This is a great debate. Even though it is a mock debate RC is asking good questions and bringing up good points without being disrespectful. When I listen to other debates (Christian vs. Atheist) atheist are usually disrespectful and look more to win the crowd over than to defeat the opposing argument.
I love this debate w/RC playing devil's advocate. I heard parts of it broadcasted over the radio a while back. It must have been terribly difficult for RC to argue from a position he doesn't believe in. It would have been very interesting to see Dr. Gerstner or RC debate a real atheist.
@businissman20: RC wasn't an atheist he was posing as one for the sake of the debate. Playing devils advocate. Listen to the introduction. Commentary tells his credentials!
For God so loved the elect and hated the world , that He gave His only Son, that whomsoever He had chosen to not perish but have eternal life should believe in Him. For God sent His Son to condemn the world, and to save the elect.
CHRISTIANS OF THE WORLD! THE FINAL WILL OF GOD IS UNITY, LOVE AND HOLINESS!
End ChristenDOOM! Leave your churches, no church=no division. Just be perfectly holy: restrain yourself from expressing evil; guard yourself against all filthy influence outside. Be love: help for free, give for free!
I don't think this would convince the scientific community. Just because you have two educated doctors, debating Christianity or the existence of God, doesn't mean that it's true. I can't believe how many times I see stuff like this, but I doubt if you're going to see much of it in the future.
sorry to say. but jesus is as real as santa. dont tell ur kids. haha u christians are so hard headed and arrogant. answer this for me, christians. what would u do if you see a alien face to face. what would you think god is real then? oh wait a min. christians dont believe in aliens. haha
what would you do if u seen God face to face, oh wait u wouldnt be able to see him no one can see God and his Glory and still live, his way are far above are ways we cant even comprehend how holy God is, every knee will bow and every tongue will confess, whether you believe or not you will have no other choice, but Christ loves you and want you to understand the Gospel
And what are credentials that makes you an expert on Jesus. Such anger and venom in a person such is you is a curios thing. Believe or don't believe thats your choice but to come on here and actively seek a fight is further evidence that there is hate in the world that there is a Satan and that he hates the word of God and seeks to destroy and discredit anything from God. Sort of like your statements you may want to worry about who is ruling your life.
Intelligence does not come from nonintelligence. To choose to not believe in God is to give your conscience a license to choose for yourself what sin is and what it isn't- or even worse to believe there is no right or wrong, good or evil. Well let me tell you, someone who rapes and murders a child is evil (Jon Bonet Ramsey). And whether you deny it or not, read it or not, every knee will bow before the ultimate authority and be judged according to how well they obeyed/refused the Bible.
Skysplash--how can you continually play the part of a fool?
You go against Christ's commandments for salvation for he gave the keys to the Kingdom to Peter which is Act2:38. You go against the teachings of all the other apostles such as Mark 16:16. You go against the teachings of the apostle Paul as he also taught the need for water baptism. You are trying to change scripture by making up or more likely repeating a lie that was taught to you. Start thinking for yourself..if you can!
You realize that this is a mock debate? what i mean is, they are both Christians, with one of them pretending to be against the others postion for the sake of the audience seeing both sides. Gershner is Sprouls mentorin reality
Once hydrogen has burned within a star and converted to heavier elements, it can never be restored to its original state. As hydrogen is burned up, the supply of this element dwindles.
If the amount of actual energy stays the same(1st law of thermodynamics), but the universe is running out of useable energy, it has never had an infinite amount - for an infinite amount can never decrease. This means that the universe could not have existed for eternity in the past.
Actually, I must make a correction, Skysplash did not delete my comments or block me, it was some kind of flaw with youtube which disabled his controls.
In Mark 11:30, regarding the baptism of John, Jesus asked, "The baptism of John, was it from heaven, or of men? answer me." Of course, the answer is from heaven. Today, people need the same question asked regarding water baptism, "Water baptism, was it from heaven, or of men? answer me." Works of men save nobody (Eph. 2:8-9), but works of God are necessary (John 6:28-29; Col 2:12-13). After all, we must obey the commands of Christ (Mark 16:16; Acts 2:38; 1 Peter 3:21).
I see you took the liberty to add baptism to that particular scripture. Sounds like you add or subtract to the scriptures whenever you disagree with God. Good luck in your quest.
