Haley Reinhart - I (Who Have Nothing) (American Idol 10 Top 4)

[MrGrahameThomson]

That is the best performance I have seen on American Idol. Truly amazing.

[mzcapricorn500]

This year 2012 JESSICA SANCHEZ is right there with Haley.!!!

[hpeselyk]

I though JLO and Randy was like "we need to save our asses, lets go"

[zooMZooMlikeATyphOOn]

Why am i looking at a human raccoon?

Absolutely amazing performance, but tell the raccoon to stay out the trash.

[GJazan]

i feel as if the three jugdes hated her from the beginning and its sad.. i feel as if they get angry because they know she is so strong and talented

[tbd]

"Look what you're capable of!" So patronizing, J-LO.

[52997crayola]

NIKKI REED AND PAUL MCCDONALD COUPLE SPOTTED AT 3:34. love them

[52997crayola]

i love the 2012 season of american idol..... but i always come back to watch the 2011 season just for you haley!

[Phagitue]

She needed more vibrato on the last note

[bhelgrafilo017]

she should have WON .. not that scotty country who stays safe and not taking any risks!! SHE WAS THE BEST on her season!!!

[ElijahB31]

Obviously, people who know what real talent is don't watch this show or else Haley would have easily won

[domejessie006]

Jlo is just like "Imma say good things so that America wont hate me anymore"

[55jrmoney]

@domejessie006 it's funny cause JLO loves haley, and supported her all the way. Most of the time when the judges didn't like Haleys Songs it was because it was lacking something & this was lacking nothing& for every standing-O the Judges gave, JLO was the first to stand up!

[kayron00]

watching in 2057 ;p

[briobrandon911]

I love how she was not so excited on the judges' standing ovation because she knows beforehand they would stand up for her.

JLO gave her so much hate because she is jealous of Haley's impeccable voice and musicality, and all her versatility, while JLO sings in her concerts using playbacks and songs shifted to 1 octaves.

WORK IT HALEY!

[fung2011ny]

Haley you give this song to me from last year before this song come out I never hear this song before after watch you sung it I was what a good performance,I'll put this song in my head forever and will not stop to watch this video again.

[jhoncbl]

haley the best... randy and j.lo fuck

[powerrangerlover2000]

she got kicked off when she tripped

[immabigdreama816]

ever since haley was sent home i havent cared for american idol at all! america doesnt know what real talent is

[fung2011ny]

Haley fan she perform her single FREE at hollywood hardrock cafe last night,go to her website or ew.com to see the video.

[Rgarvey93]

casey and haley are truly the only ones who ever game me chills like this. from the beginning to the end.

[AshlieMarie789]

Someone with this kind of talent doesn't even need American Idol to be a star <3

[sTapleEVA]

@AshlieMarie789 she is the best singer in the shows history, but the question is, is she an artist? pia, also from this season failed at this, being a great singer but poor artist. I wonder how creative haley truely is, and if she is worthy. we will all find out soon

[27murmurs]

love haley

[bdubbnm]

i was SO MAD when she got eliminated. scotty and lauren were so safe and boring.

[darya225]

i felt every word of this with my heart <3

[Sweetenuff4ya]

Love this Song!!!!. Thanks Haley!!!

[cudster305]

to imagine that this is the same haley that was in the botton three week after week...damn shes good

[cudster305]

this is like,,,the most beautiful performance in idol history

[tobiasfunke12]

2:36=magic. i die

[klairebear1986]

I am still so bitter that she didn't win. Omg cd coming out so soon.....love you Haley!!!!!

[SomeDevil55]

When Jlo says “See! This is why we can’t take it easy on you, because you are that amazing. Look what you’re capable of!”

But they can take it easy on Scotty and Lauren. So she’s pretty much implying that Haley is more amazing than them. K thanks.

[julianorobertonery]

yoyo shut up randy

[fung2011ny]

FREE is the name of her 1 single people.

[callmethugnasty]

gaga is one crazy ass motherfucker, lol.

[tiffanybede1]

THIS THE BEST 1 SHE EVER DID

[bdubbnm]

She totally should have won. Not to discount the others, but to me she was the only one that took risks and kept the show interesting.

[Jmreed1217]

that was MUCH better than her Earth Song

[lepplinlover]

if rockin rollers where more into idol she wudda won

[jjohnsice]

@lepplinlover same here.. one of the most awesome performances ive ever seen.

[hecklord]

still having the same goosebumps since I watched it the first time.. wow!

[Bp906]

One word. Replay.

