Ha, god, this is hilarious... I just love all these liberal nut-jobs on here complaining about how the USA is evil for being in wars and how Bush is the new Hitler... Well, good for you. Nobody cares. This is how things have been going basically since the beginning of time. And your complaining about Bush? Look at Obama, who got a Nobel Peace Award for nothing and has gotten this country in worse debt than ever.
War is just natural. So go back to your jobless lives and smoke your pot. Hippies.
@EmmettTheGrand this song should be about the adolf hitler and nazi germany , or the soviet union those two countries caused more death than any body else in history ! ! !
I feel bad for the troops who have no idea what they are fighting for(and its not our freedom as everyone says) and for the troops who have awaken but cant do anything about it. Its all bullshit..lol. Every last bit of it
The illusion the US fought for peoples freedom in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan is just that an illusion. People fighting for others freedom don't leave hundreds of thousands of civilians dead, millions of refugees, and countries worse off than when they started. The military-industrial-congressional-media complex will eventually leave us in poverty and destitution then move on to the next lucrative spot, perhaps China. War is a Racket - Gen. Smedley R. Butler only two-time Medal of Honor winner.
This song was about big label, fat cat record companies who make there artists make what the fans want, not what the musicians want. This isnt about war at all.
@deividzeitgeist if anyone hasnt seen zeitgeist i suggest you do. it will open your eyes to the world around you and let you see the TRUTH behind everything.
@texblues49 -- I'm a VietNam vet that's voting for Dr. Paul. I think veterans question the US policy of constant war moreso than non-veteran citizens. More veterans donate to Dr. Paul than all other candidates combined! Ask the right question, you get the right answer - End the Fed - Ron Paul
@Gearsandwar2 Don't you mean do the job for the corporations and banks who run this corrupt world. Educate yourself you will become a better person if u do.
@Gearsandwar2 liberals aren't against the troops. stfu for genralizing like an ignorant bitch. sorry to be so harsh, but i'm a liberal, and i have friends and a neighbor in afghanistan right now. i really don't apreciate you accusing me of not supporting them. they're doing their job.
for this is a pro american vid since it only shows images of doing the "right" thing... better put images of us troops killing innocents to be an anti war and not scenes of them taking into a street..... the vid has a great meaning of anti war and using this song is awesome
It's the soldier, not the reporter who has given us freedom of the press. It's the soldier, not the poet, who has given us freedom of speech. It's the soldier, not the campus organizer, who has given us the freedom to demonstrate. It's the soldier, not the lawyer, who has given us the right to a fair trial. It's the soldier who salutes the flag, serves under the flag and whose coffin is draped by the flag, who gives the protestor the right to burn the flag
@sarsfieldusmc its the government that sends inocent young man off to die and this must be stoped. so go take that propaganda bullshit and shove it somwhere nice
@sarsfieldusmc That's why we have less rights TODAY than ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Fair trial? .95% or criminal cases in the u.s.dont even go to tiral.
The go old usa also represent 25% of the world's prison population yet we are only 4% of the world population. So i dont know how fair those trilals really are.Oh yeAH and that freedom of press thing ? The usa has the most filtered and biased media in the world. That is why people, like yourself are so lost. KNOW THE FACTS!!!!!!!!
six years ago, I was in the midst of this dirty war we call OIF..... I watched good kids and young men we call Marines endure all the dark shit war entails.....sleep deprivation.realization that you really could die here in this shithole....that life back "home" goes on.....and still,they carried on, firmly believing in defending you from the evil,evil plans that the ragheads have planned for you..... while u live on,waking every morning,going to sleep every night,PEACEFULLY....
@rhfyr91 Its nothing to do with freedom,,, its just about making money for the rich elite who have all their assets in oil & war manufacturing and sevicing the war machine... getting just one bottle of water to a soldier in Afghanistan adds maybe 20$ to the price of that one bottle. its more expensive than a hollywood film stars resterount
@beoland100 It is, but would you rather have them over here? I wish everyone could just get along. But, I respect the men and woman who are fighting and have died for this country for our right to live freely.
@mawtin0 well..invading a country for made up reasons, use of paramilitary forces that are not accountable to any jurisdiction, nationalist propaganda, offshore prison camps and the excessiv use of torture...sounds pretty nazi to my ears
There's absolutely CERO evidence of the use of paramilitary forces, those are the thoughts of a kid who plays too much splinter cell and stuff of the sort. Same with offshore prison camps, too many liberal movies.
I am sure all governments apply torture, same goes for propaganda. oil is a good enough reason to invade a country. Take into account: I am not from the US, I am from South America, and I think there's nothing you CAN do about these issues, just accept them.
@100gog1l so Blackwater is not a paramilitary force? oh sure..it´s a "security company"..my ass! and what do you call guantanamo bay if not an offshore prison camp. i´m not as naive to believe that other governments do not torture. but at the same time the US occupy the moral high ground unaware that they are closer to the regime they once so bravely defeated than to the "land of the free" they want to be.
if oil is a good enough reason i hope for your sake that your country doesn´t have any
@hogolabaash Never heard of "Blackwater", it's prolly related to national security and NOT paramilitary, you should THANK the action of paramilitary forces in case they are true, because they eliminate possible threats with less risk of war. As for offshore prisons, if your gov. wants to send their crap 2 other countries, and those other countries take it, what's the friggin problem?????? And no, my country is dry in almost every sense, all thanks to the lazy working force :(
cheerz ', was trying to find a utube vid of tht actually went along with correct meaning of the words.. youve done well,. thanks. tho sheep b arguing over this while they bein marched into fema camps.
@StoneOz - why do you think this is a war song? Roger Waters has been quoted for years that this song is about the music industry. so yeah StoneOz, you sound like a stupid sh*t in your comment
@nawmie97 thz alright , you sound retarded in yours.
music industry is juz an arm of the silent war tht bn raging since you & ur retarded debt slave families let nazis overtake ur gov & poison us every which way frm sunday with 'silent bombs' .. Oh welcome to the Machine .. u fckn Retard.
war has been around since the dawn of time it is a way of life so all you anti war bitches please take the soldiers place cause we need more americans than bitches like yall
You are to be pitied. A Castro, Mao, or a Hitler loves you.
