well....looks like 69 people dont like tim burton OR beautiful voices. too bad...sorry about that amy............some people just dont know good music when they hear it
Although it may be a serious transgression, I'll say it nevertheless: I like this version much better than the original song that appears in the movie. While the original tune suits the nature of the movie better, Amy Lee's version is so much more emotional, atmospheric and "appealingly creepy".
Good cover, but Fiona's is much better. Fiona suits the character and feel of Sally much better than Amy. Obviously, Amy has a beautiful voice, but this version seems too "pop-like" for more, as opposed to a Tim Burton film. It's not Amy's song, it's Sally's, and the least you could do as a cover is to catch her feel, not your own -- the music isn't even that similar.
@PriceisRighx26 the feeling you get from a song is not %100 about the song itself or the composer of the song or the genre that the original version belongs to but also about how the a singer feels and interprets it, the instruments used and the arrangement of the cover. personally I like Amy's version more because of her style of covering the song. maybe this is just because she made the song more "enjoyable" for me a guy who enjoys hard rock or heavy metal. cheerz
honestly i'm not really sure how you can dislike this song? Even if it's not your genere it's still put together well, sung perfectly and the band hits every note? If you have enough knowledge of Amy Lee, or Nightmare revisited I really don't get it. Unless it's 61 of those people who look for stuff to dislike
This song is awesome. If you'd like to hear a version of this song that my friend sang, go search mmpv123 Sally's Song. She's an AMAZING singer. Please watch and comment!
@BoltroBankai I was sooo fucking stoked for this album... all in all it was a big let down. The only good that came from it, in my opinion, was this and Marilyn Manson's This is Halloween. Korn's Kidnap the Sandy Claws wasn't bad either.
Dont hate on me but flyleaf would have might done a better job only because the lead singer has a higher tone voice...But this is pretty good non the less!!
Amy Lee's voice is absolutely stunning. She can cover such a wide range of emotion. This song really caught my soul the first time I heard it. And it still tortures me sweetly.
I prefer Fiona Apple's music to Amy Lee's music, but Amy Lee's version is the best. So much energy and emotion. Sounds like this song means a lot to her, she did a great job.
Amy Lee's voice is AMAZING. I don't think they could have picked a better person to capture the essence that this song creates. It is just so perfect.
@lonlyheartangel I like both versions, they each have such power. Just in different styles. If you listen close enough. This comes from a Fiona and an Amy fan.
If you like this cover check out our version! Search Me vs Gravity or just click on our name from this comment! HAPPY HALLOWEEN! Thumbs up if you like it :)
@chargedboy ya for sure this is my all time favorite movie it was the first movie i saw in theaters i was 4 when it came out my mom says i cried untill she took me lol
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Amy's voice is just... generic. It's not bad, she's clearly talented... but she doesn't sound different. And this cover is just dull, like much of her work.
The real Amy Lee was discovered by Joe Elliott of Def Leppard along with unknown Kurt Cobain in '83 at age 15. Not only does the lead singer use her name, but Amy Lynn for Pres Jimmy Carter's daughter. Kurt's friend Kathleen Hanna's band Amy Carter. Singers mother for Sara Lee Bakery and John for John Mutt Lange who produced Pyromania.
@MoonlitSnowWolf i know right? amy lee is so amazing 53 and possible more people just dislike it when i love the way she sings and you are totally cool to like evanescence trust me people who hate her are just sick so sick I would barf, then I'd listen to her (from those dislikes) and its my cure...
Reminds me of my past.. I came across this song and was listening to it, and my heart told me that there is something in amiss in my relationship.. I found out that my lover was dating another person.. there, ended...
just bought this movie on blu-ray 3D (Y)
isaiahach 1 day ago
Love this song and movie
1iloveanime101 4 days ago
She is so amazing....
babyunicorn1123 5 days ago
this is pretty song
pancraful 6 days ago
69 dislikes? Hell yeah! That's a sign!
