me--amazing song. I've watched it many times.

[Minxie18]

Thank you so much! I'm glad you liked the song (I like it too).

[Suie12]

i agree! This is the best one I've seen! It almost made me cry all over again.

[Minxie18]

Thank you! I was trying to make it sad actually, so sorry if I depressed you anything ;). The song made me think Gemma/Kartik in a tragic way so that's what I was going for.

[BeautyVintageRoses]

wow this is the most powerful Karma video i have ever seen! Absolutely beautiful!

[emileeadele13]

j'adore le musique!

[bostoncremetimbit]

I loved the quotes you used! I haven't found my perfect Kartik yet, so I'm not going to comment on that. But when you used the quotes from the fight in the Winterlands, I got all teary-eyed and choked up.

GAH I love this series.

[tortgirl]

That was great!!!

[Minxie18]

Thanks! :)