Added: 4 years ago
From: SkyeSweetnamVideo
Views: 115,142
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (299)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • god i wish I lived in canada

  • I wonder where Skye found out about this song, not many non-Asians know about CPOP but I'm glad she does :)

  • I love this video

  • Theres something wrong with this...My speakers wont go up louder :(

  • 2011... still love this <3

    and the s.h.e one!

  • My favorite song by her...besides Hypocrite...and Human...and Baby Doll Gone Wrong...and Just the Way I Am...I LOVE YOU, SKYE, YOU'RE MY HERO!!!

  • Gtta luv her ryt?

  • I like "Chyna Girl" better. lolx.

    This is sweet, too.<33 Skye.~

  • they just made a new thing. came out today, its called Recording Equipment.

  • Since I got confused who sang what first, I looked up the composer...

    German producer Roberto Rosan composed "Super Star" for S.H.E. which became a hit in 2003. Roberto then had the lyrics rewritten for his Euroband, Sweetbox, as "Chyna Girl." Skye Sweetnam then re-recorded "Super Star" as "Superstar" in 2004.

    And now we're here, talking about this in 2010...

  • chyna girl by sweetbox is the EXCACT SAME SONG!!

  • @Angile13

    The song was originally from S.H.E., then Sweetbox got permission to do the same song with different words, and Skye Sweetnam got permission to translate it to English, genius.

  • @SuperpoweredGirl you know, you didn't have to get all butthurt about it. it's nice to to know all that, but my comment was that this is the same song as one from Sweetox. excuuuuuse me for not knowing who SHE is.

  • i skye sweetnam is awesome! i love her music!

  • Skye sweetnam i am a fan of yours so you also call me a superstar WE LOVE YOU FROM FEBA AND RIDA

  • @WebkinzMileyCyrus its not a fake mole. she was born with it. in fact-she sometimes gets it airbirshed out of pictures so that it looks like its not there. and she is really pretty.

  • @WebkinzMileyCyrus Who wants to act 'normal'? Or be like miley cyrus? she is just so annoying, in my opinion. I idolize Skye!

  • @rabfobon THANK GOD Skye is HERSELF not Miley Cyrus xD

  • Wow an English version

    I love it

  • Kewl. From Chinese to English. I've always loved the S.H.E version but this is also good. ^^

  • same here!!!

  • but my friend said it was korean?

  • S.H.E is from Taiwan if I'm not mistaken & I know that they're Chinese because I speak the language, well a bit of the language but I can differentiate Chinese, Japanese & Korean.

  • No it's Chinese. I'm Chinese. They are Taiwanese but the language is considered Chinese too cuz its similar anyway.

  • awesome skye! you rock! can't wait for your new album! I hope you put "Boomerang" on it cause the parts i heard in ur makeup vid were rlly good!

  • Skye is awsum xDD

    I luv her and S.H.E too

    they r amazing (:

  • WEIRD~ It's not a bad cover...

    But I will always love S.H.E's Super star the BEST!!!

    weeeee S.H.E!!!!!

  • @oniyurisan

    first is always the best

  • @ilovetodayy

    agreeeed!

  • I prefer S.H.E's version, but this Skye's version is pretty good too. :) I really like the chorus ♥

  • this sounds exactly like china girl :[

  • one copied the other

    yea they are

  • which one copied which

  • the original song was by S.H.E. it was the same as this but in some other language. Then Sweetbox changed the lyrics and made chyna girl. then skye translated superstar to english. but they all did this LEGALLY. so it's a cover. not a copy.

  • You are my superstar... I like it, especially the chours.

  • i love the music vid!

    I like skye's version the most..then Chyna Girl is my second fave...i don't like S.H.E's version...i just think it's weird....

  • ha i know a canadian called skye

  • skye, i love you missy <3

  • Both versions are great :]. S.H.E. is the original and no cover of any song by any artist can touch an original song.

    But both versions are kickass, I love em both.

    (Im not too fond of the sweetbox version tho lol)

  • i prefer SHE's original version better but I prefer Skye's over Sweetbox's version...I think Skye's is the last version to be made. But yeah, her's is better than Sweetbox's but not as good as SHE's

  • I, per sonally like this version better...although I love S.H.E 's version. :D

  • i love S.H.E. and Skye!! i love the original better of course, it's my ring tone =D S.H.E. is always coming up with awesome songs!

  • Not as good as S.H.E. but still pretty good. (:

  • i liek BOTH versions but S.H.E's version IS better though

  • S.H.E. made the song 1st

    S.H.E. is a chinese girl band

  • this version doesn't have the same lyrics. the only thing the same is the music and the part where she says "you are my superstar". i think skye sang this first tho. not sure.

  • i luv skye since her 1st record.. wow... can't wait 4 her 3rd album... hehe... you r my superstar.... hehe....

  • whichever.. skye sings it better than SHE..

  • So who sang it first? Skye or S.H.E?