DarthMohammed 6 days ago 8
well....looks like 69 people dont like tim burton OR beautiful voices. too bad...sorry about that amy............some people just dont know good music when they hear it
Fluteplayingbandgeek 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
AMY LEE MARAVILHOSA
MsIsraele 1 week ago
In love with this song
15bieberbeliever 1 week ago
<3 How could anyone dislike this? D:
xxSweetHeartLovex 1 week ago 6
I want to buy this soundtrack. The Nightmare Before Christmas. ♥ Amy Lee.
BeckiTheRockstar 1 week ago
It has been clinically proven that Amy Lee’s voice can cure headaches.
northernlights12345 2 weeks ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
i love this song
SuperCutebubble 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
I love this song better than my exboyfriend.
crempt 3 weeks ago
wow.
shoobug18 3 weeks ago
you gotta <3 her :D
bloodynightrose1016 3 weeks ago
soso beautiful. ♥
bumblebreex 3 weeks ago
She sang it first b4 nb4c
090909lisa 3 weeks ago
@090909lisa no she didnt....
MySleepyHobo 2 weeks ago
@090909lisa Actually no, the movie cane out in the 90's.
Jakeee81 1 week ago
I <3 Amy Lee!!!!
Awwison99 3 weeks ago
Although it may be a serious transgression, I'll say it nevertheless: I like this version much better than the original song that appears in the movie. While the original tune suits the nature of the movie better, Amy Lee's version is so much more emotional, atmospheric and "appealingly creepy".
WabashMan1989 4 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos 21
shes as beautiful as her voice
babybunnybrie 4 weeks ago 6
you see the dislike bar? yeah. me neither.
luvc00ki3m0nst3r 1 month ago 46
i am going to do a cover of this cause this is an amazing song and i just totaly love amy lee XD!!!
AzzaBVB 1 month ago
Great cover. Fionna Apples is ok, mainly because she sings it 2 octaves lower than the original.
Froleyboy 1 month ago
Good cover, but Fiona's is much better. Fiona suits the character and feel of Sally much better than Amy. Obviously, Amy has a beautiful voice, but this version seems too "pop-like" for more, as opposed to a Tim Burton film. It's not Amy's song, it's Sally's, and the least you could do as a cover is to catch her feel, not your own -- the music isn't even that similar.
PriceisRighx26 1 month ago
@PriceisRighx26 I disagree completely. Fiona's version isn't on the same pace and I don't really like the music that accompanys it.
LittledudeJrr 1 month ago
@PriceisRighx26 the feeling you get from a song is not %100 about the song itself or the composer of the song or the genre that the original version belongs to but also about how the a singer feels and interprets it, the instruments used and the arrangement of the cover. personally I like Amy's version more because of her style of covering the song. maybe this is just because she made the song more "enjoyable" for me a guy who enjoys hard rock or heavy metal. cheerz
Sha4x4 1 month ago
♫♪♫♪♫♪
dannyphantomrocks12 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
omg the lovelyest voice
Sychoticnightmare 1 month ago in playlist Nightmare revisited
i <3 this song!
shadowfansonicx 1 month ago
I love your voice ma'am
urikatron 1 month ago
@urikatron Her name is Amy Lee and she is the lead singer out of Evanescence
AzzaBVB 1 month ago
honestly i'm not really sure how you can dislike this song? Even if it's not your genere it's still put together well, sung perfectly and the band hits every note? If you have enough knowledge of Amy Lee, or Nightmare revisited I really don't get it. Unless it's 61 of those people who look for stuff to dislike
Nickolas351290 1 month ago 4
Fiona Apple's a smoker. Amy Lee, is a perfect creeper.
