One tree hill 8x11 scene (Brooke, Nathan, Julian, Haley, Jamie)

[meags9497]

I was so worried when I first watched this! I freaked out when I saw Jamie standing in the middle of the road!! I was like, "OMG what hapened?!!" Major freak out moment! And what was with Haley! She didn't even seem concerned at all? :D xxx

[moviemania147]

If Brooke would died, it would have made Peyton and Rachel realize how crappy they treated their friend when they were needed most. I could have imagined how Victoria would have reacted over losing her daughter.

[bonco2317]

Basically what I'm doing is watching all of my favourite scenes before the new season starts tomorrow. This scene was incredible. I for one, am not a Julian fan, but I am a huge Brooke fan, so I don't mind that they are together because she is happy. I find him boring but in this scene I thought he was spectacular. Nathan and Haley's reactions were spot on. They were in shock, they had no clue what was happening. They were too shocked to just breakdown. The music was spot on also. Love OTH. <3

[TheNico8354]

OMG that scene i cried like hell, brooke is ma fav caracter

[heavenofthealive1995]

i hate the music here :/ doesn't f****g fit the scene!!

[annisaloves]

The music was horrible. They definitely should have chosen something better. Anyway, whoever said Julian's acting was horrible- you're wrong. I just cried my eyes out

[crezza24]

This made my cry,,,,especially when Jamie said aunt Brooke is dead and when Julian was like come on Brooke fight....

[brit18s]

julians acting was HORRIBLE!!!! and wats with the music n the background it sounded happy

[SAN6781]

Julian's acting is not great in this scene...

[computeraddict15]

cried so much

[tashababy973]

yes she said thank you

[Gerhart23]

when i first saw this i thought she was going to die

[clarabelle1able]

FOr a show that usually plays the perfect music for the perfect moments, they failed with this one.haha I would have thought they'd play a little bit of a better song here.

[redkqueen1989]

i get goosebumps everytime julian feels brooke begin to breathe.

[hotgirls615]

i loved that but did haley ever tell brooke thank you for giveing your life for my son's? and i wish i could find a guy like Julian!!.

[xSaz1986x]

yeah this scene is perfect with the track they chose. I have to diagree with those saying it was cheery or not right.

[awsomeperson2222]

this ep was sooo sad i felt sooo bad for julian but when she did come bk i was so happy cuzz oth cant be a show with out brooke

[swolfe89]

I agree that the music was crap, but it was a song that Psycho Katie put on and it gave it a creepy vibe to the entire scene. As crappy as the song selection was, I honestly didn't even notice it right away. I was on edge the entire time!!!! If Brooke died, I think the entire series would too. I love this scene and couldn't help but cry WITH Julian!!!!

:'( damn OTH always pulling at my heart strings!!! haha

[lonelyprincess93]

wait...so basically everyone else on the cast had a near death experience or ended up in the hospital...but it took brooke until season 8? what is this?

[Pcharmed3100]

Sad :( but happy anding :)

[EnergeticVampiree]

God I thought she was going to die it was terrible feeling

[hellokitty72410]

i was about to cry but when her hand moved i didn't

[TheEmmyG92]

I totally disagree about the music. Angel Flying to Close to the Ground is such a beautiful song and is DEFINITELY not a happy song. I thought the music chose was perfect and I def cried watching this

[112morgie]

Here's what happened , Lauren was driving Jamie , Chuck and Madison home from the Spelling B and Their car fliped, brooke and julian were fighting so brooke drives away somewhere , stops and sees the car and gets chuck and madison into her car and lauren drives them to the hospital. Brooke is tryin to get jamie out , someone hits them into the water , julian goes in water & tries to save them. Now Brooke is tryin to fight her life.

[smarties101]

If the scene stood alone, this would have been Mark's first music fail for sure. But because of Quinn's storyline with Katie it had to stay in; besides, this song was what was playing when Sara died, so it fits in a way. Though watching it on youtube by itself does make it weird. I'm sure more dramatic music would have been played if it didn't have to connect.