Im not just sayin just be baptie and do nothing...You have to do work and have faith too but think about it in the New Testament he was baptized..and we have to try to live like him and be like him...soo that why I say what I believe in Baptism is required thnk u. and you dont have too but its nothin but choice.
The scriptures indicate that Baptism and Christianity went hand in hand. The Apostles and the first century church felt it was essential and the teachings of Jesus referenced baptism and salvation together.
Watch the entire debate. Only one thing is Needfull Only one thing is ESSENTIAL...You are JUSTIFIED by GRACE alone through Faith alone in Christ alone. And Notice THE ROOT IS GRACE. Faith is our Revelation of Jesus Christ. Baptism and all the other works of the Holy Spirit in us Including Repentance our the fruits of Christ working through us We our Christs Workmanship once we are born again.
I understood the debate but these men are not apostles and their logic does not save them. I hope for their sake and your sake that God's word is irrelevant to salvation but I am not willing to take that chance with my soul. I will be obedient and accept his grace as well. Thanks and peace to you!
20 I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me. 21I do not set aside the GRACE of God, for if righteousness could be gained through the law(OBDIENCE) Christ died for nothing!"
GRACE and OBEDIENCE listen to what your are saying. Obedience to the Law and Gods Grace. Guess Jesus did not fullfill the Entire Law.
Baptism is part of the New Covenant/New Testament and not the Mosaic Law/Old Testament. It seems that you are saying that you will gladly continue to sin and willfully disobey because of grace?
Where do I say that. Obedience to the Spirit in you, Christ in you . Fruits do not become roots. Fruits do not sustain the Root. Only the Son (Sun) who planted the Holy spirit( Incorruptable Seed) in you can have you grow in him.
The perfect Law on stone or the Perfect Law of the spirit of life in Christ Jesus. One Glory Fades the other does not.
My use of Sun Seed Plant and Grow is an anology. Jesus used the Parable of the Seed and the Sower and He was The Seed mentioned in Genesis 3. And if when you become born again and you have the incorruptable seed in your heart what can possibly seperate you from the Love of God. Romans 8. You can know you have eternal LIFE NOW 1John
Matthew the 28th chapter ended with Jesus telling the apostles to make other disciples by teaching and baptizing them. It was the last thing Jesus told those whom he was closest to before he ascended into heaven. It was very important, wouldn't you think so?
You would agree that Jesus was not implying to Bapitize Unbelievers but Believers. And Once Born Again By GOds Grace alone. The First Fruits are Faith then Repent and Be Bapitized none of the Fruits are Roots.
Leave out Gods Grace and everything you do becomes a Root A Root of Sinfull man trying to please God without Jesus as the Center.
Cant you see this in the catholic church and many others.
Very good point. Often we forget about the thief that was crucified next to Jesus. Never Baptized, yet was guaranteed that on that day he would be with Christ in paradise.
This has been flagged as spam show
Exdous Chapter 20:vers.17 Thou shalt not covet any thing that is thy neighbour's. The 10th commandment. The truth about giving.
brotherfrank62 3 weeks ago in playlist Christian Doctrine
Ontological argument fails every time.
PhilipGregory1981 3 months ago
This is a great debate. Even though it is a mock debate RC is asking good questions and bringing up good points without being disrespectful. When I listen to other debates (Christian vs. Atheist) atheist are usually disrespectful and look more to win the crowd over than to defeat the opposing argument.
Whipset 5 months ago
"the most compelling argument"
THE QUESTION WAS THE MOST COMPELLING EVIDENCE RETARD DO YOU HAVE EARS???
And lol, his answers to all the questions from the devils advocate are BECAUSE, hahahaha what a tard.
Feralus69 10 months ago
Fiction does not have to be Fact to be True.
lucasboden 10 months ago
I love this debate w/RC playing devil's advocate. I heard parts of it broadcasted over the radio a while back. It must have been terribly difficult for RC to argue from a position he doesn't believe in. It would have been very interesting to see Dr. Gerstner or RC debate a real atheist.
lisahayes3 1 year ago
This thing is scripted like an infomercial. Painful.
instereovideos 1 year ago
R.C. Sproul is really good
82jacuna 1 year ago
supramental, you are correct. =)
businessman20 1 year ago
Haha! This is an old video. At the time RC was an atheist. But now, he is a Christian long long time ago. Woo hoo!
businessman20 1 year ago
woww.. i didnt know he was an atheist!!!..
