Added: 10 months ago
From: MyWinterFirefly
Views: 195,268
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (375)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Who, in their right mind, would dislike this??

  • Broken Hearts are the WORST feeling. I cant rly describe it to anything else......

  • @musiclover456s its like dyeing, being revive, then dyeing again only to be revived then going into a comma

  • so me right now... I love this kid! I've never had my heart broken.... yet. so i don't know how it feels, but I think I finally feeling a broken heart, I don't know:/

  • Give me back my heart... the one you take and break into pieces...

  • 4 people broke the heart.. :(

  • I hate the way I helped you to get whoever you liked just to make you happy.

    i hate myself but i think im moving on but you didnt get that girl (:

  • I hate how you flirted with me for sooo long and showed me all the signs...So i asked you out and was rejected. You now love her...that low life who just gossips and talks shit about people. I was perfect for you and was always there for you when you needed me. You left me broken and worse after rejection you ignored me and just stared....Why her? Why not me? :( You broke my perfectely good heart.

  • Definatly a Taylor Swift kind of night..<3

  • This song is beautiful. I love you Taylor Swift. ♥ Any guy who has hurt you better be sorry. Because he should know that they just hurt the most beautiful, and talented girl on Earth. Swiftie forever. ♥

  • Comment removed

  • What program did you use to make this lyrics video???

  • @hopestobeasinger I use iMovie (:

  • Comment removed

  • The first time i ever got broken up with was wen i was 2. His name was Tommy i dated him until I was 3. even though my birthday was the day I started dating him. He broke up with me on my birthday. Young Love<3

  • I LOVE TAYLOR SWIFT N SWIFTIESSSSSSSSSSSSSS <3

  • Comment removed

  • this was fast right?

  • @allisonfrashure It's straight from my CD so it should be the right speed (:

  • @allisonfrashure oh it seemed fast to me but cool :D its sounds good tho

  • 4 people clearly haven't gotten their heart broken to know a amazing and beautiful song when they hear it. :/ <3

  • again until just a few days ago he said he "doesn't like me anymore. I just care about you." And I finally told him I'm in love with him the next day...

    I know we had our ups and downs, but you were my first kiss, my first heartbreak, I trust you more than myself. I love you 3

  • I had a crush on this guy named Alex starting unto November of 2010, we started going out February 19th, 2011. He stood me up March 19th. I dumped him for a guy I was flirting with named Justin on April 4th. I was miserable without Alex three days later. Justin got back with his ex. Alex wanted me to prove he could trust me again. Started dating again May 15. Broke up July 31st.

    Between now and then I've talked with Raul, Justin, and Chris. But Alex is always gnawing at my heart. We were talking

  • @livelovedanceXXO well at least you got with him again

  • a perfect song!!

  • </3

    

  • Why would I wanna break a perfectly good heart? Cause I'm a baaaad kitty!

  • does anyone know if taylor's hair is naturally curly?

  • @lettielo99 It's not curly, just naturally very wavy, but she curls it a little when she's performing or in public. So what it looks most of the time is pretty close to what it is naturally, but its not curly, just really wavy

  • @MusicChick198 oh... thanks.

  • @lettielo99 No prob

  • @lettielo99 Yes, it is :) She said, taht in high school she used to straighten her hair, but then she saw that it was impossible and stopped to straighten it :)

  • Only if guys actually cared!! I love this song!!

  • Taylor, you have a perfectly good heart, you do. <3

  • Can u do Taylor Swift - Breathe? Its on the Fearless CD. Thx!!!!!!! :D

  • The day you were in a relationship..... this perfect heart ripped in two. You don't know that you broke a perfect heart but, you broke a perfectly good heart. You left me heart broken when you started dating her. I never felt so depressed and heart broken in my life. So I know what a broken heart feels like. I been depress for a long time ever since. I hope you see it soon......... even though you didn't know you broken a perfectly good heart. </3

  • I wonder why a lot of comments here are about their love life.. even the top comments.. Me? I came here coz i like the song, and I really don't have to be heart broken to listen to this.