NeVeRsHoUtNeVeRX10 1 month ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
This song is awesome. If you'd like to hear a version of this song that my friend sang, go search mmpv123 Sally's Song. She's an AMAZING singer. Please watch and comment!
showhostpurple12 1 month ago
Love is like a heart shaped bomb so precious and lovable but can cause great destruction like a broken heart
ohaidere12 1 month ago 3
happy birthday ,Amy!
UniqualovesAustin 1 month ago
This song is beautiful! I love Amy Lee!
waterlilly166 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos 3
If you like the harmonies of the original song, listen to Gustav Mahler (classical composer).
psychicbyinternet 1 month ago
Comment removed
psychicbyinternet 1 month ago
I've been disappointed by a lot of the tracks from this album, but this one was pretty good.
BoltroBankai 1 month ago 5
@BoltroBankai I was sooo fucking stoked for this album... all in all it was a big let down. The only good that came from it, in my opinion, was this and Marilyn Manson's This is Halloween. Korn's Kidnap the Sandy Claws wasn't bad either.
lolcookies100 1 month ago
I've never seen this movie but I just heard this song because Amy Lee is singing *-* this song is amazing!
dudumarques1000 1 month ago
@dudumarques1000 see it its good
Sychoticnightmare 1 month ago
Dont hate on me but flyleaf would have might done a better job only because the lead singer has a higher tone voice...But this is pretty good non the less!!
SmileyRawkX 1 month ago
@SmileyRawkX I thought that Amy Lee did an absolutely wonderful job of capturing this song's entire feel and atmosphere.
lolcookies100 1 month ago
The Dislike Bar is Like a Ninja,There but Not Seen.
SaVeComplete 1 month ago 4
59 people who dislike this clip needs to be burned at the stakes
Darklg23 1 month ago
Amy Lee's voice is absolutely stunning. She can cover such a wide range of emotion. This song really caught my soul the first time I heard it. And it still tortures me sweetly.
lolcookies100 1 month ago 6
Anything Amy Lee touches turns to gold. Since this was already gold? I'm going to go ahead and say platinum this time.
SupremeChii 1 month ago 4
Why is the dislike bar white?
reeves50799 1 month ago
does he know how much he means to me
this line reminds me of my dear friend whom i've know since 3rd grade and now i'm in 8th grade
fashionlover419 2 months ago
Love the movie there for love all the songs . I love her voice so much.
nixon95lover 2 months ago
59 people disliked this once.. ONCE. -evil face-
MrAnimeninja57 2 months ago
Woooow ! ÔwÔ
Love <333
MrawOfMraw 2 months ago
"Does he notice my feelings for him." I think a shiver just ran down my neck and spine. Oh Amy, what your music does to me. <3
MissReflex16 2 months ago
I prefer Fiona Apple's music to Amy Lee's music, but Amy Lee's version is the best. So much energy and emotion. Sounds like this song means a lot to her, she did a great job.
kisaramercury 2 months ago
Those 59 people that hate this song are all haters....... This is the worlds most amazing song EVER!!!!!!
txbluzman71 2 months ago
WOW
COOL^^
AMIGAAUSENTE 2 months ago
Comment removed
AMIGAAUSENTE 2 months ago
Amy Lee's voice is AMAZING. I don't think they could have picked a better person to capture the essence that this song creates. It is just so perfect.
gothman1994 2 months ago
beautiful!!!!! this is the right musik and the right voice for such a film! <3
Rosiel0071 2 months ago
She is the perfict person for this song she has it down know one eals can do this song any better
Jenji2005 2 months ago
If U DONT like it DONT watch it! we dont need to see dislikes on an amazing song like this!BTW I loove this song!!!! <3
taylorlovesRay 2 months ago 2
Beautiful...... <3
CaRyS469 2 months ago
if they ever have to do a remake of this movie and cant get the real voice actor they better get amy lee for the love of god and the heavens......
undeadmanwalking 2 months ago
@undeadmanwalking she did the song in the newest rendition
thedinosaur78 2 months ago
And the best thing about this video, I don't even see a dislike bar:)
Kimbersaurx3 2 months ago
I can sing this song perfectly! Amy Lee has the voice of an angel!