DCYPL1OF1YESHUA 1 year ago
@businissman20: RC wasn't an atheist he was posing as one for the sake of the debate. Playing devils advocate. Listen to the introduction. Commentary tells his credentials!
supramental 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Here is the Calvinist translation of John 3:16
For God so loved the elect and hated the world , that He gave His only Son, that whomsoever He had chosen to not perish but have eternal life should believe in Him. For God sent His Son to condemn the world, and to save the elect.
calvinismisacult 1 year ago
Gerstner is giving the TAG argument that Sproul debated against for quite a while. Not one of his stronger points
MRKetter81 2 years ago
wow, this is an old video! Spraul is an excelent theologian!
shanemason789 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Remember god bless america and f--k of the rest of the world. god only loves america and jesus was white. lol
nonextfx777 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
.
CHRISTIANS OF THE WORLD! THE FINAL WILL OF GOD IS UNITY, LOVE AND HOLINESS!
End ChristenDOOM! Leave your churches, no church=no division. Just be perfectly holy: restrain yourself from expressing evil; guard yourself against all filthy influence outside. Be love: help for free, give for free!
.
conceil8 2 years ago
I don't think this would convince the scientific community. Just because you have two educated doctors, debating Christianity or the existence of God, doesn't mean that it's true. I can't believe how many times I see stuff like this, but I doubt if you're going to see much of it in the future.
didgodsaythat 2 years ago
why wouldnt we see it anymore?..
DCYPL1OF1YESHUA 1 year ago
You can justify it all you want. Facts these arguments do not make.
gargamel6699 2 years ago
Arty,
At the very beginning of the video it gives both of their credentials - it's not like it's a hidden fact. There is such a thing as 'mock debate.'
SidHancock3 2 years ago
This is such a con job. R.C. Sproul is a Christian apologist pretending to be a skeptic. Look him up.
Typical Christian deceit.
artyfarty2 2 years ago
Comment removed
thisnameisuniq 2 years ago
You can tell rc sproul spent a lot of time together they have the same speach patern
pungadoo 2 years ago
Gerstner was his mentor in seminary and Sproul champions him as the most Godly man he has ever known.
Grenadier1944 2 years ago
sorry to say. but jesus is as real as santa. dont tell ur kids. haha u christians are so hard headed and arrogant. answer this for me, christians. what would u do if you see a alien face to face. what would you think god is real then? oh wait a min. christians dont believe in aliens. haha
xlkeo 2 years ago
haha, good piont to bad alians dont exist you dumb star treck fan boy!
hahaha
MitchellJohnLeard 2 years ago
haha too bad god doesnt too. u fail
xlkeo 2 years ago
So is your argument that there was no 1st century Jewish rabbi who taught and was killed by the roman empire?
jgrig2 2 years ago
dont make me waste my time talking about a jew, you jew -.-
xlkeo 2 years ago
what would you do if u seen God face to face, oh wait u wouldnt be able to see him no one can see God and his Glory and still live, his way are far above are ways we cant even comprehend how holy God is, every knee will bow and every tongue will confess, whether you believe or not you will have no other choice, but Christ loves you and want you to understand the Gospel
all4s1 2 years ago
very sad, one day you'll die, and you'll have eternal hell waiting. Even atheist historians agree that jesus is real.
sungminchoice 2 years ago
and one day youll die in a horrific car accident and barely breathing
xlkeo 2 years ago
"you'll have eternal hell waiting"
Sure.
"Even atheist historians agree that jesus is real. "
They do? which atheist Biblical scholarship work have you read?
How about Christian scholars like Tom Harpur or Lloyd Geering? Have you read what they have to say about the historicity of Jesus?