  • So there's this guy I like we kinda flirt on and off but sometimes you can never tell if he is flirting or being a smart ass in other words haha and he's friends with some girls who use to be my bffs but now those girls make my life a living hell and I don't want them to find out I like this guy what do you guys think I should do...and don't say follow my heart cuz I have no idea what direction my heart is going so please help me I think I just might really be in love with him he's tall has dar

  • @hatersarepathetic1 well 1st of all forget those girls make them see how you feel ask them how they would feel if they were in your place and tell him ow you feel and if he doesn't like you back i'm sorry but remmember tell him you LIKE him not LOVE him

    i hope this helps and i went through this everybody turned their back on me for no freaken reason but that didn't stop me on telling him i had a crush on the boy i liked be strong

  • i hate how you led me on. i hate how you hit on my bestfriend. i hate how youre in love with that trashy girl. i hate how just one look or smile from you can make me smile for months, whereas you don't even care about me at all.

    i hate love.

  • I love skimming through all of the comments on this video about first love and how people get tired of girls complaining about how guys treat them badly... it just makes me wonder if it's a good thing I've still never been in love... I'm 14, but I'm okay that I still have a "perfectly good heart." hopefully if one guy decides to break my heart it's worth it (:

  • what album is this from?

  • @HunterJumpGirl Taylor Swift (her self titled album) but it's only on the enhanced edition (:

  • Nobodys perfectt

  • @Jayfri4510 what about god ?

  • I'm 15, but my crush is the only one that can fix my heart. Each day I see him my heart breaks a little inside. It's going to take FOREVER for my heart to be fixed. :'(

  • I love him for 5 years now. We've been together for a while..but he broke up to be with this pretty full of make-up girl. She is pregnant from him now, they're gonna get a baby (at age 17&18).. But she broke up with him because she cheated 3 times (?? I can't stand her..) but finally.. he admitted he loves me too. what do I have to do? He can't expect I still have a perfectly good heart.

  • I met him when I was 11, I fell in love with him when I was 11. I started dating him when I was 12, and he broke up with me when I was 14, which I am now. He was and still is my first love, even though 4 months have passed and we're still apart. But you know what? I don't care how much time passes by, I'm not giving up. It it's love, it's forever. We were too perfect and we belong together. I just needed Taylor Swift to make me realize that. And I guess she did :)

  • imma make a drawing involving this song its just so beautiful and special to alot of girlz

  • i hate women who mope all the time about how men treat them when they get dumped. they act as if all men are jerks, while they ignore the good guys that are out there. theres nothing wrong with being a little sad about a breakup and listening to a sad song about it, but moping and feeling sorry for yourself to the point where you cant function all because of a guy is pathetic. im a girl and i dont mope like hell when i get dumped. i sort my shit out and i move the fuck on with my life.

  • @ElectrikkPaperClipxx Finally, someone that stick up for the guys, THANK YOU

    

  • @jimjamsim no problem

  • OMG! My ex keeps emailing me! I'm gonna send him a few Taylor Swift songs and see what he has to say after that.

  • NICE I LOOVE ALL ABOUT TAYLOR

  • sometimes i can swear taylor swift is a mind reader

  • 3people dont have a perfectly good heart

  • 3 people have never had their hearts broken

  • My first boyfriend-ever. We dated for 6 years. He used to scream "I Love You" across the cafeteria to me!! But one day at the school dance I walked by a girl and she was talking to her friend and I heard her say "I'm dating ******" Which is his name (dont want to give anything out). I got really mad and I broke up with him. But I still want him he will always have that special place in my now broken heart..I am waiting for you still. But why would you wanna brake my perfectly good heart??

  • @likeemdark88 Well it was stupid for breaking up with him because of that.....

  • This song really gets me...I mean, back last January, one of my good friends asked me out...I was happy. My first boyfriend...but we were constantly on and off....I could not take the heart ache anymore, so I told him we weren't meant to be.

    I have someone now, who really cares....

    He would never even think of breaking my heart, even if he did, I would understand. We are thousands of miles away, but who cares?

