This is my favorite version of this song. I always play it on my headphones on the walk home from campus. I get to walk down a hill overlooking the city as I watch the sunset. It's a nice little ender to a long day.
@123123uuuuuuuu actually is Emma is a period in his life when everything went wrong, ie spliting up with his girlfriend, breaking up with his band, getting mono. Emma isn't named after anyone just a period that he wishs to forget, as explained by the forever ago bit.... :)
@JayB1699 actually, "Emma" is Sara Emma Jensen, the main muse of the album. When you hear Justin say "Emma is a time and a place, everyone has an Emma", it's because Jensen was his first love. Everyone has a first love, and your first love isn't just a person, they become more like a time in your life. everyone has experienced the pain in the end of their first love. although the album itself has songs about Jensen, it also has songs about the girlfriend from the "bad breakup" Christy Smith.
@JayB1699 if you read some more interviews, you'll figure all this out through actual answer as well as reading between the lines. For Emma, Forever Ago itself was Vernon's way of getting over his first love. just a little info :P
Much better than the album verison. Way more soul to these Myspace Transmissions versions they have. Bon iver are probably one of the most talented groups ever.
@BonIverSUCKS I love how you actually went to the effort of making an account with the sole purpose of bad mouthing a group with no valid points of argument. No one cares if you don't like Bon Iver so you don't need to make your existence known on a video. Cheers.
Love this version with the piano carrying. I really enjoy the horns and electric guitar on the studio version, but there's way too much mind-numbing acoustic strumming, and it's too high in the mix.
this version blows. gratuitously masterbatory arrangement does not equal added soulfulness and emotion. the guitar track makes the album version the amazing work of art that it is.
I would like to have his babies, so that my children could have at least 1/10th of the talent justin does...he moves me, gives me chills, makes me hot, and makes me cry all at the same time.
it would be really cool if they re-recorded For Emma, Forever Ago live with the other three guys along with Justin, the drum beat in the background is simple but changes the whole song
@cowmanman Seriously! I'm with you, fuck all the insecure, childish commenters who desperately fish for "top comments" by talking about the dislikes. Fuck all of you people who upvote them, as well.
i think i have listened to this literally 60 times since discovering this video yesterday. i saw bon iver in Dublin a few years back and his ability to translate his pain and passion into an ambient air that transcends anything i personally have ever experienced is second to none. a true talent which i pray will never get drowned in the mediocrity of mainstream.
My name is Emma :) and even though I know he didn't write it for me.... I still feel like he's singing it too me in this video, it's beautiful with the piano...
Yeah dude! Thats sick that he can play that without a double pedal. He's a fantastic percussionist, he went to the same college as me (actually so did all of these guys) his solo album is awesome
Check out a cover of Flume by searching Ramble and Wake. Check out the originals titled Pills and Coulda been bad as well. Pease comment and let us know what you think. Any feedback is good feedback. Thanks.
Brilliant version of an already beautiful song. The drum beat is perfect and the sparse parts suck you right in - the soaring falsetto harmonies give me chills. 1:50 is magic.
Brilliant version of an already beautiful song. The drum beat is perfect and the sparse parts suck you right in - the soaring falsetto harmonies give me chills. 1:50 is magic.
Hahah no that it isn't micheal Cera but it does look like him ;) I love this song my sister showed me this song a few years ago when the album came out (btw my name is Emma)
Check out a cover of Flume by searching Ramble and Wake. Check out the originals titled Pills and Coulda been bad as well. Pease comment and let us know what you think. Any feedback is good feedback. Thanks.
As seen on Reddit? That shitty site doesn't deserve a band like this. <3
GlenMuse795 4 days ago
1:51 so much passion.
pancholoco489 1 week ago
SO DAMN GOOD, a great spin on the studio version. A true artist
delaneyma 2 weeks ago
MAGIC
whudafuxgoingon 2 weeks ago
So damn beautiful...I can hear this over and over and over and over again...
Nachtogen132 1 month ago
It's unfathomable to me that anybody could dislike this.
lalinz23 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It's amazing how they create such a full sound using just percussion and vocals
icecreammmmman1991 2 months ago
Comment removed
icecreammmmman1991 2 months ago
This is my favorite version of this song. I always play it on my headphones on the walk home from campus. I get to walk down a hill overlooking the city as I watch the sunset. It's a nice little ender to a long day.
cahte1220 2 months ago 3
Mike Noyce, you bastard.. <3
moniqueislegit 3 months ago
Go find another lover - badass
tommoelbommo 3 months ago
can anyone please tell me who emma is ?? :))) i'm kinda new fan so ...