"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse. The person who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature and has no chance of being free unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself." - John Stuart Mill
@horiapopescu1 The US did not get one barrel of oil for our saving the Iraqi people from going into meat grinders. America's most expensive commodity is your ignorance. All this information on the Internet and still you are a fool. But there are others here, so don't feel too alone.
@VillariHistory Riiight :)) not a drop of oil! That's why they even plan on building oil rigs AND with a contract signed with the iraqi oil companies the US army gets at least a third of the oiled exploited...but what the hey war is fun for the war mongers :) so why shouldn't we have one!
Aside from the fact that this song was written with absolutely nothing to do with war (surprising since Roger Waters wrote it), it's quite sad when someone takes a good song and uses it to somehow bolster their argument for this or that and further their dorky political beliefs, as if it immediately make them right. I'm guilty of it myself, as I once made an anti-fur video using "Cat Scratch Fever." Got a lot of backlash from Nugent fans.
george sucked as a president, yet i'll admit he did some great things for this country. i simply believe they are outweighed by the bad. HOWEVER, everyone is entiteled to their own opinions, and political standpoints. the fact we can be having this conversation right now is a testament to how amazing america is.
Pay for all of those in pain, for those who died in vain... Scars from battle nevermore
still we march off to War! War!! War!!! War is my shepherd!!!! Hate it if we can't comprehend it, kill it if we don't understand it. Pray to god and your fate is sealed.... as you die alone in the killing fields. War is business you're gonna die for your corporations because it's profitable...
in time people will see that all presidents in the past centery have continued the same policies which is to maintain a impire,collect recorces, and maintain the millatary industreal complex. the media will do it's part in not speaking of these acts and dumbing you down with politics and shit that happens in hollywood.or the latest and greatest gadget Lets face it America. the public is dumb and believes what we are told to believe becouse it's presented to be true.
@jumbocumbo2 "centery"; "impire"; "recorces"; "millatary"; "industreal"; "becouse" -- seriously, where did you learn how to spell??? And it's the "public" who is dumb!
@jumbocumbo2 "centery"; impire"; recorces"; "millaray"; "industreal"; "becouse"; Seriously, where did you learn how to spell?? And, then you argue that the "public is dumb?" Your writing speaks for itself.
I sympathize the pain for the families of those who died in battle,but i think that its every man right to defend his country with the nessesary force.Dont expect to invade someones country without casualties.....War sucks....
@smartg159 ya but those god damn terist musilms arent peaceful nuke the middle east that way we dont kill american soldiers and then we will never be bombed again fuck those idiots im giong to im gong to iraq and will kill any terrist without question they dont deserve to live im saying terrist not all iraqes
@wannabetrooper263 man dont be like that, sure there are crazy ass muslims. but dont assume all are like that man dont group a whole group of ppl based on individuals actions.
dont hate give peace a chance its a beautiful thing
@smartg159 ya but those fucking muslims arnt peaceful fuck em its not like one country less will be missed and hey less poplution and no more det they fucked use lets fuck em harder
@wannabetrooper263 look, I understand how you feel but honestly, we should NEVER NUKE ANOTHER NATION it will only provoke a nuclear war. And not all Muslims are bad and btw, although Im christian, I know that ther are some christian extremists who are just as bad as muslim extremists!
For a great anti war documentary look for Tableau No.2: 8.15AM.MON.6AUG.1945 Parts 1-3 in My Videos Section. Directed by multi award winner, Ike Ong DGGB.
this is bs in my head any way but what really hurts is going to a funeral for my Bro's Friend and guess what there's a fuckin protest he died for his country and all you can do is bitch about it wow some people are morally fucked up
Hey man, Im a US Soldier my self, US Army, and I gotta give you a big HOOAH on your comment bro, thoughs are some powerful words. And I feel ya on that one.
it's about the record companies and how they view music as a money maker not art too. Their songs are usually have double or more meanings. Comfortably numb may seem to be about drugs but in reality it isn't
cehaletinizle neden olduğunuz acılar nesillerce sırtınızda birikiyor. kızılderilileri katleden atalarınızın günahı, zencileri köle eden atalarınızın sırtına bindi. bu gün ırakta çoluk çocuk öldüren askerlerinizin sırtında tüm bu günahlar var.
As we slip further in George Orwells 1984 of a completely controlled society and as the bankers and eugenics known as the New World Order carry out the final stages of their long running agenda, I ask, when are the people finally going to shake the sheepish looks off of their faces and the sheepish domineer out of their heads?
Thank you, INTENSEGREEK! I wonder the same almost every day. Even my own family isn't really hearing me sometimes, think I take things too far, but Dad was the one that loaned me the book! I just don't understand why people keep thinking it's funny, or it's just change. It's is SOOOO not gonna be funny in a minute. I already don't see the humor. I see total loss of freedom and people are just accepting it.
your bloody yanks ... you do realise it's you paying for all this and your boys pulling the trigger don't you??? take some responsiblity and maybe we can all work together and end it!!!
Its not all about that, your "Semi-right". Its about how people follow through with EVERYTHING there told. If someone says its that way, you think its that way, The machine is the world.
so america teaches afghans gorilla tactics then complain when they get bored of blowing russians up n start blowing u guys up. hmm u guys got independence thru gorilla tactics and terrorism. history repeats it self just this time u guys r on the receiving end. britain has always been on terror alert since i was born thru the IRA which u guys help fund maybe u should of thought of this before u put ur mighty dollar "for the cause"
How does the opening image of this video, twin towers crumbling, send an anti-war message? When the fight is brought to us, we shouldn't pursue those who killed Americans on U.S. soil? I've always thought that was the one area everyone agreed was the RIGHT time to make some war. I guess snipenater thinks we can only defend ourselves from attack, but if they penetrate our defenses, we have no right to seek out the killers? Our bad, I for not stopping them?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
the original song had nothing to do with war if you hate this country so much gtfo i just hate Obama and what hes doing with it headed in the complete opposite direction of what it was created to be. Instead of rewarding hard work lets reward poor ass people who arent doing shit with there lives besides drugs.