[jjohnsice]

@Bp906 you have that right.. watch this more often than any video ever..

[croatian23]

what is Steven saying at the beginning? don't understand

[pradosgirl14]

i love her stare at the crowd at 2:14

[jjohnsice]

@pradosgirl14 for sure a haunting performance.... the best idol performance ever i think.

[DMW111090]

chills

[simplysexxxy18]

She's sounds and looks amazing!!!

[jcoo71]

Haley's face when Randy tell's her she is in it to win it looks so "whatever Randy"

[guitarist3813]

@jcoo71 Good observation jcoo71. I noticed that too when it originally aired. Not trying to belittle (aka "diss" for all you Under-40ers) Randy, but he must keep a researcher on retainer to keep him up to date with all the latest "cool" cliches. It's also funny how he falls all over himself "dropping names" of artists he's worked with.

[andreypushkin]

lady gaga looks like cruella deville lol



[versevica1]

i like that piece in the song which immediately follows the ''window pain'' line,woh oh oh etc..thats raw soul fire right there..makes my soul go grrrr in agreement with those sentiments,passion ignites others to.

[HalienNation1]

Amazing...  pure Haley

[jrlove46]

the four ppl who disliked this- in the words of hayley I HATE YOUUU

[jrlove46]

she def. has something not nothing! she should have won! :(

[prettytvshows]

This is insanely good. Holy crap. :) with love from the Netherlands!!

[beast1022]

@realfinnatic Whoaa been awhile since I've been here like 4ever jeez I've been sooo busy w/work whew !? Yup couldnt believe that RITD vid out-viewd IWHN vid wow ?! OK Halians 'WE' gadda rack up the views on Haleys IWHN vid.... jeez who woulda thought eh.... humph ?! U want some frigid cold from Saskachewan WE got -37C which I think is near -40F & it's gonna get colder yet brrrrr near -50F near morning UGH =( When's spring comin jeez....

[JulietTony10]

EVERYONE HALEY SINGLE IS COMING OUT MARCH 1st SPREAD THE WORD!!!

[HideTheTruthInside]

She definitely just Reinharted herself into the middle of next week with this performance. Perfection. Haley has the highest ceiling of any singer since Carrie Underwood. She can go to the top of the music world with her unique blend of vocals and charisma. The problem is she has to have the right singles come out because the drama won't carry over to CD's. We as fans also have to keep supporting her no matter what because she can and will get better.

[fung2011ny]

Hi Haley fan her 1 single coming out at March 1st yessssssssssss...

[Olga910729]

lo mejor de ella es que canta sin ningun esfuerzo no hace nada de ezfuerzo al entonar las notas altas preciosa la voz me encanta

[realfinnatic]

@Olga910729 Gracias. Concuerdo con usted el 100 %

[fashionmwah]

Oh my gosh! I can't stop watching!

[boym33tsjew]

How did she not win? She is much better than Lauren and miles better than Scotty. Scotty was not even top 3 to me. Haley makes him look like a karaoke singer.

[fung2011ny]

I's 2012 I still watch her awesome video....

[rickregala]

i cant stop watching her and listen to her voice.. and keep questioning.. WHY NOT WIN?

[eduardogolino]

Love Gaga and obviusly Haley :)

[kentan9819]

It's a shame lacks the vibratos

[jbree757]

same 2012 :)

[MrDokajan]

watching in2012! =)

[gilasny]

How did Haley got eliminated is still a mystery.

I blame mostly on Lopez and her jealousy.

Haley got robbed.

Waiting for your CD.

[daughtry1611]

@gilasny I might be for the better look at Chris Daughtry

[52997crayola]

@gilasny i would TOTALLY buy her cd. and i would buy this seasons deandre cd. if anyone watches anymore!

[fung2011ny]

it's last day of 2011 i still watching this video awesome.

[jani11]

much better than that scotty guy ...

[TheTreesand]

This performance is amazing...even now. Congrats, Haylie.

[potatoesandicarrots]

Honestly she deserved the win out of the three that were in there with this performace she did amazing! :) nice work.

[Batusai1106]

Cant stop hitting the replay button

[hailei2007]

She was so great. I don t usually do this, criticize the winner, but come on! Scotty was good, obviously.. but plain... and kind of boring. Haley had a sparkle, a fire in her voice, she had something special. I'd pay to go to her show anytime.