  • S.H.E. sang it first

  • Do you like S.H.E?? I love them, i got the feeling you like them too:)) Continue rocking pretty...

  • You can write so great songs! I like it so much! and you're so adoreable when you fool around XD Keep it up!

  • I loooooooooove this song... especially when she sings the you are my superstar part

  • shes pretty and can sing and i bet she be a great actress also i love the song ^___^

  • This song is from S.H.E

    I love both versions ;D

  • Skye is the original.S.H.E cover it.

  • No, Skye covered it. SHE sang it first, then new lyrics were written for the song in English, sung by Sweetbox, then Skye covered SHE's version. SHE's Superstar came out in 2003, Skye's version came out in 2004.

  • which ever it was, skye is just like 50 times better

  • nope.

  • @Singergirlsb acctrully sweetbox came out with it 1st then S.H.E then Skye

  • I love how she changed the original song into her own.

    You can still detect the distinct style of chinese pop music behind it though. :)

  • "superstar" wow!!! love this song!!!

  • woah, this is s.h.e's superstar in english!

  • i know!

    when i saw this i was like

    woah

  • i beg to differ

    the s.h.e version was released years ago

    in 2003 or sth

  • no its from s.h.e actually

    your wrong

  • SHE HAS A BRILL VOICE

  • This is a great song, and the video's pretty cool. However, if I were her, I would have made the video a bit darker, and show more of the hero than myself goofing around haha.

  • This song kind of sounds like a chinese song by S.H.E

  • yeah its like.. the same.. but than ... English... :P

  • Skye is a superstar! =)

  • Isn't it the melody from Sweetbox - Chyna Girl?

  • yes.

  • i love this song <33 .

  • I <3 this song i am singin it in the hallways @ school 24/7!!!

  • actually i prefer s.h.e's version but this is quite cool too! ;D

  • this song is sooo cool

  • niceee songgggggg with sweetyyy :d:d:d:d

  • Ashes did a remake of this song too, called superstar it's the korean version

  • AWESOME SOUNDS =PPP

  • I love this!

    Skye did an awesome cover!

  • Lmao they kinda sound the same to me, except that Skye's is in english. and little more towards the pop side; but their both really goood =]. I haven't heard sweetbox sing it; but eh I like em all equally it's kick ass song regardless who sings it.

  • how many ppl are gonna cover this song? Sweetbox (chyna doll) , her and S.H.E. I think s.h.e did the best version

  • Why S.H.E.?

  • wow, i never thought i would hear this song in english. ahah~ i'm so used to the chinese version.

  • I kno rite

  • Who the hell is she singing to?

    This video screams pop diva, she's a good singer but the lyrics don't fit with the song...a little too deep for her (my opinion anyways) I personally like the original version done by S.H.E :)

  • Ok so from my research (yes i looked it up on wikipedia)

    The Song was originally written for the Chinese girl group S.H.E under the name "Super Star" title song for their 2003 album The same dude who wrote the song for S.H.E translated it into english, and gave it to the european group Sweetbox to sing, under the title of "China Girl". The song was once again covered by Skye under the title "Superstar" All three song alike, but I like S.H.E's version better!

  • Ty now I think I understand much better ^^

  • i know, i like this version better, i like the original but i dont like how the Chinese language sounds. its kinda annoying....and the video from SHE is really corny

  • Skye makes me put glue moustaches on my face. In a good way.

  • Well done! ^^ ´Skye´s always brilliant (even though this is not a big favouritesong of mine)and this was a great combination ^^ I´d like to hear S.H.E with this song...

  • S.H.E like the Chinese pop band?

    and I've heard this tune before, look up Chyna Girl

  • wait. nevermind. it is the same song.... oops

  • s.h.e did this song first. and skye did the cover. so technically, s.h.e was brilliant. :) haha. but skye did a good job. its a great cover.

  • ...it's weird hearing this song in english

  • haha, i totally agree!

  • I cannot FIND THIS SONG in LIMEWIRE!!!!!!

  • S.H.E. did the original song and then sweetbox and Skye Sweetnam did covers

  • did skye do a cover or did S.H.E do a cover?

  • i think skye did the cover

  • i cant find this song to download!!

  • SKYE ROCKS FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D

  • My mistake... i mean she... not he...

  • i like the S.H.E. version better.

  • everyone just shutup and listen to the pretty song!

  • Sorry...:P

  • no offence, 可是我不喜欢这个女子唱首歌。

  • i've liked skye's songs from billy s to some of her recent stuff. but i have to say, i like SHE's orginal version better =) better lyrics for sure <3

  • WOW. you better check your sources before you say something like that and embarrass yourself!

  • If that's your only comeback, that's pretty lame. Anyways, SHE released this song in their 2003 album. The person who wrote the music for this song then changed the lyrics for the band Sweetbox (called Chyna Girl). Then in 2005, Skye did this song as a cover. You'd think if SHE did the cover of this song, they would've released it AFTER Skye did. So yes, i DO make sure whatever I write has proof to support it. I suggest you do the same to keep you from making a fool of yourself.