You are full of crap. It is the lies of the conservatives that are destroying this country. You people cut the taxes of the rich and make the working class and small business men pay everything. I am been listening to your lies for 43 years and I have had enough. I am sick and tired of your anti-American type. You fly the flag during the day, but wipe your ass with it in private and divide our country. I want you and your type out of my country. Take your family and move to Cuba.
dude you do realizethe majority of presidents have been liberal over the past 43 years right? and congress was controlled by liberals 2? what lies? No conservatives are badass and not pussies that sit and cry about a war because they have nothing better to do we work hard and earn what we work for unlike democrats that i know who complain about being poor but dont do shit. The rich keep the economy going by buying shit. Obama wants this country to be like cuba. go to europe
In my lifetime there has been one liberal president, Cater. Clinton and Obama are moderates at best, especially on foreign policy.Liberals do not want to bomb kids in Pakistan.Right wing dems like Summers and Volker do.Until the current Congress came to power, it has been all right-wing Dems in my life. The Dem Party in control of Congress until 1994 was dominated by Right Wing conservative Dixiecrats. Do not give me this left wing congress crap. The Dixiecrats make Regan look liberal.
tah whose gonna make me gtfo you? Progress to what? Im not a redneck at all and your insulting me for no reason at all lol go smoke some more weed and continue to do nothing with your life hippie bitch Obama is a wreck and everybody is catching on. Oh and how come your not complaining about obama escalating the war in afghanistan? And as far as Im concerned were still in Iraq? Seriosuly go back to huggin your tree faggit
wha you said was okay, but you brought hippies into it, some of the smartest people on this planet, smoke the maddest amounts of green. you are just both straight up assholes.
When you children wake up, you'll notice you are speaking English (not German) and living in the country with the most freedom on the planet. Freedom is why you're able to say the stupid things you do. We don't start wars -we finish them. I hope someday you gain some intelligence, learn some history and respect. Freedom is not free.
My Grandfather could not speak English but paid his taxes. In the land of the free, no one MUST speak any language. If you do not like this TYPE of freedom, maybe you should move to another country. And take you dam family with you.
Hey dude don't call it freedom unless they legalize pot and stop throwing people in jail for having it. We have less freedom then most european countries and canada. the germans would of never been able to take over america anyways they would have to cross the entire atlantic ocean to get here and we would have defended the coast from attack go pick up a map by the time the germans would have got over here half of there fleet would be destroyed by both british and american ships.
I said the most freedom -not total freedom. We should be free to ruin our lives, fall off mountains, etc. I ruined mine for many years, fun, but not worth it. Which countries are you referring to? -name them. I don't call 50%+ income tax freedom. And are you even sort of aware that 400 American ships were torpedoed off our coasts by German and Japanese subs? See the black paint on old factory windows -all over the country -ask some old timer what that was about.
We won by might and luck and we may need it again -unless you like being forced to prey to allah. Oh, by the way -when you're not wasted maybe you can learn some punctuation and grammar -YouTube does spell-check for you, lucky you.
you're wrong dylan, war does not keep us free. the military's technology is 10 years more advanced than our public, we would be able to see a missile or any other kind of attack form any other country. plus our security, we're fine, we don't need war. it's just there to make money off of defense contractors so they can get rich, whilste we get poorer. 911 allowed to make us want war. look harder at your own country
or we just wanted to kill the bastards that attacked us because thats normall what you do. Sanctions dont do shit. Nothing but a bomb and a loud gunshot will get you respect hence America being formed in the first place.
bombs don't do shit but make things worse. look what it has done, we now live in a world where war is just basic way to do things and now people are just constantly getting killed for things they weren't even involved in. the only solving of these problems isn't by blowing more people up but actually working together and realizing that hurting and taking over other people actually hurts us to. the us is the new hitler in germany, we just hide it better. and that's what you're proud to support.
WE 'NOW' LIVE IN A WORLD WHERE WAR IS JUST BASIC WAY??? hey dumbass,its been like that throughout all mankind.. please go back to your nintendo, and leave the fighting for REAL men~~
:( i hate this country. there would be no need for war or even the fear/hate produced media driving people to madness and even more deaths and suffering within the country, if it wasn't for the owners of this country being so damn money hungry and apathetic to anyone but their own families. and they teach us to be like that with their fake smiley smiley system so we're all too blind to see it. wake the fuck up people
@VillariHistory I hate patriotism in general. Not particular countries. Patriotism encourages people to act like douche bags like you're acting, & to take pride in achievements they had nothing to with. Your parents fucked here, so you're an american. Doesn't make you better than anyone else.
in a war you lose even when you win..
atheer2002 5 days ago
Ha, god, this is hilarious... I just love all these liberal nut-jobs on here complaining about how the USA is evil for being in wars and how Bush is the new Hitler... Well, good for you. Nobody cares. This is how things have been going basically since the beginning of time. And your complaining about Bush? Look at Obama, who got a Nobel Peace Award for nothing and has gotten this country in worse debt than ever.
War is just natural. So go back to your jobless lives and smoke your pot. Hippies.
EmmettTheGrand 2 weeks ago
@EmmettTheGrand this song should be about the adolf hitler and nazi germany , or the soviet union those two countries caused more death than any body else in history ! ! !
MrLedzeppelinfan33 1 week ago
Of course it has to have United States Presidents in the video in order for it have to do with war.