Somehow I doubt it. More like you spout what ever garbage you have heard that makes it sound like your mythology is true.
artyfarty2 2 years ago
And what are credentials that makes you an expert on Jesus. Such anger and venom in a person such is you is a curios thing. Believe or don't believe thats your choice but to come on here and actively seek a fight is further evidence that there is hate in the world that there is a Satan and that he hates the word of God and seeks to destroy and discredit anything from God. Sort of like your statements you may want to worry about who is ruling your life.
utex67 2 years ago
what? haha go talk to someone who cares.
xlkeo 2 years ago
Intelligence does not come from nonintelligence. To choose to not believe in God is to give your conscience a license to choose for yourself what sin is and what it isn't- or even worse to believe there is no right or wrong, good or evil. Well let me tell you, someone who rapes and murders a child is evil (Jon Bonet Ramsey). And whether you deny it or not, read it or not, every knee will bow before the ultimate authority and be judged according to how well they obeyed/refused the Bible.
KaycieStarlight71 2 years ago
?'s----
1-what existed before the big bang?
2-where did the energy that caused the big bang come from?
anyone have any answers?
joebangleec 2 years ago
read a book and learn dumb ass
xlkeo 2 years ago
well then why don't you answer?
jgrig2 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
read a book and learn dumb ass
xlkeo 2 years ago
Fantasy. Its all based on writings - written by humans that are supposedly 3rd party witness statements.
No.1 argument for God:
"Because you must believe in him".
Thats exactly what a charlaton would say.
Believe in what i tell you, because you have to believe in it.
eonuk 3 years ago
very well thought out....have you eer thought of becoming a doctor?
ihaveaverybadcold 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
L.Ron Hubbard-wrote a fiction book now millions follow it as their doctrine.
The bible same fucking thing!
MarilynFilth 3 years ago
uhh not really 66 books over 40 people written over 1500s years not the same thing get your facts straight
lilchrizz123 3 years ago 4
This is awesome. Girstner is probably one of the best theologians of our time.
Bhanna4d 3 years ago
Skysplash--how can you continually play the part of a fool?
You go against Christ's commandments for salvation for he gave the keys to the Kingdom to Peter which is Act2:38. You go against the teachings of all the other apostles such as Mark 16:16. You go against the teachings of the apostle Paul as he also taught the need for water baptism. You are trying to change scripture by making up or more likely repeating a lie that was taught to you. Start thinking for yourself..if you can!
wilby1414 3 years ago
LOL. That disco music is a trip. Ankerberg's hair hasn't changed all that much.
PraiseYeshua 4 years ago
Oxford, Cambridge, Durham, Nottingham...
Not impressed.
youmeandsomeknives 4 years ago
Sproul is wrong on this.
Psalm130 4 years ago
You realize that this is a mock debate? what i mean is, they are both Christians, with one of them pretending to be against the others postion for the sake of the audience seeing both sides. Gershner is Sprouls mentorin reality
bigawp 3 years ago 6
crank up that 70's music, because where going to prove god with a funk style kicking it to ya.
godscuttingyoudown 4 years ago
Astronomers have pointed out:
Once hydrogen has burned within a star and converted to heavier elements, it can never be restored to its original state. As hydrogen is burned up, the supply of this element dwindles.
If the amount of actual energy stays the same(1st law of thermodynamics), but the universe is running out of useable energy, it has never had an infinite amount - for an infinite amount can never decrease. This means that the universe could not have existed for eternity in the past.
Glorthac 4 years ago 2
Actually, I must make a correction, Skysplash did not delete my comments or block me, it was some kind of flaw with youtube which disabled his controls.
runningchance 4 years ago
fantasy
NathairSaille 4 years ago
I still say baptism.
diamondofchrist 4 years ago 2
Skysplash deleted some of the comments on the baptism debate video as well as disabling the comments. He really was up to hearing the truth.
runningchance 4 years ago
In Mark 11:30, regarding the baptism of John, Jesus asked, "The baptism of John, was it from heaven, or of men? answer me." Of course, the answer is from heaven. Today, people need the same question asked regarding water baptism, "Water baptism, was it from heaven, or of men? answer me." Works of men save nobody (Eph. 2:8-9), but works of God are necessary (John 6:28-29; Col 2:12-13). After all, we must obey the commands of Christ (Mark 16:16; Acts 2:38; 1 Peter 3:21).
vhopson 4 years ago 2
Amen! Having faith without deeds is a faith that is dead. Even the demons believe and tremble at the name of Christ!
runningchance 4 years ago
Baptism is my vote thnx u
diamondofchrist 4 years ago
I am saved By Grace Alone through fatih alone in Christ alone. I have nothing to boast about.