123123uuuuuuuu 3 months ago
@123123uuuuuuuu
Emma is his ex girlfriend, he made an album called For Emma Forever Ago
2cool4urplatypus 3 months ago 2
@123123uuuuuuuu actually is Emma is a period in his life when everything went wrong, ie spliting up with his girlfriend, breaking up with his band, getting mono. Emma isn't named after anyone just a period that he wishs to forget, as explained by the forever ago bit.... :)
JayB1699 2 months ago
@JayB1699 actually, "Emma" is Sara Emma Jensen, the main muse of the album. When you hear Justin say "Emma is a time and a place, everyone has an Emma", it's because Jensen was his first love. Everyone has a first love, and your first love isn't just a person, they become more like a time in your life. everyone has experienced the pain in the end of their first love. although the album itself has songs about Jensen, it also has songs about the girlfriend from the "bad breakup" Christy Smith.
PogoPantheon 3 weeks ago
@JayB1699 if you read some more interviews, you'll figure all this out through actual answer as well as reading between the lines. For Emma, Forever Ago itself was Vernon's way of getting over his first love. just a little info :P
PogoPantheon 3 weeks ago
9 Emma's watched this video
findingnvrland21 3 months ago 2
lol myspace..
hkim927 4 months ago 4
brb, crying.
BasedOnFantasy 4 months ago 5
batatatamm batattataamm <3
WampiForGermany 4 months ago in playlist Zu Favoriten hinzugefügte Videos von WampiForGermany
hate the fact the guy doing backing vocals is wearing flip flops. loser.
telehead23 4 months ago
@telehead23 we love mikey, you're the loser!
crowdie 4 months ago
@telehead23 I'd be curious to find put what the temperature was that day.
steakstar 4 months ago
I WILL FIGHT WHOEVER DISLIKED THIS!!!!
cjl49 4 months ago in playlist cjl49's Favorited Videos
@lortamai shutup, faggot
slatejob11 4 months ago
calivermusic.bandcamp.com!!!!!! Very intimate acoustic music similar to this performance by Justin Vernon!
harrisonnantz 5 months ago
@BonIverSUCKS BUM THE POO WEE FART PANTS
Treefingrs 5 months ago
Much better than the album verison. Way more soul to these Myspace Transmissions versions they have. Bon iver are probably one of the most talented groups ever.
JonasHelsing 5 months ago
Love Bon Iver's music...
transmissionslipping 5 months ago
too short arg!
Monstufpud 6 months ago
Fantastic music, love it
DonzeJ 6 months ago
vernon plays those keys with so much soul
yoyobaa100 6 months ago
Michael Cera on the backup vocals
bbaroo5 6 months ago 10
@bbaroo5 hahaha
kalynbaur 6 months ago
@BonIverSUCKS I love how you actually went to the effort of making an account with the sole purpose of bad mouthing a group with no valid points of argument. No one cares if you don't like Bon Iver so you don't need to make your existence known on a video. Cheers.
EoinMurMur93 6 months ago 5
@EoinMurMur93 Congrats. You just fed that user the attention they were looking for. I love Bon Iver though :)
monokid1 6 months ago
@EoinMurMur93 I agree!
msboobooboo03 6 months ago in playlist chill out
7 beiber fans
hediedat7 6 months ago 2
Oh my god, I WANT THAT PIANO
agolden847 6 months ago
Love this version with the piano carrying. I really enjoy the horns and electric guitar on the studio version, but there's way too much mind-numbing acoustic strumming, and it's too high in the mix.
jameshaire 7 months ago 2
this version blows. gratuitously masterbatory arrangement does not equal added soulfulness and emotion. the guitar track makes the album version the amazing work of art that it is.
carcinopunk 7 months ago
ahh i remember myspace
rhysj987 7 months ago 2
Every asshole with a high school band thinks they have the right to critic musicians the likes of these...Sad.
mikesc281 7 months ago 4
Damn, my leg hurts FOR the drummer! His leg should be a national treasure!
Amazing version. Best one I've heard.
Thanks for the upload
PerennialKillJoy 7 months ago 62
@PerennialKillJoy heal toe technique, you can go for ages
J4KETS 2 months ago
holy beards!