    I will love him until the day I die...

    Alli&Alex

  • taylor swift is perfect.

  • eddie, why would u break a perfectly good, even mine ?????

  • Comment removed

  • @bribri9910 Because you're thirteen. Get over it.

  • @chasingponies It doesnt matter how old you are love is love, it doesnt have an age requirement...Grow a heart and leave her alone. @bribri9910 im sorry, ): love has its ups and downs, you cant control it, the guy ive beeen in love with for 2 and half yrs left me for his ex bc she got pregnant and the dad wouldnt take care of her or the babys....I know he was trying to help. But thats hurt me more than anthing. Love is in a way unpredictable. </3

  • @bribri9910--I know exactly how you feel. The same things happened to me. I was dating a guy for over a year and a half. Then one day, he decided that he would cheat on me with one of my best friends. I, also, still love the guy who broke my heart.

  • @bribri9910 because he's a douche bag :/ there are many mroe fish in the sea so go show them what you got girl :D

  • @bimbo202 that is so cute!

  • @Craigluver809 i gave up on love before.. dont give up itll make ur life worse if you get broken then youll know what happens ive been broken 3 times and im 11 but i still believe

  • I sometimes wish I could go BACK TO DECEMBER when we sang OUR SONG, saying YOU BELONG WITH ME. I felt INVISIBLE until you came on your WHITE HORSE. You had BEAUTIFUL EYES back then, when you were INNOCENT. Now it's all just a PICTURE TO BURN, and our LOVE STORY turned around when your life became a THUG STORY. I'm still HAUNTED by memories of our LAST KISS, but I know YOU'RE NOT SORRY for what you did to me. I now feel UNTOUCHABLE, so watch out, because there's nothing I do BETTER THAN REVENGE.

  • and this is why i dont date

  • I remember when we sang OUR SONG wishing i could go BACK TO DECEMBER where i waited for you to come on your WHITE HORSE now its all just a PICTURE TO BURN so now i sometimes sit and drop TEARDROPS ON MY GUTAIR people told me to SPEAK NOW but i thought i could BREATHE with out you, my friends say theres noone AS COLD AS YOU

  • THE STORY OF US started good. I thought that TODAY WAS A FAIRYTALE when you rode up on your WHITE HORSE and said YOU BELONG WITH ME. I was ONLY ME WHEN I'M WITH YOU and I felt I was UNTOUCHABLE. Then our LOVE STORY turned into a THUG STORY and you dumped me for someone else. But I said to myself to JUMP THEN FALL and on THE OTHER SIDE OF THE DOOR you became another PICTURE TO BURN. Now I go BACK TO DECEMBER when we were TIED TOGETHER WITH A SMILE but I know to never trust you again.

  • One day I am going to have the guts to sing this to my very first boyfriend who dumped me. I was only young but still he fell in love with the "prettiest" girl in my class. I don't care if my voice isn't the best. I am going to do it!!

  • @KellyTaylorMileyCCS u r very brave i think tht it ios a good idea everyone one gets their heart broken and the guy deserves to kno how u feel pls subscribe to my channel

  • @KellyTaylorMileyCCS Nice to know you hate on people who's prettier than you.

  • Comment removed

  • He asked me to the dance

    I made sure I looked special for him

    Since he said he save me a kiss

    But when I got there

    He was kissing another girl

    The next day he told me he was in love with my best friend

    That day I gave up on love.....

  • @Craigluver809 Dont give up! You WILL find the one for you. And you will be able to tell if hes the right one, because actions spesk louder then words.

  • @Craigluver809

    NEVER give up on love

  • @cinnaminstix5

    There's no point to it........ You'll just get broken again

  • @Craigluver809 You get broken, sure. It happens to everyone and you aren't alone. But someday, you will find the perfect guy for you!!! I've gotten my heart broken time and time again, but I havn't given up. I won't give up. Never. You shouldn't either.