[ErinKnckl]

The music was used because of the other storyline in the episode. Music always carries over from storyline to story line like always. This song wasn't picked for this particular scene it was picked because of Quinn and Katie. I actually think it suits the scene really well. I did like Metics's song better but they couldn't just switch between the two songs when one works for both. This scene ALWAYS gets me though, simply because of Jilian.

[TheRealAmandaBrady]

Why does no one like the music? Angel Flying Too Close To The Ground? How was that a giveaway that she was going to live? I was actually really worried.

[beachbumm3695]

@TheRealAmandaBrady I agree! i loved the music, you also have to see the scene before where crazy katie is trying to kill quinn, which goes back to season 7 when they showed how sara died (clays wife). ever since then i've been in love with this song! Also it's not a happy song, listen to the lyrics, i felt that it went great with the scene!

[TheRealAmandaBrady]

@beachbumm3695 AGREED : )

[amanda8706]

@TheRealAmandaBrady exactly! cause the song is about this mans woman dieing.... so actually even thought this song was for quinn and katie..it was also really good for this scene, seeing as how julians woman was dieing... lol

[newlybrokenroad]

@TheRealAmandaBrady I thought it was a terrible song choice at first, but when I saw this, I was still getting caught up on the series, not realizing why they had previously played it. Now I listen to it all the time.

[youshouldclickme]

I cried. 

[RichardWiskerFanx1]

What Happened To Her ???

[twifreak89]

when did this air? i don't remember it

[psiloveyoucomet]

I actually think the music was fine. It wasn't that happy and i definitely thought Brooke might die, but would they seriously kill off a main character after the who peyton/lucas loss... Nah I don't think so.

[Tomgellar2]

for a minute i really thought she's dead...

[Dr21Ace]

i was getting teary eyed im like noo she has to live!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[mareeeeeeL]

@Dr21Ace which episode of season 8 is this?

[Dr21Ace]

@mareeeeeeL its episode 11 says so on the title =]

[BoysLovingBoys]

Anyone else think Haley didnt seem sad enough that her bestfriend of like, 10 years, is dying/dead? Julian, obviously upset. Nathan, shocked/distraught.. where as Haley.. I dunno, not so much.

[newlybrokenroad]

@BoysLovingBoys Probably shock.

[SingerSister111]

Yeah so of course Nathan and Haley just stand there while Julian tries to save her lol

[sinead4edwardcullen]

what has one tree hill come to....

[kittea24]

The music sucks it almost sounds like people are cheering in the background

[ForeverLost108]

I just saw this scene in a tribute to that episode with a beautiful piece of music. I didn't see season 8 yet so I was shocked, it was so sad and so perfect. And than I searched for the original clip and discover that this is the original music they put on it. Really?

My opinion about this scene completely changed just because of this music. It looked ridiculous, like they where putting together some stupid joke. Nice work OTH makers, you guys ruined a perfect scene with bad music!

[misskris111]

The music wasn't happy, it was actually meloncholy, which fit the scene. I think it was the perfect choice.

[SatinTaupe23]

I didn't even notice the music because I was too busy looking at the desperation from Julian.

[135maxgirl]

OMG! i started to cry when i watched this! i was like nooooooo! Brooke cant die! but of course she came back! i would have stopped watching the show if they killed her of...

[Tinu91]

the music doesn't really fit. I really wanted to see the reaction of nathan and haley when she "comes back".

[EllezBellez888]

i don't understand why so people are saying the music was bad, it's relevance was because its the same music used for when sarah died, which proves how this can be used for another sad scene

[caryalvarez]

Nathans face is brilliant!