JBeezie428 7 months ago
I watch this video once a day.
cheshirevan 7 months ago
every version of this song is amazing!
rustyasscrack 7 months ago
the beat looks like "streets of philadelphia" from bruce springsteen
alecstopirose 7 months ago
oh lord, this is phenomenal
PersistenceMusic 7 months ago
I just bonivergasmed
jjjrulez 7 months ago 48
who's doing the tambourine?!
TheReasons2010 8 months ago
@TheReasons2010 The guy on drums usually plays bass live, the drummer is off to the side next to the xylophone rocking the tamborine =)
cmatthews926 8 months ago
@TheReasons2010
drummer's left foot :)
aniqai 7 months ago
Jesus... Mary... and freakin' Joseph..... I just died and went to heaven..
kimbostube 8 months ago
@kimbostube AMEN
yahighness 8 months ago
Go find another lover...
DMBMBS 8 months ago
it's terrifying to go back to that place when you lost someone you loved and feel what you felt again... this song brings me back to forever ago
Larry1u23 8 months ago
I just want to fix him. He is magnificant.
loseourselvesx 8 months ago
Wish this version was on the album. Great album and amazing tune
demonteeth82 8 months ago
Kl track, check out kulu change of heart video. there album no rider is on i tunes.
takeitbackfloyd 8 months ago
thanks for sound from heaven !!!!
boominju 8 months ago
six people are turds.
this is wonderful
nanabell500 8 months ago
six ppl missed the like button
carlose0318 8 months ago
Comment removed
nanabell500 8 months ago
No one should ever, in a thousand trillion eons, attempt to cover a Justin Vernon masterpiece. Ra-tards. Leave it to the gifted one.
Nardingtons 8 months ago 2
around 0:00-2:57 gives me goosebumps.
AnnaBjornholt 9 months ago
when i die i would like to listen to this
ImTheInf3rn0 9 months ago 3
@delasol hahahahah
TheZachGraham 9 months ago
around 1:50 gives me goosebumps
willywoo95 9 months ago
Comment removed
willywoo95 9 months ago
How ridiculously amazing is this? Best version of For Emma, by far.
licilovely 9 months ago 4
I would like to have his babies, so that my children could have at least 1/10th of the talent justin does...he moves me, gives me chills, makes me hot, and makes me cry all at the same time.
Amy1518 9 months ago
WHAT. AN. AMAZING. VERSION. OF. FOR. EMMA
rianalanking 9 months ago 2
I like how much soul this version has. Another face to Vernon's undying talents
georgegabriel9 9 months ago 2
it would be really cool if they re-recorded For Emma, Forever Ago live with the other three guys along with Justin, the drum beat in the background is simple but changes the whole song
hubeeqb 10 months ago
5 people have their own opinions and i respect that
cowmanman 10 months ago 5
@cowmanman Seriously! I'm with you, fuck all the insecure, childish commenters who desperately fish for "top comments" by talking about the dislikes. Fuck all of you people who upvote them, as well.
Yotes4Life 9 months ago 2
@Yotes4Life thanks bro haha
cowmanman 9 months ago
I wish they would come play in Chicago...
abaracudagirl 10 months ago
What a moving song.
SPART3NKiLL3R 10 months ago
"joke about how 5 people must have some defect in their morals"
rodekill27 10 months ago 7
@rodekill27 BAZINGA!
RyanFails 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is this entire session available as an album? Magnificente!
BillyShearrs 10 months ago
Is this entire session available as an album! Magnificente!
BillyShearrs 10 months ago
5 people like bieber > vernon
jarvis1700 10 months ago
I like this more than the original :)
jakem4444 10 months ago 2
5 people must have sucky taste in music. This is amazing.
iamjoshbrooks 11 months ago
magical <3
stellatocca 11 months ago
So apropos...Saw death on a sunny snow
For every life...forego the parable.
Seek the light....my knees are cold.
Running home, Running home, Running home, Running home
Go find another lover...To bring and to string along!
With all your lies... You're still very lovable.
I toured a light...So many foreign roads
For Emma, forever ago
davindoc 11 months ago 7
I love how he switches up the songs -- different instruments in all his live performances.
Godlynessinate 11 months ago
This would've been a perfect song without the drums.
mschafer13 11 months ago
@mschafer13
lieinmygrave 11 months ago
THERE IS NO DOUBLE BASS PEDAL!