  • @Craigluver809

    "No guy is worth your tears, the one who is will never make you cry"

  • @ShannonScottMusic Yeah thanks but now he broke my heart he broke up with me right before Christmas Break from school..now im still in love with the guy i've always been in love with we've been best friends forever :) but I went back to this song and thought he wasn't good enough for me anyways so i ought to move on he broke my heart and maybe thats the best now i have Jake one i have truly loved except hes dating well lets just say his girlfriend relates to "Better Than Revenge".......

  • He broke my heart. I can't hold back the tears anymore. He made the very first scar.

  • when the STORY OF US started you seemed so INNOCENT you should TELL ME WHY this LOVE STORY ended my friends said i should SPEAK NOW and tell you that my life would CHANGE with you gone and i cant BREATHE when i keep thinking to myself YOU BELONG WITH ME and THE BEST DAY of us was the last. i thought i was ENCHANTED with your BEAUTIFUL EYES you told me to STAY BEAUTIFUL and i knew i was FEARLESS one thing i know is that YOURE NOT SORRY and i knew that i SHOULDVE SAID NO if i go BACK TO DECEMBER

  • @candylover481 if you love him and he asks you to help him ask someone out, for the fun of it you tell him the opposite of what to do:)

  • @MsDarly1 i am too:)

  • great job and to noah "why would you wanna break a perfectly good heart? why would you wanna take our love and tear it all apart now?"

  • Beautiful.

    ~Stay bubbly deary!

  • "Why would you wanna make the very first scar?" I love that line. So sad. :(

  • This video is so COOL! I Like it. . . You're Concept Is so AMAZINGLY BEAUTIFUL!!!

  • omg.. the button thingy is a snowwflake!! btw. great vid! you make the best ts vids...EVER!!!

  • I have see all your videos you have make of taylor swift and i love it all you are really good making video hope someday be a little as good like you keep with the good job hope to see more videos made it for you take care and marry chrismast mywinterfirefly

  • i came home from school today and listened to t his song....i got dumped today:'( why would he wanna break my perfectly good heart?????

  • This is my fave vid so far from u, MyWinterFirefly

  • this reminds me of the first cut is the is the ddepest, by cat stevens

  • i had someone i loved so much but he wernt who he seemed to be and when i found out i was so broken but there was none there to put me back together. moral: never let a boy come inbetween friends because there the only ones that can fix you if he breaks you.

  • Love the image :) and the song obviously

  • my <3 is still perfectl good and repaired w/ jakob.

  • Hey Stephen, Tell Me Why would you'd wanna break A Perfectly Good Heart? I used to think I couldn't Breathe without you, but I realised I'll never find anyone as Cold As You again. You Haunted me, you still do.

  • When I wanted you to love me The Way I Loved You, you were just so Mean to me, treated me like I was Invisible, and I still can't believe I held on for so long. I used to think You Belong With Me, that we'd have a pretty perfect Love Story. There wasn't A Place In This World I wouldn't have went for you. I thought you were all Mine and that that sort of love could've been Ours. 

  • But the Story Of Us was cut a few chapters too short, and Our Song a couple of verses too soon, and in hindsight, I wish I could take it Back To December, before I felt the Sparks Fly, before I was Fifteen. I should've been more Fearless,and left sooner. Should've listened to myself when my mind said "Speak Now" and left you earlier. I Should’ve Said No from the very beginning. Now I've realised I was wasting my time and all I have is your Picture To Burn.

  •  I used to believe I'd Never Grow Up without you, thought you could be my Superman. If I was asked was it all worth it, I don't think I'd Lie. It wasn't worth all the Teardrops On My Guitar, you being up there on your White Horse thinking you were Untouchable, that you could do whatever you wanted and I'd come crawling back For You.

  • I honestly thought you'd turn a new leaf and Change... Of course I was wrong. The Best Day of our three and a half year relationship had to have been our last. Didn't want a Last Kiss, couldn't bear the fact I thought you'd treat me well Forever And Always... how wrong was I. I never really had any moments when I thought yeah, "Today Was A Fairytale", "I'm Only Me When I'm With You" because nothing I did was ever good enough.