[Roosters25653012]

omgg watt happened too brooke how did she die ..

why did she hve to die shes the best person in the movieeplz someone upload full ep

and cnt belioeve she wont b in oth anymoree i cnt watch it unless shes in it already that took out chad michael murray now her 2 :(

whats happeniing

[SPCA17]

@Roosters25653012 Watch the entire video ... :)

[JackLivesTogether]

I must be the minority because I thought the music set the mood. It wasn't a 'happy song'. The music is haunting.

[123nenagirl]

The music was okay I mean it was sad specially when he started hitting the ground but yeah. I also think Haley and Nathan's reactions were okay. I mean they are in shock it's not like they will start crying right at the second lol in my opinion :p also we know she wouldn't die lols

[volleyballgal108]

I absolutely freakn love this episode. So intense. So when Nathan said "I'll be right back. Stay here" i was like "WOO! go Nathan!!" then I see him run 2 feet in frontnof him and I just died. Kinda angry that at least nathan couldn't hav helped. And Nathan and Haley reactions when they thought she was dead was kinda subtle. Nathan trembled a bit but I expected some tears lol. Watever. Luv this :D

[Mi2sxM2iLkAa]

Oh my god .. Nervous tears fell from my eyes .. I was so afraid for Brooke. The scene is incredible, Julian broke my heart. He looks so desperate... And Nathan's look, like a deep blue ocean. ♥

[purerachagan]

@mdsfmdsfmdsf thank you so much, i just checked it, you're really good! :)

xx

[serephinedeer]

that almost made me cry :( x

[LancyForever]

the music is the song that played when clay's wife died

[iPodMusician]

kinda knew she wasn't going to die, or else the show would have been screwed...no lucas, peyton...NOW brooke? i don't think so haha

[coco23548]

this was such a sad scene.....

[kempokarate12]

the music totally killed it. that was the only give away that she was most definitely going to live. because they would not have happy music in the background if she died. if the music was different this scene would have been so much better!!!! i still loved it thought. don't get me wrong

[mdsfmdsfmdsf]

@kempokarate12 i agreed about the music i tried to remove the original song and to put a new one check it out if you want the link is is this video or you can just go to my account

[paszireka]

@kempokarate12 I don't agree with you.I think this song was the best choise for this scene. It was also used in when Sara died and if you listen you can hear that this is not a happy song. Just listen to the lyrics. So i don't understand why you don't like it, I was crying like baby when Willie sings: "so leave me if you need to...".

Heartbreaking scene. Sorry for my bad English.

[kempokarate12]

@paszireka I'm sorry, I didn't honestly didn't mean to make you upset. I definitely heard the lyrics and they are VERY sad, but I tend to listen to the instruments more than the lyrics when it comes to background music, since I'm trying to hear what the actors are saying. So because I was concentrating on that aspect, it just didn't quite fit to me. I was having a hard time being really sad when all I could think about was a guy sitting on a soap box playing a banjo. But it is still a sad song

[JackLivesTogether]

@paszireka YAY I am not the only one. This song is NOT happy. It's so haunting too. I thought it set the mood; it was a good choice.

P.S your English is fine. :D

[rhiny1234]

@kempokarate12 yea totally agreed, music ruin it, the music they had when she was in the car and he was trying to save her was more suited than this...i think they used this music to trick to think she was going to die because its the same music they used for sarah when she died....but it ruined it for me too! i couldn get so much into it because of it!

[colibookworm]

@kempokarate12 I think the music is sad because of the memories attached to it. It was the song when sara died. That I think made it sad.

[kempokarate12]

@colibookworm Very very true. I guess it doesn't help that I don't like Quinn and Clay and think they do absolutely nothing for the show. So I don't really pay any attention to their story. Which is why the memory of Sara dieing to that song doesn't phase me as much. I don't know.

[evilpride21]

@kempokarate12 who is sara?