CarlosAVal3 11 months ago 5
i think i have listened to this literally 60 times since discovering this video yesterday. i saw bon iver in Dublin a few years back and his ability to translate his pain and passion into an ambient air that transcends anything i personally have ever experienced is second to none. a true talent which i pray will never get drowned in the mediocrity of mainstream.
stevesleeve09 11 months ago 7
My name is Emma :) and even though I know he didn't write it for me.... I still feel like he's singing it too me in this video, it's beautiful with the piano...
TheYoungDirector15 11 months ago
Awesome!!
CHECK OUT OUR COVER OF THIS SONG MIXED WITH BRUNO MARS' 'JUST THE WAY YOU ARE' :) Please leave your thoughts, it would mean the world to us xoxo
itsfrancesca1409 11 months ago
FIVE PEOPE HAS AIDS
brooks450 11 months ago
his voice...<3 LOVE IT
EilzHad 1 year ago
whats an older version of michael cera doing there?
aRchEneMy543 1 year ago
this is perfect!
EmAge79 1 year ago
1:45-1:55. piano parts. no words.
nicholasmlee 1 year ago 2
goodness gracious. o_o
nicholasmlee 1 year ago
does anyone have the tabs for piano bit??
entershikari95 1 year ago
@entershikari95 hey man i tried figuring it out on my own.
basically the 3 main chords are C G (notes lower B D and the G from previous c chord) and F
just keep watching the video and you'll get the hang of it
Stayclassy110 1 year ago
@Stayclassy110 Cheers :), im not a pianist so im a wee bit retarded when it comes to these things!
entershikari95 1 year ago
I'm pretty sure 200,000 of these views are mine.
bdegennaro 1 year ago
@bdegennaro You must've been mistaken 'cause 220,000 of the views are mine ;)
EliasFrostMusic 1 year ago
I don't really like this.
too many instruments.. too professional. :)
h0olzschuh 1 year ago
Can I get a download or something
guimonsterjustin 1 year ago
@guimonsterjustin try keeptube - just google it. you can download as an .mp4 format :)
AbstinentUser 1 year ago
@AbstinentUser Thanks! The only thing I have listened to for the last week!
guimonsterjustin 1 year ago
how can anyone dislike this? it's mesmerising.
AbstinentUser 1 year ago
@AbstinentUser
I agree. It's just how the summer sun sounds
Tratamentu 1 year ago
i want some sheet music for this..or a tutorial.
I FUGGIN LOVE THIS.
cartmanandkylefan 1 year ago
so beautiful. I'm all wet now!
hankblalock9 1 year ago
this is beautiful. i've been watching it everyday since i found it, thanks!
LBSUNFLWR 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
bon iver has enough soul to move an old negro spiritual
shooter0404 1 year ago 155
@shooter0404 ryan ur azn
melfassy13 1 year ago
@shooter0404 If bon iver sang an old negro spiritual, i'm pretty sure the world would implode
rodekill27 9 months ago
@shooter0404 DOOM <3
Madvillain14 7 months ago
@Madvillain14 hahaha yessir. best rapper hands down, in my opinion.
shooter0404 6 months ago
That drummers got a fuckin good leg!
SabianTamaDrummer 1 year ago 11
@SabianTamaDrummer
Yeah dude! Thats sick that he can play that without a double pedal. He's a fantastic percussionist, he went to the same college as me (actually so did all of these guys) his solo album is awesome
mercilpb 1 year ago
@mercilpb That's so rad! Did you know them personally?
SabianTamaDrummer 1 year ago
5 people hate themselves
delasol 1 year ago 65
@delasol 5ppl are...for emmo
yoyosk8ccs 10 months ago
@delasol You mean 6.
SnipingDistrictFMJ 9 months ago
@SnipingDistrictFMJ it's funny because it wasn't always 6
demarsbar 9 months ago
@delasol you silly guy. lol. shut up.