  • In the end, I wasn't Enchanted to meet you, nor were you near as Innocent as you looked with those Beautiful Eyes of yours. Well, Long Live your unrealistic standards and your ignorance, I'm Every Woman, and you won't find a girl that will stick with you with the way you treat them, and that's Better Than Revenge for me. Lucky You. You've left stains 'Cross My Heart with Permanent Marker and You're Not Sorry. I'm glad I wasn't Brought Up That Way. And you know what else I was wrong about?

  • I've not been left Breathless without you. I'm much Better Off without you now I'm out in this Brand New World where I don't have to pretend I'm Tied Together With A Smile. You don't Come In With The Rain, the rain comes in with you.Its My Turn To Be Me, I'll Never Need You Now. I don't know if I'll ever be the Same Girl I was before,but I suppose That's Life Sugar. I

  • I will strive to be the girl Who I've Always Been without you holding me back. You knew I wasn't Bulletproof. You can say We Were Happy, but you know that your only speaking for yourself. This Is Really Happening and you won't ever get to hold me down again. My consolation is that I now know you're a Stupid Boy, and, well, all I've left to say is I've got my Matches ready...

  • @Shail0852 did you come up with the whole story yourself? i read all of it, it's cute :)

  • Comment removed

  • Ugh, Idk what to do. My crush is getting back with my EX-Best Friend after an on again off again relationship breakup. (Stupid right?) So now... I'm just ticked. She's just such a jerk... and he's... so... special. Did I tell you that she broke up with my crush THEN went back with her other ex AND THEN now my crush and her r datin.. AlI I can say is dating is overated.... and I'm 12... -.-

  • This is true for me, a week after Formal at my school last year, my boyfriend broke up with me. That Monday, he wanted me back, I was telling him no. He was trying everythig he could to get back with me. He was trying all during the summer to get me back. I guess after a while, he gave up on me.

  • Its not unbroken anymore..

  • Amazing video. Great job!!

    Taylor songs deserve videos like that. <3

  • why would you wanna break a perfectly good heart???

    tell me why???

  • It is a nice song but it brings back alot of memories... It reminds me of my first bf... He dated with me although the person he truly liked is another girl then he keep on playing with my feelings and breaking up my heart & mind although I really love him...

    But now, I got someone better than him by 10000... times..

  • @Bling423 That happened to me too. I was dating a jerk, and he was playing with my feelings all the time. Once, he even cheated on me with two onther girls. I should've told him "It's either me, or her, choose now, and if you can't, I will" I guess that's why a lot of people say that love is blind. 

  • This reminds me of a guy I was in love with, and I finally got the guts to tell him. He said no, and I was really sad. Then, he told everyone in school I liked him & started saying super mean things to me. I never did anything to him. Ever. So, Jimmy, I have a question for YOU.

    Why would you wanna break a perfectly good heart?

  • @FunnyBunny77902 wow same exact story to me...-.-

  • first relationship lasted like 8 hours... just great:/

  • It Sucks, Sometimes Because I hate it when boys Just go out with you,For The Fun of it and Just Break you :(

  • This song really makes me think. everything I have now won't be here all the time. I don't know why it makes me think this way.. it just does. is that weird?

  • freakin douchebag jsut broke mt heart over a txt a couple hours ago. he lied. he said he loved me when he rlly loves somebody else. wut an asshole. why wuld u do tht to me? u shuldnt have asked me out in the first place. then i wldnt be so pissed at u. WHY WUILD U WANNA BREAK MY HEART?

  • @StillGlassLife SAME HEER!!!!!!

  • i luv this video and the song :D perfect work (:

  • This video was awesome, the quality of sound and video are perfect, and the music is beautiful. Good work. ;)

  • When I said I loved you, I meant it... I was gone for 2 months and now your txting me for help to ask someone out... Do you know how much its killing me???