Natureboy10307 2 weeks ago
I feel bad for the troops who have no idea what they are fighting for(and its not our freedom as everyone says) and for the troops who have awaken but cant do anything about it. Its all bullshit..lol. Every last bit of it
NlNJAPRlME26 3 months ago
The illusion the US fought for peoples freedom in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan is just that an illusion. People fighting for others freedom don't leave hundreds of thousands of civilians dead, millions of refugees, and countries worse off than when they started. The military-industrial-congressional-media complex will eventually leave us in poverty and destitution then move on to the next lucrative spot, perhaps China. War is a Racket - Gen. Smedley R. Butler only two-time Medal of Honor winner.
mrbag60 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
there should be pro peace rally's not anti war rally's
4.08 the devils puppet
atech246 11 months ago
there should be pro peace rally's not anti war rally's
atech246 11 months ago 2
well done
rainmanx63 1 year ago
the scene where all the bodies are washed up on the shore ..thats from saving private ryan ...great video btw
thewall3313 1 year ago
The U.S. is the largest war machine currently seen, and worse, Bush makes
Hittler same things done and is not penalized, why? Because he was president
U.S. .. The United States of America is a killing machine! Bush too!
pelifemoreira 1 year ago 2
This song was about big label, fat cat record companies who make there artists make what the fans want, not what the musicians want. This isnt about war at all.
Rush1013 1 year ago
Who ever says my Over the Top video is related to this! It's not, mine is about car smashing!! You Wankers
LtBriJMAC 1 year ago
Join the Zeitgeist Movement, stop supporting the war
deividzeitgeist 1 year ago
@deividzeitgeist if anyone hasnt seen zeitgeist i suggest you do. it will open your eyes to the world around you and let you see the TRUTH behind everything.
frizzlefryfourtwenty 1 year ago
In war you shoot & kill & kill some more. In the end you realize you've just killed yourself.
texblues49 1 year ago 12
This has been flagged as spam show
@texblues49 -- I'm a VietNam vet that's voting for Dr. Paul. I think veterans question the US policy of constant war moreso than non-veteran citizens. More veterans donate to Dr. Paul than all other candidates combined! Ask the right question, you get the right answer - End the Fed - Ron Paul
Dr. Paul needs MONEY!
vechorik 2 months ago
In war you shoot & kill & kill some more. In the end you realize that you've just killed yourself.
texblues49 1 year ago
America=DEAD PEOPLE ALL OVER THE WORLD! SAD BUT TRUE!
rocksteadyBGD87 1 year ago
hate to burst your bubble,but this is an anti music industry song. I suggest black sabbath war pigs
Takedownrap 1 year ago
@Takedownrap well actually...this song is about anti war...and so is black sabbaths war pigs :) both are awesome songs...
elfgirlsareyummy 1 year ago
Sarsfeildwhatever... You're a fucking idiot
kevinkoda 1 year ago
Gearsandwars2... Yeah, let them do their jobs!! The next mission is to eliminate all braindead blinkered idiot fucks..psst, I'd start running now!
kevinkoda 1 year ago
Shutup you whiny, bitchy liberals and let the troops do their job.
Gearsandwar2 1 year ago
@Gearsandwar2 Don't you mean do the job for the corporations and banks who run this corrupt world. Educate yourself you will become a better person if u do.
nazboxing1 1 year ago
@Gearsandwar2 liberals aren't against the troops. stfu for genralizing like an ignorant bitch. sorry to be so harsh, but i'm a liberal, and i have friends and a neighbor in afghanistan right now. i really don't apreciate you accusing me of not supporting them. they're doing their job.
scgcdmluvr 1 year ago 5
@lauralexco you're right....
for this is a pro american vid since it only shows images of doing the "right" thing... better put images of us troops killing innocents to be an anti war and not scenes of them taking into a street..... the vid has a great meaning of anti war and using this song is awesome
MEGAPOPO 1 year ago
sarsfieldusmc 1 year ago
@sarsfieldusmc its the government that sends inocent young man off to die and this must be stoped. so go take that propaganda bullshit and shove it somwhere nice
Octtom 1 year ago
@sarsfieldusmc That's why we have less rights TODAY than ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Fair trial? .95% or criminal cases in the u.s.dont even go to tiral.
The go old usa also represent 25% of the world's prison population yet we are only 4% of the world population. So i dont know how fair those trilals really are.Oh yeAH and that freedom of press thing ? The usa has the most filtered and biased media in the world. That is why people, like yourself are so lost. KNOW THE FACTS!!!!!!!!
nazboxing1 1 year ago
TOUCH. MY. PINGAS
chacuis 1 year ago
that was gay
LtBriJMAC 1 year ago
six years ago, I was in the midst of this dirty war we call OIF..... I watched good kids and young men we call Marines endure all the dark shit war entails.....sleep deprivation.realization that you really could die here in this shithole....that life back "home" goes on.....and still,they carried on, firmly believing in defending you from the evil,evil plans that the ragheads have planned for you..... while u live on,waking every morning,going to sleep every night,PEACEFULLY....
mudmarine0311 1 year ago
If you are anti-american, you should get the FUCK OUT OF HERE!!!
RatifiedCow 1 year ago
@RatifiedCow if ur anti war ur pretty much anti american.
defenderofmacragge 1 year ago
@defenderofmacragge no shit
RatifiedCow 1 year ago
@RatifiedCow lol
defenderofmacragge 1 year ago
@RatifiedCow is being anti-war anti-american?
rhfyr91 1 year ago
@rhfyr91 In my opinion, yes. If you live in a country, you should not criticize the very thing keeping your freedoms in tact.
RatifiedCow 1 year ago
@RatifiedCow We are not fighting for our freedoms over in Iraq and Afghanistan. We are fighting for theirs.
rhfyr91 1 year ago
@rhfyr91 I know. There are MANY other reasons, but I am not going to argue those reasons as I did in the past. (500+ comments)
RatifiedCow 1 year ago
@rhfyr91 Its nothing to do with freedom,,, its just about making money for the rich elite who have all their assets in oil & war manufacturing and sevicing the war machine... getting just one bottle of water to a soldier in Afghanistan adds maybe 20$ to the price of that one bottle. its more expensive than a hollywood film stars resterount
jim1a2a 1 year ago
@RatifiedCow
USA = Devil
samonesi 2 weeks ago
@samonesi USA= God's Country... screw off anti-war fuckheads!!!