Chameaulino1 8 months ago
@delasol 6
MuseDen 8 months ago
@delasol I make that 6
phantomfeline 7 months ago
cant believe myspace just captured this better than blogotheque, but i guess you cant carry around a baby grand
jonhavener 1 year ago
Comment removed
jonhavener 1 year ago
what r the chords for piano
kylepatton100 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out a cover of Flume by searching Ramble and Wake. Check out the originals titled Pills and Coulda been bad as well. Pease comment and let us know what you think. Any feedback is good feedback. Thanks.
rambleandwake 1 year ago
this is easily the best version. . hands down
TheSirbongalot 1 year ago 4
Beards mean less shaving
doa2382 1 year ago 2
I feel like I just lost my virginity to this song.
oasisxo 1 year ago 6
How come so many dudes on MySpace Transmission vids have beards? it's not all but enough that I'm left wondering...
scoty0808 1 year ago
@scoty0808 It's the hipster uniform.
bobfenster 1 year ago
@scoty0808 It's the hipster uniform. (That's not a dig at Justin, he's awesome.)
bobfenster 1 year ago
it should be a crime to be this good. :(
twist3dmoon 1 year ago
Some Justin Vernon from 'Feels Like Home' /watch?v=K8Q5Wk0HHE4 :D
12park12 1 year ago
130 to 1 ration of likes to dislikes has to be one of the highest on youtube
mcquick22 1 year ago
my name is emma :D
MySceneKidd 1 year ago
I'm almost positive I like this version better than the original. Both make me melt, though.
xaaallieex 1 year ago
Wow. 1:50. well, the whole thing. but especially 1:50. Sublime
roszko 1 year ago
Brilliant version of an already beautiful song. The drum beat is perfect and the sparse parts suck you right in - the soaring falsetto harmonies give me chills. 1:50 is magic.
GMcTav7 1 year ago 3
Brilliant version of an already beautiful song. The drum beat is perfect and the sparse parts suck you right in - the soaring falsetto harmonies give me chills. 1:50 is magic.
GMcTav7 1 year ago
Splendiforous
mcquick22 1 year ago
These kinda drums fit perfectly with Bon Iver. You just swell into it!
LennGuitar 1 year ago
so fucking incredible! Its flaws are what makes it Flawless
rossmorris 1 year ago
"With all your lies,
You're still very lovable."
jessiewollyyy 1 year ago 2
such good reverb in that room
Dkolps 1 year ago
Favorite.
4TwentyFriendly 1 year ago
Comment removed
4TwentyFriendly 1 year ago
1:40 :-)
milkchurn24 1 year ago
Comment removed
milkchurn24 1 year ago
whos the other guy singing??
entershikari95 1 year ago
bon eeeeeeeevair, made me see the light!!! mairceee i bow koooo!!!
ndnrj 1 year ago
I have been hearing this song for around 30 min now... Can't seriously stop listening to it! :)
Simix4000 1 year ago
Hahah no that it isn't micheal Cera but it does look like him ;) I love this song my sister showed me this song a few years ago when the album came out (btw my name is Emma)
BabySaSQuatch14 1 year ago
I didn't know Michael Cera did backup vocals in this band.
Wemetaliens 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out a cover of Flume by searching Ramble and Wake. Check out the originals titled Pills and Coulda been bad as well. Pease comment and let us know what you think. Any feedback is good feedback. Thanks.
rambleandwake 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
words can't even explain how much of a genius Justin Vernon is.
Like I can't even type a comment that is worthy enough to explain how amazing Bon Iver is.
BasedOnFantasy 1 year ago
Comment removed
BasedOnFantasy 1 year ago
Comment removed
BasedOnFantasy 1 year ago
How beautiful is that? <3
tinacdorr 1 year ago 2
i typed in my name and this popped up (psst my name is Emma) and i love it!!!!!!! so awesome!
mrsmclean100 1 year ago 3
Pure beauty. Art and heart.
I just love it.
joshuagajicki 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
probably the worst version of this song. still my favorite band though.
abbottrich 1 year ago
This is one of the best bands in the world. Vernon is genious and the music he creates and performes is as deep as it could ever be...
LiudaSQ 1 year ago 6
i love justins hair..
bLackmarketRadio 1 year ago
#OMG can it get any better than bon iver!
jcrack23 1 year ago
sweet jesus this is great.
greatdivideee 1 year ago
This is the closest thing to perfect I have ever seen.
MSCurtin 1 year ago 41
@MSCurtin I agree 1000%. These guys are unbelievably good.
jazzandmint 1 year ago
@MSCurtin Then you should really see the Take Away Show video of this song.
bhretters 11 months ago
this is by far epic. I loove this
miosanchez 1 year ago
so great i gotta go play this on my piano
TheLongestMile 1 year ago