[pupleono]

Grow up Randy and stop talking like your 17 years old

[cornnful]

best perfomence ever by haley reinhart

[honeymat]

my gosh i miss haley i wish haley is my classmate:)

[shanatelevision]

wow, how annoying is randy. "this is what's going down"? he still talks like it's american idol season 1!

[brianrod1]

what i love about Haley is that she knows how to redeem herself, God Bless The Child, House of the Rising Son, and I Who Have Nothing all prove how amazing she is at redemption

[reemt1975]

still love her

[annabeth1720]

that stare @2:17

[sock2905]

im a halien.... and its december.

[iNarciiSi]

December :D

[8JuJas8]

what a voice! rare talented! the last time that i watched such a gr8 singer - was leona lewis! Germany wants haley!!! we need such talents here! all the casting-show singers here are ****

[avirah1]

She is so sexy

[101bookgirl]

Her best song- ugh, I always get goosebumps

[zoovido]

true winner... i love u haley...

[kkcrucial99]

jlo- i cant stop talking!

well you should.

[dalavade]

Give me goosebumps..



[Oxaad]

i know i'm gonna get so many dislikes, but... who the f*** is lady gaga to tell how to sing?

[PresentTheOctopus]

@Oxaad It wasn't just about the singing. She wanted to bring the element of the drama into the song to make sure it wasn't just a song as much as it was a incredible performance from her.

[mrseanpride]

@Oxaad i agree lady gaga suck hairy balls.. cant believe her songs even get watched

[Oxaad]

@mrseanpride yeah. and she's famous because she's weird and new, but i think soon her time will pass and people realise how badly she sucks XD

[HideTheTruthInside]

@Oxaad You're a freaking moron...Her rendition of "Moanin" was classic...Her artistic value,her looks and her vocals will carry her VERY far. I for one can't wait for her first album. It will be a classic.

[Oxaad]

@HideTheTruthInside For her first album? Are we talking about the same person? If you are talking about Haley Reinhart, then you have completely understood me wrong. I never said anything bad about Haley, she was my favourite on the show. It's Lady GaGa who I was talking about.

[Mooseracks]

Lots of people probally agree that this young lady sould have won...but AI uses criteria and a weighted voting system to determine who 'they want to win' Have a look at the number of viewers on this site who viewed Haley's videos vrs ALL other contestents on that show...Again IF AI wanted her too win...it would have happened...

Cheers to all

[hsamalrsam]

@Mooseracks All the better for Haley to NOT win. The winner gets locked into a Fox contract and they OWN that person and make a fortune off them. Haley can do much better without Fox. Let's hope she puts out a great album and gets a MUCH bigger recording contract than what Fox typically gives the winner of these things.

[293Laie]

WTH is up with gaga's make-up?

[laguida1982]

gaga's shoes are sick!

[docrichie9]

I'd buy that album!!

[donabelleA]

i still can't believe a country boy with one pitch beat all this. by far the greatest performance in all of american idol history!!!

[XxSuRrEaLiStSxX]

@donabelleA Brokeback mountain followed by Hannah Montana, while Hailey, Casey and James were dropped. America is stupid.

[brewcrew18]

ill probably jinx this but... HOLY SHIT 0 dislikes??

[johnkess2174]

@brewcrew18 Man, you blew that one.

[jjohnsice]

without a doubt... the best idol performace if not the best performance ive seen of any song

[DrewBerry92]

I've Watched This SO MANY Times That I Know All Of The Words Haley Says, Gaga Says, And The Judges Say. Obsessed?

You Bet Your Ass I Am.

Haley Reinhart Is That Amazing. <3 :')

[rebth1st]

@DrewBerry92 Me too, but what are the words from 2:30 to 2:36?

[kaybee033]

@rebth1st "But I could only watch you with my nose pressed up against the window pane..."

[rebth1st]

@kaybee033 Thanks

[avirah1]

wtf is up with gaga

[mrkgt12]

@avirah1 I think, she was shooting the edge of glory music video that time, judging from her appearance which is similar to what she looked like in edge of glory music video.

[mike31693]

This Was the BEST PERFORMANCE on American Idol History!!!!!! I'm still shaking it was so amazing this girl has and will go far with her talent I just i could meet her because she is out of this world GO HALEY!!!!!

[kaleidoscopeKhaos]

Oh, but she has sooooo much!!!!! Great job Haley!!! I love your music! ;)

[loveq026]

she's so great

[webmail111]

lets just say, she is no Tom Jones.

[shunguy]

Between 2.17 & 2. 52 an angel came in..but the rest, honey is much more discussable..u need -to understand your lyrics ;)

[TINBITZPHAM]

Theres no performance that gives this much goosebump. Every single time.