RatifiedCow 2 weeks ago
War is Bull shit
beoland100 1 year ago
@beoland100 It is, but would you rather have them over here? I wish everyone could just get along. But, I respect the men and woman who are fighting and have died for this country for our right to live freely.
ninjaglare3497 1 year ago
So Americans are like Nazi's? Go fuck yourself. I hope Pink Floyd finds you and anally rapes you...
Did you exchange a walk on part in a war for a lead role in a cage, dickhead?
mawtin0 1 year ago
@mawtin0 well..invading a country for made up reasons, use of paramilitary forces that are not accountable to any jurisdiction, nationalist propaganda, offshore prison camps and the excessiv use of torture...sounds pretty nazi to my ears
hogolabaash 1 year ago
@hogolabaash
There's absolutely CERO evidence of the use of paramilitary forces, those are the thoughts of a kid who plays too much splinter cell and stuff of the sort. Same with offshore prison camps, too many liberal movies.
I am sure all governments apply torture, same goes for propaganda. oil is a good enough reason to invade a country. Take into account: I am not from the US, I am from South America, and I think there's nothing you CAN do about these issues, just accept them.
Welcome!
100gog1l 1 year ago
@100gog1l so Blackwater is not a paramilitary force? oh sure..it´s a "security company"..my ass! and what do you call guantanamo bay if not an offshore prison camp. i´m not as naive to believe that other governments do not torture. but at the same time the US occupy the moral high ground unaware that they are closer to the regime they once so bravely defeated than to the "land of the free" they want to be.
if oil is a good enough reason i hope for your sake that your country doesn´t have any
hogolabaash 1 year ago
@hogolabaash Never heard of "Blackwater", it's prolly related to national security and NOT paramilitary, you should THANK the action of paramilitary forces in case they are true, because they eliminate possible threats with less risk of war. As for offshore prisons, if your gov. wants to send their crap 2 other countries, and those other countries take it, what's the friggin problem?????? And no, my country is dry in almost every sense, all thanks to the lazy working force :(
100gog1l 1 year ago
@mawtin0 you have absolutly no idea what you are talking about, so dont go qouting pink floyd unless you fucking know what you"re talking about
Octtom 1 year ago
The Machine is the music business..but that does kind of relate to the NWO..
1ZosoLZ 1 year ago
cheerz ', was trying to find a utube vid of tht actually went along with correct meaning of the words.. youve done well,. thanks. tho sheep b arguing over this while they bein marched into fema camps.
StoneOz 1 year ago
@StoneOz - why do you think this is a war song? Roger Waters has been quoted for years that this song is about the music industry. so yeah StoneOz, you sound like a stupid sh*t in your comment
nawmie97 1 year ago
@nawmie97 thz alright , you sound retarded in yours.
music industry is juz an arm of the silent war tht bn raging since you & ur retarded debt slave families let nazis overtake ur gov & poison us every which way frm sunday with 'silent bombs' .. Oh welcome to the Machine .. u fckn Retard.
StoneOz 1 year ago
@nawmie97
That is true, but there are similarities between the mentality Waters intended to criticize and the mentality common in the military today.
So it can really go either way.
AMetalNinja 1 year ago
war has been around since the dawn of time it is a way of life so all you anti war bitches please take the soldiers place cause we need more americans than bitches like yall
marineboy931 1 year ago
War is going to always happen no matter who's the President or what political conditions exist, you'll lean that soon enough boy.
AmericanBadass44 1 year ago
@AmericanBadass44 sure, as long as we have people like you around. but don´t start crying when it comes right back biting your ass
hogolabaash 1 year ago
Hey Anti-war people...you're all faggots.
AmericanBadass44 1 year ago
@AmericanBadass44 wow, now you really gave it to them. they´ll probably shut up now and hide in their basements. LOL
hogolabaash 1 year ago
You are to be pitied. A Castro, Mao, or a Hitler loves you.
"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse. The person who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature and has no chance of being free unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself." - John Stuart Mill
VillariHistory 1 year ago
no one is saying they hate the soliders thire saying we hate the officers
lsdpot67 1 year ago
fuck war and fuck all the war-for-oil lovers! Welcome to the corporate machine...
horiapopescu1 1 year ago
@horiapopescu1 The US did not get one barrel of oil for our saving the Iraqi people from going into meat grinders. America's most expensive commodity is your ignorance. All this information on the Internet and still you are a fool. But there are others here, so don't feel too alone.
VillariHistory 1 year ago
@VillariHistory Riiight :)) not a drop of oil! That's why they even plan on building oil rigs AND with a contract signed with the iraqi oil companies the US army gets at least a third of the oiled exploited...but what the hey war is fun for the war mongers :) so why shouldn't we have one!
horiapopescu1 1 year ago
wow I cannot believe I just gave this video a view, but I love the song!
Inline6boost 1 year ago
@lauralexco its not the president, its the whole system.
barret2378 1 year ago
dwarfdic,rather than critque the cosmetics of what is stated ,why not the content?
does anyone poke fun at you for being a stutterer.you said the same thing twice
amagpi 1 year ago
Aside from the fact that this song was written with absolutely nothing to do with war (surprising since Roger Waters wrote it), it's quite sad when someone takes a good song and uses it to somehow bolster their argument for this or that and further their dorky political beliefs, as if it immediately make them right. I'm guilty of it myself, as I once made an anti-fur video using "Cat Scratch Fever." Got a lot of backlash from Nugent fans.
JobberBud 1 year ago
What's worse than Killing for ZOG?
Dieing for ZOG!
CelticSouthland 1 year ago
ATTENTION LIBERAL ASSHOLES: Go fuck yourselves.