LouderxThanxThunder 2 months ago
Dislikes? What fuckery is this?! Amy is amazing.
zeroendless2 2 months ago
@zeroendless2 haha...."fuckery". that's my new favorite word.
iFenceU 2 months ago
@iFenceU Haha. Happy to help XD
zeroendless2 2 months ago
@iFenceU Lmao xD This comment made my day :D
lupinLyrics 2 months ago
Dear Amy Lee,
I hope your voice feels better soon, I'm sorry for forcing you to sing this song over and over and over again.^^
Get well soon, Everyone Who Listened To This Song.
kagetatsu360 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 64
It's raining really hard outside right now.. and hearing her sing is just amazing :D so soothing.
EmoAddress666 2 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I luv this song so much! But it relates 2 me and the guy i lik ALOT!:(
anime123231 2 months ago in playlist Liked
I luv this song so much! But it relaes 2 me and the guy i lik ALOT!:(
anime123231 2 months ago in playlist Liked
LOVE THIS SONGGGGG
TeeAhhRAWR 2 months ago
Everytime i hear this song my heart melts sally would not be only proud she would be flabbergasted ;)
doomdawg76 2 months ago 3
Sally would be proud :')
blackrose3131 2 months ago 8
best part of this? 0:00 to 3:35
my least favorite part? 3:36
THANK YOU YOUTUBE FOR REPLAY BUTTON
ShadowWolf0000 2 months ago 5
Every time I listen to Amy my confidence in my voice goes down. FUUUUUUUUU....
TheNerdTopia 2 months ago 14
Dear Dislikers,
Were.Coming.For.You.
Love,
The Monsters under your bed >:)
bffl4eva2u 2 months ago 253
@bffl4eva2u if your a chick all be waiting
TalkingWithMeRADIO 1 month ago
Dark, melancholic, and full of wonder. I love the original and Amy Lee's version. Beautiful.
viciouspurple 2 months ago 5
I <3 Amy Lee
tHeFuTuReMrSBELLAMY1 2 months ago
i love you Amy !!
Dolbezian 2 months ago
if I get like, 20 likes. I'll do a cover of this?
itsemilybr0 2 months ago 100
@itsemilybr0 you got 21 what now
016632 2 months ago
@itsemilybr0 I did one just cause...:I
TehSingingSheep 2 months ago
@itsemilybr0 get to singing :)
anthonee69 1 month ago
I love you amy lee
hopethedrummer1 2 months ago
my music.
LupStabler 2 months ago
she has the voice of an angel. <3
itsemilybr0 2 months ago 7
@itsemilybr0
A rather Dark Angel, but Still a beautiful angel
SparxofFlame 2 months ago
eu ainda não paro de escutar essa música hehehehe
lainz567 2 months ago
only she could have done this justice.
TrubblewithTribbles 2 months ago
favoriite 2iinger and my favoriite moviie... perfect!
crpoirrier 2 months ago
1:38 fav part
vikkithefearless 2 months ago
@vikkithefearless epic
TalkingWithMeRADIO 2 months ago
Comment removed
vikkithefearless 2 months ago
she shouldve sang it instead of sally :) <3 i love this version so much better!
AlexandraMoniqueful 2 months ago 2
Her voice is a beautiful lullaby<3
Tarbarx 2 months ago
I love her voice, but her band is just plain god awful.
napalmman420 2 months ago
I LOVE THE BEGINNING!
fashionlover419 2 months ago
Love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheAmylee1981 2 months ago
Wow. It's been along time since I've gotten chills listening to a song. This is pretty much on par with the origional in everyway!
Vampireslayer64 2 months ago
*-* there are no words to explain how beautiful this is...