You have something to boast about Baptism + Grace.
For you Baptism is the Root.
Form Me Baptism is a Fruit.
Matthew 7 Many shall say Jesus I was Baptized I cast out demons I did this and that. Jesus will say he never Knew You.
What is Grace if it cannot stand alone as Gods work and we are his Workmanship.
SKYSPLASH 4 years ago
I see you took the liberty to add baptism to that particular scripture. Sounds like you add or subtract to the scriptures whenever you disagree with God. Good luck in your quest.
runningchance 4 years ago
Im not just sayin just be baptie and do nothing...You have to do work and have faith too but think about it in the New Testament he was baptized..and we have to try to live like him and be like him...soo that why I say what I believe in Baptism is required thnk u. and you dont have too but its nothin but choice.
diamondofchrist 4 years ago 2
Amen Diamon, these guys really had to twist and turn it just right to logically get past baptism. Man's wisdom is foolishness to God.
runningchance 4 years ago
The scriptures indicate that Baptism and Christianity went hand in hand. The Apostles and the first century church felt it was essential and the teachings of Jesus referenced baptism and salvation together.
runningchance 4 years ago
Watch the entire debate. Only one thing is Needfull Only one thing is ESSENTIAL...You are JUSTIFIED by GRACE alone through Faith alone in Christ alone. And Notice THE ROOT IS GRACE. Faith is our Revelation of Jesus Christ. Baptism and all the other works of the Holy Spirit in us Including Repentance our the fruits of Christ working through us We our Christs Workmanship once we are born again.
SKYSPLASH 4 years ago
I understood the debate but these men are not apostles and their logic does not save them. I hope for their sake and your sake that God's word is irrelevant to salvation but I am not willing to take that chance with my soul. I will be obedient and accept his grace as well. Thanks and peace to you!
runningchance 4 years ago
Galatians 2
20 I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me. 21I do not set aside the GRACE of God, for if righteousness could be gained through the law(OBDIENCE) Christ died for nothing!"
GRACE and OBEDIENCE listen to what your are saying. Obedience to the Law and Gods Grace. Guess Jesus did not fullfill the Entire Law.
SKYSPLASH 4 years ago
Baptism is part of the New Covenant/New Testament and not the Mosaic Law/Old Testament. It seems that you are saying that you will gladly continue to sin and willfully disobey because of grace?
runningchance 4 years ago
Where do I say that. Obedience to the Spirit in you, Christ in you . Fruits do not become roots. Fruits do not sustain the Root. Only the Son (Sun) who planted the Holy spirit( Incorruptable Seed) in you can have you grow in him.
The perfect Law on stone or the Perfect Law of the spirit of life in Christ Jesus. One Glory Fades the other does not.
SKYSPLASH 4 years ago
My use of Sun Seed Plant and Grow is an anology. Jesus used the Parable of the Seed and the Sower and He was The Seed mentioned in Genesis 3. And if when you become born again and you have the incorruptable seed in your heart what can possibly seperate you from the Love of God. Romans 8. You can know you have eternal LIFE NOW 1John
SKYSPLASH 4 years ago
Matthew the 28th chapter ended with Jesus telling the apostles to make other disciples by teaching and baptizing them. It was the last thing Jesus told those whom he was closest to before he ascended into heaven. It was very important, wouldn't you think so?
runningchance 4 years ago
You would agree that Jesus was not implying to Bapitize Unbelievers but Believers. And Once Born Again By GOds Grace alone. The First Fruits are Faith then Repent and Be Bapitized none of the Fruits are Roots.
Leave out Gods Grace and everything you do becomes a Root A Root of Sinfull man trying to please God without Jesus as the Center.
Cant you see this in the catholic church and many others.
SKYSPLASH 4 years ago 2
Very good point. Often we forget about the thief that was crucified next to Jesus. Never Baptized, yet was guaranteed that on that day he would be with Christ in paradise.
budcarfan 4 years ago
How do you know he wasn't baptized.
JonathanDWhitehead 3 years ago
Mark 16:16, Acts 2:38, Acts 22:16, 1 Peter3:18-21
Jmac0585 4 years ago
Great message thanks for sharing this! :)
ManofGodChristian144 4 years ago