TheTreemeister 1 year ago
@TheTreemeister
attention dumb shit, your people got us here
fathersky24688642 1 year ago
@TheTreemeister not all liberals are assholes, buddy.
george sucked as a president, yet i'll admit he did some great things for this country. i simply believe they are outweighed by the bad. HOWEVER, everyone is entiteled to their own opinions, and political standpoints. the fact we can be having this conversation right now is a testament to how amazing america is.
scgcdmluvr 1 year ago
Comment removed
XElvikingoX 1 year ago
@TheTreemeister
Pay for all of those in pain, for those who died in vain... Scars from battle nevermore
still we march off to War! War!! War!!! War is my shepherd!!!! Hate it if we can't comprehend it, kill it if we don't understand it. Pray to god and your fate is sealed.... as you die alone in the killing fields. War is business you're gonna die for your corporations because it's profitable...
XElvikingoX 1 year ago
@lauralexco I wanna see them shot so badly when they make a speech.
killuminati7777777 1 year ago
in time people will see that all presidents in the past centery have continued the same policies which is to maintain a impire,collect recorces, and maintain the millatary industreal complex. the media will do it's part in not speaking of these acts and dumbing you down with politics and shit that happens in hollywood.or the latest and greatest gadget Lets face it America. the public is dumb and believes what we are told to believe becouse it's presented to be true.
jumbocumbo2 1 year ago
@jumbocumbo2 "centery"; "impire"; "recorces"; "millatary"; "industreal"; "becouse" -- seriously, where did you learn how to spell??? And it's the "public" who is dumb!
dlwardfcsl 1 year ago
@jumbocumbo2 "centery"; impire"; recorces"; "millaray"; "industreal"; "becouse"; Seriously, where did you learn how to spell?? And, then you argue that the "public is dumb?" Your writing speaks for itself.
dlwardfcsl 1 year ago
I sympathize the pain for the families of those who died in battle,but i think that its every man right to defend his country with the nessesary force.Dont expect to invade someones country without casualties.....War sucks....
prorock2 1 year ago
fuck war!!! give peace a chance
smartg159 1 year ago
@smartg159 ya but those god damn terist musilms arent peaceful nuke the middle east that way we dont kill american soldiers and then we will never be bombed again fuck those idiots im giong to im gong to iraq and will kill any terrist without question they dont deserve to live im saying terrist not all iraqes
wannabetrooper263 1 year ago
@wannabetrooper263 man dont be like that, sure there are crazy ass muslims. but dont assume all are like that man dont group a whole group of ppl based on individuals actions.
dont hate give peace a chance its a beautiful thing
smartg159 1 year ago
@smartg159 ya but those fucking muslims arnt peaceful fuck em its not like one country less will be missed and hey less poplution and no more det they fucked use lets fuck em harder
wannabetrooper263 1 year ago
@wannabetrooper263 look, I understand how you feel but honestly, we should NEVER NUKE ANOTHER NATION it will only provoke a nuclear war. And not all Muslims are bad and btw, although Im christian, I know that ther are some christian extremists who are just as bad as muslim extremists!
litlemadguitarist 1 year ago
@litlemadguitarist I agree. Every muslim I have met was kinder than most christians I know.
Barrettfloyd82 1 year ago
@smartg159 If we could, we most certainly would.
ninjaglare3497 1 year ago
War is the best business.
swingerlatino 1 year ago
For a great anti war documentary look for Tableau No.2: 8.15AM.MON.6AUG.1945 Parts 1-3 in My Videos Section. Directed by multi award winner, Ike Ong DGGB.
zainazrai 1 year ago
straziante...nn possiamo vivere così.nn si può
Silver861 1 year ago
So Welcome to This Century!
TsaRlieCaT 1 year ago
it's all right we told you what to dream
Ascendaeus 1 year ago
it's all right we told you what to dream
Ascendaeus 1 year ago
this world is a fucked up place..... nothing is ever gonna change.... open your mind quade
jamesgospursgo 1 year ago
@jamesgospursgo very fucked up, if the wars in the world finish is because everyone will be already dead
EdJackBlog 1 year ago
Maybe the uncle Sam wants a new war.
Butyrin 1 year ago
i hate news reporters
they stick the microphone in
everyones face
they're kinda dumbasses
TheLyricsMan111 1 year ago
wow theres a lot of anger, rude words and bad grammar here.
why dont we all just listen to the pretty song and forget about politics for now?
good idea yes?
:)
indifly95 1 year ago
bravo!! nice video.
spanishdude714 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheLyricsMan111 1 year ago
this is bs in my head any way but what really hurts is going to a funeral for my Bro's Friend and guess what there's a fuckin protest he died for his country and all you can do is bitch about it wow some people are morally fucked up
TXRedDevil888 1 year ago
@TXRedDevil888
Hey man, Im a US Soldier my self, US Army, and I gotta give you a big HOOAH on your comment bro, thoughs are some powerful words. And I feel ya on that one.
russjiujitsu 1 year ago
@TXRedDevil888 He didn't die for his country.He died for israel
PumpkinPuffer 1 year ago
@PumpkinPuffer How so? Obama spits in the face of Israel every chance he gets.
TheArmy19D 1 year ago
@TXRedDevil888 HOORAH
RatifiedCow 1 year ago
Lift your skinny fists like antennaes to heaven
TookYerJob1 1 year ago
god i hate people who just comment on this video thinking they are smart. 1. We all know about the Patriot Act
2. America has change, we are smarter now. What is the point of having liberty if you are dead?
3. The people who hate soldiers annoy me the most. People are fighting so that you don't have to, and you are telling them to make peace?
4. Don't bother commenting on me i really will never look again or check my messages.
BTW- Let people interpret the song in different ways, its okay.
cowswithgunz123 1 year ago
stoopid fuck, if ya looked back yu would see your own shit. facist pig.
prichardmark420 1 year ago
we are trapped in the belly of this terrible machine and the machine is bleeding to death
TookYerJob1 1 year ago
Godspeed!!!
Everyone should listen to the new Silver Mt. Zion Memorial Orchestra and Tra La La Band if you like floyd!
rythelastman 1 year ago
SHHHHHH big brother is watching right now
What right is the GOV going to take next, or what lie are they feeding us now?