  • SPARKS FLY when we are eye to eye. I feel INVISIBLE around you. You have A PERFECTLY GOOD HEART and I was ENCHANTED TO MEET YOU , that is THE WAY I LOVED YOU. Now that I know how you feel Im TIED TOGETHER WITH A SMILE but I Have TEAR DROPS ON MY GUITAR. I wish this love was OURS not hers. I wish you where MINE. I will say I love you FOREVER AND ALWAYS. And I will write your name on the wall with PERMANENT MARKER. And Im HAUNTED without you. Missu

  • Reminds me of a boy that gave a note to another girl asking her out when we going out but Yu know what I'm over it he lost someone awesome nice an cool

  • @loveis4ever10 I hate it when boys just date girls for the fun of it! Dont you?

  • I heard this before but only just now figured out is was Taylor swift cuz I was doing one of those things where you listen to any song if it says "by Taylor Swift" ;)

  • reminds me of my ex went out with me for 2 years then just dropped me after he had said forever and always........................­.............................

    but i hav som1 better now who respects me and doesnt listen to rhumers

    (sorry i cant spell eeeeeeeeek)

  • @charlottesamazing its good that u got over him...and that you have someone better...u should be respected and should be held as a prize

  • Can you re do Last Kiss 'cuz youtube took it down , thanks <3

  • 10 likes and i will sing this to my first/only person to brake my heart

  • At 0:20 , that heart looks the one as the background .

  • i am begging you to stop reading my diary

  • Amazing video thanks

  • I wasn't depressed but listined to this and thought back when my boyfriend that im datin now cheated on me back ago and didn't know what to do and couldn't talk to him and then he kept sayin sorry i fianlly forgave him and the girl he cheated on me with keeps tryin to get him....for 3 yrs now known him for 4 datin him 4 3yrs now and now i just relized i don't really know why i forgave him.....we have a long story behind us ihaven't thought about.....don't know if understand i love him or not</3

  • @BonnieRocks04 if there's doubt it's usually not true love...

    immature love says: i love you because i need you

    mature love says: i need you because i love you

    i hope that helps dear <3 you'll get through it

  • @BonnieRocks04 If there's doubt it's usually not true love...

    Immature love says: i love you because i need you.

    Mature love says: i need you because i love you.

    I hope that helps dear <3

    It's been a month since you posted your comment.. but hey its never too late.

  • The awkward moment when you're listening to this song and tears are rolling down your cheek, yet you just realized it. </3

  • That awkward moment when you're in the middle of this song and realize that you're depressed...

  • Love the way you did this Talyor Swift music video.

    please tell me the name of Talyor Swift first album

  • @Laura88195 It's just called Taylor Swift (:

  • @Laura88195 Taylor first ablum is Taylor Swift

  • nvr heard these songs from her. maybe coz i didnt buy her first album. i didnt know her tht time..

  • @MyWinterFirefly how do you get it to be full screen on the video?

  • I don't remember having a perfectly good heart.O.o

    D:

  • Ur bestfriend becomes your worst enemy. Lollipops turn into cigarettes. The innocent ones turn into sluts. Homework goes in the trash. Soda becomes vodka. Undies turn into g-strings. Kisses turn into sex. Remember when protection meant wearing a helmet? Your worst enemies were your siblings. War was only a card game. The only drug you knew was cough medicine. The only things that hurt were skinned knees and goodbyes only meant until tomorrow? copy n paste if you wish you never grew up

  • @LuvEmy101 wow that makes me realise it now......

  • Draven why did you break my heart I loved you

  • @lindsay20011 I think it's Edwardian Script ITC cause I had seen that font before.

  • I don't remember this being on her first album

  • does imovie give viruses?

  • @TheWeeklyKinz It shouldn't because it's an official program. But if you mean the downloads the claim to be Windows version, then yes they're just viruses, you can't get iMovie for Windows, sorry.

  • @MyWinterFirefly iMovie is free or have to pay?

  • @TheLuisa234 It's about £25 ($30) - oh and I can't remember if I mentioned before but it's only available for macs. If you don't want Windows Movie Maker you could try Sony Vegas (:

  • @MyWinterFirefly

    Can you tell me how to make the imovie videos in a way that I can post them on youtube? I made several videos but I can't post them for some reason.