[76DHerrick]

2:35  holy shit

[Taati999]

omg she is perfect! nice greez from germany haley

[rapidd9]

and who got the most standing ovations? .. oh yeah Haley!! the masses of america don't know what they're missing -_-

[stephluvspenguins38]

i miss haley she should of won!! she was my fav from the beginning

[generationaluv]

@stephluvspenguins38 well, she just did a xmas duet w/ Casey Abrams and got signed by a lable, too. so she will be with us now and in the future! she is gorgeous, spunky, and a mega, chill-giving talent!

[stephluvspenguins38]

@generationaluv OMG REALLY?!?! YEAAHHH YAYY :)SHES THE BEST

[generationaluv]

@stephluvspenguins38 I totally agree!

[neurotiiko]

Haley was my favorite! <3

[heykayde]

Does anyone else get annoyed at how JLo and Randy gave her so much criticism, then they'd try to take credit for her amazing performance? She's going to be a huge star in spite of American Idol's lame need for vanilla.

[megustacantar310]

@heykayde i know the judges pissed me off i'm glad haley proved them wrong

[cesasoft]

I simply don't understand why she didn't win. Someone please explain!

[hausofteeth]

She has the best voice out of all the contestants. Too bad she didn't win :/

[Wizardylan]

I just remembered why I continued to watch AI10 but never knew the ending!

[smartcandies103]

@Wizardylan You are now my best friend, cause I did the same thing

[jheigm]

goosebumps

[CrazyExciting82]

Amazing Voice and crazy gorgeous. I love her. Women that can sing like this are just all the more sexier.

[elightsound]

its october and i am still glued to Haley's songs... gosh...never been like this before.

[233roz]

@elightsound Me too. I have been following Ai for 10 years & have rooted for some like Kelly and Carrie to name a few. But I have never been so captured by anyone like I am by Haley. She is just one amazing talent. I watch her videos all the time and even have some of the Ai shows saved on my DVR that I watch again many times & will never erase. I have her EP palying in my car all the time. Someone like Haley does not come along that often and we got a hold on her. I see super stardom for her.

[elightsound]

@233roz thanks for replying... now I know i am normal after all...gosh never did this to anyone singer... but really i still enjoy her and her voice even after AI... i hope to see her as a replacement for the likes of streisand, cher, houston and all the aging divas around.

[ayobabukhadra]

she is fucking amazing!!!!!!!1

[kary2119]

so much talent,and unique voice.one of the best voices that world give to us

[MsRaider1313]

i love how how different you made the song

[MJKINGMD]

In your faces JLo and Randy! love you so damn much haley <3 way to go

[MendosiA]

If she doesn't become extremely successful I will officially have zero faith in the legitimacy of the Music Industry

[Narrelle]

It's so good I could cry..

[zdrasvui]

JLo you are so fake!

[drkulikauskas]

simply. PERFECT!

[skymiles00795]

Still can't get over how Casey and Haley wasn't in the finals

[007squirel]

@skymiles00795 and james

[Happyfer]

I can't stand Jennifer Lopez, what the FUCK??!?! she doesn't sing well at all, I know in music business i'ts not only about singing, you have to be an entertainer, but common, JLO what the hell is she doing judging people and their style of singing, I keep thinking she should be judged as well by the public, and get these girls some record deals, I can't understand if there are so many beautiful girls like this who sing like that...Why do they have to produce other singers wich are not SO good

[jasonsinanan]

@Happyfer great point this is the best comment i have seen yet

[vampesorocaba]

I know theres a lot of scotty fans and hes good 2 but HOW THE HELL that alaina shit got a better place on the competition than Haley???

Dear God...

[darthGavin]

Best performance of the night twice and one best performance of the year... and she didn't win... *sigh*

[cmgjr8]

@darthGavin to think of it the winner never had any of that..

[clueless989minds]

what happened to gaga's faaaaace?? its like she was sleeping and a 4 year old drew on her face! she looks like nanny NcPhee!!!

[HaleyReinhartGuy]

OMG that was amazing she is sooooo good this is why i LOVE HALEY!!

[saintdarky]

Randy shouldnt be judging american idol. Just my humble opinion.

[89jake89]

0:12 - 0:16 CHILLS. wow. and of course the whole performance as well. SING BITCH!

[jblplaser]

Randy and JLo get on my nerves. She was good from the very beginning of this competition to me, and she only got better

[vampesorocaba]

Both amazing