WatchOutForBunnies 2 months ago
Amy lee does so much better job then Fiona apple, cause Amy lee capture the emotion sally feeling at the point in the movie better.
lonlyheartangel 2 months ago 3
@lonlyheartangel I like both versions, they each have such power. Just in different styles. If you listen close enough. This comes from a Fiona and an Amy fan.
Popofindyred 2 months ago 4
I like her sooooooooooooooo much!
ksenyakremis 2 months ago
By far the best remake for the nightmare before christmas. better than in the movie...
ke11yke11z 2 months ago
This is fantastic. Her voice is perfect so clean and smooth. :)
Taylorjade54 2 months ago
Wow all the more reason why I love Amy Lee
punkroxs 3 months ago
I LOVE THIS SONG!!! over 50 likes and i'll dance to this for the talent show!
lenabean121 3 months ago 4
her voice is amazing
StephenHawkingsChair 3 months ago
one, two, three, four, five, six. one, two, three, four, five, six. Trick or treat, I give you treats and tricks! ONE, TWO, THREE, FOUR, FIVE, SSSIX! BOO! ^ ^
DArKNeSSDiScIPLe 3 months ago
52 people don't think its christmas or halloween. NOOBZ >.>
chibscutes 3 months ago
Her voice is PERFECT for this song. Btw nightmare before chirstmas rocks!
lildude2828 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you like this cover check out our version! Search Me vs Gravity or just click on our name from this comment! HAPPY HALLOWEEN! Thumbs up if you like it :)
mevsgravity 3 months ago
best voice ever
japanskeunger 3 months ago
i want to here tarja sing this :]
HONEYDROP11 3 months ago
@HONEYDROP11 then it would sound like SHIT lol
sTapleEVA 3 months ago
@sTapleEVA Hey, don't be dissin' Tarja lol...but no, Tarja's too operatic for this. Amy Lee is just perfect :)
AimeeHalloway23 3 months ago
@sTapleEVA i fail to agree i think shes beautiful not saying anyone is better than the other.
HONEYDROP11 2 months ago
beautiful<3<3
XXxanimefanx 3 months ago
@VictoriaBatiz That's a completely different singer
timchap32 3 months ago
this is where she redeemed herself after "what's this?", haha(:
VictoriaBatiz 3 months ago
@VictoriaBatiz That's lacy mosely from Flyleaf.
RavenEvanescence 2 months ago
amazing <3
VampirishhSA 3 months ago
her voice is my cure <3
koujilittlemonster 3 months ago 81
i luv her voice
lov4mj111 3 months ago in playlist lov4mj111's favorites
WHO EVEN DISLIKED THIS?
MorinneTV 3 months ago 61
@MorinneTV Sally disliked it 59 times because her voice isn't as awesome as Amy Lee's.
BensonIz3pik 2 months ago 2
Amy Lee has a beautifully haunting voice that suits this song perfectly. It would be hard to find it sung better.
holderoftheheart 3 months ago 5
Comment removed
smiley1040 3 months ago
Amazing...Movie :) No other words to describe it...and Amazing...Voice...Evanescence is SO awesome!!
SimsCat988 3 months ago 2
This is one of the two tracks where the cover is, imo, better than the original (the other being Marilyn Manson's cover of "This is Halloween").
Amy Lee really is the best choice for doing this cover, she's just freaking awesome. I like Fiona Apple's version too, but this one is better ^^.
TTarOtaku 3 months ago
i luv her voice
lov4mj111 3 months ago
:'D
Galletarawr 3 months ago
0:00 again!
twpv71093 3 months ago
this shit goes hard!!!
ADancinggirl34565 3 months ago
This song was made for her! Out of all the tracks on the Revisitied album, this is one of the most well done!