NEDhardly84 1 year ago
This video will be well fitted about topics related to consumerism and the abuse of mechanical technology with consumerism.
Kensei2009 1 year ago
It doesn't work. This song is about consumerism and how mechanical it is. Not warfare. You'll want The Final Cut for that stuff.
hotelmario510 2 years ago
it's about the record companies and how they view music as a money maker not art too. Their songs are usually have double or more meanings. Comfortably numb may seem to be about drugs but in reality it isn't
TheTinCanHitMan 2 years ago
yeah, consumerism, in other words.
hotelmario510 2 years ago
ah amerika ahhhhhh.......
ah amerikanın cahil halkı. gelenekten, erdemden, hümanizmden, inançtan yoksun yoz, kiç, piç millet.
cehaletinizle neden olduğunuz acılar nesillerce sırtınızda birikiyor. kızılderilileri katleden atalarınızın günahı, zencileri köle eden atalarınızın sırtına bindi. bu gün ırakta çoluk çocuk öldüren askerlerinizin sırtında tüm bu günahlar var.
suatmuat 2 years ago
Maybe the Sheople will never wake up ... they did not in the Nazi death camps!! maybe they just stay asleep and let us all be killed!!
aliceincode 2 years ago
you are a zombie..
snicklefritz1989 2 years ago
We need zombies. Get enough of them to start eating people, THEN maybe the world will start uniting.
Maybe.
TheEndKing 2 years ago
As we slip further in George Orwells 1984 of a completely controlled society and as the bankers and eugenics known as the New World Order carry out the final stages of their long running agenda, I ask, when are the people finally going to shake the sheepish looks off of their faces and the sheepish domineer out of their heads?
INTENSEGREEK 2 years ago 2
Thank you, INTENSEGREEK! I wonder the same almost every day. Even my own family isn't really hearing me sometimes, think I take things too far, but Dad was the one that loaned me the book! I just don't understand why people keep thinking it's funny, or it's just change. It's is SOOOO not gonna be funny in a minute. I already don't see the humor. I see total loss of freedom and people are just accepting it.
windbeamproductions 2 years ago
Yes. We continually trade freedom for safety (PATRIOT Act anyone?).
Remember the Revolutionary War? Whatever happened to "Live Free or Die?"
Arovmorin 1 year ago
Where's Lee Harvey Oswald. Ooops sorry that was dark.
mulliganstew72 1 year ago
man just chill out all of ye man trippy as fuck......... xoom
gaara363 2 years ago
And it won't stop with Obama. The last true american president was JFK, and we all know what happened to him.
clapphamjunction 2 years ago
your bloody yanks ... you do realise it's you paying for all this and your boys pulling the trigger don't you??? take some responsiblity and maybe we can all work together and end it!!!
aliceincode 2 years ago
WE NEED A WORLD WIDE REVOLUTION!
INTENSEGREEK 2 years ago
We do ... I agree! there is no other way out!
aliceincode 2 years ago
hear, hear!
MegaBenFranklin 2 years ago
"Forward he cried from the rear
and the front rank died.
And the general sat and the lines on the map
moved from side to side.
Haven't you heard it's a battle of words
The poster bearer cried.
Listen son, said the man with the gun
There's room for you inside. "
-PF- DSOTM
CAPITALIST1000000000 2 years ago
EXCELLENT!
2207757 2 years ago
The eagle has always been a predatory animal. Which makes you think as to why it is shown with a tear. Just hope that we are not the prey now.
metalagony 2 years ago
this movie is not about war its about the music indistry (or more likley) roger waters dislike of the 70s music indistry. ot os MUCH worse now
aaronaaronjarvis 2 years ago
Its not all about that, your "Semi-right". Its about how people follow through with EVERYTHING there told. If someone says its that way, you think its that way, The machine is the world.
"And you didn't like school
And you know you're nobody's fool"
Explains it all in that line.
ChicagoYuk 2 years ago
salvor1.... it's "pray", not "prey."
sweinundhundherz 2 years ago
To much bullshit just listen to the fookin tune bitch
HELLO2YOU3 2 years ago
so america teaches afghans gorilla tactics then complain when they get bored of blowing russians up n start blowing u guys up. hmm u guys got independence thru gorilla tactics and terrorism. history repeats it self just this time u guys r on the receiving end. britain has always been on terror alert since i was born thru the IRA which u guys help fund maybe u should of thought of this before u put ur mighty dollar "for the cause"
miknot 2 years ago
How does the opening image of this video, twin towers crumbling, send an anti-war message? When the fight is brought to us, we shouldn't pursue those who killed Americans on U.S. soil? I've always thought that was the one area everyone agreed was the RIGHT time to make some war. I guess snipenater thinks we can only defend ourselves from attack, but if they penetrate our defenses, we have no right to seek out the killers? Our bad, I for not stopping them?
apes4life 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the original song had nothing to do with war if you hate this country so much gtfo i just hate Obama and what hes doing with it headed in the complete opposite direction of what it was created to be. Instead of rewarding hard work lets reward poor ass people who arent doing shit with there lives besides drugs.
numba1netsfan 2 years ago
You are full of crap. It is the lies of the conservatives that are destroying this country. You people cut the taxes of the rich and make the working class and small business men pay everything. I am been listening to your lies for 43 years and I have had enough. I am sick and tired of your anti-American type. You fly the flag during the day, but wipe your ass with it in private and divide our country. I want you and your type out of my country. Take your family and move to Cuba.
tbuontempo 2 years ago
dude you do realizethe majority of presidents have been liberal over the past 43 years right? and congress was controlled by liberals 2? what lies? No conservatives are badass and not pussies that sit and cry about a war because they have nothing better to do we work hard and earn what we work for unlike democrats that i know who complain about being poor but dont do shit. The rich keep the economy going by buying shit. Obama wants this country to be like cuba. go to europe
numba1netsfan 2 years ago
In my lifetime there has been one liberal president, Cater. Clinton and Obama are moderates at best, especially on foreign policy.Liberals do not want to bomb kids in Pakistan.Right wing dems like Summers and Volker do.Until the current Congress came to power, it has been all right-wing Dems in my life. The Dem Party in control of Congress until 1994 was dominated by Right Wing conservative Dixiecrats. Do not give me this left wing congress crap. The Dixiecrats make Regan look liberal.