  • HA! not really. "Superstar" has been one of my fav songs ever since it came out, so i do know for a fact that they came out with it FIRST. If Skye made the original, and it was SHE who covered, Skye would've released the song BEFORE SHE did, not 2 years after. I hope that's easy enough for you to understand =)

  • you're avoiding the issue being discussed here. yes, SHE has done some cover songs, but that doesn't mean ALL of their songs are covers of other artists. this song in particular IS an original song from SHE. so again, "Superstar" from Skye Sweetnam is a cover from SHE's "Superstar", not the other way around. believe what you want, but the facts are listed in my previous posts. i'm gonna stop trying to convince a close minded 10 year old now =S

  • that's damn rite! besides, this version is WAAAAY different from the original CHINESE one!

  • who`s she?

  • SHE or Skye Sweetnam? =S

  • I Mean SHE

  • SHE is a Taiwanese/Chinese (whichever lol) girl bad with 3 members, Selina, Hebe and Elle (hence S.H.E)lol they just released their latest album recently =) you can google them or wiki them for more info ^^

  • ah! so many typos -_- i meant, girl band, and Ella, not Elle lol

  • She is definitely not Chinese/Taiwanese...

  • lol, i was talking about S.H.E, the Chinese/Taiwanese girl band, not "SHE" as in Skye lol

  • Skye just re-recorded the song and removed the space in the title! S.H.E is still the original! I mean, Skye wouldn't have waited for another two years, if he were not just covering, would he?

  • Can you please tell me who she is? I just found her and am clueless about Skye.

  • Skye is candian and has 2 albums, noise from the basement and sound soilder.

    i recimend sharada and tangled up in me

  • yeah there my fav.

  • OMMGGGGGG sharada is the most AMAAAZZINGG song EVER!! it really is :D:D

  • Sharada has the WORST beggining. It is just completely RAMDOM and personally I hate the beggining but the rest is ok. That is her worst song but besides that she rules!!!!!!!!

  • lool sharada, cartoon, boyhunter, human and like.. a few other songs by skye are me faves atm :D

  • i like S.H.E better.

  • Skye all the way !!!!!!!!!

  • i like the 2,the video of she is better but the songs,the 2 are awesome!

  • i like S.H.E better .

    no offence but this is kinda like a biter..

  • So did Skye cover the sng, or did SHE?

  • Sky covered this song. S.H.E's version was the first and original.

  • what about the korean version?

  • Hm, I did not know there was a Korean version. It's most likely a cover as well, but that's awesome that there is. :D

  • i like the chinese version way better

  • omggg i lovee skyee (even tho i just recently discovered her LOL) and i love SHE

    AWESOME!!!

  • I luv the chorus to this!! <3

  • cool song!

  • i think SHE sings it better tbh... not that its because its a mandarin song, but um.... when u hear it, u will know wat i mean :)

  • I have heard S.H.E's version and it wasn't until recently that I heard Sweetbox had this song and from that discussion, I heard of Skye Sweetnam's verison. I already was a fan of Skye when I heard that, so i rushed to hear it, and I like it a lot. It sounds a lot like S.H.E's version, and I like that about a cover that if it is in a different language that the lyrics stay somewhat the same, then you can switch it up.

    Erin

  • true, i've heard the chinese version- so this is a cover, right?

  • No, they covered her.

  • wow i like the english version! but i love most the original even i cant understand mandarine LOL!

  • this is good but i think s.h.e. was better

    -asumi

  • I love this song and vid. Did Skye make the vid herself? =).

  • She is far better than the chinese singers

  • I <3 SHE!

  • ok who the original artist that sing superstar

  • S.H.E.

  • man, how many people have used this tune? XD

    skye, S.H.E, sweetbox...

  • Don't forget the korean singer Han Soo Youn xD

  • dude, that's crazy! XD

    anyways, is there a karaoke song...for ANY of the versions?

  • I listened to SHE's version of Superstar. To be honest, apart from the voices they sound the same. But SHE's version suits it more becuase their japanese and the songs sounds like the song that they sing better9it hrad to explain). But thsi version is still great. No offence to my favourite singer of all time, it was kind of stupid to cover a song taht your not going to change much, 'cos if you want to cover a song you should change it a lot so it sounds different.

  • oh wiat, it wasen't stupid. I just relised, thsi version is the english version, snd without we woulden't knwo the english words

  • lol the SHE version is chinese, not japanese

  • ...S.H.E. is a Chinese band.

  • oh whoops! That was a mistake, I was ment to type chinese

  • Well, technically they're a Taiwanese band, not Chinese.

  • but they speak mandarin

  • Just because it's good, you assume it's Japanese? Honestly people, stop getting so obsessed with Japan, it's MANDARIN!!

  • thats was an accident, i kept watching anime and acidently typed that