ZeeJeff 3 months ago
me encanta amy lee y evanescence!!
brenchuru 3 months ago
52 ppl can't sense anything in the wind. Lol
iAndyEllie 3 months ago
@flarixs it's still sad... it takes something so bad to bring them together.
chargedboy 3 months ago
@chargedboy ya for sure this is my all time favorite movie it was the first movie i saw in theaters i was 4 when it came out my mom says i cried untill she took me lol
flarixs 3 months ago
:( i know how Sally feels now....
dexx2323 3 months ago
kai gamo :P
joker9111980 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Amy's voice is just... generic. It's not bad, she's clearly talented... but she doesn't sound different. And this cover is just dull, like much of her work.
Mechanthrope 3 months ago
@Mechanthrope Really? Because I don't know a single singer that sounds the same.
AngelxSonic 3 months ago
XDDD i love thiz movieee
TheKIkILiLr0cK3R 3 months ago
51 DISLIKES?! YOU'RE JOKING! YOU'RE JOKINNNG ME, YOU GOTTA BE!
ClairiLucille 3 months ago
LOVE THIS SONG!!! Amy Lee has an voice I am so jealous! GO AMY!!! <3 <3 <3
DareDreamLove 3 months ago
@DareDreamLove Yep. She does indeed have a voice, as do i, in fact. Jealous? :D
GenericFantasyXO 3 months ago
@GenericFantasyXO lol some one likes themselves lolz
DareDreamLove 3 months ago
@DareDreamLove I assume you have a voice too, so what is there to be jealous of, honestly? XD
GenericFantasyXO 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The real Amy Lee was discovered by Joe Elliott of Def Leppard along with unknown Kurt Cobain in '83 at age 15. Not only does the lead singer use her name, but Amy Lynn for Pres Jimmy Carter's daughter. Kurt's friend Kathleen Hanna's band Amy Carter. Singers mother for Sara Lee Bakery and John for John Mutt Lange who produced Pyromania.
Boddahism 3 months ago
This is pure AWESOMENESS!!! ♥
MonicaChan14 3 months ago
51 people just plain suck. >.>
MoonlitSnowWolf 3 months ago 64
@MoonlitSnowWolf i know right? amy lee is so amazing 53 and possible more people just dislike it when i love the way she sings and you are totally cool to like evanescence trust me people who hate her are just sick so sick I would barf, then I'd listen to her (from those dislikes) and its my cure...
skywick1 2 months ago 2
Amy lee is the best to me her music touches my soul and makes me shiver everytime.
MrSevilnatas 3 months ago 4
Reminds me of my past.. I came across this song and was listening to it, and my heart told me that there is something in amiss in my relationship.. I found out that my lover was dating another person.. there, ended...
Gideono 3 months ago 4
@Gideono poor thing TT_TT
Ninathedragon1997 3 months ago
@Gideono wasnt the one, thats all. i hope oneday you find someone who treats you right
ProudGoth 3 months ago
I lovelovelove this version!!!
PrincessGummiBear99 3 months ago
This is better than drugs...
deppgurl150 3 months ago 5
a voz da amy lee fica mais linda cantando a musica da sally *---*
vampirblanchard 3 months ago
~ Addictive ~
TheRa8ra8 3 months ago
Can't stop listening to this... Can't stop crying... Can't stop thinking of my lover...
Black666Petal 3 months ago
@HorsesRcool69 Me too >:O XD
cartoongirl2224 3 months ago
Comment removed
cartoongirl2224 3 months ago
51 people missed the like button
MsLinklover101 3 months ago 5
I can't name one person who would sing this better
MsLinklover101 3 months ago 121
@MsLinklover101 Have you heard the Fiona Apple version?
64thquaver 3 months ago
@MsLinklover101 I can, Fiona Apple's version's better.
happymonsterr 3 months ago
i like this remake better than fiona apple...just saying.
MissCureCrazy 3 months ago in playlist Halloween Dream
i love this film and i love amy lee so puting them both togeather is just soooooo epic
TheNyx616 3 months ago
@ShardsofGlassInMe Woot!
KoalaBaby2015 3 months ago