tbuontempo 2 years ago
As for Cuba, at least they have health care. All we have is over priced Health insurance that no one can afford. Or afford to use.
tbuontempo 2 years ago
if you hate your president so much and the direction we steered it in. then GTFO, redneck motherfucker. Progress takes sacrifice.
prichardmark420 1 year ago
tah whose gonna make me gtfo you? Progress to what? Im not a redneck at all and your insulting me for no reason at all lol go smoke some more weed and continue to do nothing with your life hippie bitch Obama is a wreck and everybody is catching on. Oh and how come your not complaining about obama escalating the war in afghanistan? And as far as Im concerned were still in Iraq? Seriosuly go back to huggin your tree faggit
numba1netsfan 1 year ago
wha you said was okay, but you brought hippies into it, some of the smartest people on this planet, smoke the maddest amounts of green. you are just both straight up assholes.
ClockworkOrange 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love pink floyd
farcry2345 2 years ago
When you children wake up, you'll notice you are speaking English (not German) and living in the country with the most freedom on the planet. Freedom is why you're able to say the stupid things you do. We don't start wars -we finish them. I hope someday you gain some intelligence, learn some history and respect. Freedom is not free.
salvor1 2 years ago
My Grandfather could not speak English but paid his taxes. In the land of the free, no one MUST speak any language. If you do not like this TYPE of freedom, maybe you should move to another country. And take you dam family with you.
tbuontempo 2 years ago
Hey dude don't call it freedom unless they legalize pot and stop throwing people in jail for having it. We have less freedom then most european countries and canada. the germans would of never been able to take over america anyways they would have to cross the entire atlantic ocean to get here and we would have defended the coast from attack go pick up a map by the time the germans would have got over here half of there fleet would be destroyed by both british and american ships.
zeppelinmaiden32 2 years ago
I said the most freedom -not total freedom. We should be free to ruin our lives, fall off mountains, etc. I ruined mine for many years, fun, but not worth it. Which countries are you referring to? -name them. I don't call 50%+ income tax freedom. And are you even sort of aware that 400 American ships were torpedoed off our coasts by German and Japanese subs? See the black paint on old factory windows -all over the country -ask some old timer what that was about.
salvor1 2 years ago
We won by might and luck and we may need it again -unless you like being forced to prey to allah. Oh, by the way -when you're not wasted maybe you can learn some punctuation and grammar -YouTube does spell-check for you, lucky you.
salvor1 2 years ago
you're wrong dylan, war does not keep us free. the military's technology is 10 years more advanced than our public, we would be able to see a missile or any other kind of attack form any other country. plus our security, we're fine, we don't need war. it's just there to make money off of defense contractors so they can get rich, whilste we get poorer. 911 allowed to make us want war. look harder at your own country
Freakntheworld 2 years ago 3
or we just wanted to kill the bastards that attacked us because thats normall what you do. Sanctions dont do shit. Nothing but a bomb and a loud gunshot will get you respect hence America being formed in the first place.
numba1netsfan 2 years ago
bombs don't do shit but make things worse. look what it has done, we now live in a world where war is just basic way to do things and now people are just constantly getting killed for things they weren't even involved in. the only solving of these problems isn't by blowing more people up but actually working together and realizing that hurting and taking over other people actually hurts us to. the us is the new hitler in germany, we just hide it better. and that's what you're proud to support.
Freakntheworld 2 years ago
WE 'NOW' LIVE IN A WORLD WHERE WAR IS JUST BASIC WAY??? hey dumbass,its been like that throughout all mankind.. please go back to your nintendo, and leave the fighting for REAL men~~
veedubyuh82 2 years ago
@Freakntheworld
When you figure out how to persuade everyone to get along you let me know
elite128 2 years ago
:( i hate this country. there would be no need for war or even the fear/hate produced media driving people to madness and even more deaths and suffering within the country, if it wasn't for the owners of this country being so damn money hungry and apathetic to anyone but their own families. and they teach us to be like that with their fake smiley smiley system so we're all too blind to see it. wake the fuck up people
djda99 2 years ago 5
@djda99 You hate the country? Leave. I'll pay your passage to Pakistan and we'll be rid of your stench.
VillariHistory 1 year ago
@VillariHistory I hate patriotism in general. Not particular countries. Patriotism encourages people to act like douche bags like you're acting, & to take pride in achievements they had nothing to with. Your parents fucked here, so you're an american. Doesn't make you better than anyone else.
djda99 1 year ago
wow, what a kindergarten :)
If you kids want to understand Pink Floyd better, read Orwell.
JuliaBabo4ka 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
retarted this song has nothing to do with war
carlon1187 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
war keeps us free, we would be slaves to hitler without it.
dylanNEEDSCOWBELL 2 years ago
this shows the evils of war
31kouku56 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
yo fuck war, fuck the army, fuck the police. fuck all that bull shit. spam me what ever i dont give a fuck, just fuck it all man
rastafari220 2 years ago
fuck YOU man! hahaha
Snakepit4321 2 years ago
hallejujah!
produqt17 2 years ago
great song!
slcyukons 2 years ago 5
He is not in pain he is dieing and the guy with the gun was probably the one who shot him waiting to shoot again if he stands up
skunkgr 2 years ago
what the hell at the biggining the guys on the ground in pain and there not helpin but pointin guns at him
MsOrca 2 years ago
Sentimental attachment to geographical birth location is a leading cause of human mortality.
IVoteNone 2 years ago 3
Ein sehr beeindruckendes Video.
Alle Achtung!
Berolinus 2 years ago 2
What a waste of a pink floyd song
LastXombieProduction 2 years ago
I would only go to war if another Hitler came to power and i would fight against him.
rob92410 2 years ago