[kempokarate12]

@evilpride21 Sara was Clay's wife. There was this entire (( unnecessary )) episode centered around how they met and how she randomly died in their kitchen. I don't know how much you watched but that's why in the beginning Clay would always see this blonde headed girl telling him to be with Quinn and move on. Then there was that stupid thing with Katie who was Sara's doppleganger I guess. She was psychotic and tried to become Sara and shot Quinn. It was all very stupid if you ask me. Haha

[evilpride21]

@kempokarate12 thank you so much

[kempokarate12]

@evilpride21 Yeah no problem!

[ToonBecks]

@kempokarate12 I guess but i think they put that on because it's the music that played when Sara died

[kempokarate12]

@ToonBecks Yeah I knew that was the song playing when Sara died. I guess that's another reason why I didn't like it. I thought Sara's story line was pointless. But tha'ts just me.

[7livelaughlove]

this scene could have been amazing, if not for the crappy music :(

[mdsfmdsfmdsf]

@7livelaughlove the music was just not right for this scene so i tried to remove the original song and to put a new one check it out if you want the link is is this video or you can just go to my account

[jlafferty23]

I thought she was dead for sure.

[VictoriNoRisuu]

Who the hell chose the music for this scene!? It just couldn't suit less, ruined everything! I couldn't feel any emotion because of it :/

[mdsfmdsfmdsf]

@VictoriNoRisuu yeah the music wasnt the best for this scene so i tried to remove the original song and to put a new one check it out if you want the link is is this video or you can just go to my account

[wardsha]

@VictoriNoRisuu I think they chose this music because it was the same music that was playing when Sarah died...

[uspsdt6]

I thought ole girl was gone for a moment!!! Brooke and Julian are a little to drama for me sometime. Julian loves Brooke and all her hang ups and that why I like this couple.

[janejanejane15]

ok so the music and acting was not great but i was pleased to see a bit of drama and old school one tree hill action for once. I used to be a huge tree hill fan and i still watch it but this episode was the least boring it has been in a long time! all the brooke scenes were the best.

[mdsfmdsfmdsf]

@janejanejane15 i agreed about the music i tried to remove the original song and to put a new one check it out if you want the link is is this video or you can just go to my account

[dreamywriter]

How come Haley and Nathan just stood there? They're her best friends!

Anyway, I can't believe I'm saying this, but I actually liked BJu in this. Usually I can't stand them (the couple, not the characters), but they were sweet here.

[tweety32312]

This scene is *____*

I mean the music is wtf and Nathan and Haley just standing there?!! They should have been freaking out and her miraculousy waking up umm yeah.

[mdsfmdsfmdsf]

@tweety32312 you are right the music wasnt the best choice so i tried to remove the original song and to put a new one check it out if you want the link is is this video or you can just go to my account

[GhostWhispererJimel]

The music ruined the scene... if they had played a sadder song, this scene would've made my heart break. Not to say the acting wasn't amazing.

[mdsfmdsfmdsf]

@GhostWhispererJimel i agreed about the music i tried to remove the original song and to put a new one check it out if you want the link is is this video or you can just go to my account

[Live4TV22]

ok, why would nathan and haley just STAND there!

[possefever]

This episode was the best One Tree Hill has been since season 4. The acting wasn't SPECTACULAR, but the episode was a huge improvement over what its been since season 5. Only way it could've been better was with a cliffhanger.

[Florie2723]

yeah you're right the music is wieird ... and yeah really believable brooke's waking up 10 minutes after loool

[mdsfmdsfmdsf]

@Florie2723 yeah i agreed the music is weird so i tried to remove the original song and to put a new one check it out if you want the link is is this video or you can just go to my account

[Florie2723]

@mdsfmdsfmdsf I just checked it and I loved it!! GREAT JOB!! I was more into the scene! I hope it makes everyone realise that music is as important as the acting! :D THANKS!!!

[purerachagan]

wth? somehow i don't at all find this scene believable... the music, julains acting and nathan and haley just standing there...

and i'm such a big fan of oth!

[mdsfmdsfmdsf]

@purerachagan i agreed about the music i tried to remove the original song and to put a new one check it out if you want the link is is this video or you can just go to my account : )